Abstract
Nowadays, due to the global increase in migration movements, forensic age estimation of living young adults has become an important focus of interest. Minors often have no identification documents providing their correct birth dates. Establishing the age of majority is therefore fundamental in order to determine whether juvenile penal systems or penal systems in force for adults are to be applied. Radiological examination of the clavicles is one of the methods recommended by the Study Group on Forensic Age Diagnostics. In this retrospective study, a sample of chest radiographs of 274 subjects, aged between 12 and 25 years, was studied according to Schmeling’s method in order to examine the ossification of both medial clavicular epiphyses. All stage classifications were evaluated by five examiners. Intra- and inter-examiner reliability was analysed by Cohen’s K statistic. Intra-examiner agreement was insufficient for two of the experts. Inter-examiner agreement, among the other three operators, was moderate (K = 0.509). Study of reliability highlighted difficulties in interpretation, the need to select qualified personnel and choice of the best radiographic image in order to reduce any anatomic overlaps. Although ossification of the medial clavicular epiphyses is recommended to assess whether an individual has already reached the age of majority or not, these results suggested that it is very difficult to clearly identify the five stages of ossification by using conventional chest radiography.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Schmeling A, Garamendi PM, Prieto JL, Landa MI (2011) Forensic age estimation in unaccompanied minors and young living adults. In: Duarte NV (ed) Forensic medicine—from old problems to new challenges. InTech, Rijeka, pp 77–120
Schmeling A, Geserick G, Reisinger W, Olze A (2007) Age estimation. Forensic Sci Int 165:178–181
Schmeling A, Reisinger W, Geserick G, Olze A (2006) Age estimation of unaccompanied minors. Part I. General considerations. Forensic Sci Int 159S:S61–S64
Hjern A, Brendler-Lindqvist M, Norredam M (2011) Age assessment of young asylum seekers. Acta Paediatrica; doi:10.1111/j.1651-2227.2011.02476.x
Garamendi PM, Landa MI, Ballesteros J, Solano MA (2005) Reliability of the methods applied to assess age minority in living subjects around 18 years old. A survey on a Moroccan origin population. Forensic Sci Int 154:3–12
Schmeling A, Grundman C, Fuhrman A, Kaatsch HJ, Knell B, Ramstahler F, Reisinger W, Riepert T, Ritz-Timme S, Rosing FW, Rotzscher K, Geserick G (2008) Criteria for age estimation in living individuals. Int J Legal Med 122(6):457–460
Foti B, Lalys L, Adalian P, Giustiniani J, Maczel M, Signoli M, Dutour O, Leonetti G (2003) New forensic approach to age determination in children based on tooth eruption. Forensic Sci Int 132(1):49–56
Demirjian A, Goldstein H, Tanner JM (1973) A new system of dental age assessment. Hum Biol 45:211–227
Mincer HH, Harris EF, Berryman HE (1993) The A.B.F.O. study of third molar development and its use as an estimator of chronological age. J Forensic Sci 38:379–390
Cameriere R, Ferrante L, De Angelis D, Scarpino F, Galli F (2008) The comparison between measurement of open apices of third molars and Demirjian stages to test chronological age of over 18 year olds in living subjects. Int J Legal Med 122:493–497
Tanner M, Healy MJR, Goldstein H, Cameron N (2001) Assessment of skeletal maturity and prediction of adult height (TW3 method). Saunders, London
Roche AF, Cameron Chumlea W, Thissen D (1988) Assessing the skeletal maturity of the hand-wrist: FELS method. Charles C. Thomas, Springfield
Cameriere R, Ferrante L (2008) Age estimation in children by measurement of carpals and epiphyses of radius and ulna and open apices in teeth: a pilot study. Forensic Sci Int 174:60–63
