Estimating measurement uncertainty in an afternoon. A case study in the practical application of measurement uncertainty

Abstract

The ISO/IEC 17025:1999 standard requires chemical testing laboratories to have an estimate of the uncertainty of their measurements. This is a new requirement for many laboratories and there is confusion as to how to estimate uncertainty. Concerns have been raised about the time and effort required to obtain uncertainty estimates.

Uncertainty budgets were prepared for the measurement of benzene, toluene, ethyl benzene and xylenes (BTEX) in water using purge and trap coupled with GC/MS. A time limit of one working afternoon (2 pm–5.30 pm) was imposed for preparing the uncertainty estimate. Details of the uncertainty estimate for toluene are described.

The method in question had been in routine use for several years and the laboratory held third party (NATA) accreditation for the test. Consequently a considerable amount of performance data was readily available. Relevant information was extracted from the documented test method, validation data, instrument calibration and from routine quality control. This data was combined according to the principles of the ISO Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty, as promulgated in the Eurachem document "Quantifying Uncertainty in Analytical Measurement."

The uncertainty estimates were compared to estimates obtained from generalised empirical models (the Horwitz and Lowthian equations), and from interlaboratory studies of this analysis.

A traceability chain from routine measurements to the SI units of metre, kilogram and mole is described.

Realistic and useful uncertainty estimates were obtained with a few hours work using data extant in the laboratory.