The benthic diversity, abundance and biomass showed clear seasonal patterns with the highest values recorded in the spring and the lowest in the summer and winter. Seasonality was evident for both meio- and macrofauna. Vertical fluxes of organic and mineral matter controlled both the food supply and substrate conditions and seemed to be the driving factors for the observed seasonal changes in the diversity and standing stocks of benthic biota. The results of the RDA indicate the high impact of both organic and inorganic fluxes on benthos, suggesting that both physical disturbances, caused by inorganic matter supplied with glacial meltwaters, and the food supply can drive changes in the benthic structure.
Winter abundance and biomass
In the winter months, the macrobenthic biomass was much lower than that observed in the spring or summer. The density and number of taxa were also slightly lower. In November of 2006, the meiofaunal abundance and biomass were relatively high. In February of 2007, the abundance was slightly higher than the annual minimum, and the biomass was low. In October of 2007, increases in the meio- and macrofaunal densities and biomass were observed. During the winter the rivers were frozen, and the terrestrial material supply was at an absolute minimum, resulting in relatively undisturbed substrate conditions for the benthic fauna when compared to the summer conditions. Winter is also a period when food supply is limited—primary production during polar night is stunted. Despite this fact, the particulate organic matter (POM) flux in the near-bottom layer was comparable to the values observed in May (Zajączkowski et al. 2010). The main food source during this period was probably provided by resuspended particles in the near-bottom water layers and/or organic matter deposited in sediments. Atypically high meiofaunal abundance and diversity in November 2006 probably resulted mainly from the reduction of the disturbance level due to a lower sedimentation rate, compared to summer months.
Spring abundance and biomass
The highest benthic abundance and diversity was documented in April, immediately after the phytoplankton bloom when recently produced organic matter became available (Fig. 10). The spring phytoplankton bloom is responsible for most of the total annual organic carbon supply to Arctic fjord marine ecosystems (Wiktor 1999). In Arctic ecosystems, the timing and rates of primary production is related to the presence and thickness of the sea ice cover. The most important effect of sea ice observed in West Greenland is the shortening of the productive period. Sea ice, covered with snow, reflects almost all the sunlight, and the phytoplankton bloom can occur only after the ice disappears (Petersen 1977). Petersen (1964) noted that the peak of primary production in the Disko Bay (West Greenland) took place in May–June, just after the ice breakup. A similar situation was observed in Adventfjorden in 1995 when the phytoplankton bloom occurred in May after the ice cover was reduced from 65 to 15 cm, and the euphotic zone extended to 15 m (Wiktor 1999). In winter 2006/2007, water in Adventfjorden was not sufficiently cooled to form an ice cover. The lack of sea ice advanced the primary production and accelerated the bloom. The main phytoplankton biomass appeared in April. High numbers of zooplankton occurred as a response to the phytoplankton bloom, exerting considerable grazing pressure on the particulate matter and phytoplankton population. Furthermore, increased grazing did not seem to be followed by an increase in the faecal pellet vertical flux. The Adventfjorden zooplankton in the spring consisted mostly of Cirripedia nauplii, which produce small faecal pellets that probably remain in suspension (Zajączkowski et al. 2010). Glud et al. (2007) predicted that primary production in Young Sound, Greenland would benefit from the thinning of sea ice and increase import of nutrients, resulting from the increased exchange between the fjord and the Greenland Sea as a result of climate change. This would lead to an increase in primary production and organic matter sedimentation and thus to an intensification of the decomposition processes at the sea bottom. The higher sedimentation would stimulate the development of benthic communities, but intensive bacterial mineralisation would reduce oxygen availability in the sediment. In Adventfjorden enhanced primary productivity did not lead to increased sedimentation. Heavy grazing pressure combined with a small number of faecal pellets resulted in a lower flux of organic matter, compared with previous ice-covered years (Zajączkowski et al. 2010). From a benthic perspective, the lower organic flux means a reduction of the food base, and this can result in a reduction of the standing stocks of benthic communities.