Thevissen PW, Fieuws S, Willems G (2010) Human dental age estimation using third molar developmental stages: does a Bayesian approach outperform regression models to discriminate between juveniles and adults? Int J Legal Med 124(1):35–42
Tise M, Mazzarini L, Fabbrizzi G, Ferrante L, Giorgetti R, Tagliabracci A (2011) Applicability of Greulich and Pyle method for age assessment in forensic practice on an Italian sample. Int J Legal Med 125(3):411–416
Thevissen PW, Alqerban A, Asaumi J, Kahveci F, Kaur J, Kim YK, Pittayapat P, Van Vlierberghe M, Zhang Y, Fieuws S, Willems G (2010) Human dental age estimation using third molar developmental stages: accuracy of age predictions not using country specific information. Forensic Sci Int 201:106–111
Gunst K, Mesotten K, Carbonez A, Willems G (2003) Third molar root development in relation to chronological age: a large sample sized retrospective study. Forensic Sci Int 136:52–57
Rozkovcova E, Markova M, Mrklas L (2005) Third molar as an age indicator in young individuals. Prague Med Rep 106(4):367–398
Liversidge HM, Herdeg B, Rosing FW (1998) Dental age estimation of non adults. A review of methods and principles. In: Alt KW, Rosing FW, Teschler-Nicola M (eds) Dental anthropology fundamentals, limits, and prospects. Springer, New York, pp 419–442
Knell B, Ruhstaller P, Prieels F, Schmeling A (2009) Dental age diagnostics by means of radiographical evaluation of the growth stages of lower wisdom teeth. Int J Legal Med 6:465–469
Gardner E (1968) The embryology of the clavicle. Clin Orthop Relat Res 58:9–16
Neer CS (1960) Non-union of the clavicle. J Am Med Assoc 172:1006–1011
Todd TW, D’ Errico J (1928) The clavicular epiphyses. Am J Anat 41:25–50
McKern TW, Stewart TD (1957) Skeletal age changes in young American males. Analysed from the standpoint of age identification. In: Technical report EP 45. Quartermaster Research and Development Center, Environmental Protection Research Division. Natick, Massachusetts, pp. 89–971
Owings Webb PA, Myers Suchey J (1985) Epiphyseal union of the anterior iliac crest and medial clavicle in a modern multiracial sample of American males and females. Am J Phys Anthropol 68:457–466
MacLaughlin SM (1990) Epiphyseal fusion at the sternal end of the clavicle in a modern Portuguese skeletal sample. Antropol Port 8:59–68
Ji L, Terazawa K, Tsukamoto T, Haga K (1994) Estimation of age from epiphyseal union degrees of the sternal end of the clavicle. Hokkaido Igaku Zasshi 69:104–111
Black SM, Scheuer JL (1996) Age changes in the clavicle: from the early neonatal period to skeletal maturity. Int J Osteoarcheol 6:425–434
Shirley NR (2009) Age and sex estimation from the human clavicle: an investigation of traditional and novel methods. Dissertation. University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Singh J, Chavali KH (2011) Age estimation from clavicular epiphyseal union sequencing in a Northwest Indian population of the Chandigarh region. J Forensic Legal Med 18:82–87
Flecker H (1933) Roentgenographic observations of the times of appearance of epiphyses and their fusion with the diaphyses. J Anat 67:118–164
Galstaun G (1937) A study of ossification as observed in Indian subjects. Indian J Med Res 25:267–324
Jit I, Kullkarni M (1976) Times of appearance and fusion of epiphysis at the medial end of the clavicle. Indian J Med Res 64:773–782
Schmeling A, Schulz R, Reisinger W, Mühler M, Wernecke KD, Geserick G (2004) Studies on the time frame for ossification of medial clavicular epiphyseal cartilage in conventional radiography. Int J Legal Med 118:5–8
Garamendi PM, Landa MI, Botella MC, Alemán I (2011) Forensic age estimation on digital X-ray images: medial epiphyses of the clavicle and first rib ossification in relation to chronological age. J Forensic Sci 56:S3–S12
