Abstract
The age-at-death estimation thresholds have recently been shifted towards a more objective assessment of the aging process. Such a non-subjective approach offers quantitative methods of age estimation; for instance, the method relating to the surfaces of pubic symphyses of males published by Stoyanova et al. (J Forensic Sci 62:1434–1444, 2017). A validation study was conducted to test the method performance in European samples. The sample consisted of 96 meshes of pubic symphyses of male individuals (known sex and age) that came from four different samples (two Portuguese collections, one Swiss, and one Crete). Stoyanova’s method based on five regression models (three univariate and two multivariate models) performed worse in our sample, but only when the whole sample (without age limitation) was included. A sample limited to individuals under 40 years of age achieved better results in our study. The best results were reached through the thin plate spline algorithm (TPS/BE) with a root mean square error of 5.93 years and inaccuracy of 4.47 years. Generally, the multivariate regression models did not contribute to better age estimation. In our sample in all age categories, age was systematically underestimated. The quantitative method tested in this study works best for individuals under 40 years of age and provides a suitable basis for further research.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Hoppa RD, Vaupel JW (2002) The Rostock Manifesto for paleodemography: the way from stage to age. In: Hoppa RD, Vaupel JW (eds) Paleodemography: age distributions from skeletal samples. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 1–8
Baccino E, Schmitt A (2006) Determination of adult age at death in the forensic context. In: Schmitt A, Cunha E, Pinheiro J (eds) Forensic anthropology and medicine: complementary sciences from recovery to cause of death. Humana Press Inc., Totowa, pp 259–280
Cattaneo C (2007) Forensic anthropology: developments of a classical discipline in the new millennium. Forensic Sci Int 165:185–193
Kemkes-Grottenthaler A (2002) Aging through the ages: historical perspectives on age indicator methods. In: Hoppa R, Vaupel J (eds) Paleodemography: age distributions from skeletal samples. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 48–72
Overbury RS, Cabo LL, Dirkmaat DC, Symes SA (2009) Asymmetry of the os pubis: implications for the Suchey-Brooks method. Am J Phys Anthropol 139:261–268
Passalacqua NV (2009) Forensic age-at-death estimation from the human sacrum. J Forensic Sci 54:255–262
Buckberry J (2015) The (mis)use of adult age estimates in osteology. Ann Hum Biol 42:323–331
Cappella A, Cummaudo M, Arrigoni E, Collini F, Cattaneo C (2017) The issue of age estimation in a modern skeletal population: are even the more modern current aging methods satisfactory for the elderly? J Forensic Sci 62:12–17
Todd WT (1920) Age changes in the pubic bone. I. The male white pubis. Am J Phys Anthropol 3:285–334
Gilbert BM, McKern TW (1973) A method for aging the female os pubis. Am J Phys Anthropol 38:31–38
Katz D, Suchey JM (1989) Race differences in pubic symphyseal aging patterns in the male. Am J Phys Anthropol 80:167–172
Brooks S, Suchey JM (1990) Skeletal age determination based on the os pubis: a comparison of the Acsádi- Nemeskéri and Suchey-Brooks methods. Hum Evol 5:227–238
Chen X, Zhang Z, Tao L (2008) Determination of male age at death in Chinese Han population: using quantitative variables statistical analysis from pubic bones. Forensic Sci Int 175:36–43
Hanihara K, Suzuki T (1978) Estimation of age from the pubic symphysis by means of multiple regression analysis. Am J Phys Anthropol 48:233–240
Hartnett KM (2010) Analysis of age-at-death estimation using data from a new, modern autopsy sample—part I: pubic bone. J Forensic Sci 55:1145–1151
Stoyanova D, Algee-Hewitt BFB, Slice DE (2015) An enhanced computational method for age-at-death estimation based on the pubic symphysis using 3D laser scans and thin plate splines. Am J Phys Anthropol 158:431–440
Stoyanova DK, Algee-Hewitt BFB, Kim J, Slice DE (2017) A computational framework for age-at-death estimation from the skeleton: surface and outline analysis of 3D laser scans of the adult pubic symphysis. J Forensic Sci 62:1434–1444
Savall F, Hérin F, Peyron PA, Rougé D, Baccino E, Saint-Martin P, Telmon N (2018) Age estimation at death using pubic bone analysis of a virtual reference sample. Int J Legal Med 132:609–615
