Abstract
This is an account of the origins of the concept of social mentoring and development of a social mentoring project in a local community in the city of Brighton and Hove in the UK. The account highlights the potential of social intervention for investigating the gaps and opportunities for mentoring services for people living with Asperger Syndrome. This initiative provides a model for supporting a parallel dialogue alongside and beyond the practice initiative so as to create a space for reflection on the impact and the broader application of the intervention. This project was made possible by the commitment and tenacity of a number of local community activists and welfare entrepreneur’s on the ground who were able to set in train a number of events. These events are mapped out starting with community concerns, campaign initiatives, survey of the area of need and the use of evidence to secure funding and establish a client specific city-wide initiative. The role and importance of establishing alliances between the community and the local university academic community through a participatory research approach is highlighted and the benefits of creating space for the sharing of evidence from the literature and squaring this with evidence from practice through the development of a wider community of practice network is discussed. The resulting knowledge synthesis regarding the differentiation between mentoring, social mentoring and befriending is presented.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alleman E (1986) Measuring mentoring––frequency, quality, impact. In: Gray WA, Gray MM (eds) Mentoring: aid to excellence in career development, business and the professions, vol 11. International Association for Mentoring, Vancouver
Anderson EM, Shannon LA (1995) Toward a conceptualisation of mentoring. In: Kerry T, Shelton Mayes AS (eds) Issues in mentoring. Routledge, London
Benioff S (1997) A second chance: developing mentoring and education projects for young people. Commission for Racial Equality/Crime Concern, London
Bradshaw T, Haddock G (1998) Is befriending by trained volunteers of value to people suffering from long-term mental illness. J Adv Nurs 27(4):713–720
Cannon C, Warren C (1997) Social action with children and families: a community development approach to child and family welfare. Routledge, London
Colley H (2003) Mentoring for social exclusion: a critical approach to nurturing mentor relationships. Routledge Falmer, New York
Collis J (1993) Befriending in Robin Hood country (volunteer befriending for people with mental health problems in rural areas): new directions, vol 4. Spring
Cornwall A, Jewkes R (1995) What is participatory action research? Soc Sci Med 41(12):1667–1676
Cox AD (1993) Befriending young mothers. Br J Psychiatry 163:6–18
Cruddas L (2005) Learning mentors in schools: policy and practice. Trent Books Ltd, Stoke-on-Trent
Dean J, Goodlad R (1998) Supporting community participation; the role and impact of befriending. Joseph Rowntree Foundation, Pavilion
Dalz L (1983) Mentors: teachers who make a difference. Change 15(6):24–27
Daniels H (2001) Vigotsky and pedagogy. RoutledgeFalmer, London
Francis J (1995) Alcohol: less talk, more do. (CATCH, a volunteer befriending Scheme in Chichester which offers more than counselling for people with alcohol problems. Community Care, p 10
Freedman M (1995) The kindness of strangers: adult mentors, urban youth and the new voluntarism. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Froland C, Pancoast DL, Chapman N, Kimboko PJ (1981) Helping networks and human services. Sage, Beverley Hills
Flynn PT (1992) Friendly visiting: considerations and resources. Educ Gerontol 18:305–316
Gay P, Pitkeathley J (1982) Just like a friend: befriending discharged psychiatric patients. Kings Fund Project Paper No 32
Gay B, Stephenson J (1998) The mentoring dilemma: guidance and/or direction? Mentoring Tutoring 6(1):43–54
Gill KS, Jones A (2005) Navigating health in the community, University of Brighton
Gollay E, Friedman R, Wyngarden M, Kurtz NR (1997) Coming back; the community experience of mentally retarded people. ABT Books, Cambridge
Jackson C (1992) Community mothers: trick or treat? (volunteer mothers who befriend other mothers in the community. Health visitor 65(6):12–13
Katz M (1997) On playing a poor hand well: insights from the lives of those who have overcome childhood risks and adversities. WW Norton, New York
King M (1998) Dosti––befriending scheme for Asians with mental health problems in Hillingdon: open mind, Aug/Sept 1995, vol 76, p 18
Klopf G, Harrison J (1981) Moving up the carreer ladder: a case for mentors. Principal 61:41–43
Lepski J (2002) Befrienders, newsletter for the medical foundation for the victims of torture, issue 21, pp 4–5
Levinson DJ, Darrow CN, Klein EB, Levinson MH, McKee B (1978) The seasons of a man’s life. Ballantine, New York
Lorenz (2002) cited in Vitler K (2002) Social pedagogy: what’s in it for us? http://www.childrenuk.co.uk
Merriam S (1983) Mentor’s and proteges: a critical review of the literature. Adult Educ Q 33(3):161–173
Moffat C (1986) Befriending in Belfast (volunteer scheme to help mentally handicapped young people) New Society, vol 76, p 21
Murphy S (1986) Mentoring and adult development. Paper presented at first international Conference on Mentoring. Vancouver, BC
Petrioni P (1997) The impact of a volunteer community care project in a primary health care setting. In: Petrioni P, Petrioni C (eds) Innovation in community care and primary health: Churchill Livingstone, pp 53–59
Phillips-Jones L (1982) Mentors and proteges. New York, Arbor House
Pound A (1990) The development of attachment in adult life––the Newpin Experiment. (A pilot Home Visiting and Befriending Service to support mothers and families to develop children’s attachment). Br J Psychotherapy 7(1):77–85
Rhodes J (1994) Older and wiser: mentoring relationships in childhood and adolescence. J Prim Prev 14:187–196
Rhodes J, Ebart L, Fischer K (1992) Natural mentors: an overlooked resource in the social networks of adolescent mothers. Am J Community Psychol 20(4):445–461
Russell J, Dexter G, Bond T (1992) Differentiation report between advice, guidance, befriending, counselling skills and counselling. The advice, guidance and counselling lead body, British Association for Counselling (BAC) and Department of Employment (DOE)
Scottish National Development Forum (1997) Code of practice: working together to promote good practice in befriending. Scottish Befriending Development Forum, Falkirk
Skinner A, Fleming J (1999) Mentoring socially excluded young people: lessons from practice. National Mentoring, Manchester
Smith M (1999) Social pedagogy. http://www.infed.org/biblio/b-socped.htm
Surestart (2001) http://www.surestart.gov.uk
Vitler K (2002) Social pedagogy: what’s in it for us? http://www.childrenuk.co
Ward-Panter J (1992) A door opens on the special hospitals. (Ashworth Special Hospital Woman’s Befriending Project). Open Mind 56:16–17
Werner EE, Smith RS (1982) Vulnerable but invincible, a longtitudinal study of resilient children and youth. McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York
Widdows J (1997) A special need for inclusion: children with disabilities, their families and everyday life. The Children’s Society, London
Zey MC (1984) The mentor connection. Dow Jones-Irving, Homewood
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Jane Frost of ASSERT, Fiona Edwards of CUPP, Ollie Glass of University of Sussex, Gail Louw of the Institute of Postgraduate Medicine, Polly Rodrigues of CUPP, and Jeremy Potter (resident scholar) for their commitment, participation and contributions to the evolution of the Social Mentoring Network and the EQUAL Brighton and Hove Social Mentoring Research Programme.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McGowan, B., Saintas, P. & Gill, K.S. On mentoring, social mentoring and befriending. AI & Soc 23, 613–630 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-008-0184-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-008-0184-z