Kreitner K-F, Schweden F, Schild HH, Riepert T, Nafe B (1997) Die computertomographisch bestimmte Ausreifung der medialen Klavikulaepiphyse—eine additive Methode zur Altersbestimmung im Adoleszentenalter und in der dritten Lebensdekade? Fortschr Röntgenstr 166:481–486
Schulz R, Mühler M, Mutze S, Schmidt S, Reisinger W, Schmeling A (2005) Studies on the time frame for ossification of the medial epiphysis of the clavicle as revealed by CT scans. Int J Legal Med 119:142–145
Schulze D, Rother U, Fuhrmann A, Richel S, Faulmann G, Heiland M (2006) Correlation of age and ossification of the medial clavicular epiphysis using computed tomography. Forensic Sci Int 158:184–189
Bassed RB, Drummer OH, Briggs C, Valenzuela A (2010) Age estimation and the medial clavicular epiphysis: analysis of the age of majority in an Australian population using computed tomography. Forensic Sci Med Pathol. doi:10.1007/s12024-010-9200-y
Kellinghaus M, Schulz R, Vieth V, Schmidt S, Pfeiffer H, Schmeling A (2010) Enhanced possibilities to make statements on the ossification status of the medial clavicular epiphysis using an amplified staging scheme in evaluating thin-slice CT scans. Int J Legal Med 124:321–325
Kellinghaus M, Schulz R, Vieth V, Schmidt S, Schmeling A (2010) Forensic age estimation in living subjects based on the ossification status of the medial clavicular epiphysis as revealed by thin-slice multidetector computed tomography. Int J Legal Med 124:149–154
Schmidt S, Mühler M, Schmeling A, Reisinger W, Schulz R (2007) Magnetic resonance imaging of the clavicular ossification. Int J Legal Med 121:321–324
Hillewig E, De Tobel J, Cuche O, Vandemaele P, Piette M, Verstraete K (2011) Magnetic resonance imaging of the medial extremity of the clavicle in forensic bone age determination: a new four-minute approach. Eur Radiol 21:757–767
Schulz R, Zwiesigk P, Schiborr M, Schmidt S, Schmeling A (2008) Ultrasound studies on the time course of clavicular ossification. Int J Legal Med 122:163–167
Quirmbach F, Ramsthaler F, Verhoff MA (2009) Evaluation of the ossification of the medial clavicular epiphysis with a digital ultrasonic system to determine the age threshold of 21 years. Int J Legal Med 123:241–245
Cunha E, Baccino E, Martrille L, Ramsthaler F, Prieto JL, Schuliar Y, Lynnerup N, Cattaneo C (2009) The problem of ageing human remains and living individuals: a review. Forensic Sci Int 193:1–13
Cattaneo C, Baccino E (2002) A call for forensic anthropology in Europe. Int J Legal Med 116:N1–N2
Baccino E (2005) Forensic Anthropology Society of Europe (FASE): a subsection of IALM. Int J Legal Med 119:N1
Kreitner KF, Schweden FJ, Riepert T, Nafe B, Thelen M (1998) Bone age determination based on the study of the medial extremity of the clavicle. Eur Radiol 8:1116–1122
Ramsthaler F, Proschek P, Betz W, Verhoff MA (2009) How reliable are the risk estimates for X-ray examinations in forensic age estimations? A safety update. Int J Legal Med 123:199–204
Brenner DJ (2002) Estimating cancer risks from pediatric CT: going from the qualitative to the quantitative. Pediatr Radiol 32:228–233
Mühler M, Schulz R, Schmidt S, Schmeling A, Reisinger W (2006) The influence of slice thickness on assessment of clavicle ossification in forensic age diagnostics. Int J Legal Med 120:15–17
Galbraith KS (1999) Moving people: forced migration and international law. 13 Geo Immigr LJ 597
Cranston A (2000) Refugees in crisis. 3 Alt LJ 12
Feller E (2001) The UN and the protection of human rights: the evolution of the International Refugee Protection Regime. Washington J Law P 5:129–143
R Development Core Team (2008). R: a language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. ISBN 3-900051-07-0, URL http://www.R-project.org (Last access 12/03/2012)
Cohen J (1960) A coefficient of agreement for normal scales. Educ Psychol Meas 20:37–46
Light RJ (1971) Measures of response agreement for qualitative data: some generalizations and alternatives. Psychol Bull 76(5):365–377
