Radiation and Environmental Biophysics

, Volume 48, Issue 2, pp 169–179 | Cite as

Screening effects in risk studies of thyroid cancer after the Chernobyl accident

  • Jan Christian Kaiser
  • P. Jacob
  • M. Blettner
  • S. Vavilov
Original Paper


In this article scenarios have been developed, which simulate screening effects in ecological and cohort studies of thyroid cancer incidence among Ukrainians, whose thyroids have been exposed to 131I in the aftermath of the Chernobyl accident. If possible, the scenarios were based on directly observed data, such as the population size, dose distributions and thyroid cancer cases. Two scenarios were considered where the screening effect on baseline cases is either equal to or larger than that of radiation-related thyroid cancer cases. For ecological studies in settlements with more than ten measurements of the 131I activity in the human thyroid in May–June 1986, the screening bias appeared small (<19%) for all risk quantities. In the cohort studies, the excess absolute risk per dose was larger by a factor of 4 than in the general population. For an equal screening effect on baseline and radiation-related cancer (Scenario 1) the excess relative risk was about the same as in the general population. However, a differential screening effect (Scenario 2) produced a risk smaller by a factor of 2.5. A comparison with first results of the Ukrainian–US-American cohort study did not give any indication that a differential screening effect has a marked influence on the risk estimates. The differences in the risk estimates from ecological studies and cohort studies were explained by the different screening patterns in the general population and in the much smaller cohort. The present investigations are characterized by dose estimates for many settlements which are very weakly correlated with screening, the confounding variable. The results show that under these conditions ecological studies may provide risk estimates with an acceptable bias.


