Extreme ultraviolet tomography of multi-jet gas puff target for high-order harmonic generation

Abstract

A volume, tomographic reconstruction of a novel, multi-jet gas puff target, developed for possible applications in high-order harmonic generation (HHG), is presented. The target, produced by pulsed injection of argon gas through nozzle in a form of linearly oriented small orifices, has been characterized in the extreme ultraviolet at 13.5 nm wavelength. Target density estimations were performed, and 3-D representation of pulsed gaseous target has been obtained by combining 2-D shadowgram images, recorded at various rotation angles. More detailed information about higher-order jets, formed as a result of collisions of primary jets, was obtained. Tomographic studies of such type of targets dedicated for HHG have been obtained to our knowledge for the first time.

Introduction

The characterization measurements of pulsed gas jets, gas puff targets, array of gas jets and dual-gas multi-jet targets proved to be useful in efficient generation of extreme ultraviolet (EUV) and soft X-ray (SXR) radiation [1, 2] and was already reported in a variety of papers, [3–10], using different diagnostic methods. The most common method that was used in the characterization measurements of various target systems is laser interferometry [11, 12]. Other studies show the possibility to perform characterization of rapidly evolving (in the nanosecond time scale) gaseous targets using shadowgraphy techniques [13–15]. In this study, however, to extract even more complete information about those targets, we combined radiography technique (shadowgraphy) [16], with tomography, which is capable of rendering 3-D objects from multiple projections.

Detailed characterization of target density is essential for quasi-phase-matching (QPM) in high-order harmonic generation (HHG) employing modulated density media and may strongly increase energy conversion efficiency [17–20]. QPM has been proven experimentally using gas-filled capillaries [21], gas-filled hollow-core fibers with a modulated inner diameter [22], coherent superposition of harmonics generated in two successive sources by the same laser pulse [23], however, with limited or no characterization measurements of gas density profiles in the laser interaction region, which are essential to perform numerical simulations and to understand the QPM process.

In this paper, we present application of EUV tomography to combine 2-D shadowgram projections into a volume reconstruction of multi-jet modulated density gas puff target for more precise study of the target density. This target, developed in our group, might have potential application for phase-matching in HHG experiments. 2-D projections alone are often insufficient for in-depth target characterization, especially if accurate density profiles are required. Tomographic method using hard X-ray energy range was already proven for nondestructive observing of the internal structure of selected objects across a wide range of scientific [24], industrial [25] and especially medical applications [26], for imaging biological tissues [27, 28]. The tissues belong to the group of materials with low atomic number and low density, which is very similar to the gas objects [29]. These samples usually exhibit very low absorption contrast in the hard X-ray energy range [30, 31]. Therefore, the selection of appropriate energy range (wavelength) considering the absorption of a sample is very important. Heavier elements with a higher atomic number require a shorter wavelength, or vice versa. For our gas target, the EUV backlighting method at 13.5 nm wavelength was used, based on the source described in detail in [32]. The target was formed by pulsed injection of gas through nozzle in a form of small orifices drilled in in-line geometry. Pulsed operation mode allows for sufficient removal of gas from the chamber and operation at ~10⁻³ to 10⁻⁴ mbar chamber pressure during the valve operation, limiting EUV reabsorption in the neutral, residual gas. This method allows for imaging of target density features, unseen previously directly from EUV shadowgrams, which can now be studied in detail. The results of the studies will be useful for research on HHG and for understanding of the HHG process. Moreover, this method can be immediately applied to characterize targets used in experiments related to e-beam acceleration, ion acceleration, generation of EUV and SXR radiation, laser–matter interaction and EUV and SXR lasers.

Experimental arrangement for EUV tomography

The gas target is backlighted with EUV pulses at 13.5 nm wavelength at various angles, rendering 2-D projections of the object, and later, by combining those projections, we were able to obtain 3-D rendering of operating gas puff target.

The EUV pulses have been obtained by spectral selection of a xenon plasma emission. The spectral narrowing was performed using thin-film filters and a Mo/Si multilayer mirror. Similar technique has been previously applied for characterization of gas jet xenon targets [33], elongated geometry gas targets [15] and multi-jet gas puff targets [13].