Martín-de las Heras S, García-Fortea P, Ortega A, Zodocovich S, Valenzuela A (2008) Third molar development according to chronological age in populations of Spanish and Magrebian origin. Forensic Sci Int 174:47–53
Altman DG (1991) Practical statistics for medical research. Chapman & Hall, London
UNHCR (2011) Birth registration. UNICEF, Geneva. http://www.unhcr.org/4ed34f1c9.html (Last access 07/03/2012)
UNICEF (2005) The ‘rights’ start to life: a statistical analysis of birth registration. UNICEF, New York, pp 5–11
Kvittingen AV (2011) Negotiating childhood: age assessment in the UK asylum system. Working paper series Oxford: Refugee Studies Centre, Oxford Department of International Development, University of Oxford
UNHCR (2009) Guidelines on international protection: Child Asylum Claims under Articles 1(A)2 and 1(F) of the 1951 Convention and/or 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees
UNHCR (1997) Guidelines on policies and procedures on dealing with unaccompanied children seeking asylum, p 5
UNHCR (1994) Refugee children: guidelines on protection and care preface, Geneva
Willems G, Moulin-Romsee C, Solheim T (2002) Non-destructive dental-age calculation methods in adults: intra- and inter-observer effects. Forensic Sci Int 126:221–226
Thevissen PW, Pittayapat P, Fieuws S, Willems G (2009) Estimating age of majority on third molar developmental stages in young adults from Thailand using a modified scoring technique. J Forensic Sci 54(2):428–432
Huda W, Atherton JV, Ware DE, Cumming WA (1997) An approach for the estimation of effective radiation dose at CT in pediatric patients. Radiology 203:417–422
Maher MM, Kalra MK, Toth TL, Wittram C, Saini S, Shepard J (2004) Application of rational practice and technical advances for optimizing radiation dose for chest CT. J Thorac Imaging 19:16–23
Jurik AG, Jensen LC, Hansen J (1996) Radiation dose by spiral CT and conventional tomography of the sternoclavicular joints and the manubrium sterni. Skeletal Radiol 25:467–470
Schmeling A, Reisinger W, Geserick G, Olze A (2006) Age estimation of unaccompanied minors. Part I. General considerations. Forensic Sci Int 159(Suppl 1):S61–S64
Aynsley-Green A (2009) Unethical age assessment. Brit Dent J 206:337
Hall EJ (2009) Radiation biology for pediatric radiologists. Pediatr Radiol 39(suppl 1):57–64
Hall EJ, Brenner DJ (2008) Cancer risks from diagnostic radiology. Br J Radiol 81:362–378
Hogge JP, Messmer JM, Doan QN (1994) Radiographic identification of unknown human remains and interpreter experience level. J Forensic Sci 39(2):373–377
Koot MG, Sauer NJ, Fenton TW (2005) Radiographic human identification using bones of the hand: a validation study. J Forensic Sci 50(2):1–6
Pescarini L, Inches I (2006) Systematic approach to human error in radiology. Radiol Med 111:252–267
Robinson PJ (1997) Radiology’s Achilles’ heel: error and variation in the interpretation of the Rontgen image. Br J Radiol 70:1085–1098
Schmidt H, Köhler A, Zimmer EA, Freyschmidt J, Holthusen W (1993) Borderlands of normal and early pathologic findings in skeletal radiography. Georg Thieme, Stuttgart, pp 305–309
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank the staff of the Department of Radiology at Macerata Hospital (Italy) for their assistance on this project and also Ms. Gabriel Walton for editing the English text. The authors are also grateful to anonymous reviewers for their comments and suggestions which greatly improved the manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cameriere, R., De Luca, S., De Angelis, D. et al. Reliability of Schmeling’s stages of ossification of medial clavicular epiphyses and its validity to assess 18 years of age in living subjects. Int J Legal Med 126, 923–932 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-012-0769-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-012-0769-4