Abstract
Equipment installed in a power system network has to tolerate impulse overvoltage throughout its life span. Lightning impulses are one of the primary reasons of this overvoltage. Hence, insulation of the power equipment is designed and tested with standard lightning impulse. However, in reality, various complex, oscillatory non-standard lightning impulse waveforms exist in natural lightning impulses. Therefore, for the better design of insulation of the power equipment, identification of the non-standard lightning impulse waveform is essential. This article presents a comprehensive review of the effects of non-standard lightning impulse voltage on the insulation of power equipment. This article will help to classify the non-standard lightning impulse waveforms and identify the parameters, generation circuit, and analysis of non-standard lightning impulse waveforms till the present day. Hence, the information presented in the article can be helpful for the insulation design of the power equipment.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Jana S, Biswas P K, Das U (2018) Numerical computational analysis of lightning energy storage system using single stage two level impulse generator. In: 2nd international conference on power, energy and environment: towards smart technology (ICEPE) (2018): 1–6
Jana S, Biswas PK, Sain C (2022) Mathematical modeling of impulse Island controller to safely store the energy from high voltage lightning impulse. Energy Storage 2022:1–11. https://doi.org/10.1002/est2.325
High Voltage Test Techniques Part 1: General Definitions and Test Requirements, Standard IS 2071–1, Indian Standard (2004)
High-voltage Test Techniques-Part 1: General Definitions and Test Requirements, Standard IEC 60060–1, International Electrotechnical Commission (2010)
High-Voltage Test Techniques: IEC Publication 60 (1962)
Venkatesan S, Usa S, Kumar KU (2002) Unconditionally sequential approach to calculate the impulse voltages strength of air for non-standard impulse voltages. In: Proceedings IEEE/PES Asia Pacific transmission and distribution conference and exhibition. 2: 1236–1240
Okabe S, Yuasa S, Kaneko S (2007) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of gas-insulated switchgear for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms -analysis and generation circuit of non-standard lightning impulse waveforms in actual field. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 14(2):312–320
Ueta G, Wada J, Okabe S (2011) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of CO2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms - method for converting non-standard lightning impulse waveforms into standard lightning impulse waveforms-. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 18(5):1724–1733
Wada J, Ueta G, Okabe S (2013) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of N2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms - method for converting non-standard lightning impulse waveforms into standard lightning impulse waveforms-. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 20(2):505–514
Faria GH et al (2020) Lightning withstand of medium voltage switches and cut-out fuses considering standard and non-standard impulse shapes. IEEE Electr Insul Mag 36(4):47–55
Okabe S, Takami J (2008) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of oil-immersed transformers under non-standard lightning impulse waveforms - method for converting non-standard lightning impulse waveforms into standard lightning impulse waveforms. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 15(5):1288–1296
Bhuyan K, Chatterjee S (2010) Study of effects of standard and non-standard impulse waves on power transformer. In: Proc Power Electr Drives and Energy Syst Int Conf (2010): 1–4
Bhuyan K, Chatterjee S (2015) Electric stresses on transformer winding insulation under standard and non-standard impulse voltages. Electric Power Sys Res 123:40–47
AIEE Committee Report (1934) Flashover voltages of insulators and gaps. Elect Eng 53(6):882–886
Carrus A, Funes LE (1984) Very short-tailed lightning double exponential wave generation techniques based on Marx circuit standard configurations. IEEE Trans. Power App Syst PAS- 103(4):782–787
Burrage LM, Veverka EF, McConnell BW (1987) Steep front short duration low voltage impulse performance of distribution transformers. IEEE Trans Power Del PWRD 2(4):1152–1156
Carrus A (1989) An inductance on the Marx generator tail branch. New technique for high efficiency laboratory reproduction of short time to Half value lightning impulses. IEEE Trans Power Del 4(1):90–94
Lux E, Miller DB, Kempkes DL (1989) The effect of steep-front short-duration pulses on polyethylene cable insulation. In: Proc IEEE Eng Info Tech in the Southeast 1989. vol 3, pp 1372–1376
Shaw JH (1989) Instrumentation system used to determine the effects of steep front short duration impulses on electric power system Insulation. IEEE Trans Power Del 4(2):938–941
