Abstract
In this paper, we present a pilot study in which we use probabilistic risk analysis (PRA) to assess patient risk in anesthesia and its human factor component. We then identify and evaluate the benefits of several risk reduction policies. We focus on healthy patients, in modern hospitals, and on cases where the anesthetist is a trained medical doctor. When an accident occurs for such patients, it is often because an error was made by the anesthesiologist, either triggering the event that initiated the accident sequence, or failing to take timely corrective measures. We present first a dynamic PRA model of anesthesia accidents. Our data include published results of the Australian Incident Monitoring Study as well as expert opinions. We link the probabilities of the different types of accidents to the “state of the anesthesiologist” characterized both in terms of alertness and competence. We consider different management factors that affect the state of the anesthesiologist, we identify several risk reduction policies, and we compute the corresponding risk reduction benefits based on the PRA model. We conclude that periodic recertification of all anesthesiologists, the use of anesthesia simulators in training, and closer supervision of residents could reduce substantially the patient risk.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Buck, N., H.B. Devlin and J.L. Lunn, Report on the confidential enquiry into perioperative deaths, Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust, The Kings Fund Publishing House, London, 1987.
Campling, B.A., H.B. Devlin, R.W. Hoile and J.N. Lunn, Report of the national confidential enquiry into perioperative deaths, 1990, National confidential enquiry into perioperative deaths, London, UK, 1992.
Chappelow, J., The psychology of safety, Balliere's Clinical Anaesthesiology, 2, 1988, 265–281.
Chappelow, J.W., Error in military aviation, Position paper forConference on Human Error in Anesthesia, Asilomar, CA, 1991.
Cook, R.I., D.D. Woods and J.S. McDonald, Human performance in anesthesia. A corpus of cases, CSEL Report CSEL91.003, Cognitive Systems Engineering Laboratory, Ohio State University, Columbus, 1991.
Cooper, J.B., C.D. Long, R.S. Newbower and J.H. Philip, Critical incidents associated with intraoperative exchanges of anesthesia personnel, Anesthesiology 56, 1982, 456–461.
Cooper, J.B., R.S. Newbower and R.J. Kitz, An analysis of major errors and equipment failures in anesthesia management: Considerations for prevention and detection, Anesthesiology 60, 1984, 34–42.
Cooper, J.B., R.S. Newbower, C.D. Long and B. McPeek, Preventable anesthesia mishaps: A study of human factors, Anesthesiology 49, 1978, 399–406.
Davies, J.M. and L. Strunin, Anesthesia in 1984: How safe is it?, Canadian Medical Association Journal 131, 1984, 437–441.
Dement W., Sleep deprivation and anesthetic errors, Position paper forConference on Human Error in Anesthesia, Asilomar, CA, 1991.
Gaba, D.M., Human error in anesthetic mishaps, International Anesthesiology Clinics 27, 1989, 137–147.
Gaba, D., Human performance issues in anesthesia patient safety, Problems in Anesthesia 5, 1991, 329–350.
Gaba, D., Dynamic decision-making in anesthesiology: Cognitive models and training approaches, inAdvanced Models of Cognition for Medical Training and Practice, D. Evans and V. Patel, eds., Springer, Berlin, 1992a, pp. 122–147.
Gaba, D.M., Improving anesthesiologists' performance by simulating reality (editorial), Anesthesiology 76, 1992b, 491–494.
Gaba, D.M., Human work environment and simulators, inAnesthesia, R.D. Miller, ed., Churchill Livingstone, New York, 1994, chapter 85.
Gaba, D.M., K.J. Fish and S.K. Howard,Crisis Management in Anesthesiology, Churchill Livingstone, New York, 1994.
Gaba, D.M. S.K. Howard and B. Jump, Production pressure in the work environment: California anesthesiologists' attitudes and experiences, Anesthesiology, 1994.
Henley, E.J. and H. Kumamoto,Reliability Engineering and Risk Assessment, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1981.
Inlander, C.B., L.S. Levin and E. Weiner,Medicine on Trial: The Appalling Story of Medical Ineptitude and the Arrogance that Overlooks it, Pantheon, New York, 1988.
Keenan, R.L. and C.P. Boyan, Cardiac arrest due to anesthesia; A study of incidence and causes, Journal of the American Medical Association 253, 1985, 2373–2377.
Krueger, G.P., Sustained work, fatigue, sleep loss and performance: Areview of the issues, Work & Stress 3, 1989, 129–141.
Lee, R.B., Issues in pilot performance and flight safety,Proceedings of Orient Airlines Association Safety Seminar, Manila, 1987.
Lee, R.B., Human error: The lessons from aviation, Position paper forConference on Human Error in Anesthesia, Asilomar, CA, 1991.
Paté-Cornell, M.E., Organizational aspects of engineering system safety: The case of offshore platforms, Science 250, 1990, 1210–1217.
Paté-Cornell, M.E., Subjective de-biasing of data sets: A Bayesian approach, inProceedings of the Engineering Foundation Conference on Risk-Based Decision Making, Santa Barbara, CA, 1993.
Paté-Cornell, M.E. and R.G. Bea, Management errors and system reliability: A probabilistic approach and application to offshore platforms, Risk Analysis 12, 1991, 1–18.
Paté-Cornell, M.E. and P.S. Fischbeck, PRA as a management tool: Organizational factors and risk-based priorities for the maintenance of the tiles of the space shuttle orbiter, Reliability Engineering and System Safety 40, 1993, 239–257.
Paté-Cornell, M.E., D.M. Murphy and L.M. Lakats, Anesthesia patient safety: Probabilistic risk analysis and benefits of organizational improvements, Stanford University, Research report to the Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation, 1994.
Runciman, W.B., A. Sellen, R.K. Webb, J.A. Williamson, M. Currie, C. Morgan and W.J. Russel, Errors, incidents and accidents in anaesthetic practice, Anaesthesia and Intensive Care 21, 1993a, 506–519.
Runciman, W.B., R.K. Webb, I.D. Klepper, R. Lee, J.A. Williamson and L. Barker, Crisis management: Validation of an algorithm by analysis of 2000 incident reports, Anaesthesia and Intensive Care 21, 1993b, 579–592.
Verhovek, S.H., Whispered factor in rising cost of care: Medical incompetence, The New York Times, 9 April 1994, pp. 1, 8.
Webb, R.K., M. Currie, C.A. Morgan, J.A. Williamson, P. Mackay, W.J. Russel and W.B. Runciman, The Australian incident monitoring study: An analysis of 2000 incident reports, Anaesthesia and Intensive Care 21, 1993, 520–528.
Weinger, M.B. and C.E. Englund, Ergonomic and human factors affecting anesthetic vigilance and monitoring performance in the operating room environment, Anesthesiology 75, 1990, 995–1021.
Williamson, J.A., R.K. Webb, A. Sellen, W.B. Runciman and J.H. Van der Walt, Human failure: An analysis of 2000 incident reports, Anaesthesia and Intensive Care 21, 1993, 678–83.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Paté-Cornell, E., Murphy, D., Lakats, L. et al. Patient risk in anesthesia: Probabilistic risk analysis and management improvements. Ann Oper Res 67, 211–233 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02187030
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02187030