Abstract
In the mid-1970s, a new apple variety named ‘Meran’ was discovered in South Tyrol (northern Italy), which harbours the largest continuous apple growing area in Europe. The cultivar was registered for varietal protection and patented in several countries, and was declared to be a cross of the varieties ‘Golden Delicious’ and ‘Morgenduft’ (synonym ‘Rome Beauty’). The parentage of ‘Meran’ has, however, been questioned, and the present study aimed to assess the descent of this cultivar by the combined use of molecular genetic and bioinformatic tools. Five accessions of ‘Meran’ were collected from three different European germplasm collections and analysed at 14 variable microsatellite DNA loci. Subsequently, computer software was used to allocate the most likely parent pair from a set of cultivars representative for the apple growing area of South Tyrol in 1975. The molecular genetic data clearly excluded ‘Morgenduft’ as a gene donor to ‘Meran’ and provided strong evidence that ‘Meran’ is a cross of the cultivars ‘Golden Delicious’ and ‘Jonathan’, confirming previous assumptions based on morphological traits of the tree and fruit.
Zusammenfassung
Die Apfelsorte ‘Meran’ wurde Mitte der 1970er-Jahre in Südtirol (Nord-Italien), dem größten zusammenhängenden Obstbaugebiet Europas, entdeckt. Die Sorte wurde für den Sortenschutz registriert, in verschiedenen Ländern patentiert, und als Kreuzung von ‘Golden Delicious’ und ‘Morgenduft’ (Synonym ‘Rome Beauty’) deklariert. Die Elternschaft der Sorte ‘Meran’ wurde jedoch in Frage gestellt, sodass in der vorliegenden Arbeit die Abstammung dieser Sorte, mit Hilfe eines kombinierten molekulargenetischen und bioinformatischen Ansatzes, aufgeklärt werden soll. Fünf Akzessionen der Sorte ‘Meran’ aus drei verschiedenen europäischen Genbanken wurden an 14 variablen Mikrosatelliten-Loci untersucht. Das molekulargenetische Profil wurde in einer bioinformatischen Analyse einem Referenz-Daten-Set der 1975 in Südtirol am häufigsten angebauten Sorten gegenübergestellt, um das höchst wahrscheinlichste Elternpaar zu identifizieren. Die molekulargenetischen Daten schließen eine Elternschaft von ‘Morgenduft’ eindeutig aus, und es besteht eine klare Evidenz dafür, dass die Sorte ‘Meran’ eine Kreuzung von ‘Golden Delicious’ mit ‘Jonathan’ ist. Damit wird die, auf Grund der morphologischen Merkmale des Baumes und der Früchte angenommene Alternativhypothese zur Elternschaft, nun molekulargenetisch bestätigt.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Apple (Malus × domestica Borkh) is one of the most important temperate fruit crops worldwide (Dalla Via and Baric 2012; Ellinger 2006), and while several thousand different varieties of the domesticated apple are documented, present day commercial apple production is dominated by only a small number of cultivars (Janick et al. 1996). Nevertheless, many efforts are being put into the breeding and selection of novel cultivars to be able to cope with future challenges of apple production, such as environmental changes, emergence of new pests and diseases or the altered demands of consumers (Lespinasse 2009).
South Tyrol (northern Italy) harbours the largest continuous European apple growing area, with more than 1.1 million of metric tons of annual produce on approximately 18,500 ha. In the mid-1970s, a new apple variety named ‘Meran’ was discovered in this region showing a number of interesting properties (Mantinger et al. 1986; Zanon 1988a). Compared to the cultivar ‘Golden Delicious’, ‘Meran’ was characterised by earlier onset of bearing, later harvesting time and better natural disease resistance. In addition, the medium-sized spherical fruit with a shining light red covering colour exhibited remarkable storage and shelf-life behaviour and received favourable ratings in tasting panels (Mantinger et al. 1986; Zanon 1988b). In 1982, ‘Meran’ was registered for varietal protection in Italy and the propagation license was granted to the Consortium of South Tyrolean Tree Nurseries (Mantinger et al. 1986), and in subsequent years, ‘Meran’ was entered into a variety of testing programmes in several European countries (Kellerhals 1987; Zanon 1988b).