Aoshima Y, Miyake K (1989) Flashover characteristics of air gaps for short tail waves (Japanese). The Trans Ins Elect Eng Japan B 109(3):135–142
Miller DB, Lux AE, Barnes PR (1990) The effects of steep-front, short-duration impulses on power distribution components. IEEE Trans Power Del 5(2):708–714
Grzybowski S, Jacob PB (1990) The steep-front, short-duration pulse characteristics of distribution insulators with wood. IEEE Trans Power Del 5(3):1608–1616
Motoyama H (1996) Experimental study and analysis of breakdown characteristics of long air gaps with short tail lightning impulse. IEEE Trans Power Del 11(2):972–979
Carrus A et al (1999) Short tail lightning impulse behaviour of medium voltage line insulation. IEEE Trans Power Del 14(1):218–226
Venkatesan S, Ranjan PV, Ashokaraju D (2003) A comparative study on methods for evaluation of lightning impulse parameters. In: Proc Asia-Pacific Region Convergent Tech Conf (TENCON 2003), 2003. vol 4, pp 1562–1566
Grzybowski S, Song Y, Kappenman J (2004) CFO voltage and V-t characteristic of 15 kV polymer suspension insulator under lightning and Steep front short duration impulses. In: Proc IEEE Int Symp Elect Insul Conf. pp 308–311
Grzybowski S, Song S, Kappenman J (2004) Study on the electrical strength of distribution insulators under steep front, short-duration pulse. In: Proc Electr Insul Dielectr Phenomena Conf 2004. pp 643–646
Ancajima A et al (2007) Breakdown characteristics of air spark-gaps stressed by standard and short-tail lightning impulses: experimental results and comparison with time to sparkover models. J Electrostatics 65(5–6):282–288
Braz CP et al (2014) Analysis of different procedures for the application of the disruptive effect model to distribution insulators Subject to short tail lightning impulses. Electr Power Syst Res 113:165–170
Ancajima A et al (2010) Behavior of MV insulators under lightning-induced overvoltages: experimental results and reproduction of volt-time characteristics by disruptive effect models. IEEE Trans Power Del 25(1):221–230
Lantharthong T et al (2014) Effect of waveform and impulse resistance on lightning performance in distribution system. In: Proc IEEE Int Conf Lightning Protection (ICLP). pp 1766–1769
Wang X, Yu Z, He J (2014) Breakdown process experiments of 110- to 500-kV insulator strings under short tail lightning impulse. IEEE Trans Power Del 29(5):2394–2401
Yuan Z et al (2014) Experimental study and analysis of insulator breakdown characteristics with short-tail lightning impulse. J Int Council on Elect Eng 4(3):199–203
Sima W et al (2016) Impact of time parameters of lightning impulse on the breakdown characteristics of oil-paper insulation. High Volt 1(1):18–24
Yamamoto K, Masuda K, Sumi S (2018) Long-wave-tail current Generator to generate real winter lightning current. In: Proceedings of 34th international conference on lightning protection (ICLP). pp 1–5
Xiao P et al (2018) Experimental study on the flashover characteristics of polluted insulators under short-tail lightning impulse waveform. In: Proc IEEE Int Conf High Volt Eng App (ICHVE). pp 1–4
Zhao X et al (2018) Breakdown characteristics of a 220-kV composite insulator string under short tail lightning impulses based on the discharge current and images. IEEE Trans Power Del 33(6):3211–3217
Han Y et al (2018) Study on influencing factors of insulators flashover characteristics on the 110 kV true tower under the lightning impulse. IEEE Access 6:66536–66544
Okabe S et al (2009) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of gas-insulated switchgear for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms -method for converting non-standard lightning impulse waveforms into standard lightning impulse waveforms-. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 16(1):42–51
Koto M et al (1998) Insulation characteristics of GIS for non-standard lightning surge waveforms. In: Proc 8th Int Sym Gaseous Dielectr (1998). pp 547–553
Okabe S et al (1999) Insulation characteristics of GIS for non-standard lightning surge waveforms < No-2: gas gaps and spacer surface >. In: Proc Eng Symp High Volt (1999). vol 3, pp 163–166
Okabe S et al (2003) Analysis of non-standard lightning impulse voltage for actual substation and generation circuit (Japanese). IEEJ Trans Power Energy 123(2):175–180
Wada J, Ueta G, Okabe S (2012) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of CO2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse WAVEFORMS - breakdown characteristics under double-frequency oscillation waveforms and single-frequency oscillation waveforms in the presence of bias voltage. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 19(5):1799–1809
Ueta G, Wada J, Okabe S (2011) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of CO2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms - breakdown characteristics under single-frequency oscillation waveforms of 5.3 MHz to 20.0 MHz. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 18(1):238–245
