## Abstract

We apply the formalism of amplitude symmetries to the angular distribution of the decays *B → D*^{∗}*ℓν* for *ℓ* = *e, μ, τ* . We show that the angular observables used to describe the distribution of this class of decays are not independent in absence of New Physics contributing to tensor operators. We derive sets of relations among the angular coefficients of the decay distribution for the massless and massive lepton cases which can be used to probe in a very general way the consistency among the angular observables and the underlying New Physics at work. We use these relations to access the longitudinal polarisation fraction of the *D*^{∗} using different angular coefficients from the ones used by Belle experiment. This in the near future can provide an alternative strategy to measure \( {F}_L^{D\ast } \) in *B → D*^{∗}*τν* and to understand the relatively high value measured by the Belle experiment. Using the same symmetries, we identify three observables which may exhibit a tension if the experimental value of \( {F}_L^{D\ast } \) remains high. We discuss how these relations can be exploited for binned measurements. We also propose a new observable that could test for specific scenarios of New Physics generated by light right-handed neutrinos. Finally we study the prospects of testing these relations based on the projected experimental sensitivity of new experiments.

## Article PDF

### Similar content being viewed by others

Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.

## References

S. Descotes-Genon, T. Hurth, J. Matias and J. Virto,

*Optimizing the basis of B → K*^{∗}*ℓ*^{+}*ℓ*^{−}*observables in the full kinematic range*,*JHEP***05**(2013) 137 [arXiv:1303.5794] [INSPIRE].LHCb collaboration,

*Measurement of Form-Factor-Independent Observables in the Decay B*^{0}*→ K*^{∗0}*μ*^{+}*μ*^{−},*Phys. Rev. Lett.***111**(2013) 191801 [arXiv:1308.1707] [INSPIRE].LHCb collaboration,

*Angular analysis of the B*^{0}*→ K*^{∗0}*μ*^{+}*μ*^{−}*decay using 3 fb*^{−1}*of integrated luminosity*,*JHEP***02**(2016) 104 [arXiv:1512.04442] [INSPIRE].ATLAS collaboration,

*Angular analysis of*\( {B}_d^0\to {K}^{\ast 0}{\mu}^{+}{\mu}^{-} \)*decays in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s} \) = 8*TeV with the ATLAS detector*, ATLAS-CONF-2017-023.CMS collaboration,

*Measurement of the P*_{1}*and*\( {P}_5^{\prime } \)*angular parameters of the decay*B^{0}*→*K^{∗0}*μ*^{+}*μ*^{−}*in proton-proton collisions at*\( \sqrt{s} \) = 8*TeV*, CMS-PAS-BPH-15-008.Belle collaboration,

*Angular analysis of B*^{0}*→ K*^{∗}(892)^{0}*ℓ*^{+}*ℓ*^{−}, arXiv:1604.04042 [INSPIRE].LHCb collaboration,

*Test of lepton universality using B*^{+}*→ K*^{+}*ℓ*^{+}*ℓ*^{−}*decays*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***113**(2014) 151601 [arXiv:1406.6482] [INSPIRE].LHCb collaboration,

*Test of lepton universality with B*^{0}*→ K*^{∗0}*ℓ*^{+}*ℓ*^{−}*decays*,*JHEP***08**(2017) 055 [arXiv:1705.05802] [INSPIRE].Belle collaboration,

*Lepton-Flavor-Dependent Angular Analysis of B → K*^{∗}*ℓ*^{+}*ℓ*^{−},*Phys. Rev. Lett.***118**(2017) 111801 [arXiv:1612.05014] [INSPIRE].B. Capdevila, A. Crivellin, S. Descotes-Genon, J. Matias and J. Virto,

*Patterns of New Physics in b → sℓ*^{+}*ℓ*^{−}*transitions in the light of recent data*,*JHEP***01**(2018) 093 [arXiv:1704.05340] [INSPIRE].M. Algueró et al.,

*Emerging patterns of New Physics with and without Lepton Flavour Universal contributions*,*Eur. Phys. J. C***79**(2019) 714 [*Addendum ibid.***80**(2020) 511] [arXiv:1903.09578] [INSPIRE].BaBar collaboration,

*Evidence for an excess of*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*^{(∗)}*τ*^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \)*decays*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***109**(2012) 101802 [arXiv:1205.5442] [INSPIRE].BaBar collaboration,

*Measurement of an Excess of*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*^{(∗)}*τ*^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \)*Decays and Implications for Charged Higgs Bosons*,*Phys. Rev. D***88**(2013) 072012 [arXiv:1303.0571] [INSPIRE].Belle collaboration, Measurement of the branching ratio of \( \overline{B} \)

