Abstract
Access to better health care anticipates that more medical devices can be found alongside skeletal remains. Those employed in oral rehabilitation, with available brands or batch/series, can prove useful in the identification process. A previous study in the Colecção de Esqueletos Identificados Século XXI described macroscopically the dental prostheses. An unusual case of a dental device with chromatic alterations demonstrated to require a more detailed analysis. The individual, a 53-year-old male, exhibited, at both arches, a fixed tooth-supported rehabilitation, with gold colouring classified initially as a gold-palladium alloy. Simultaneously, a green pigmentation deposit was observable in bone and prosthesis. This investigation aimed to verify the elemental composition of the dental prosthesis alloy. Elemental analysis was performed by X-ray fluorescence in two regions (labial surface of the prosthetic crown and the root surface of the lower right lateral incisor). Both the spectra and the qualitative results found higher levels of copper and aluminium, followed by nickel, iron, zinc, and manganese. No gold or palladium was detected. The most probable assumption is that a copper-aluminium alloy was used, as its elemental concentration corresponds to those measured in similar devices. Dental prostheses of copper-aluminium alloys have been made popular since the 1980s, particularly in the USA, Japan, and Eastern Europe. Apart from the biographical information, it was also known that the individual’s place of birth was an Eastern European country, which highlighted the usefulness of this type of information when dealing with missing people cases.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Forensic anthropology has significantly evolved in the last decades, thriving to adapt to the need of the practice and the challenges of today’s society [1, 2]. While identification is still the primary goal, it is expected from the forensic anthropologist to be able to gather and document as much information on context as possible to achieve scientifically sound conclusions that may be applied to the search and identification of the missing [3,4,5].
Nowadays, due to broader access to health care, it is anticipated that more medical devices will be found alongside skeletal remains [6]. It is conceivable that this scenario, with more clinical data available for comparison and these devices having unique characteristics such as brands or batch/series numbers, may facilitate the human identification process [7, 8].
Among the broad range of medical devices that can be found [7], those employed in oral rehabilitation are a focus of interest. Tooth loss is a widespread occurrence; thus, the presence of such devices has become more frequent across populations [9]. However, the exploitation of dental prostheses in the identification process has been hindered by an absence of brands or serial numbers, as well as a lack of systematic register on databases, and not enough research on the subject [10,11,12].
Seldom literature addresses the analysis of these devices [7, 13,14,15]. Previously, Oliveira-Santos and colleagues [10] explored the Colecção de Esqueletos Identificados Século XXI (21st Century Identified Collection - CEI/XXI) [6] and macroscopically described the dental prostheses found in this osteological collection. No other analyses were executed to aid in the classification process. However, a specific case presenting chromatic alterations indicated the need for a more precise characterization of the metal alloy present.
The macroscopic analysis of a 53-year-old male skeleton (CEI/XXI_278; date of death: July 2011) from the CEI/XXI was previously performed in a study aimed to describe the dental prostheses found in skeletal remains and explore their application in the human identification process [10]. The devices were classified according to position, type of rehabilitation, number of units, and type of materials (please refer to [10]).
The individual exhibited a fixed dental-supported rehabilitation (Fig. 1): the maxilla presented a twelve-unit bridge supported by 5 teeth (FDI 12, 15, 23, 24, and 25) and the mandible a four-unit bridge supported by 2 teeth (FDI 42 and 43), both metal-acrylic. The gold colouring of metal differentiated this case from the remaining fixed prostheses, and a classification of a gold-palladium (Au-Pd) alloy was obtained by comparison with what is applied in Portuguese dental practice nowadays.
Simultaneously, a green corrosion-like deposit was observable in both arches, over the bone and root surfaces and prosthesis. Although changes in pigmentation in skeletal remains may be the result of several factors, it cannot be excluded that the colour change may be indicative of the composition of the metal alloy present in this device [16], arousing suspicion about the initial assessment of gold-palladium.
Elemental analysis of dental devices has already been applied in forensic practice and leads to a positive identification of human skeletal remains [17,18,19]. Thus, this work aimed to verify the macroscopic observation by identifying the metal alloy prosthesis’s elemental composition and consequently identify the origin of the oral rehabilitation.
Methods
Elemental analysis was conducted in a bench top fluorescence X-ray (XRF) analyser with a high-sensitivity energy dispersive Hitachi SEA6000VX HSfinder, with X-ray tube, W target, and Si multi-cathode detector, housed at the Centre of Physics of the University of Coimbra (CFisUC). X-ray fluorescence is a quantitative technique where the height of the peak for any element is directly related to the concentration of the same element. Therefore, the volume fraction of a certain element can be determined by knowing its X-ray fluorescence intensity [20].