The review of the available literature on ‘Meran’, however, raises a number of questions regarding its origin. Several sources state that the farmer Franz Waldner discovered the apple variety as a chance seedling in a field on the outskirts of the town of Meran (Drahorad 1992; Kellerhals 1987; Mantinger et al. 1986; Mantinger 1987; Votteler 2005). Other sources, in turn, reveal that the apple variety was registered for patent in the United States as “A new and distinct variety of apple created by crossing” by the ‘inventors’ Karl Zanon and Franz Waldner (USPTO 1985). Moreover, the patent even specified that “‘Meran’ is a cross of the varieties ‘Golden Delicious’ and ‘Morgenduft’”. This parentage, however, was questioned by some experts based on morphological traits of the tree and fruit (Drahorad et al. 1993). The present study thus aimed to assess the parentage of ‘Meran’ by the combined use of molecular genetic and bioinformatic tools in order to shed some light on the descent of this cultivar.
Material and Methods
Leaf material was collected from five different accessions of the apple cultivar ‘Meran’ in three distinct cultivar collections; three accessions derived from the Research Centre Laimburg, one accession from the Höhere Bundeslehranstalt und Bundesamt für Wein- und Obstbau Klosterneuburg (Austria) and one from the National Fruit Collection Brogdale (UK). DNA was isolated from leaf discs using the “NucleoSpin Plant Mini Kit” (Macherey-Nagel, Düren, Germany). Each DNA sample was genotyped at 14 microsatellite loci (CH01c06, CH01d08, CH01f02, CH01f07a, CH02b10, CH02c02a, CH02c09, CH02c11, CH02d08, CH02d12, CH02h11a, CH03a04, COL, CH01h01; Liebhard et al. 2002) and analysed at a CEQ 8000 Genetic Analysis System (Beckman Coulter, Fullerton, CA, USA) (Baric et al. 2008). Allele sizes were assigned using the Fragment Analysis Software Version 8.0 from the same manufacturer.
The computer program PAPA version 2.0 (Duchesne et al. 2002) was employed so as to assess the potential parents of the cultivar ‘Meran’. The genotype obtained for this cultivar was inserted into the ‘offspring file’, while the ‘collected parents file’ contained the molecular genetic profiles of ten apple cultivars from the database of the Research Centre Laimburg, which were genotyped at the same set of 14 microsatellite loci (Baric et al. 2009). The ‘collected parents’ dataset included the most commonly grown apple cultivars in 1975, which according to Stainer (2000) comprise ‘Golden Delicious’, ‘Jonathan’, ‘Morgenduft’ (synonym ‘Rome Beauty’), ‘Red Delicious’ and ‘Granny Smith’ (the triploids ‘Gravensteiner’ and ‘Winesap’ were omitted). Other locally grown old apple cultivars ‘Champagner Renette’, ‘Kalterer Böhmer’, ‘Steinpepping’, ‘Goldparmäne’ and ‘Tiroler Spitzlederer’ were also included in the dataset. The allocation procedure for non-sexed specimens, choosing the No Error model that assumes perfect scoring, was run to allocate the most likely parental pair for ‘Meran’. In order to assess the allocation accuracy, parental simulations using the same error model as above were run. The number of iterations was set to 10 and the number of pseudo-offspring generated at each iteration was set to 45.
Results
The same genotype was found for all the five ‘Meran’ accessions analysed (Table 1), confirming that the true-to-type genotype is maintained in all the three cultivar collections sampled. The parentage analysis performed with PAPA 2.0 resulted in the most likely allocation of the offspring ‘Meran’ to the parental pair ‘Golden Delicious’ and ‘Jonathan’. The statistical assessment of the allocation accuracy using the dataset of 14 loci resulted in the highest possible rate of correctness among allocated pseudo-offspring (= 1) as well as the highest possible number of correct allocations over the number of offspring (= 1).
The molecular genetic data clearly disproved the parentage for the cultivar ‘Morgenduft’. Seven of the 14 microsatellite loci did not match with the ‘Meran’ genotype when ‘Morgenduft’ was considered alone and 11 did not match when ‘Golden Delicious’ was considered to represent the second parent (Table 1). The true-to- typeness of the molecular genetic profiles of ‘Golden Delicious’, ‘Morgenduft’ and ‘Jonathan’ was previously verified by the analysis of distinct accessions of these cultivars from at least three different European germplasm collections (Baric et al. 2009, 2011).