*→ D*^{(∗)}τ^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \)*relative to*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*^{(∗)}*ℓ*^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\mathrm{\ell}} \)*decays with hadronic tagging at Belle*,*Phys. Rev. D***92**(2015) 072014 [arXiv:1507.03233] [INSPIRE].LHCb collaboration,

*Measurement of the ratio of branching fractions*\( B\left({\overline{B}}^0\to {D}^{\ast +}{\tau}^{-}{\overline{\nu}}_{\tau}\right)/B\left({\overline{B}}^0\to {D}^{\ast +}{\mu}^{-}{\overline{\nu}}_{\mu}\right) \),*Phys. Rev. Lett.***115**(2015) 111803 [*Erratum ibid.***115**(2015) 159901] [arXiv:1506.08614] [INSPIRE].LHCb collaboration,

*Measurement of the ratio of the B*^{0}*→ D*^{∗−}*τ*^{+}*ν*_{τ}*and B*^{0}*→ D*^{∗−}*μ*^{+}*ν*_{μ}*branching fractions using three-prong τ -lepton decays*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***120**(2018) 171802 [arXiv:1708.08856] [INSPIRE].Belle collaboration,

*Measurement of*ℛ(*D*)*and*ℛ(*D*^{∗})*with a semileptonic tagging method*, arXiv:1904.08794 [INSPIRE].HFLAV collaboration,

*Averages of b-hadron, c-hadron and τ -lepton properties as of 2018*, arXiv:1909.12524 [INSPIRE].Belle collaboration,

*Measurement of the D*^{∗−}*polarization in the decay B*^{0}*→ D*^{∗−}*τ*^{+}*ν*_{τ}, arXiv:1903.03102 [INSPIRE].Belle collaboration,

*Measurement of the τ lepton polarization and R*(*D*^{∗})*in the decay*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*^{∗}*τ*^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \) ,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***118**(2017) 211801 [arXiv:1612.00529] [INSPIRE].Belle collaboration,

*Measurement of the τ lepton polarization and R*(*D*^{∗})*in the decay*\( \overline{B} \) → D^{∗}τ^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \)*with one-prong hadronic τ decays at Belle*,*Phys. Rev. D***97**(2018) 012004 [arXiv:1709.00129] [INSPIRE].M. Blanke et al.,

*Impact of polarization observables and B*_{c}*→ τ ν on new physics explanations of the b → cτ ν anomaly*,*Phys. Rev. D***99**(2019) 075006 [arXiv:1811.09603] [INSPIRE].M. Blanke, A. Crivellin, T. Kitahara, M. Moscati, U. Nierste and I. Nišandžić,

*Addendum to*“Impact of polarization observables and*B*_{c}→ τ ν on new physics explanations of the b → cτ ν*anomaly”*,*Phys. Rev. D***100**(2019) 035035 [arXiv:1905.08253] [INSPIRE].D. Bečirević, M. Fedele, I. Nišandžić and A. Tayduganov,

*Lepton Flavor Universality tests through angular observables of*\( \overline{B}\to {D}^{\left(\ast \right)}\mathrm{\ell}\overline{\nu } \)*decay modes*, arXiv:1907.02257 [INSPIRE].C. Murgui, A. Peñuelas, M. Jung and A. Pich,

*Global fit to b → cτ ν transitions*,*JHEP***09**(2019) 103 [arXiv:1904.09311] [INSPIRE].P. Asadi and D. Shih,

*Maximizing the Impact of New Physics in b → cτ ν Anomalies*,*Phys. Rev. D***100**(2019) 115013 [arXiv:1905.03311] [INSPIRE].R.-X. Shi, L.-S. Geng, B. Grinstein, S. Jäger and J. Martin Camalich,

*Revisiting the new-physics interpretation of the b → cτ ν data*,*JHEP***12**(2019) 065 [arXiv:1905.08498] [INSPIRE].U. Egede, T. Hurth, J. Matias, M. Ramon and W. Reece,

*New physics reach of the decay mode*\( \overline{B}\to {\overline{K}}^{\ast 0}{\mathrm{\ell}}^{+}{\mathrm{\ell}}^{-} \),*JHEP***10**(2010) 056 [arXiv:1005.0571] [INSPIRE].J. Matias and N. Serra,

*Symmetry relations between angular observables in B*^{0}*→ K*^{∗}*μ*^{+}*μ*^{−}*and the LHCb*\( {P}_5^{\prime } \)*anomaly*,*Phys. Rev. D***90**(2014) 034002 [arXiv:1402.6855] [INSPIRE].L. Hofer and J. Matias,

