Abstract
I recently took issue with Kathryn George's contention that vegetarianism cannot be a moral obligation for most human beings, even assuming that Tom Regan's stringent thesis about the equal inherent value of humans and many sentient nonhumans is correct. I argued that both Regan and George are incorrect in claiming that his view would permit moral agents to kill and eat innocent, non-threatening rights holders. An “unequal rights view”, by contrast, would permit such actions if a moral agent's health or life is at stake. I then argued that current nutritional research does not support Professor George's claim that some wealthy adult males (and many fewer wealthy women) are the only persons whose health does not require the consumption of nonhuman animals and their products. In her 1992 response to my critique, George did not address my moral argumentation. She concentrated her entire paper on a wholesale rejection of my discussion of nutrition. Although she now takes a somewhat more moderate position on who can safely contemplate strict vegetarianism, she still believes that most people are not in a position to follow such a diet. In my counter-reply, I argue that her rejection is based upon numerous distortions, omissions, and false charges of fallacy. She even devotes a substantial section of her paper to criticizing me for saying the opposite of what I actually wrote. As I did in my earlier paper, I cite current research, including George's own preferred source on the topic of vegetarianism, to support my view. I conclude that Professor George has still not shown that for most human beings it is dangerous to follow a diet that omits nonhuman animals and their products. Moral agents who take the rights of humansand nonhumans seriously will find vegetarianism well worth considering.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abeloe, B. J. et al. 1992. Cross-cultural Association between Dietary Animal Protein and Hip Fracture: A Hypothesis.Calcified Tissue International 50: 14–18.
ADA Reports 1988. Position of the American Dietetic Association: Vegetarian Diets.The Journal of the American Dietetic Association 88 (3): 351–55.
American Academy of Pediatrics. 1992. The Use of Whole Cow's Milk in Infancy.Pediatrics 89 (6): 1105–9.
Brody, Jane. 1982.Jane Brody's Nutrition Book. New York, NY. Bantam Books.
—. 1990. Huge Study of Diet Indicts Fat and Meat.The New York Times: Science Times, May 8: C1, C14.
Burstyn, P. 1982. Effects of Meat on BP. Letter toJournal of the American Medical Association 248 (1): 29–30.
Campbell, T. Colin, and Junyao, Li. 1990.Diet, Lifestyle, and Mortality in China: A Study of the Characteristics of 65 Counties. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
— and T. Brun et al. 1990a. Questioning Riboflavin Recommendations on the Basis of a Survey in China.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 51: 436–45.
— and J. Chen et al. 1990b. Nonassociation of Aflatoxin with Primary Liver Cancer in a Cross-Sectional Ecological Survey in the People's Republic of China.Cancer Research 50: 6882–93.
— and J. Chen et al. 1992. China: From Diseases of Poverty to Diseases of Affluence. Policy Implications of the Epidemiological Transition.Ecology of Food and Nutrition 27: 133–44.
Carter, J.P., et al. 1987. Preeclampsia and Reproductive Performance in a Community of Vegans.Southern Medical Journal 80 (6): 692–97.
Cohen, Joel E. 1992. How Many People Can Earth Hold?Discover Magazine, November: 114–19.
Cramer, D. W. et al. 1989. Galactose Consumption and Metabolism in Relation to the Risk of Ovarian Cancer.Lancet 2: 66–71.
Deskins, Barbara. 1991. Lean Diet of Chinese Sets Example.The Pittsburgh Press, December 12: F 1–6.
Durning, A. B., and Brough, H. 1991. Taking Stock: Animal Farming and the Environment.Worldwatch Paper 103. Washington, DC: Worldwatch Institute.
Dwyer, J.T. 1991. Nutritional Consequences of Vegetarianism.Annual Reviews in Nutrition 11: 61–91.
George, Kathryn P. 1990. So Human an Animal ..., or the Moral Relevance of Being an Omnivore.The Journal of Agricultural Ethics 3 (2): 172–86.
— 1992. The Use and Abuse of Scientific Studies.The Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 5 (2): 217–33.
Heaney, R. P., and Weaver, C. 1990. Calcium Absorption from Kale.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 51: 656–7.
Hegsted, D. M. 1986. Calcium and Osteoporosis.Journal of Nutrition 116: 2316–19.
Herbert, V. H. 1988. Vitamin B12: Plant Sources, Requirements, and Assay.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 48: 852–8.
Karjalainen, J. et al. 1992. A Bovine Albumin Peptide as a Possible Trigger of Insulin-Dependent Diabetes Mellitus.The New England Journal of Medicine 327 (5): 302–7.
Kelsay, J. L. et al. 1988. Impact of Variation in Carbohydrate Intake on Mineral Utilization by Vegetarians.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 48: 875–79.
Lappé, Frances. 1982.Diet for a Small Planet. Tenth Anniversary Edition. New York, NY: Ballentine Books.
Levy, E. M. et al. 1985. Patients with Kaposi Sarcoma Who Opt for No Treatment.Lancet July 27: 223.
Malter, M. et al. 1989. Natural Killer Cells, Vitamins, and Other Blood Components of Vegetarian and Omnivorous Men.Nutrition and Cancer 12 (3): 271–8.
Mason, Jim, and Singer, Peter. 1990.Animal Factories, 2nd Edition. New York, NY: Harmony Books.
Millet, P. et al. 1989. Nutrient Intake and Vitamin Status of Healthy French Vegetarians and Nonvegetarians.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 50: 718–27.
Moffat, Anne S. 1990. China: A Living Lab for Epidemiology.Science 248, May 4: 553–555.
O'Connell, et al. 1989. Growth of Vegetarian Children: The Farm Study.Pediatrics 84 (3): 475–480.
Pluhar, Evelyn B. Who Can be Morally Obligated to be a Vegetarian?The Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 5 (2): 189–215.
Regan, Tom. 1983.The Case for Animal Rights. Berkeley, CA: The University of California Press.
Riggs, B. L. et al. 1987. Dietary Calcium Intake and Rates of Bone Loss in Women.Journal of Clinical Investigation 80 (October): 979–82.
Roberts, Leslie. 1988. Diet and Health in China.Science 240: 27.
Rosen, Stephen. 1987.Food for the Spirit: Vegetarianism and the World Religions. New York, NY: Bala Books.
Rouse, I. L., and Armstrong, B.K. 1983. Blood-Pressure-Lowering Effect of a Vegetarian Diet.Lancet January: 5–10.
Sacks, F. M. et al. 1981. Effect of Ingestion of Meat on Plasma Cholesterol of Vegetarians.Journal of the American Medical Association 246 (6): 640–44.
Science. 1986. Research News: How Important is Dietary Calcium in Preventing Osteoporosis? August 1: 519–20.
Science News. 1992. Inside Broccoli: A Weapon Against Cancer. March 21: 183.
Scrimshaw, Nevin. 1991. Iron Deficiency.Scientific American, October: 46–52.
Simoons, F. J. 1982. A Geographic Approach to Senile Cataracts: Possible Links with Milk Consumption, Lactase Activity, and Galactose Metabolism.Digestive Diseases and Sciences 27 (3): 257–64.
Time Magazine. 1992. Fortified Bread. December 7: 30.
Varkonyi, Cherlyne. 1990. No Bones About It, You Need Calcium.The Pittsburgh Press, June 24: E 7.
Zemel, M. B. 1988. Calcium Utilization: Effect of Varying Level and Source of Dietary Protein.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 48: 880–3.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pluhar, E.B. On vegetarianism, morality, and science: A counter reply. J Agric Environ Ethics 6, 185–213 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01965483
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01965483