Schmitt A (2004) Age-at-death assessment using the os pubis and the auricular surface of the ilium: a test on an identified Asian sample. Int J Osteoarchaeol 14:1–6
Sakaue K (2006) Application of the Suchey–Brooks system of pubic age estimation to recent Japanese skeletal material. Anthropol Sci 114:59–64
San Millán M, Rissech C, Turbón D (2013) A test of Suchey-Brooks (pubic symphysis) and Buckberry-Chamberlain (auricular surface) methods on an identified Spanish sample: paleodemographic implications. J Archaeol Sci 40:1743–1751
Berg GE (2008) Pubic bone age estimation in adult women. J Forensic Sci 53:569–577
Rivera-Sandoval J, Monsalve T, Cattaneo C (2018) A test of four innominate bone age assessment methods in a modern skeletal collection from Medellin, Colombia. Forensic Sci Int 282:232–2e1
Wink AE (2014) Pubic symphyseal age estimation from three-dimensional reconstructions of pelvic ct scans of live individuals. J Forensic Sci 59:696–702
Telmon N, Gaston A, Chemla P, Blanc A, Joffre F, Rougé D (2005) Application of the Suchey-Brooks method to three - dimensional imaging of the pubic symphysis. J Forensic Sci 50:1–6
Lottering N, MacGregor DM, Meredith M, Alston CL, Gregory LS (2013) Evaluation of the Suchey-Brooks method of age estimation in an Australian subpopulation using computed tomography of the pubic symphyseal surface. Am J Phys Anthropol 150:386–399
Tocheri MW, Razdan A, Dupras TL, Bae M, Liu D (2002) Three dimensional quantitative analyses of human pubic symphyseal morphology: can current limitations of skeletal aging methods be resolved? Am J Phys Anthropol (Suppl 34) 155
Biwasaka H, Sato K, Aoki Y, Kato H, Maeno Y, Tanijiri T, Fujita S, Dewa K (2013) Three dimensional surface analyses of pubic symphyseal faces of contemporary Japanese reconstructed with 3D digitized scanner. Legal Med 15:264–268
Meindl RS, Lovejoy CO, Mensforth RP, Walker RA (1985) A revised method of age determination using the os pubis, with a review and tests of accuracy of other current methods of pubic symphyseal aging. Am J Phys Anthropol 68:29–45
Lovejoy CO, Meindl RS, Tague R, Latimer B (1995) The senescent biology of the hominoid pelvis: its bearing on the pubic symphysis and auricular surface as age-at-death indicators in the human skeleton. Riv di Antropol 73:31–49
Lovejoy CO, Meindl RS, Tague R, Latimer B (1997) The comparative senescent biology of the hominoid pelvis and its implications for the use of age-at-death indicators in the human skeleton. In: Paine R (ed) Integrating archaeological demography: multidisciplinary approaches to prehistoric population. Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale, pp 43–63
Schmitt A, Murail P, Cunha E, Rougé D (2002) Variability of the pattern of aging on the human skeleton: evidence from bone indicators and implication on age at death estimation. J Forensic Sci 47:1203–1209
Márquez-Grant N (2015) An overview of age estimation in forensic anthropology: perspectives and practical considerations. Ann Hum Biol 42:308–322
Buk Z, Kordik P, Bruzek J, Schmitt A, Snorek M (2012) The age at death assessment in a multi-ethnic sample of pelvic bones using nature-inspired data mining methods. Forensic Sci Int 220:294 e1-e9
Rissech C, Estabrook GF, Cunha E, Malgosa A (2006) Using the acetabulum to estimate age at death of adult males. J Forensic Sci 51:213–229
Gocha TP, Ingvoldstad ME, Kolatorowicz A, Cosgriff-Hernandez MTJ, Sciulli PW (2015) Testing the applicability of six macroscopic skeletal aging techniques on a modern Southeast Asian sample. Forensic Sci Int 249:318–3e1
Meindl RS, Russell KF (1998) Recent advances in method and theory in paleodemography. Annu Rev Anthr 27:375–399
Dudzik B, Langley NR (2015) Estimating age from the pubic symphysis: a new component-based system. Forensic Sci Int 257:98–105
Baccino E, Zerilli A (1997) The two step strategy (TSS) or the right way to combine a dental (Lamendin) and an anthropological (Suchey–Brooks system) method for age determination. In: Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences XLIX, p 150
Baccino E, Sinfield L, Colomb S, Baum TP, Martrille L (2014) Technical note: the two step procedure (TSP) for the determination of age at death of adult human remains in forensic cases. Forensic Sci Int 244:247–251
Lamendin H (1988) Appréciation d’age par la méthode de Gustafson <<simplifiée>>. Chir Dent Fr 427:205–214
Lamendin H, Baccino E, Humbert JF, Tavernier JC, Nossintchouk RM, Zerilli A (1992) A simple technique for age estimation in adult corpses: the two criteria dental method. J Forensic Sci 37:1373–1379