The highest numbers of juveniles were observed in the spring months (April and May). The effect of recruitment, apart from fluxes of suspended matter, may be another factor that contributes to the seasonal changes of benthic standing stocks. In an Arctic environment, phytoplankton outburst seems to be an inducing factor for the spawning of many invertebrate species (Petersen 1977). Petersen (1978) observed the highest feeding and breeding activity of mollusks in the Disko Bugt (West Greenland) during the spring bloom, when temperature was still low. To match in time with the spring bloom, organisms should release larvae just before or during the productive period (Węsławski et al. 1991); thus, most of the larvae of benthic animals are present in coastal plankton from April to early June (Węsławski et al. 1988). In the boreal and temperate areas, development of invertebrates is directly influenced by the environmental temperature (Todd and Doyle 1981). Most species reproduce in spring (Thorson 1946), when temperature is rising, but some invertebrates are able to reproduce also in winter. Buhl-Jensen and Fossa (1991) observed in Gullmarfjord (western Sweden) a general tendency for neritic mysids to be most abundant in spring and winter. Mysid Erythrops erythrophthalma seemed to have reproductive maximum in winter, but juveniles were observed year-round. Maximum reproduction in spring as well as second maximum in autumn has been observed for many boreal shallow-water amphipods (Sainte-Marie and Brunel 1983; Carrasco and Arcos 1984; Costello and Myers 1989).
Summer abundance and biomass
In summer months, the input of terrigenous material transported by the rivers produced high particle flux, which affected both the benthic food availability and substrate conditions. The organic matter content in surface sediments was lower in the summer than in the spring (Zajączkowski et al. 2010). The decrease in the organic matter concentration in sediments resulted from a “dilution” of the organic matter in the mass of inorganic particles (Görlich et al. 1987). The high supply of terrigenous material also produced a signal in the granulometric composition of sediments. The silt and clay fractions made up 95% of the sediment in July and August. Also, the water content in the sediment increased substantially from 47% in May to about 57% in July and August. Large loads of fine deposits lead to the formation of a layer of unconsolidated, easily eroded sediments that are frequently resuspended and redeposited (Syvitski and Shaw 1995; Zajączkowski and Włodarska-Kowalczuk 2007).
Physical disturbances caused by the large terrigenous inflow in the summer led to a reduction in the numbers and biomass of both meio- and macrofauna in Adventfjorden sediments (Fig. 10). In July and August, the meiobenthic density and biomass was at a minimal level. Only in July the biomass of meiofauna rose, as a result of the presence of a few large individuals of Polychaeta. The abundance and biomass of macrobenthos also decreased during the summer. The strong seasonal effects of mineral sedimentation on Adventfjorden benthic standing stocks correspond well with studies reporting the spatial patterns related to the gradients of sediment disturbance. Włodarska-Kowalczuk et al. (2007) studied meio- and macrobenthic characteristics in three zones of the Adventfjorden estuary that differed significantly with relation to mineral material sedimentation and sediment stability. In the unstable sediments of the prodelta slope where high rates of inorganic sedimentation and frequent gravity-driven sediment flows occur, both meio- and macrobenthic densities and biomass were much lower than in the stable sediments of the central basin. A similar situation was observed in Kongsfjorden (a fjord off west Spitsbergen) where the macrobenthic biomass decreased with increasing proximity to the glacier (Włodarska-Kowalczuk et al. 2005). Newell et al. (1998) showed that dredging in coastal waters results in a decrease in macrobenthic standing stocks with a 40–70% reduction in the number of individuals and a 60–90% reduction in the biomass. Blanchard and Feder (2003) recorded a signal for biomass decline in a macrofaunal community disturbed by dredging in Alaskan coastal waters. They showed that benthic fauna was able to return to pre-disturbance biomass, although re-adjustment could be greater than 5 years in some cases.
The seasonal meiofaunal abundance reduction in July and August and low biomass in August contradict previous reports that indicated high resistance of meiofauna to sediment disturbance. An investigation of a benthic community in Bermuda performed by Warwick et al. (1990) showed that meio- and macrobenthos were affected differently by environmental disturbances. The densities of macrobenthos decreased significantly, while meiofauna was slightly impacted. Sherman and Coull (1980) found that despite a significant drop in meiobenthic numerical abundance after a disturbance, 12 h was sufficient for the major groups to return to pre-disturbance levels. This process could be delayed by frequently repeated disturbances combined with a low number of juveniles (Austen and Widdicombe 2006). Somerfield et al. (1995) showed that mechanical sediment disturbances connected with sediment resuspension and redeposition affect both macrofauna and meiofauna. Jewett and Feder (1977) wrote that the seasonal pattern for the abundance of the harpacticoid Harpacticus uniremis in Alaska reflects its reproductive cycle and is characterised by the sequential occurrence of successive life stages. Seasonal fluctuations in the density and biomass of meiofauna in Adventfjorden are probably the result of the interaction of environmental factors (i.e., disturbances and food supply as discussed earlier) and natural life cycles (natural mortality of adult individuals in the winter: February and October).