The experimental setup for EUV shadowgraphy, described in details elsewhere [14], is depicted in Fig. 1a. Pulses of EUV radiation are produced using a compact laser plasma EUV source based on a double-stream Xe/He gas puff target. More details about source optimization can be found in [34]. Emission at central wavelength λ = 13.5 nm with the bandwidth of about 1 nm was obtained using a flat Mo/Si multilayer mirror, positioned at 45° incidence angle for its theoretical peak reflectivity at λ = 13.5 nm of about 38 % (measured value ~31 %). Additionally to eliminate longer wavelengths from Xe plasma, including the visible light, a composite Zr/Si₃N₄ filter was used. The thickness of each layer was 200 nm. Spectral measurements were performed using a transmission grating spectrometer (TGS), equipped with a 4 μm period, free-standing grating located 720 mm from the plasma. An entrance slit, 33 μm in width, was positioned ~4 mm from the grating. A normalized Xe plasma emission spectrum, transmission curves of thin-film filters, the reflectivity curve of the Mo/Si mirror and the EUV spectrum after spectral filtration are depicted in Fig. 2. Spectrally narrowed, quasi-monochromatic, pulsed EUV radiation with inverse relative bandwidth of λ/Δλ = 13.5 illuminates gaseous target produced by electromagnetic valve system.

Fig. 1

Experimental arrangement for EUV tomography setup of a multi-jet modulated gas puff target. (a) Photographs of the valve (b) and the nozzles—small inset in the image. Argon was supplied to all seven nozzles

Fig. 2

Spectra obtained using TGS showing the EUV emission from Xe plasma, transmission curves for all filters, reflectivity curve for the Mo/Si mirror and the EUV spectrum of radiation used in the tomography experiment after spectral narrowing. Transmission/reflection curves are calculated based on data available from [37]

The gaseous target was formed by nozzles, supplied with gas pressurized inside gas reservoirs. The flow of the gas is controlled by a fast-acting electromagnetic valve. The valve can operate with gas backing pressures up to 5 bars. The nozzles form a multi-jet gas puff target by a repeatable and periodic modulation of gaseous target density. To facilitate the use of this kind of target in HHG experiments, we used argon gas.

Previously, as reported in [14], this target was preliminarily characterized and it was found that the target density profiles depend on a few parameters, such as the nozzle geometry, backing pressures of gas or gasses, supplied to the valve, the time duration of gas flow and finally on the mode of operation. The information on the target density profiles is very important for source development-related research (including HHG); however, obtaining two-dimensional density maps and later, density profiles, does not allow to obtain a complete, 3-D picture of the investigated object (target). Thus, in this study, we employed a tomography to visualize in 3-D at the lithographic wavelength of 13.5 nm, a rapidly changing phenomenon of a gaseous target formation. For that, we use arrangement of seven orifices in in-line geometry, similar to the work described in [14], each 0.5 mm in diameter, with period equal to 1 mm. The orifices were electrodrilled in 8-mm-thick stainless steel plate, yielding a diameter to length aspect ratio of 1:16. The entire valve, depicted in Fig. 1b, was mounted on top of a high-resolution rotation stage (model 8MR174-11, from Standa) to ensure rotation of the valve and nozzles while acquiring projections.

To form a stable gas target, the valves supplying Ar gas to the nozzles were opened and closed, synchronously with the Nd:YAG laser, for the duration of 2 ms, after which the EUV pulse arrived. Shadowgrams are produced by the EUV light illuminating the target, locally and partially absorbed by the gas, forming an intensity image at the detector plane, further downstream the EUV beam. For each angle Θ, depicted schematically in Fig. 1a, the shadowgrams of the multi-jet gas puff target were registered using a back-illuminated charge-coupled device (CCD) camera, X-vision M-25 (from Reflex company, Czech Republic), equipped with 512 × 512 pixels CCD chip, 0.5 × 0.5 in². in size. The distances between the source to the characterized target and the source to the CCD camera were 880 and 995 mm, respectively. Geometrical magnification of our system is equal to 1.13×. Assuming EUV source size ~200 μm, measured previously using pinhole camera, the spatial resolution possible to achieve in this configuration is approximately 30 μm, which corresponds roughly to a size of a single CCD pixel (~25 μm). This was confirmed experimentally by measuring resolution using a knife-edge criterion in shadowgrams at the edge of the valve, which results in a value of 1.5 pixels or ~38 μm. The resolution might be further improved by moving the object closer to the detector; however, the ultimate resolution limit is the CCD pixel size. To ensure a proper pixel segmentation number of equiangular projections N _p has to fulfill the condition (1):

$$N_{\text{p}} \ge \frac{\pi }{2} \cdot N_{\text{d}}$$

(1)

where N _d is a number of detector pixels in the plane of object rotation. The angular step Θ can be calculated as Θ ≤ 2π/N _p and in this experiment is equal to Θ < 0.45°, thus we chose Θ = 0.4^o and the number of projections equal to 900. The CCD chip was cooled down to −20 °C to decrease its thermal, intrinsic noise. To obtain each shadowgram (projection), 5 EUV pulses were acquired using the CCD camera, in order to minimize a shot-to-shot variation in EUV pulse energy and to statistically average the gas transmission in each shadowgram, which in turn is beneficial for the accuracy of further 3-D reconstruction.