*Exploiting the symmetries of P and S wave for B → K*^{∗}*μ*^{+}*μ*^{−},*JHEP***09**(2015) 104 [arXiv:1502.00920] [INSPIRE].P. Colangelo, F. De Fazio and F. Loparco,

*Probing New Physics with*\( \overline{B} \)*→ ρ*(770)ℓ^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\mathrm{\ell}} \)*and*\( \overline{B} \)*→ a*_{1}(1260)ℓ^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\mathrm{\ell}} \) ,*Phys. Rev. D***100**(2019) 075037 [arXiv:1906.07068] [INSPIRE].P. Biancofiore, P. Colangelo and F. De Fazio,

*On the anomalous enhancement observed in B → D*^{(∗)}*τ*\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \)*decays*,*Phys. Rev. D***87**(2013) 074010 [arXiv:1302.1042] [INSPIRE].M. Duraisamy and A. Datta, The Full B → D

^{∗}τ^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \)*Angular Distribution and CP-violating Triple Products*,*JHEP***09**(2013) 059 [arXiv:1302.7031] [INSPIRE].M. Duraisamy, P. Sharma and A. Datta,

*Azimuthal B → D*^{∗}*τ*^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \)*angular distribution with tensor operators*,*Phys. Rev. D***90**(2014) 074013 [arXiv:1405.3719] [INSPIRE].D. Becirevic, S. Fajfer, I. Nisandzic and A. Tayduganov,

*Angular distributions of*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*^{(∗)}\( \mathrm{\ell}{\overline{\nu}}_{\mathrm{\ell}} \)*decays and search of New Physics*,*Nucl. Phys. B***946**(2019) 114707 [arXiv:1602.03030] [INSPIRE].R. Alonso, A. Kobach and J. Martin Camalich,

*New physics in the kinematic distributions of*\( \overline{B}\to {D}^{\left(\ast \right)}{\tau}^{-}\left(\to {\mathrm{\ell}}^{-}{\overline{\nu}}_{\mathrm{\ell}}{\nu}_{\tau}\right){\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \),*Phys. Rev. D***94**(2016) 094021 [arXiv:1602.07671] [INSPIRE].Z. Ligeti, M. Papucci and D.J. Robinson,

*New Physics in the Visible Final States of B → D*^{(∗)}*τ ν*,*JHEP***01**(2017) 083 [arXiv:1610.02045] [INSPIRE].D. Hill, M. John, W. Ke and A. Poluektov,

*Model-independent method for measuring the angular coefficients of B*^{0}*→ D*^{∗−}*τ*^{+}*ν*_{τ}*decays*,*JHEP***11**(2019) 133 [arXiv:1908.04643] [INSPIRE].J. Aebischer, T. Kuhr and K. Lieret,

*Clustering of*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*^{(∗)}*τ*^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \)*kinematic distributions with ClusterKinG*,*JHEP***04**(2020) 007 [arXiv:1909.11088] [INSPIRE].J. Matias, F. Mescia, M. Ramon and J. Virto,

*Complete Anatomy of*\( {\overline{B}}_d\to {\overline{K}}^{\ast 0}\left(\to K\pi \right){\mathrm{\ell}}^{+}{\mathrm{\ell}}^{-} \)*and its angular distribution*,*JHEP***04**(2012) 104 [arXiv:1202.4266] [INSPIRE].B. Bhattacharya, A. Datta, S. Kamali and D. London,

*CP Violation in*\( \overline{B} \)^{0}*→ D*^{∗+}*μ*^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\mu } \) ,*JHEP***05**(2019) 191 [arXiv:1903.02567] [INSPIRE].P. Colangelo and F. De Fazio,

*Scrutinizing*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*^{∗}(*Dπ*) ℓ^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\mathrm{\ell}} \)*and*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*^{∗}(*Dγ*) ℓ^{−}\( {\overline{\nu}}_{\mathrm{\ell}} \)*in search of new physics footprints*,*JHEP***06**(2018) 082 [arXiv:1801.10468] [INSPIRE].S. Descotes-Genon, J. Matias, M. Ramon and J. Virto,

*Implications from clean observables for the binned analysis of B → K ∗ μ*^{+}*μ*^{−}*at large recoil*,*JHEP***01**(2013) 048 [arXiv:1207.2753] [INSPIRE].X.-Q. Li, Y.-D. Yang and X. Zhang,