Xanthopoulou P, Valakos E, Youlatos D, Nikita E (2018) Assessing the accuracy of cranial and pelvic ageing methods on human skeletal remains from a modern Greek assemblage. Forensic Sci Int 286:266–2e1
Martrille L, Ubelaker DH, Cattaneo C, Seguret F, Tremblay M, Baccino E (2007) Comparison of four skeletal methods for the estimation of age at death on white and black adults. J Forensic Sci 52:302–307
Galera V, Ubelaker D, Hayek L (1995) Interobserver error in macroscopic methods of estimating age at death from the human skeleton. Int J Anthr 10:229–239
Kimmerle EH, Prince DA, Berg GE (2008) Inter-observer variation in methodologies involving the pubic symphysis, sternal ribs, and teeth. J Forensic Sci 53:594–600
Kotěrová A, Navega D, Štepanovský M, Buk Z, Brůžek J, Cunha E (2018) Age estimation of adult human remains from hip bones using advanced methods. Forensic Sci Int 287:163–175
Algee-Hewitt BFB (2013) Age estimation in modern forensic anthropology. In: Tersigni-Tarrant MA, Shirley NR (eds) Forensic anthropology: an introduction. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp 181–230
Villa C, Buckberry J, Lynnerup N (2016) Evaluating osteological ageing from digital data. J Anat. https://doi.org/10.1111/joa.12544
Villa C, Buckberry J, Cattaneo C, Frohlich B, Lynnerup N (2015) Quantitative analysis of the morphological changes of the pubic symphyseal face and the auricular surface and implications for age at death estimation. J Forensic Sci 60:556–565
Stock M, Morse P, Villa C (2017) Quantitative assessment of age-related topographic changes in the pubic symphysis. In: 86th Annual Meeting of the American Association of Physical Anthropologists, p 371
Bunn JM, Boyer DM, Lipman Y, St. Clair EM, Jernvall J, Daubechies I (2011) Comparing Dirichlet normal surface energy of tooth crowns, a new technique of molar shape quantification for dietary inference, with previous methods in isolation and in combination. Am J Phys Anthropol 145:247–261
Godfrey LR, Winchester JM, King SJ, Boyer DM, Jernvall J (2012) Dental topography indicates ecological contraction of lemur communities. Am J Phys Anthropol 148:215–227
Pampush JD, Winchester JM, Morse PE, Vining AQ, Boyer DM, Kay RF (2016) Introducing molaR: a new R package for quantitative topographic analysis of teeth (and other topographic surfaces). J Mamm Evol 23:397–412
Spradley JP, Pampush JD, Morse PE, Kay RF (2017) Smooth operator: the effects of different 3D mesh retriangulation protocols on the computation of Dirichlet normal energy. Am J Phys Anthropol 163:94–109
Slice DE, Algee-Hewitt BFB (2015) Modeling bone surface morphology: a fully quantitative method for age-at-death estimation using the pubic symphysis. J Forensic Sci 60:835–843
Daubert V. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals (1993), Inc., 509 US 579
Grivas CR, Komar DA (2008) Kumho, Daubert, and the nature of scientific inquiry: implications for forensic anthropology. J Forensic Sci 53:771–776
Cunha E, Wasterlain S (2007) The Coimbra identified osteological collections. In: Grupe G, Peters J (eds) Skeletal series in their socioeconomic context. Documenta Archaeobiologiae. Verlag Marie Leidorf, Rahden, pp 23–33
Ferreira MT, Vicente R, Navega D, Gonçalves D, Curate F, Cunha E (2014) A new forensic collection housed at the University of Coimbra, Portugal: the 21st century identified skeletal collection. Forensic Sci Int 245:202–2e1
Kranioti EF, Işcan MY, Michalodimitrakis M (2008) Craniometric analysis of the modern Cretan population. Forensic Sci Int 180:1–5
Kranioti EF, Michalodimitrakis M (2009) Sexual dimorphism of the humerus in contemporary cretans—a population-specific study and a review of the literature. J Forensic Sci 54:996–1000
Perreard Lopreno G (2007) Adaptation structurelle des os du membre supérieur et de la clavicule à l’activité. Doctoral dissertation, University of Geneva
Abegg C, Desideri J (2017) A probable case of multiple myeloma in a female individual from the Simon Identified Skeletal Collection (late 19th–early 20th century, Vaud, Switzerland). Int J Paleopathol 21:158–165. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpp.2017.02.001
Cignoni P, Callieri M, Corsini M, Dellepiane M, Ganovelli F, Ranzuglia G (2008) MeshLab: an open-source mesh processing tool. In 6th Eurographics Ital Chapter Conf, pp 129–136
Miranker M (2016) A comparison of different age estimation methods of the adult pelvis. J Forensic Legal Med 61:1173–1179