Discussion
The present study provides strong evidence that the South Tyrolean apple cultivar ‘Meran’ is not a cross of the cultivars ‘Golden Delicious’ and ‘Morgenduft’ but of ‘Golden Delicious’ and ‘Jonathan’. Should ‘Meran’ have been created by controlled breeding, as was suggested in the United States Patent document number P5406 (USPTO 1985), then the molecular data indicate that ‘Golden Delicious’ was pollinated by a different gene donor and the breeding records should be revised. In fact, the descent of ‘Meran’ has already been disputed and some experts suspected a closer relatedness to ‘Jonathan’ (Drahorad et al. 1993). Drahorad et al. (1993) pointed to the slightly smaller size of the fruit with an aromatic and acidic pulp, the particular form of the leaves and fruit-bearing branches as well as the low scab susceptibility as the arguments in favour of a progenitor/offspring relationship between ‘Jonathan’ and ‘Meran’.
The cultivar ‘Meran’ has initially aroused great interest within the apple growing industry due to some of its advantageous features, in particular its remarkable storage and shelf-life performance (Drahorad 1992; Kellerhals 1987; Mantinger et al. 1986; Rolff 2001; Zanon 1988a, b). However, ‘Meran’ also exhibited some shortcomings, such as a tendency towards excessive fruit setting and the need for extensive thinning to prevent development of undersized and discoloured fruit. Furthermore, the trees required particularly favourable climatic conditions in order to bear high quality fruit (Drahorad 1992; Kellerhals 1987; Mantinger 1986). These might have been the reasons why ‘Meran’ has never become a widely-grown cultivar and has made its way from experimental plots to germplasm collections.
Molecular markers such as microsatellites have proven to be useful tools for cultivar identification, relationship analyses, and estimates of genetic diversity within and among germplasm collections (Baric et al. 2009; Guarino et al. 2006; Guilford et al. 1997; Hokanson et al. 1998; Wünsch and Hormaza 2002) but also for the monitoring of breeding programmes and parentage allocation (Cabe et al. 2005; Evans et al. 2011). In this study, molecular genetic data have contributed to a critical revision of the parentage of the only registered apple variety originating from South Tyrol up to date.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank W. Guerra and R. Stainer from the Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry Laimburg (South Tyrol, Italy), K. Vogl and L. Wurm from the Höhere Bundeslehranstalt und Bundesamt für Wein- und Obstbau Klosterneuburg (Austria), and M. Ordidge from the National Fruit Collection in Brogdale (United Kingdom) for providing samples of the apple cultivar ‘Meran’ as well as J. Collinge from the University of Warwick for reviewing the language.
The study was conducted in the course of the project “Health and Nutrition—Old and New Apple Varieties at the Service of Health” (“Apfel-Fit”, 1–1a-56), which is funded within the ERDF 2007–2013 Programme of the European Union. Part of the data was elaborated within the projects “GENE-SAVE” and “APPLE-FINGERPRINT” funded by the European Union under the INTERREG IIIA programme between Italy and Austria and by the governments of South Tyrol (Italy) and Tyrol (Austria). The authors are grateful to the Foundation for Research and Innovation of the Autonomous Province of Bozen/Bolzano for covering the Open Access publication costs.