*Revisiting the one leptoquark solution to the R*(*D*^{(∗)})*anomalies and its phenomenological implications*,*JHEP***08**(2016) 054 [arXiv:1605.09308] [INSPIRE].R. Alonso, B. Grinstein and J. Martin Camalich,

*Lifetime of*\( {B}_c^{-} \)*Constrains Explanations for Anomalies in B → D*^{(∗)}*τ ν*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***118**(2017) 081802 [arXiv:1611.06676] [INSPIRE].A.G. Akeroyd and C.-H. Chen, Constraint on the branching ratio of \( {B}_c\to \tau \overline{\nu} \)

*from LEP1 and consequences for R*(*D*^{(∗)})*anomaly*,*Phys. Rev. D***96**(2017) 075011 [arXiv:1708.04072] [INSPIRE].A. Greljo, J. Martin Camalich and J.D. Ruiz-Álvarez,

*Mono-τ Signatures at the LHC Constrain Explanations of B-decay Anomalies*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***122**(2019) 131803 [arXiv:1811.07920] [INSPIRE].D. Bečirević, I. Doršner, S. Fajfer, N. Košnik, D.A. Faroughy and O. Sumensari,

*Scalar leptoquarks from grand unified theories to accommodate the B-physics anomalies*,*Phys. Rev. D***98**(2018) 055003 [arXiv:1806.05689] [INSPIRE].M. Tanaka and R. Watanabe, New physics in the weak interaction of \( \overline{B} \)

*→ D*^{(∗)}τ \( \overline{v} \),*Phys. Rev. D***87**(2013) 034028 [arXiv:1212.1878] [INSPIRE].U. Egede, M. Patel and K.A. Petridis,

*Method for an unbinned measurement of the q*^{2}0 dependent decay amplitudes of \( {\overline{B}}^0 \)*→ K*^{∗0}*μ*^{+}*μ*^{−}*decays*,*JHEP***06**(2015) 084 [arXiv:1504.00574] [INSPIRE].M. González-Alonso, J. Martin Camalich and K. Mimouni,

*Renormalization-group evolution of new physics contributions to (semi)leptonic meson decays*,*Phys. Lett. B***772**(2017) 777 [arXiv:1706.00410] [INSPIRE].N. Isgur and M.B. Wise,

*Weak Decays of Heavy Mesons in the Static Quark Approximation*,*Phys. Lett. B***232**(1989) 113 [INSPIRE].N. Isgur and M.B. Wise,

*Weak transition form-factors between heavy mesons*,*Phys. Lett. B***237**(1990) 527 [INSPIRE].A.F. Falk and M. Neubert,

*Second order power corrections in the heavy quark effective theory. 1. Formalism and meson form-factors*,*Phys. Rev. D***47**(1993) 2965 [hep-ph/9209268] [INSPIRE].B. Grinstein and Z. Ligeti,

*Heavy quark symmetry in*_{B→D(∗)lν}\( \overline{\nu} \)*spectra*,*Phys. Lett. B***526**(2002) 345 [*Erratum ibid.***601**(2004) 236] [hep-ph/0111392] [INSPIRE].C. Boyd, B. Grinstein and R.F. Lebed,

*Model independent extraction of —V(cb)— using dispersion relations*,*Phys. Lett. B***353**(1995) 306 [hep-ph/9504235] [INSPIRE].I. Caprini, L. Lellouch and M. Neubert,

*Dispersive bounds on the shape of*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*(*∗*)*lepton anti-neutrino form-factors*,*Nucl. Phys. B***530**(1998) 153 [hep-ph/9712417] [INSPIRE].P. Gambino, T. Mannel and N. Uraltsev,

*B → D*^{∗}*at zero recoil revisited*,*Phys. Rev. D***81**(2010) 113002 [arXiv:1004.2859] [INSPIRE].P. Gambino, T. Mannel and N. Uraltsev,

*B → D*^{∗}*Zero-Recoil Formfactor and the Heavy Quark Expansion in QCD: A Systematic Study*,*JHEP***10**(2012) 169 [arXiv:1206.2296] [INSPIRE].N. Gubernari, A. Kokulu and D. van Dyk,

*B → P and B → V Form Factors from B-Meson Light-Cone Sum Rules beyond Leading Twist*,*JHEP***01**(2019) 150 [arXiv:1811.00983] [INSPIRE].C. Bernard et al., The \( \overline{B} \) → D

^{∗}ℓ\( \overline{\nu} \)*form factor at zero recoil from three-flavor lattice QCD: A model independent determination of |V*_{cb}*|*,*Phys. Rev. D***79**(2009) 014506 [arXiv:0808.2519] [INSPIRE].Fermilab Lattice and MILC collaborations,