Considering the macroscopic features of the prosthesis, the chemical analysis focused on elements that may be employed in metal alloys, such as aluminium (Al), manganese (Mn), iron (Fe), nickel (Ni), copper (Cu), zinc (Zn), silver (Ag), gold (Au), and palladium (Pd). Calcium (Ca) and phosphorus (P) were also included as they are major components of bone and dental tissues [21].
The samples were measured in two regions of the lower lateral incisor: the labial surface of the crown (Fig. 2A) and the root surface supporting the prosthesis (Fig. 2B).
Results
The qualitative results of the spectrum analysis are presented in Figs. 3 and 4. In those, high and low energy spectra are represented. The quantitative analysis was reported for the prosthesis sample and is available in Table 1.
The qualitative analysis made it possible to assess that Au and Pd were not present in the device, at least not in detectable quantities.
Regarding the elements found, in the prosthesis spectrum (Fig. 3) and in the quantitative analysis (Table 1), higher levels of Cu and Al, followed by Ni, Fe, Zn, and Mn, were observed.
The root sample was explored in an attempt to assess if any elemental exchanges occurred between the device and surrounding tissues. As expected, high expressions of Ca and P were evident. Nonetheless, elements present in the alloy were also found in the root sample, namely Ni, Fe, and Mn.
Discussion
While the macroscopic observation of the prosthesis was crucial, the alterations observed in the individual under study motivated the need for a more thorough analysis. Thus, the aim to accurately identify the metal composition of oral rehabilitation used was explored with the aid of a chemical analysis tool.
The green pigmentation observed in both prostheses and bone could, as mentioned above, has several origins. The colour change in bone is well documented, providing a good source of information for the reconstruction of the postdepositional context [16]. Although the most common causes for chromatic changes are the soil, the presence of organic materials, and/or the presence of metals, both intrinsic and extrinsic factors may affect bone, resulting in a multitude of colours [16, 22]. Thus, at first, it could not be excluded that the green pigmentation observed in this individual might have been caused by external agents. Furthermore, it is documented that skeletonized remains from cemetery contexts frequently exhibit localized stains due to the proximity to corroding mineral sources [23]. Since the skeletons from the CEI/XXI are from a cemetery context, this could have been the cause of the green colouring observed. However, this hypothesis was unlikely seeing that the different pigmentation was limited to the area of the dental prostheses and mandible, and no other area of the skeleton presented such alterations.
Focusing on the area under scrutiny, one plausible cause was in fact the presence of the metal alloy. The preliminary assessment of the alloy was a gold and palladium composition, due to the gold tone of the device. These two elements are documented to be highly resistant to corrosion, and their biocompatibility makes them a good option for oral rehabilitations [24,25,26]. When observing the results of the elemental analyses, there was no evidence of these two elements. It was possible that the colour change could be a consequence of the corrosion of other metals used in the device. In fact, contact with copper or copper alloy is generally associated with green and greenish blue tones [27]. In the prosthesis analysed, high concentrations of copper, aluminium, nickel, and iron were present. Hence, it was possible to assess that the hypothesis of the pigmentation being caused by corrosion of the metal alloy is the most plausible and that the presence of the green colour was an important indicator for the correct identification of the materials comprising these prostheses.
As well as the colour, the initial assessment of the alloy was also sustained by the current trends in the Portuguese dental practice reported by the dentists consulted throughout the research. However, considering the elements that comprised that part of the prosthesis in reality, the most probable assumption is that they correspond to a copper-aluminium alloy [28]. López-Alías and colleagues [29] assessed the elemental composition (X-ray diffraction) of two copper-aluminium alloys used in common dental practices (Orcast® - Madespa S.A., Spain and NPG® - Aalba Dent Inc., Fairfield, CA, USA). Levels of Al (87–106 g/kg), Mn (15 g/kg), Fe (15–21 g/kg), Ni (36–46 g/kg), and Cu (809–830 g/kg) were similar to those found in the current research, thus corroborating the identification of the alloy as copper-aluminium.
Dental prostheses made from copper-aluminium alloys have been used in various countries, particularly since the 1980s [28]. Their popularity was mainly due to their visual similarity to gold-rich alloys [30] while being less expensive as it is not comprised of noble metals [31, 32]. They are usually alloyed with minor additions of modifying elements such as Ni, Fe, and Mn [33]. However, its application became less frequent as it was demonstrated that, with time, pitting and corrosion occurred [34]. In fact, copper-based alloys corroded extensively in most laboratory tests when compared to other dental alloys, making the Au-Pd compound much more attractive [31]. In addition, colourimetric analysis has demonstrated that copper-aluminium alloys, when in contact with saliva, tend to become more yellow and slightly greener. In cases of extreme corrosion, green colours are expected to emerge abundantly [30], which explains the evident pigmentation in this case (Fig. 1).
