Abstract
This study comparatively analyzes the environmental policy development processes in the three East Asian countries: Japan, Korea, and China. The history of policy development and relative sociopolitical background are investigated and compared in relation to the countries’ economic growth using quantitative economic indicators. The comparisons show that environmental policies in the three countries, in the long run, have been converging, except for a certain time lag, and that the environmental policy development processes in the three countries were closely related to economic growth. However, when compared to Japan, the tempo of environmental policy development in China and Korea has been faster than that of their economic growth. Major differences identified in these processes were due to several factors: the role of local government, information disclosure, influence of international pressure, latecomer status, the market mechanism, and environmental issues in the policy agenda. The applicability of these findings to other East Asian countries’ experiences is examined in the final section.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agency of Natural Resource and Energy, Japan (1995) Sogo energy tokei: heisei 7 nendo (Comprehensive energy statistics: 1995 fiscal year). Tsusyosangyo Kenkyusya, Tokyo
Economic Planning Administration, Republic of Korea (1982) Major statistics of Korean economy 1982. Economic Planning Administration, Seoul
Economic Planning Agency, Japan (1995) Keizai hakusyo: heisei 7 nendo (Economic white paper: 1995 fiscal year). Printing Bureau, Ministry of Finance, Tokyo
Hao Y (1992) Environmental protection in Chinese foreign policy. Journal of Northeast Asian Studies 11(3):25–46
Harashima Y (1995) A comparative analysis of environmental policy development processes in East Asian countries (in Japanese). In: 1995 Nenkai koen yoshisyu (Collection of discussion papers in 1995 annual meeting). Society of Environmental Science, Tsukuba, p 35
Harashima Y (1996) A comparative study of environmental policy development processes in East Asian countries (in Japanese). In: 1996 Nenkai koen yoshisyu (Collection of discussion papers in 1996 annual meeting). Society of Environmental Science, Tsukuba, pp 176–177
Harashima Y, Morita T (1995) A comparative analysis of environmental policy development processes in East Asian countries (in Japanese). Keikaku Gyosei (Planning Administration) 18(3):73–85
Hishida K (1986) The current state of environmental problems in China (in Japanese). Sangyo Kogai (Industrial Pollution) 22(7):14–23
Huntington S (1991) The third wave: democratization in the late twentieth century. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman
Imura H, Katsuhara T (eds) (1995) Higashi Asia no kogyoka to kankyo mondai (Industrialization and environmental problems in East Asia). Kokusai Higashi Asia Kenkyu Centre, Kita-kyusyu
Kato K (1996) Legal frameworks for environmental governance in East and Southeast Asian countries (East-West Center working paper). East-West Center, Honolulu
Kojima R, Fujisaki S (eds) (1993) Kankyo to kaihatsu: higashi Asia no keiken (Environment and development: the East Asian experiences). Asia Keizai Kenkyuujyo, Tokyo
Koo Y (1979) Legal aspects of environmental protection in Korea. Korean Journal of Comparative Law 7:1–59
Korea Energy Economic Institute (1992) 1992 Yearbook of energy statistics. Korea Energy Economic Institute, Seoul
Korea Energy Economic Institute (1994) 1994 Yearbook of energy statistics. Korea Energy Economic Institute, Seoul
Korea Institute for International Economic Policy (1993) A study in Sino-Korean environmental cooperation (in Korean). Korea Institute for International Economic Policy, Seoul
Lee J, Harashima Y, Lee D, Morita T (1995) A comparative analysis of processes used in developing environmental policies in Japan and Korea (in Japanese). Kankyo Kagaku (Environmental Science) 8(2):181–192
Levine M, Liu F, Sinton J (1992) China’s energy system: historical evolution, current issues, and prospects. Annual Review of Energy and the Environment 17:405–435
Ministry of Environment, Republic of Korea (1992) National report of the Republic of Korea to UNCED, Seoul
Morishima A (1981) Japanese environmental policy and law. In: Kato I, Kumamoto N, Matthews W (eds) Environmental law and policy in the Pacific Basin area. University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, pp 77–84
National Statistical Office, Republic of Korea (1996) Major statistics of Korean economy 1996. National Statistical Office, Seoul
O’Connor D (1994) Managing the environment with rapid industrialization: lessons from the East Asian experience. OECD, Paris
OECD (1977) Environmental policies in Japan. OECD, Paris
Pearce D, Markandya A, Barbier E (1989) Blueprint for a green economy. Earthscan, London
People’s Republic of China (1992) National report of the People’s Republic of China on environment and development. China Environmental Science Press, Beijing
Porter G, Brown J (1996) Global environmental politics, 2nd edn. Westview Press, Boulder, CO, USA
Qu G (1990) China’s environmental policy and world environmental problems. International Environmental Affairs 2(2):103–108
Qu G (1991) Environmental management in China. UNEP/China Environmental Science Press, Beijing
Siml V (1993) China’s environmental crisis: an inquiry into the limits of national development. M.E. Sharp, Armonk, NY, USA
State Statistical Bureau, People’s Republic of China (1992) China statistical yearbook 1992. China Statistical Publishing House, Beijing
State Statistical Bureau, People’s Republic of China (1995) China statistical yearbook 1995. China Statistical Publishing House, Beijing
Summers R, Heston A (1991) The Penn world table (Mark5): an expanded set of international comparison 1950–1988. Quarterly Journal of Economics May 1991:327–368
Toyo-Keizai (ed) (1991) Kanketsu Syowa kokusei soran: dai 1 kan (Statistics of the state of a country in Syowa era; vol 1). Toyo-Keizai, Tokyo
Vogel D (1987) The comparative study of environmental policy: a review of the literature. In: Dierkes M, Weiler H, Antal A (eds) Comparative policy research: learning from experience. Gower Publishing, Hants, pp 99–169
Wakabayashi K (1989) Chugoku no jinko mondai (Population problems in China). University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo
World Bank (1992) World development report 1992. Oxford University Press, New York
World Commission on Environment and Development (1987) Our common future. Oxford University Press, London
Yamazawa I (1993) Transmission of industrial development and international industrial adjustment. Keizai Bunseki (Economic Analysis) 129:14–36
Zhang K, Jin R (eds) (1992) A course in China’s environmental protection law. Tsinghua University Press, Beijing
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
About this article
Cite this article
Harashima, Y., Morita, T. A comparative study on environmental policy development processes in the three East Asian countries: Japan, Korea, and China. Environ Econ Policy Stud 1, 39–67 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03353894
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03353894