Calce SE (2012) A new method to estimate adult age-at-death using the acetabulum. Am J Phys Anthropol 148:11–23
Chai T, Draxler RR (2014) Root mean square error (RMSE) or mean absolute error (MAE)?—Arguments against avoiding RMSE in the literature. Geosci Model Dev 7:1247–1250
Tambusso PS, Mcdonald HG, Fariña RA (2015) Description of the stylohyal bone of a giant sloth (Lestodon armatus). Palaeontol Electron 18:1–10
González MÁM, Yravedra J, González-Aguilera D, Palomeque-González JF, Domínguez-Rodrigo M (2015) Micro-photogrammetric characterization of cut marks on bones. J Archaeol Sci 62:128–142
Edwards J, Rogers T (2017) The accuracy and applicability of 3D modeling and printing blunt force cranial injuries. J Forensic Sci 63:683–691. https://doi.org/10.1111/1556-4029.13627
Viciano J, López-Lázaro S, Pérez-Fernández Á, Amores-Ampuero A, D’Anastasio R, Jiménez-Triguero JM (2017) Scheuermann’s disease in a juvenile male from the late Roman necropolis of Torrenueva (3rd-4th century CE, Granada, Spain). Int J Paleopathol 18:26–37
Klein S, Avery M, Adams G, Pollard S, Simske S (2014) From scan to print: 3D printing as a means for replication. In: NIP & Digital fabrication conference. Society for imagining science and technology, pp 417–421
Porter ST, Roussel M, Soressi M (2016) A simple photogrammetry rig for the reliable creation of 3D artifact models in the field: lithic examples from the Early Upper Paleolithic sequence of Les Cottés (France). Adv Archaeol Pract 4:71–86
Massinon M, Dumont B, De Cock N, Salah SOT, Lebeau F (2015) Study of retention variability on an early growth stage herbaceous plant using a 3D virtual spraying model. Crop Prot 78:63–71
Secher JJ, Darvann TA, Pinholt EM (2017) Accuracy and reproducibility of the DAVID SLS-2 scanner in three-dimensional facial imaging. J Cranio-Maxillofacial Surg 45:1662–1670
Katz D, Suchey JM (1986) Age determination of the male os pubis. Am J Phys Anthropol 69:427–435
Savall F, Rérolle C, Hérin F, Dédouit F, Rougé D, Telmon N, Saint-Martin P (2016) Reliability of the Suchey-Brooks method for a French contemporary population. Forensic Sci Int 266:586–5e1
Mays S (2014) A test of a recently devised method of estimating skeletal age at death using features of the adult acetabulum. J Forensic Sci 59:184–187
Kimmerle EH, Konigsberg LW, Jantz RL, Baraybar JP (2008) Analysis of age-at-death estimation through the use of pubic symphyseal data. J Forensic Sci 53:558–568
Spradley MK, Jantz RL, Robinson A, Peccerelli F (2008) Demographic change and forensic identification: problems in metric identification of Hispanic skeletons. J Forensic Sci 53:21–28
Brůžek J, Murail P (2006) Methodology and reliability of sex determination from the skeleton. In: Schmitt A, Cunha E, Pinheiro J (eds) Forensic anthropology and medicine: complementary sciences from recovery to cause of death. Humana Press Inc., Totowa, pp 225–242
L’Abbé E, Steyn M (2012) The establishment and advancement of forensic anthropology South Africa. In: Dirkmaat DC (ed) A companion to forensic anthropology. Wiley-Blackwell, Malden, pp 626–638
Kim J (2017) Understanding population-specific age estimation using documented Asian skeletal samples. In: 86th Annual meeting of the american association of physical anthropologists, p 243
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the Department of Life Sciences, University of Coimbra, for providing access to the 21st Century Identified Skeletal Collection and the Coimbra Identified Skeletal Collection (CISC). We also thank Dr. Elena Kranioti for providing access to the Cretan Collection and Ms. Lada Šťovíčková for digitizing it. Last but not least, we would like to thank Dr. Jocelyn Desideri and those at the Laboratory of Prehistoric Archaeology and Anthropology of the University of Geneva for providing access to the Simon Collection, and to Dr. François Marchal for providing the David SLS-2 surface scanner. Finally, we would like to thank to Ms. Šárka Roušavá for the linguistic corrections.
Funding
This research has been supported by the research grant GAUK No. 642218.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kotěrová, A., Velemínská, J., Cunha, E. et al. A validation study of the Stoyanova et al. method (2017) for age-at-death estimation quantifying the 3D pubic symphyseal surface of adult males of European populations. Int J Legal Med 133, 603–612 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-018-1934-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-018-1934-1