  1. Cardis E, Kesminiene A, Ivanov V, Malakhova I, Shibata Y, Khrouch V, Drozdovitch V, Maceika E, Zvonova I, Williams D (2005) Risk of thyroid cancer after exposure to 131I in childhood. J Natl Cancer Inst 97:724–732Google Scholar
  2. Davis S, Stepanenko V, Rivkind N, Kopecky KJ, Voillequé P, Shakhtarin V, Parshkov E, Kulikov S, Lushnikov E, Abrosimov A, Troshin V, Romanova G, Doroschenko V, Proshin A, Tsyb A (2004) Risk of thyroid cancer in the Bryansk oblast of the Russian Federation after the Chernobyl power station accident. Radiat Res 162:241–248CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Franssila KO, Harrach HR (1986) Occult papillary carcinoma of the thyroid in children and young adults. Cancer 58:715–719CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Ivanov VK, Gorski AI, Maksioutov MA, Vlasov OK, Godko AM, Tsyb AF, Tirmarche M, Valenty M, Verger P (2003) Thyroid cancer incidence among adolescents and adults in the Bryansk region of Russia following the Chernobyl accident. Health Phys 84(1):46–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Ivanov VK, Gorski AI, Tsyb AF, Maksioutov MA, Tumanov KA, Vlasov OK (2006) Radiation-epidemiological studies of thyroid cancer incidence among children and adolescents in the Bryansk oblast of Russia after the Chernobyl accident (1991–2001 follow-up period). Radiat Environ Biophys 45(1):9–16CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Jacob P, Bogdanova TI, Buglova E, Chepurniy M, Demidchik Y, Kenigsberg J, Meckbach R, Schotola C, Shinkarev S, Tronko MD, Ulanovsky A, Vavilov S, Walsh L (2006a) Thyroid cancer risk in areas of Ukraine and Belarus affected by the Chernobyl accident. Radiat Res 165:1–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Jacob P, Bogdanova TI, Buglova E, Chepurniy M, Demidchik Y, Gavrilin Y, Kenigsberg J, Kruk J, Schotola C, Shinkarev S, Tronko MD, Vavilov S (2006b) Thyroid cancer among Ukrainians and Belarussians, who were childrens or adolescents at the time of the Chernobyl accident. J Radiol Prot 26:51–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Kalbfleisch JD, Prentice RL (1980) The statistical analysis of failure time data. Wiley, New YorkMATHGoogle Scholar
  9. Kopecky KJ, Stepanenko V, Rivkind N, Voillequé P, Onstad L, Shaktarin V, Parshkov E, Kulikov S, Lushnikov E, Abrosimov A, Troshin V, Romanova G, Doroschenko V, Proshin A, Tsyb A, Davis S (2006) Childhood thyroid cancer, radiation dose from Chernobyl, and dose uncertainties in Bryansk oblast, russia: a population-based case control study. Radiat Res 166:367–374CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Lang W, Borrush H, Bauer L (1988) Occult carcinomas in the thyroid. Evaluation of 1020 sequential autopsies. Am J Clin Pathol 90:72–76Google Scholar
  11. Likhtarov I, Kovgan L, Vavilov S, Chepurny M, Bouville A, Luckyanov N, Jacob P, Voillequé P, Voigt G (2005) Post-Chernobyl thyroid cancers in Ukraine. Report 1: estimation of thyroid doses. Radiat Res 163:125–136CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Likhtarov L, Kovgan L, Vavilov S, Chepurny M, Ron E, Lubin J, Bouville A, Tronko N, Bogdanova T (2006) Post-Chernobyl thyroid cancers in Ukraine, Report 2: risk analysis. Radiat Res 166:375–386CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Lubin JH (1998) On the discrepancy between epidemiologic studies in individuals of lung cancer and residential radon and Cohen’s ecologic regression. Health Phys 75(1):4–20ADSGoogle Scholar
  14. Lubin JH (2002) The potential for bias in Cohen’s ecological analysis of lung cancer and residential radon. J Radiol Prot 22:141–148CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Schneider AB, Ron E, Lubin J, Stovall M, Gierlowski TC (1993) Dose–response relationships for radiation-induced thyroid cancer and thyroid nodules: evidence for the prolonged effect of radiation on the thyroid. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 77:362–369CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Shakhtarin V, Tsyb A, Stepanenko V, Orlov M, Kopecky K, Davis S (2003) Iodine deficiency, radiation dose, and the risk of thyroid cancer among children and adolescents in the Bryansk region of Russia following the Chernobyl power station accident. Int J Epidemiol 32:584–591CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Stezhko VA, Buglova EE, Danilova LI, Drozd VM, Krysenko NA, Lesnikova NR, Minenko VF, Ostapenko VA, Petrenko SV, Polyanskaya ON, Rzheutski VA, Tronko MD, Bobylyova OO, Bogdanova TI, Ephstein OV, Kairo IA, Kostin OV, Likhtarev IA, Markov VV, Oliynik VA, Shpak VM, Tereshchenko VP, Zamotayeva GA, Beebe GW, Bouville AC, Brill AB, Burch JD, Fink DJ, Greenebaum E, Howe GR, Luckyanov NK, Masnyk IJ, McConnell RJ, Robbins J, Thomas TL, Voillequé PG, Zablotska LB (2004) A cohort study of thyroid cancer and other thyroid diseases after the Chernobyl accident: objectives, design and methods. Radiat Res 161:481–492. Chornobyl Thyroid Diseases Study Group of Belarus, Ukraine, and the USACrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Tronko MD, Bogdanova TI, Komisarenko IV, Epshtein OV, Likhtaryov IA, Markov VV, Oliynyk VA, Tereshchenko VP, Shpak VM, Voillequé P (1999) Thyroid carcinoma in children and adolescents in Ukraine after the Chernobyl accident: statistical data and clinicomorphic characteristics. Cancer 86:149–156CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Tronko MD, Bobylyova OO, Bogdanova TI, Epshtein OV, Likhtaryov IA, Markov VV, Oliynyk VA, Tereshchenko VP, Shpak VM, Beebe G, Bouville A, Brill A, Burch D, Fink D, Greenebaum E, Howe G, Luckyanov N, Masnyk I, McConnell R, Robbins J, Thomas T, Voillequé P (2003) Thyroid gland and radiation (Ukrainian–American thyroid project). In: Shibata Y, Yamashita S, Watanabe M, Tomonaga M (eds) Radiation and humankind. Elsevier, Amsterdam, vol 1258, International Congress Series, pp 91–104. Proceedings of the 1st Nagasaki symposium of the international consortium for medical care of Hibakusha and radiation life science, Nagasaki, Japan, 21–22 February 2003Google Scholar
  20. Tronko MD, Howe GR, Bogdanova TI, Bouville AC, Epstein OV, Brill AB, Likhtarev IA, Fink DJ, Markov VV, Greenebaum E, Olijnyk VA, Masnyk IJ, Shpak VM, McConnell RJ, Tereshchenko VP, Robbins J, Zvinchuk OV, Zablotska LB, Hatch M, Luckyanov NK, Ron E, Thomas TL, Voillequé PG, Beebe GW (2006) A cohort study of thyroid cancer and other thyroid diseases after the Chernobyl accident: thyroid cancer in Ukraine detected during first screening. J Natl Cancer Inst 98:897–903CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. USSR (1991) The USSR 1989 census: the age-by-sex population distribution of the UkSSR. The UkSSR Ministry of Statistics Publication, KievGoogle Scholar
  22. Wakefield J (2004) A critique of statistical aspects of ecological studies in spatial epidemiology. Environ Ecol Stat 11:31–54CrossRefMathSciNetGoogle Scholar
  23. Whelan SL, Ferlay J, Teppo L, Thomas DB (2003) Cancer incidence in five continents. International Agency for Research on Cancer, Lyon, vol VIII. IARC Scientific Publications No. 156Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag 2009

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jan Christian Kaiser
    • 1
  • P. Jacob
    • 1
  • M. Blettner
    • 2
  • S. Vavilov
    • 3
  1. 1.Helmholtz-Zentrum München, German Research Centre for Environmental HealthInstitute of Radiation ProtectionNeuherbergGermany
  2. 2.Institut für Medizinische BiometrieEpidemiologie und Informatik Johannes Gutenberg-Universität MainzMainzGermany
  3. 3.Radiation Protection InstituteAcademy of Technological SciencesKievUkraine

Personalised recommendations