EUV tomography results

The tomography of the target has been performed for argon backing pressure of 1.5 bar. The EUV shadowgrams for Θ = 0^o and Θ = 90^o are depicted in Fig. 3a, c. Shadowgram in Fig. 3a shows that characteristic gas jets are produced as a result of free expansion of gas from the orifices into a vacuum. Such gas jets are typical for sonic expansion of gas flowing through a small orifice (sonic nozzle) under high pressure [4].

Fig. 3

EUV shadowgrams (raw data) of multi-jet gas puff target produced by supplying Ar gas to the nozzles at 1.5 bar backing pressure, for variable rotation angle Θ = 0^o and 90° (a and c, respectively). 2-D density map (b) obtained from EUV shadowgram (a) using data from image (c) to obtain path-length d(y) for density calculations

If argon is supplied to nozzles surrounded by similar nozzles, secondary jets are forming as a result of collision between two jets originating from the nozzles—primary jets. For larger distances ~2.7 mm from the nozzle, one can observe formation of the tertiary jets as a result of collision between the secondary jets. The number of the secondary jets is at one smaller than the number of the primary jets. This mode of operation is similar to the data presented in [14], where only one kind of gas was supplied to all nozzles. Detailed study of gas backing pressure dependence on the target formation can also be found elsewhere [14, 15].

From the shadowgrams in Fig. 3a, c, it was possible to obtain the density of the target. The gas density maps of the 3-D gas density distributions were calculated from the EUV shadowgrams using the Eq. (2):

$$\rho (x,y) = \frac{{ - \ln \left[ {{\text{Tr}}(x,y)} \right]}}{{\mu_{a} \cdot d(y)}} \cdot m_{at}$$

(2)

where Tr(x, y) is a 2-D transmission map of the gas puff target, μ _a = 2r ₀ · λ · f ₂ is an atomic photoabsorption cross section, r ₀ = 2.82 × 10⁻¹⁵ m is the classical electron radius, λ = 13.5 nm is the wavelength, f ₂ is the imaginary part of the atomic scattering factor, d(y) is the path-length on which the EUV beam is absorbed in the gas, measured in direction of the EUV beam, horizontally, as indicated in Fig. 3c, m _at is the atomic mass of the gas puff target material and (x, y) are spatial coordinates at the detector plane, horizontal and vertical, respectively. The 1-D path-length d(y) can be found by measuring averaged FWHM widths of the density sections, obtained at various distances from the nozzle oriented as in Fig. 3c. The FWHM widths, corresponding to the path-lengths, are then interpolated to find analytical equations, d(y), describing the path-length as a function of a distance from the nozzle plane y. It needs to be stressed that this method is greatly simplified, thus not highly accurate, however, allows to find the 2-D density maps for 3-D density distributions, assuming a uniform path-length d(y) in orthogonal direction to the x–y imaging plane. For the density calculations, we also assumed a monochromatic radiation; however, due to a certain bandwidth of the EUV radiation, equal to ~1 nm, measured as a FWHM of the spectrum depicted in Fig. 2b, there is additionally an error associated with slightly different absorption of the EUV radiation at different wavelengths. The 2-D density map obtained from shadowgram data is presented in Fig. 3b. The modulation depth of the gas density profiles in this case reaches 70 %, 1.2 mm away from the nozzle plane, with maximum and minimum attainable densities of Ar equal to 2.3 × 10¹⁸ and 6.6 × 10¹⁷ atoms/cm³, respectively, in the region where the secondary jets are forming.

Density resolution was also assessed as the smallest density change which this setup is capable of detecting. This can be estimated directly from Fig 3b—a density map, for higher-order jets, where we can see primary jets very well (7 orifices above the nozzle plane reaching 5 × 10¹⁸ atoms/cm³), then secondary jets (2–3 × 10¹⁸ atoms/cm³) and tertiary jets (1–1.5 × 10¹⁸ atoms/cm³) up to a distance of −4 mm on vertical axis. Fourth-order jets are much more difficult to see; however, three of them (of four) are visible at ~−6 mm distance (reaching density <1 × 10¹⁸ atoms/cm³). There is also some gas, surrounding fourth-order jets, with density down to 3 × 10¹⁷ atoms/cm³ and, in our opinion, it is on the edge of detecting capability for our setup.