References
Baric S, Monschein S, Hofer M, Grill D, Dalla Via J (2008) Comparability of genotyping data obtained by different procedures—an interlaboratory survey. J Horticult Sci Biotechnol 83:183–190
Baric S, Storti A, Hofer M, Dalla Via J (2009) Molecular genetic characterisation of apple cultivars from different germplasm collections. Acta Hortic 817:347–353
Baric S, Wagner J, Storti A, Dalla Via J (2011) Application of an extended set of microsatellite DNA markers for the analysis of presumed synonym cultivars of apple. Acta Hortic 918:303–308
Cabe PR, Baumgarten A, Onan K, Luby JJ, Bedford DS (2005) Using microsatellite analysis to verify breeding records: a study of ‘Honeycrisp’ and other cold-hardy apple cultivars. HortScience 40:15–17
Dalla Via J, Baric S (2012) Tree fruit growing—research and production in Germany: a statistical and bibliometric analysis of the period 1950–2010. Erwerbs-Obstbau 54:11–30
Drahorad W (1992) Die Apfel-Sorte ‘Meran’: Beobachtungen am Datumhof. Obstbau Weinbau 29:320–321
Drahorad W, Bradlwarter M, Gritsch H (1993) Apfelsorte ‘Meran’—frisch und attraktiv. Obstbau Weinbau 30:264–265
Duchesne P, Godbout M-H, Bernatchez L (2002) PAPA (Package for the Analysis of Parental Allocation): a computer program for simulated and real parental allocation. Mol Ecol Notes 2:191–193
Ellinger W (2006) Der Markt für Obst. Agrarwirtschaft 55, 69–78. http://ageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/97175/2/6_Obst.pdf. Accessed 1 July 2012
Evans KM, Patocchi A, Rezzonico F, Mathis F, Durel CE, Fernandez-Fernandez F, Boudichevskaia A, Dunemman F, Stankiewicz-Kosyl M, Gianfranceschi L, Komjanc M, Lateur M, Madduri M, Noordijk Y, van de Weg WE (2011) Genotyping of pedigreed apple breeding material with a genome-covering set of SSRs: trueness-to-type of cultivars and their parentages. Mol Breed 28:535–547
Guarino C, Santoro S, De Simone S, Lain O, Cipriani G, Testolin R (2006) Genetic diversity in a collection of ancient cultivars of apple (Malus × domestica Borkh.) as revealed by SSR-based fingerprinting. J Horticult Sci Biotechnol 81:39–44
Guilford P, Prakash S, Zhu JM, Rikkerink E, Gardiner S, Bassett H, Forster R (1997) Microsatellites in Malus × domestica (apple): abundance, polymorphism and cultivar identification. Theor Appl Genet 94:249–254
Hokanson SC, Szewc-McFadden AK, Lamboy WF, McFerson JR (1998) Microsatellite (SSR) markers reveal genetic identities, genetic diversity and relationships in a Malus × domestica Borkh. core subset collection. Theor Appl Genet 97:671–683
Janick J, Cummins JN, Brown SK, Hemmat M (1996) Apples. In: Janick J, Moore JN (Eds.) Fruit Breeding, Vol 1, Trees and Tropical Fruits. Wiley, New York, pp 1–77
Kellerhals M (1987) Porträt neuer Obstsorten. Die Apfelsorte ‘Meran’. Schweiz Z Obst- Weinbau 123:166
Lespinasse Y (2009) Review of pome fruit breeding in Europe: which strategies for the near future? Acta Hortic 814:865–871
Liebhard R, Gianfranceschi L, Koller B, Ryder CD, Tarchini R, van de Weg E, Gessler C (2002) Development and characterisation of 140 new microsatellites in apple (Malus × domestica Borkh). Mol Breed 10:217–241
Mantinger H (1987) Information über Neuheiten im Apfelsortiment (4). Besseres Obst 32:166–167
Mantinger H, Stainer R, Nardin C (1986) Die Apfelsorte ‘Meran’. Obstbau Weinbau 23:298–301
Rolff JH (2001) Der Apfel: Sortennamen und Synonyme. Selbstverlag Johann-Heinrich Rolff, Kiefersfelden
Stainer R (2000) Südtirol: Grösstes geschlossenes Obstbaugebiet im Herzen Europas. Schweiz Z Obst- Weinbau 26/00:695–699
USPTO—United States Patent and Trademark Office (1985) Apple tree ‘Meran’. Patent number: Plant 5406, United States Patent. http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect2=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&p=1&u=/netahtml/PTO/search-bool.html&r=1&f=G&l=50&d=PALL&RefSrch=yes&Query=PN/PP5406. Accessed 1 July 2012
Votteler W (2005) Verzeichnis der Apfel- und Birnensorten. Obst- und Gartenbauverlag, München, p 312
Wünsch A, Hormaza JI (2002) Cultivar identification and genetic fingerprinting of temperate fruit tree species using DNA markers. Euphytica 125:59–67
Zanon K (1988a) ‘Meran’, die neue Südtiroler Apfelsorte. Fruchthandel 24:1425–1426
Zanon K (1988b) ‘Meran’—neue Südtiroler Apfelsorte. Besseres Obst 33:217
Open Access
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
About this article
Cite this article
Baric, S., Storti, A., Hofer, M. et al. Resolving the Parentage of the Apple Cultivar ‘Meran’. Erwerbs-Obstbau 54, 143–146 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10341-012-0167-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10341-012-0167-6