Furthermore, concerns about its potential toxicity increased as the release of copper and aluminium ions can lead to adverse reactions, including inflammation and hypersensitivity, reasons why several stakeholders advise against its use [29].
Upon further scrutiny, it is evident that these results agree with the biographic data of the individual. Apart from the biographical information of sex and age at death, it was also available the individual’s place of birth. This 53-year-old male was born in an Eastern European country, which becomes more noteworthy when crossing this data with the reported information that copper-aluminium alloys are more usual in markets other than Portuguese, such as the USA, Japan, Brazil, and Eastern European countries [28].
It is important to remark on the usefulness of this type of information when dealing with missing people cases. While it must be cautiously used, this data may aid to reconstruct the life context of the unidentified. In this case, even without knowing when the procedure was made, or when the individual arrived in Portugal, the fact is that the scarce presence of this type of alloy in the clinical practice in Portugal would be of great value in reconstructing the individual’s identity.
Conclusion
In forensic anthropology practice, correctly identifying a dental prosthesis with the help of a dental expert seemed a very straightforward procedure. As mentioned, restorations fabricated from Cu-Al alloys oftentimes remain similar in appearance to the gold compounds, and their misclassification is common. Hence, if an extended examination of this case had not been performed, fundamental details would be lost, and in a practical scenario, the comparison with available ante mortem data would be compromised.
The analysis of this type of device may be a fundamental step for individualization in the human identification process or to guide the expert in constructing a geographical and chronological context. Confidence in what is observed and classified is utmost. In this case, the X-ray fluorescence analysis allowed us to accurately classify the materials and contribute to knowing more about the individual’s life history. This technique is of great interest for forensic analysis due to its rapidness, non-destructive nature, and straightforward interpretation of results.
Data availability
Not applicable.
Code availability
Not applicable.
References
Cunha E (2017) Considerações sobre a Antropologia Forense na Atualidade. Rev Bras Odontol Leg 4:110–117. https://doi.org/10.21117/rbol.v4i2.133
Ubelaker DH (2018) A history of forensic anthropology. Am J Phys Anthropol 165:915–923. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.23306
Beatrice JS, Soler A, Reineke RC, Martínez DE (2021) Skeletal evidence of structural violence among undocumented migrants from Mexico and Central America. Am J Phys Anthropol 176:584–605. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.24391
ICRC IC of the RC (2022) The forensic human identification process: an integrated approach. Interational Commitee of the Red Cross, Geneva
Páez DER (2020) Integration of information on missing persons and unidentified human remains. Forensic science and humanitarian action. Wiley, Ltd, pp 157–169
Ferreira MT, Coelho C, Makhoul C et al (2021) New data about the 21st century identified skeletal collection (University of Coimbra, Portugal). Int J Legal Med 135:1087–1094. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-020-02399-6
Cappella A, Gibelli D, Obertová Z et al (2019) The utility of skeletal and surgical features for the personal identification process: a pilot study. J Forensic Sci 64:1796–1802. https://doi.org/10.1111/1556-4029.14117
Heit OFJ (2020) Importancia de los registros pre y post tratamiento clínico odontológico para la identificación humana-Reporte de un caso forense. Rev Arg Odontol Leg 4:24–28
Konishi M, Verdonschot RG, Kakimoto N (2021) An investigation of tooth loss factors in elderly patients using panoramic radiographs. Oral Radiol 37:436–442. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11282-020-00475-6
Oliveira-Santos I, Coelho C, Cunha E et al (2021) The dental prosthesis (removable and fixed) from the Colecção de Esqueletos Identificados Século XXI (CEI/XXI). Int J Legal Med 135:2595–2602. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-021-02701-0
Datta P, Sood S (2010) The various methods and benefits of denture labeling. J Forensic Dent Sci 2:53. https://doi.org/10.4103/0975-1475.81281
Mohan J, Dhinesh Kumar CD, Simon P (2012) “Denture marking” as an aid to forensic identification. J Indian Prosthodont Soc 12:131–136. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13191-012-0125-x
Gómez Jiménez L, Velandia Palacio LA, de Luca S et al (2019) Validation of the third molar maturity index (I3M): study of a Dominican Republic sample. J Forensic Odontostomatol 3:27–33
Merlati G, Danesino P, Savio C et al (2002) Observations on dental prostheses and restorations subjected to high temperatures: experimental studies to aid identification processes. J Forensic Odonto-Stomatol 20:17–24