Using a full data set of 900 radiography projections with additional 50 shadowgrams without the gas target—flat-field images, we performed a tomographic reconstruction of the gas puff target. The flat-field images (the valve was closed during shadowgram acquisition) were obtained before and after data set acquisition. Figure 4 shows a sequence of a few EUV shadowgram images of the target recorded over π/2 rotation angle.

Fig. 4

Sequence of a few EUV shadowgram images of the target over π/2 rotation angle

The standard reconstruction algorithm for parallel beam geometry in Octopus software [35] was used for processing of 2-D radiography projections into CT slices. VGStudio 2.1.5 software (http://www.volumegraphics.com) was used for stacking of CT slices and for the three-dimensional rendering and visualization. The slices were generated from projection data with a voxel size of (25 µm)³. Some of those slices are presented in Fig. 5b–i for planes represented by dashed lines in Fig. 5a at various distances from the nozzle plane y. The dark numbers for each slice represent the slice number (1–512), starting from the very top of 2-D projections down. The white numbers were recalculated distances from the nozzle exit plane, based on the voxel size. The white areas represent regions with increased electron density, while the circular pattern present in all images is associated with the reconstruction artifacts. In Fig. 5b, only extruded part of the valve can be seen. Directly above the nozzle (Fig. 5c), the gas jets, formed by the nozzles (primary jets), are present. The number of gas jets corresponds to the number of the nozzles. As expected, the gas jets are circularly symmetric, even though it is not immediately evident from the data. Approximately 200 µm away from the nozzles, secondary jets are formed in between the primary jets (Fig. 5d). Their number is at one less than the number of primary jets. From the top view, we can observe directly the cross section of those jets and precisely evaluate their shape which is impossible to see directly just from the 2-D projections. Small inset in Fig. 5d shows the initial moment of formation of the secondary jets. If we are moving away from the nozzles, at the distance of ~1 mm, the main contribution to the reconstructed electron density is from the secondary jets, as can be seen in Fig. 5e. There is still, however, some gas density in between the secondary jets, which might be attributed to the primary jets. Moreover, we can also change the duty cycle of the modulated gaseous target by adjusting the distance from the nozzles. As can be observed in Fig. 5f, at ~1.4 mm away, the duty cycle for modulated target approaches 50 %, more than in Fig. 5e, which was ~30 %. This is a very important feature that might be useful for HHG phase-matching to increase the conversion efficiency of the process. In the region, where secondary jets start to overlap (Fig. 5g), there is no density modulation, as presented in the corresponding slice; however, ~400 µm above that plane, we can again clearly observe some modulation associated with the formation of the tertiary jets as shown in Fig. 5h. Those jets, although less visible due to reduced density of ~1.75 × 10¹⁸ atoms/cm³ (~2.8 mm away from the nozzle plane), still change their width, and thus, the duty cycle for modulated density target can be optimized for efficient HHG in that region as well (Fig. 5i).

Fig. 5

Slices produced in the reconstruction process (b–i) for planes represented by dashed lines in (a) for various distances y from the nozzle plane. The dark numbers are the slice number (1–512), starting from the very top of 2-D projections down. The white numbers indicate distances from the nozzle exit plane. The white areas represent regions with increased electron density, while the circular pattern, present in all the images, is associated with the reconstruction artifacts

This is in accordance with the sinogram data. Sinogram is obtained as a set of projection vectors $\vec{x}$, obtained from 2-D shadowgrams at a particular distance from the nozzle y versus the projection angle Θ, which is depicted in Fig. 6a. The sinograms for various reconstruction planes (slices) are presented in Fig. 6b–e and correspond directly to slices presented in Fig. 5c, d, e, i, because they were obtained at precisely the same distances from the nozzle plane y. Figure 6b represents angular distribution of the projection data just above the nozzle, where only primary jets are present. Those jets are visible from 120° to 240° angles, over more than 60° on each side of the central projection at 180°. 225 µm above that plane, secondary jets start to emerge in between strong primary jets, which is depicted in Fig. 6c. At 1 mm above the nozzle plane (Fig. 6d), contribution of secondary jets is most significant; moreover, their angular spread is reduced to ΔΘ ~ 40°. Weakly visible tertiary jets are also present in the sinogram data (Fig. 6e), with angular spread of ΔΘ ~ 16^o. Smaller angular spread means that their path-length d(y) is much larger than of the other jets.