Wada J, Ueta G, Okabe S (2011) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of CO2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms under non-uniform electric field - breakdown characteristics for Single-frequency oscillation waveforms. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 18(2):640–648
Wada J, Ueta G, Okabe S (2011) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of N2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms - breakdown characteristics under single-frequency oscillation waveforms and with bias voltages. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 18(5):1759–1766
Wada J, Ueta G, Okabe S (2013) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of CO2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms - breakdown characteristics in the presence of bias voltages under non-uniform electric field. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 20(1):112–121
Wada J et al (2014) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of CO2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms -breakdown characteristics for double-frequency oscillation waveforms under non-uniform electric field. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 21(2):617–626
Okabe S et al (2001) Insulation characteristics of GIS under non-standard lightning impulse oscillations - insulation characteristics under high frequency oscillations- (Japanese). T IEE Japan 121-B(11):1587–1593
Yokoi T, Kaneko S, Okabe S (2006) Insulation characteristics of CO2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse oscillations - insulation characteristics under single-frequency oscillations from 5.3 to 20 MHz- (Japanese). T IEE Japan 126(5):539–544
Kaneko S, Yokoi T, Okabe S (2006) Insulation characteristics of CO2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse oscillations - insulation characteristics under single-frequency oscillations from 1.3 to 4.0 MHz- (Japanese). IEEJ Trans PE 126(1):91–96
Kaneko S, Okabe S (2007) Insulation characteristics and its evaluation of N2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms (Japanese). IEEJ Trans PE 127(7):854–862
Okabe S, Yuasa S, Kaneko S (2008) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of gas-insulated switchgear for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms - breakdown characteristics for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms associated with disconnector switching surges-. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 15(3):721–729
Wada J, Ueta G, Okabe S (2013) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of N2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms - breakdown characteristics under double-frequency oscillation waveforms and pressure-distance characteristics. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 19(5):1810–1818
Jones AR (1954) Evaluation of the integration method for analysis of non-standard surge voltages. AIEE Trans 73:984–990
Shindo T, Suzuki T (1985) A new calculation method of breakdown voltage-time characteristics of long air gaps. IEEE Trans Power App Syst PAS- 104(6):1556–1563
Li Z, Kuffel R, Kuffel E (1986) Volt-time characteristics in air, SF6/AIR mixture and N2 for coaxial cylinder and rod-sphere gaps. IEEE Trans Elect Insul EI- 21(2):151–155
Darveniza M, Vlastos AE (1988) Generalised breakdown models and the integration method for predicting non-standard waveshape impulse strengths. In: Proc of Prop and Appl of Dielectr Mater Sec Int Conf (1988). vol 1, pp 284–287
Darveniza M, Vlastos AE (1988) The generalized integration method for predicting impulse volt-time characteristics for non-standard wave shapes - a theoretical basis. IEEE Trans Electr Insul 23(3):373–381
Pigini A et al (1989) Performance of large air gaps under lightning overvoltages: experimental study and analysis of accuracy predetermination methods. IEEE Trans Power Del 4(2):1379–1392
Task Force 15.09 on Non-standard Lightning Voltage Waves, Lightning and Insulator Subcommittee of the T & D Committee (1994) Review of research on non-standard lightning voltage waves. IEEE Trans Power Del 9(4):1972–1981
Chowdhuri P et al (1994) The effects of non-standard lightning voltage waveshapes on the impulse strength of short air gaps. IEEE Trans Power Del 9(4):1991–1999
Chowdhuri P, Mishra AK, McConnell BW (1997) Volt-time characteristics of short air gaps under non-standard lightning voltage waves. IEEE Trans Power Del 12(1):470–476
Zhang XQ (2006) Study on corona characteristics under non-standard lightning impulses. Electr Eng 89:519–524
Ancajima A et al (2007) Optimal selection of disruptive effect models parameters for the reproduction of mv insulators volt-time characteristics under standard and non-standard lightning impulses. IEEE Lausanne Power Tech 760–765
Aniserowicz K, Zielenkiewicz M (2007) Non-standard Lightning Protection Devices-A Criticism. In: Proc Int Conf Electr Contr Tech: 177–180.