Jensen S (1991) Identification of human remains lacking skull and teeth. A case report with some methodological considerations. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 12:93–97. https://doi.org/10.1097/00000433-199106000-00001
Schultz JJ, Dupras TL (2021) Identifying the origin of taphonomic bone staining and color changes in forensic contexts. Man Forensic Taphonomy 443–472. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003171492-12
Bunget A, Bîcă MD, Bărbăcioru IC et al (2022) The use of X-ray spectrometry in forensic expertise. Dental alloy control. Ann Univ Craiova Ser Chem 28:56–62. https://doi.org/10.52846/aucchem.2022.1.06
Bush MA, Miller RG, Prutsman-Pfeiffer J, Bush PJ (2007) Identification through X-ray fluorescence analysis of dental restorative resin materials: a comprehensive study of noncremated, cremated, and processed-cremated individuals. J Forensic Sci 52:157–165. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1556-4029.2006.00308.x
Berketa JW, James H, Langlois NEI, Richards LC (2014) A study of osseointegrated dental implants following cremation. Aust Dent J 59:149–155. https://doi.org/10.1111/adj.12170
Arai T (2006) Introduction. In: BeckhoffB B, Kanngießer B, Langhoff N et al (eds) Handbook of practical X-ray fluorescence analysis. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, pp 1–31
Gaffney-Stomberg E (2019) The impact of trace minerals on bone metabolism. Biol Trace Elem Res 188:26–34. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12011-018-1583-8
Cheney E (2021) Forensic taphonomy: copper and aluminum staining on skeletal material. In: Master in Forensic Science. George Mason University
Pokines JT (2018) Differential diagnosis of the taphonomic histories of common types of forensic osseous remains. J Forensic Identif 68:87–145
Wataha JC, Shor K (2010) Palladium alloys for biomedical devices. Expert Rev Med Devices 7:489–501. https://doi.org/10.1586/erd.10.25
Taher NM, Al Jabab AS (2003) Galvanic corrosion behavior of implant suprastructure dental alloys. Dent Mater 19:54–59. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0109-5641(02)00008-8
Sun D, Monaghan P, Brantley WA, Johnston WM (2002) Potentiodynamic polarization study of the in vitro corrosion behavior of 3 high-palladium alloys and a gold-palladium alloy in 5 media. J Prosthet Dent 87:86–93. https://doi.org/10.1067/MPR.2002.121239
Borrini M, Mariani PP, Murgia C et al (2012) Contextual taphonomy - superficial bone alterations as contextual indicators. J Biol Res-Bollettino della Società Italiana di Biologia Sperimentale LXXXV:217–219
Eschler PY, Lüthy H, Reclaru L et al (2003) Copper-aluminium bronze - a substitute material for gold dental alloys? Eur Cell Mater 5:49–50
López-Alías JF, Martinez-Gomis J, Anglada JM, Peraire M (2006) Ion release from dental casting alloys as assessed by a continuous flow system: nutritional and toxicological implications. Dent Mater 22:832–837. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dental.2005.11.011
Mueller HJ (1989) Corrosion and colorimetry of MS copper-aluminum dental restorative alloy. Corrosion 45:735–740. https://doi.org/10.5006/1.3585028
Ardlin BI, Lindholm-Sethson B, Dahl JE (2009) Corrosion of dental nickel-aluminum bronze with a minor gold content-mechanism and biological impact. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater 88:465–473. https://doi.org/10.1002/jbm.b.31143
Thomson DH (1983) Use of industrially available aluminium-bronze alloys for cast restorations I. Preliminary study. Aust Dent J 28:153–155. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1834-7819.1983.tb05271.x
Leinfelder KF (1997) An evaluation of casting alloys used for restorative procedures. J Am Dent Assoc 128:37–45. https://doi.org/10.14219/jada.archive.1997.0024
Bates JF, Knapton AG (1977) Metals and alloys in dentistry. Int Metals Rev 22:39–60. https://doi.org/10.1179/imtr.1977.22.1.39
Funding
Open access funding provided by FCT|FCCN (b-on). This work was supported by the R&D Unit Centre for Functional Ecology–Science for People and the Planet (CFE), with reference UIDB/04004/2020, financed by FCT/MCTES through national funds (PIDDAC). The co-authors Inês Oliveira-Santos, Ricardo A.M.P Gomes, and Catarina Coelho were financed by FCT (grant numbers SFRH/BD/139158/2018, SFRH/BD/145343/2019, and SFRH/BD/129826/2017).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics approval
Positive legal decision from the Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Medicine of the University of Coimbra, Portugal (CE_026.2016).
Informed consent
Not applicable.
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Oliveira-Santos, I., Gomes, R.A., Coelho, C. et al. All that glitters is not gold: X-ray fluorescence analysis of a fixed dental prosthesis from Colecção de Esqueletos Identificados Século XXI, Portugal (CEI/XXI). Int J Legal Med 138, 685–691 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-023-03048-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-023-03048-4