*Update of |V*_{cb}*| from the*\( \overline{B} \)*→ D*^{∗}ℓ\( \overline{\nu} \)*form factor at zero recoil with three-flavor lattice QCD*,*Phys. Rev. D***89**(2014) 114504 [arXiv:1403.0635] [INSPIRE].J. Harrison, C. Davies and M. Wingate,

*|V*_{cb}*| from the*\( {\overline{B}}^0 \)*→ D*^{∗+}ℓ^{−}\( \overline{\nu} \)*zero-recoil form factor using*2 + 1 + 1*flavour HISQ and NRQCD*,*PoS***LATTICE2016**(2017) 287 [arXiv:1612.06716] [INSPIRE].F.U. Bernlochner, Z. Ligeti, M. Papucci and D.J. Robinson,

*Combined analysis of semileptonic B decays to D and D*^{∗}*: R*(*D*^{(∗)})*, |V*_{cb}*| and new physics*,*Phys. Rev. D***95**(2017) 115008 [*Erratum ibid.***97**(2018) 059902] [arXiv:1703.05330] [INSPIRE].D. Melikhov and B. Stech,

*Weak form-factors for heavy meson decays: An update*,*Phys. Rev. D***62**(2000) 014006 [hep-ph/0001113] [INSPIRE].P. Asadi, M.R. Buckley and D. Shih,

*It’s all right(-handed neutrinos): a new W*^{′}*model for the R*_{D(∗)}*anomaly*,*JHEP***09**(2018) 010 [arXiv:1804.04135] [INSPIRE].A. Greljo, D.J. Robinson, B. Shakya and J. Zupan,

*R*(*D*^{(∗)})*from W*^{′}*and right-handed neutrinos*,*JHEP***09**(2018) 169 [arXiv:1804.04642] [INSPIRE].D.J. Robinson, B. Shakya and J. Zupan,

*Right-handed neutrinos and R*(*D*^{(∗)}),*JHEP***02**(2019) 119 [arXiv:1807.04753] [INSPIRE].A. Azatov, D. Barducci, D. Ghosh, D. Marzocca and L. Ubaldi,

*Combined explanations of B-physics anomalies: the sterile neutrino solution*,*JHEP***10**(2018) 092 [arXiv:1807.10745] [INSPIRE].J. Heeck and D. Teresi,

*Pati-Salam explanations of the B-meson anomalies*,*JHEP***12**(2018) 103 [arXiv:1808.07492] [INSPIRE].P. Asadi, M.R. Buckley and D. Shih,

*Asymmetry Observables and the Origin of R*_{D(∗)}*Anomalies*,*Phys. Rev. D***99**(2019) 035015 [arXiv:1810.06597] [INSPIRE].K.S. Babu, B. Dutta and R.N. Mohapatra,

*A theory of R*(*D*^{∗}*, D*)*anomaly with right-handed currents*,*JHEP***01**(2019) 168 [arXiv:1811.04496] [INSPIRE].D. Bardhan and D. Ghosh,

*B -meson charged current anomalies: The post-Moriond 2019 status*,*Phys. Rev. D***100**(2019) 011701 [arXiv:1904.10432] [INSPIRE].J.D. Gómez, N. Quintero and E. Rojas, Charged current \( b\to c\tau {\overline{\nu}}_{\tau } \)

*anomalies in a general W*^{I}*boson scenario*,*Phys. Rev. D***100**(2019) 093003 [arXiv:1907.08357] [INSPIRE].R. Mandal, C. Murgui, A. Peñuelas and A. Pich,

*The role of right-handed neutrinos in*\( b\to c\tau \overline{\nu} \)*anomalies*, arXiv:2004.06726 [INSPIRE].

##
**Open Access**

This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC-BY 4.0), which permits any use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited

## Author information

### Authors and Affiliations

### Corresponding author

## Additional information

### Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

ArXiv ePrint: 2003.02533

## Rights and permissions

This article is published under an open access license. Please check the 'Copyright Information' section either on this page or in the PDF for details of this license and what re-use is permitted. If your intended use exceeds what is permitted by the license or if you are unable to locate the licence and re-use information, please contact the Rights and Permissions team.

## About this article

### Cite this article

Algueró, M., Descotes-Genon, S., Matias, J. *et al.* Symmetries in *B → D*^{∗}*ℓν* angular observables.
*J. High Energ. Phys.* **2020**, 156 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP06(2020)156

Received:

Revised:

Accepted:

Published:

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP06(2020)156