Bhuyan K, Chatterjee S (2008) Study of effect of standard and non-standard impulse waves on power equipments. In: Proc NCEEERE (2008). pp 1–6
Yuvarajan M et al (2008) Behavior of LN2/ Paper composite insulating material under AC, standard and non-standard lightning impulse voltage. In: Proc Electr Insul Dielectr Phenomena Conf (2008). pp 641–644
Kadir MZAA, Ahmad MH, Jasni J (2008) Effect of the non-standard lightning current and waveshape on lightning surge analysis. Asian J Appl Sci 1(2):168–176
Venkatesan S, Usa S (2010) Volt–time characteristics of small airgaps with hyperbolic model. Electr Power Syst Res 80(7):739–742
Braz P, Piantini A (2011) Analysis of the dielectric behavior of distribution insulators under non-standard lightning impulses voltages (Portuguese). IEEE Lat Am Trans 9(5):732–739
Braz P et al (2012) Analysis of the disruptive effect model for the prediction of the breakdown characteristics of distribution insulators under non-standard lightning impulses. In: Proc Lightning Protection Int Conf (2012). pp 1–7
Lopes G P, Pedroso J A D, Martinez M L B (2013) Evaluation of CFO for medium voltage insulators submitted to non-standard impulse shapes experimental results. In: Proc IEEE Electr Insul Conf (EIC) (2013). pp 419–423
Metwally IA (2013) Performance improvement of slow-wave rogowski coils for high impulse current measurement. IEEE Sens J 13(2):538–547
Bhuyan K, Chatterjee S (2015) Simulation of overvoltage stresses on surge arrester insulation. Int Trans Electr Energy Syst 26(6):1210–1225
Krithika G, Usa S (2015) v-t Characteristics using extended disruptive effect model for impulses of varying front times. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 22(4):2191–2195
Shigihara M, Piantini A (2016) Volt-time curves of 24 kV porcelain insulators under non-standard impulse waveshapes. In: Proc Lightning Protection (ICLP) Int Conf (2016). pp 1–5
Bhattacharyya S et al (2016) Electric stress analysis of a medium voltage cable termination subjected to standard and non-standard lightning impulse voltages. In: Proc Intelligent Contr Power Instru (ICICPI) Int Conf (2016). pp 169–173
Huang K, Zhang X (2016) An experimental study on corona q-u curves under non-standard lightning impulses. J Electrostatics 81:37–41
Lopes G P et al (2016) Lightning withstand of medium voltage cut-out fuses stressed by non-standard impulse shapes experimental results. In: Proc IEEE Electr Insul Conf (EIC) (2016). pp 210–214
Shigihara M et al (2018) Generation of non-standard lightning impulse unipolar waveshapes. In: Proc IEEE High Volt Eng App (ICHVE) Int Conf (2018). pp 1–4
Mahmood F, Rizk MdEM, Lehtonen M (2019) Risk-based insulation coordination studies for protection of medium-voltage overhead lines against lightning-induced overvoltages. Electr Eng (Springer) 101:311–320
Liang H, Du B, Li J (2020) Non-intrusive measurement of transient electric field distribution under AC and impulse voltages. IEEE Sens J 20(18):10898–10902
Wickert HM, Marchesan TB (2021) A method for representing non-standard waveform in factory tests using impulse waveforms. IEEE Trans Power Del 1–10, 2021 [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1109/TPWRD.2021.3129603
Caldwell RO, Darveniza M (1973) Experimental and analytical studies of the effect of non-standard waveshapes on the impulse strength of external insulation. IEEE Trans Power App Syst PAS 92(4):1420–1428
Suzuki T, Miyake K (1977) Experimental study of breakdown voltage-time characteristics of large air gaps with lightning impulses. IEEE Trans Power App Syst 96(1):227–233
Okabe S et al (1999) Dielectric characteristics of oil-filled transformer insulation models under non-standard lightning impulse voltages. In: Proc Eng Symp High Volt (1999). (467): 345–348
Okabe S et al (2001) Dielectric characteristics of oil-filled transformer under non-standard lightning surge waveforms: dielectric characteristics of oil-filled transformer insulation models under fast Front short-duration impulse voltages (Japanese). IEEJ Trans Power Energy 121(6):775–781
Savadamuthu U, Udayakumar K, Jayashankar V (2002) Modified disruptive effect method as a measure of insulation strength for non-standard lightning waveforms. IEEE Trans Power Del 17(2):510–515
Rokunohe T et al (2002) Insulation characteristics of SF6 gas for non-standard impulse voltages polarity reversal pulse waveforms (Japanese). T IEE Japan 122-B(11):1232–1237
Okabe S, Yuasa S (2003) Evaluation method of non-standard lightning impulse waveform for oil-filled transformer. IEEJ Trans Power Energy 123(12):1580–1586
Yuasa S, Okabe S (2003) Breakdown characteristics of SF6 gas for non-standard lightning impulse voltage - insulation characteristics of gas gap and spacer surface under single pulse waveform- (Japanese). IEEJ Trans PE 123(10):1242–1249
