Abstract
Although interstitial techniques are invasive, they are still the first-line therapeutic modalities for certain types of tumour. They are mainly relevant to tumours that are either inoperable or located so deep that access is complicated. Of the various types of radiation that can be delivered by the interstitial route, ultrasound is the most suitable for deep heating. The study compares the efficacy of two types of applicator with respect to their ability to induce cylindrical zones of coagulation necrosis. The transducer of the first applicator is tubular, whereas the second is plane and can rotate around its axis. Both have an external diameter of 4mm, are fitted with surface cooling systems and operate at 10.7 MHz and 14W.cm−2. Comparison involves mathematical modelling of ablated tissue in the targeted area by resolving the bioheat transfer equation (BHTE) using an algorithm based on finite differences. The BHTE gives a temperature value from which the thermal dose can be determined. It is shown that tissue ablation by tubular transducers is slow, and, in consequence, perfusion disturbs the heating pattern: in vivo, irradiation with a tubular transducer lasting 1081 s would be required to ablate a tissue mass with a radius of 8mm. The corresponding period using a rotating plane transducer with 20 firing angles is only 618s. The mean exposure time of each shot lasts 31±7s. Therefore perfusion would have much less impact in the case of therapy administered using a plane transducer than that using a tubular one.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Billard, B. E., Hynynen, K., andRoemer, R. B. (1990): ‘Effects of physical parameters on high temperature ultrasound hyperthermia’,Ultrasound Med. Biol.,16, pp. 409–420
Bioulac-Sage, P., Le Bail, B., andBaladaud, C. (1993): ‘Histologie du foie et des voies biliaires’,in Benhamou, J.P., Bircher, J., MacIntyre, N., Rizetto, M., andRodes, J. (Eds.): ‘Hépathologie clinique’ (Med. Sciences/Flammarion), pp. 12–20
Chapelon, J. Y., Margonari, J., Vernier, F., Gorry, F., Ecochard, R. andGelet, A. (1992): ‘In vivo effects of high-intensity ultrasound on prostatic adenocarcinoma Dunning R 3327’,Cancer Res.,52, pp. 6353–6357
Chato, J. S., Gautherie, M., Paulsen, K. D., andRoemer, R. B. (Eds.) (1990): ‘Thermal dosimetry and treatment planning. Fundamentals of bioheat transfer’ pp. 1–56
Damianou, C. A., Sanghvi, N. T., andFry, F. J. (1995): ‘Ultrasonic attenuation of dog tissues as a function of temperature’. IEEE Ultrasonic Symposium, pp. 1203–1206
Diederich, C. J. (1996a): ‘Ultrasound applicators with integrated catheter-cooling for interstitial hyperthermia: theory and preliminary experiments’,Int. J. Hyperthermia,12, (2), pp. 279–297
Diederich, C. J. (1996b): ‘Direct-coupled interstitial ultrasound applicators for simultaneous thermobrachytherapy: a feasibility study’,Int. J. Hyperthermia,12, (3), pp. 401–419
Fry, W. J., Mosberg, W. H., Barnard, J. W., andFry, F. J. (1954): ‘Production of focal destructive lesions in the central nervous system with ultrasound’,Neurosurg.,11, pp. 471–478
Hynynen, K., Dennie, J., Zimmer, J. E., Simmons, W. N., He, D. S., Marcus, F. I., andAguirre, M. (1997): ‘Cylindrical ultrasonic transducers for cardiac catheter ablation’,IEEE Trans.,BME-44, (2), pp. 144–151
Lafon, C., Chapelon, J. Y., Prat, F., Gorry, F., Margonari, J., Theillere, Y., andCathignol, D. (1998a): ‘Design and preliminary results of an ultrasound applicator for interstitial thermal coagulation’,Ultrasound Med. Biol.,24, (1), pp. 113–122
Lafon, C., Chapelon, J. Y., Prat, F., Gorry, F., Theillère, Y., andCathignol, D. (1998b): ‘Design andin vitro results of a high intensity ultrasound interstitial applicator’Ultrasonic,36, pp. 683–687
Lafon, C., Prat, F., Chapelon, J. Y., Gorry, F., Margonari, J., Theillère, Y., andCathignol, D. (1999): ‘Cylindrical thermal coagulation necrosis using an interstitial applicator with a plane ultrasonic transducer.In vitro andin vivo experiments versus computer simulations’,Int. J. Hypertherm., to be published
Malcolm, A. L., andTer Haar, G. (1996): ‘Ablation of tissues using high intensity focused ultrasound’,Ultrasound Med. Biol.,22, (5), pp. 659–669
O'Neil, H. T. (1949): ‘Theory of focusing radiators’,J. Acoust. Soc. Am.,21, (5), pp. 516–526
Sapareto, S. A., andDewey, W. C. (1984): ‘Thermal dose determination in cancer therapy’,Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys.,10, pp. 787–800
Stauffer, P. R., Diederich, C. J., andSeegenschmidt, M. H. (1995): ‘Interstitial technologies’in Seegenschmiedt, M. H., Fessenden, P., andVernon, C. C. (Eds.), ‘Thermo-radiotherapy and thermo-chemotherapy’ (Springer Verlag, Berlin, Germany) pp. 279–320
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lafon, C., Chavrier, F., Prat, F. et al. Theoretical comparison of two interstitial ultrasound applicators designed to induce cylindrical zones of tissue ablation. Med. Biol. Eng. Comput. 37, 298–303 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02513303
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02513303