Fig. 6

Scheme for generating sinograms (a) and sinograms (b–e) obtained for various distances from the nozzle plane y corresponding to slices presented in Fig. 5c–e, i)

Modulation profiles were also obtained directly from slices and are presented in Fig. 7. Figure 7a corresponds to slice from Figs. 5c, 7b to 5d,…, etc. The profiles in Fig. 7a, b show very pronounced primary jets with saturated intensity in the reconstructed image. In Fig. 7b, small secondary jets appear, visible in the profile image, just in between strong primary jets. Those secondary jets are dominating the profile in Fig. 7c, producing rectangular density profile with lower duty cycle. Figure 7d depicts similar profile with higher duty cycle in the density modulation plot. Figure 7e shows no periodic structure in the density plot, due to previously explained collision of the secondary jets; however, Fig. 7f, g shows once again modulation originating from the formation of tertiary jets. Modulation depth of the density profile, formed by tertiary jets, is much smaller than in case of secondary jets (for data in Fig. 7c equal to ~31 %) and is equal to ~8 % (Fig. 7f) or ~4 % of the reconstruction dynamic range from 0 to 255 shades of gray. Combining the slices, we obtain a volumetric reconstruction of the multi-jet target. The result of 3-D tomographic reconstruction can be seen in Fig. 8, while the short movie of rotating 3-D target can be found in supplementary materials online.

Fig. 7

Modulation profiles obtained directly from slices presented in Fig. 5, with 8 bits dynamic range of gray levels. Insets and profiles correspond to slices in Fig. 5

Fig. 8

Three-dimensional visualization of the reconstructed gas puff target showing primary and secondary gas jets. Additionally, positions of the nozzles were schematically indicated. Movie of rotating 3-D target can be found in supplementary materials online

Preliminary high-order harmonic generation measurements for modulated density gas puff targets

Modulated density targets might be used in the future to enhance the conversion process in HHG. To achieve that a phase-matching between the laser fundamental beam and the harmonics, generated by coherent addition of HHG signal from a large collection of atoms, is required. It was theoretically demonstrated that HHG phase-matching in targets with modulated density will increase HHG signal, as reported in [20].

To prove that we have performed initial measurements of HHG signal from an array of seven nozzles, each 0.5 mm in diameter, arranged equidistantly in-line geometry over a distance of 9 mm (~1.3 mm period) and compared the emission to non-modulated target having the same length. The example result of spectral measurements for 21–31 harmonics is presented in Fig. 9, for argon gas backing pressure of 1 bar, λ = 810 nm wavelength, t = 40 fs, E ~ 1 mJ pulses, focused by an f = 750 mm lens onto a targets 1.5 mm above the nozzle exit. The diameter of the focus at FWHM was 90 µm, giving the laser intensity in the focus of about 10¹⁴ W/cm². The modulated target density, measured using a shadowgraphy technique, was equal (2.16 ± 0.13) × 10¹⁸ atoms/cm³ across secondary gas jet and (1.53 ± 0.06) × 10¹⁸ atoms/cm³ between two jets, at the target density duty cycle equal to 37 %. Target density measured for the slit nozzles was equal to (1.79 ± 0.15) × 10¹⁸ atoms/cm³. Error quoted here is a ±standard deviation from 20 measurements. The spectrum was measured using reflective diffraction grating (1,200 groves/mm) coupled to a back-illuminated CCD camera, sensitive to the EUV radiation (Andor, model DX440-BN). The increase in signal is modest at this time, ~100 % for most intense harmonics, due to the fact that the design of the nozzles was not particularly optimized for that purpose; however, it promises improvement in HHG efficiency and is a part of an ongoing work including simulations and experimental confirmation, which cannot be currently presented. Employing modulated density targets also allows tweaking the HHG emission spectrum, by channeling the energy flow to different harmonics, which was recently demonstrated in [36].

Fig. 9

Spectral measurements for 9-mm-long modulated density gas puff target (dashed line) and for 9-mm-long slit nozzle with near-constant density (solid line)

Conclusions

In summary, we have performed the tomographic reconstruction of the multi-jet gas puff target by combining shadowgraphy projection images into a 3-D reconstruction volume. Reconstructed gas jets compose a uniform, modulated density gas-comb-like pattern. The spatial density profiles along the nozzle array are strongly modulated. Their density and shape depend on the distance from the nozzle, which was experimentally studied in detail in this paper. Those results might be of high importance to optimize and characterize possible targets for phase-matched HHG and in turn possible future applications of improved efficiency of HHG sources. Some additional information regarding the secondary jets might be directly observed only form 3-D reconstructions. Even though the contrast of the shadowgram is not high, due to small gas backing pressure used in the experiment, the tomographic technique is capable of visualizing gas density distribution in the range of 10¹⁸ atoms per cm³ in much detail.