Kumar JSS et al (2004) Effective model for prediction of impulse strength of oil-impregnated paper insulation under non-standard impulse voltages. In: Proc Power Syst Tech Int Conf (POWERCON) (2004). pp 1619–1622
Okabe S et al (2004) Dielectric characteristics of oil-filled transformer in the presence of non-standard lightning surge waveforms. Electr Eng Jpn 146(3):39–45
Okabe S, Yuasa S (2004) Evaluation method of non-standard lightning impulse waveforms for GIS (Japanese). IEEJ Trans PE 124(1):156–161
Venkatesan S, Usa S (2005) Impulse volt-time characteristics of oil and OIP insulation. Am J App Sci 2(2):591–596
Ancajima A et al (2005) Breakdown characteristics of MV distribution and electric traction lines insulators stressed by standard and short tail lightning impulses. In: 2005 IEEE Russia Power Tech. pp 1–7
Kaneko S, Yokoi T, Okabe S (2006) Insulation characteristics of CO2 gas for non-standard lightning impulse oscillations - evaluation method of non-standard lightning impulse waveform for CO2 gas insulation- (Japanese). IEEJ Trans PE 126(7):701–707
Venkatesan S, Usa S (2007) Impulse strength of transformer insulation with non-standard waveshapes. IEEE Trans Power Del 22(4):s4-2221
Okabe S (2007) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of oil-immersed transformers under non-standard lightning impulse waveforms - definition of non-standard lightning impulse waveforms and insulation characteristics for waveforms including pulses-. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 14(1):146–155
Okabe S (2007) Evaluation of breakdown characteristics of oil-immersed transformers under non-standard lightning impulse - insulation characteristics for non-standard lightning impulse waveforms with oscillations. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 14(3):679–688
Mitra P, De A, Chakrabarty A (2009) Investigation on the voltage stresses developed on transformer insulation under non-standard terminal excitations. In: Proc IEEE Region 10 Conf (TENCON) (2009). pp 1–5
Okabe S, Tsuboi T, Takami J (2009) Evaluation of k-factor based on insulation characteristics under non-standard lightning impulse waveforms. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 16(4):1124–1126
Wang Z et al (2013) The oil-paper insulation breakdown characteristics under non-standard lightning impulse voltages. In: Proc IEEE Annual Report Electr Insul Dielectr Phenomena Conf (2013) pp 883–886
Krithika G, Usa S (2013) Volt-time characteristics of OIP under non-standard impulses. In: IEEE Condition Assessment Techniques In Electr Syst 1st Int Conf (2013). pp 281–285
Sankarganesh A, Karthikeyan K, Sudha R (2013) Breakdown characteristics of transformer under non-standard impulse voltage. Int J Eng Res Tech (IJERT) 2(4):1266–1269
Sarathi R et al (2013) Understanding the breakdown characteristics of liquid nitrogen under non-standard transient voltages. In: IEEE Industry Info Syst 8th Int Conf (ICIIS) (2013). pp 96–99
Sun P et al (2015) Study on voltage-number characteristics of transformer insulation under transformer invading non-standard lightning impulses. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 22(6):3582–3591
Wang T et al (2015) Turn-to-turn insulation breakdown characteristics under non-standard lightning impulse voltages. In: Proc IEEE Prop App Dielectr Materials (ICPADM) 11th Int Conf (2015). pp 200–203
Wang Z et al (2015) Breakdown characteristics of oil-paper insulation under lightning impulse waveforms with oscillations. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 22(5):2620–2627
Hua J et al (2017) Study on voltage-number characteristics of capacitor insulation under impulse voltages with different waveforms. In: IEEE 19th Int Conf Dielectr Liquids (ICDL) (2017). pp 1–4
Zhou Y et al (2017) Adjustment of wave front time and overshoot in lightning impulse test for transformer insulation. In: 2017 IEEE conference on electrical insulation and dielectric phenomenon (CEIDP) (2017). pp 270–273
Mubarak ZA, Usa S (2019) Effect of oil impregnated paper thickness and impulse waveshapes on voltage-number characteristics. Electr Eng (Springer) 101:1189–1197
Florkowski M et al (2020) Propagation of lightning, oscillating and non-standard impulse waveforms in transformer windings. In: Proc of the 21st international symposium on high voltage engineering (2020). pp 1254–1264. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-31676-1117
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Ghosh, P., Das, A.K., Dalai, S. et al. The effects of non-standard lightning impulse on electrical insulation: a review. Electr Eng 104, 4239–4254 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00202-022-01616-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00202-022-01616-2