Seasonal changes in diversity and species composition
Different responses to summer disturbance pressures were noted when different aspects of diversity, such as species richness and evenness, were examined. A decline in species richness was not accompanied by a decrease in evenness, expressed by the Pielou index. Species diversity (measured by the Shannon–Wienner index), which combines both species richness and evenness, decreased as a result of the decline in the species richness. During the study performed along the spatial gradient of sediment disturbances in Adventfjorden, the same trend was observed—a significant decrease in species richness and no effect on evenness in the disturbed localities (Włodarska-Kowalczuk et al. 2007). Magurran (2004) also showed that the disturbance is not always accompanied by a decline in evenness and stated that species richness measures are better indicators of a perturbation than evenness or species diversity metrics.
No clear seasonal patterns were recorded when the taxonomic composition of the fauna was analysed, either for the macrofauna examined at the species level or for the meiofaunal higher taxonomic groups. The lack of clear seasonal trends in the nMDS plot could result from the low number of replicates collected and the large variability among replicates, exceeding the variability among the months (Fig. 9). The natural patchiness in the distribution of benthic organisms and the high frequency of physical disturbances may result in high variability between replicates that can mask the seasonal trends. This effect is often observed in sampling programs based on low number of replicates (Sibert 1979).
In the multivariate analyses, only August seems to be different both for meio- and macrofauna. The sedimentation of organic and mineral material proceeded from April to June, respectively. The sampling point was located on a steep slope where sedimenting material accumulated until the critical threshold when gravity generated a flow of sediment or a mixture of sediment and fluid. Long-lasting sedimentation processes make gravity flow more probable (Zajączkowski and Włodarska-Kowalczuk 2007), and the strong decline of the fauna in August could result from an episodic catastrophic event at the sampling station, e.g., the mass flow of sediments on the slope.
The taxonomic composition of the macrofauna was similar to that recorded in previous summer surveys of the Adventfjorden sediments (Holte et al. 1996; Węsławski and Szymelfenig 1999; Włodarska-Kowalczuk et al. 2007). In 2006–2007 (present study), the polychaetes Chaetozone spp., Heteromastus filiformis and C. longocirrata were the most numerous, while Włodarska-Kowalczuk et al. (2007) listed Capitella capitata, Chaetozone setosa and C. longocirrata as the dominant species on the delta slope in 2001–2002. C. capitata is a common coloniser of defaunated sediments and is very resistant to sediment instabilities (McCall 1977; Blanchard and Feder 2003). Ch. setosa and C. longocirrata are common dominants in Spitsbergen glacial bays and are resistant to high sedimentation (Włodarska-Kowalczuk et al. 1998). Communities living in fine mobile sediments are characterised by large populations of species that are well adapted to rapid recolonisation of disturbed sediments (Newell et al. 1998). Włodarska-Kowalczuk and Pearson (2004) noted that in glacial bays, known as areas with high levels of physical sediment disturbances, the fauna was dominated by small-bodied deposit-feeding species and characterised by low biomass and low diversity.
More than 90% of the meiofauna belonged to Nematoda throughout all seasons. The lowest abundances of Harpacticoid copepods were observed in May, July and August, months when sediments were disturbed by inorganic sedimentation. Experimental studies showed that nematodes migrate deep through the sediment and thereby can avoid negative effects of high sedimentation and burial (Schratzberger et al. 2004). Harpacticoida occupy the surface layer of sediment that is unstable and can be easily removed by gravity flows. Jewett and Feder (1977) observed that the harpacticoid copepod H. uniremis did not perform downward migration in sediments. Probably, harpacticoids can recolonise disturbed areas only by active or passive migration in near-bottom water (Chandler and Fleeger 1983).