Summary
The Bowen ratio-energy balance (BREB) and the stability-corrected aerodynamic method were used to estimate turbulent fluxes of sensible and latent heat at an irrigated alfalfa site in a semi-arid valley in northern Utah, U.S.A., during August and September of 1991. Despite inclusion of a generalized stability factor, the aerodynamic method underestimated the daytime (sunrise-sunset) sensible and latent heat fluxes by approximately 30% in comparison with the BREB method. The sum of the aerodynamic estimates of sensible and latent heat seldom balanced the energy avaiable from net radiation and change in storage. Wind speed was low during the experiment (averaging 1.6 m s−1), and so a second analysis was run for data from daytime, non-rainy, turbulent conditions (wind > 1.5 m s−1). This showed that sensible and latent heat were still underestimated by approximately 30% in comparison with the BREB approach. This suggests that underestimation of sensible and latent heat fluxes by the aerodynamic method was not related to the wind speed conditions during the experiment. These results show that the stability-corrected aerodynamic model did not agree with the Bowen ratio method in this experiment. It appears unlikely that the discrepancies resulted from measurement errors. Perhaps the theoretical foundation of the similarity parameters (stability functions) in the aerodynamic model are not sufficiently generalized. The discrepancies found here confirm the necessity of calibration checks on the validity of aerodynamic estimates of the turbulent fluxes.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bowen, I. S., 1926: The ratio of heat losses by conduction and by evaporation from any water surface.Phys. Rev. 27, 779–787.
Brutsaert, W. H., 1975: Comments on surface roughness parameters and the height of dense vegetation.J. Meteor. Soc. Jpn. 53, 96–97.
Burman, R. D., Jensen, M. E., Allen, R. G., 1987: Thermodynamic factors in evapotranspiration. pp. 140–148. In: James, L. G., English, M. J. (eds.) Proc. Irrig. Drain. Specialty Conf., Portland, OR. 28–30 July 1987. ASCE, New York.
Covey, W., 1963: A method for the computation of logarithmic wind profile parameters and their standard errors. The Energy Budget at Earth Surface. Part 2. U.S. Dept. Agric. Prep., 28–33.
Denmead, O. T., McIllroy, I. C., 1970: Measurements of non-potential evaporation from wheat.Agric. Meteorol. 7, 285–302.
Dugas, W. A., Fritschen, L. J., Gay, L. W., Held, A. A., Matthias, A. D., Reicosky, D. C., Steduto, P., Steiner, J. L., 1991: Bowen ratio, eddy correlation, and portable chamber measurements of sensible and latent heat flux over irrigated spring wheat.Agric. For. Meterorol. 56, 1–20.
Hanks, R. J., Ashcroft. G. L., 1980:Applied Soil Physics. New York: Springer, 159 pp.
Hill, R. W., Johns, E. L., Frevert, D. K., 1983: Comparison of equations used for estimating agricultural crop evapotranspiration with field research. Tech. Rep., U.S. Dept. Inter., Bureau of Reclam., Eng. Res. Ctr. Denver, CO. 262 pp.
List, R. J., 1984:Smithsonian Meteorological Tables. Washington D.C.: Smithsonian Institute, 527 pp.
Malek, E., Bingham, G. E., McCurdy, G. D., 1990: Evapotranspiration from the margin and moist playa of a closed desert valley.J. Hydrol. 120, 15–34.
Malek, E., Bingham, G. E., McCurdy, G. D., Hanks, R. J., 1992: Determination of alfalfa evapotranspiration irrigated with saline waste water from the electrical power plant.Irrig. Sci. 13, 73–80.
Matthias, A. D., Kustas, W. P., Gay, L. W., Cooper, D. I., Alves, L. M., Pinter, P. J., Jr., 1990: Aerodynamic parameters for a sparsely roughened surface composed of small cotton plants and ridged soil.Remote Sensing Environ. 32, 143–153.
Monteith, J. L., Unsworth, M. H., 1990:Principles of Environmental Physics. New York: Routledge Chapman and Hall Publ., 228 pp.
Ohmura, A., 1982: Objective criteria for rejecting data for Bowen ratio flux calculations.J. Appl. Meteor. 21(4), 595–598.
Oke, T. R., 1970: Turbulent transport near the ground in stable conditions.J. Appl. Meteor. 9, 778–786.
Oke, T. R., 1987:Boundary Layer Climatology 2nd edn. New York: Methuen, 435 pp.
Robinson, S. M., 1962: Computing wind profile parameters.J. Atmos. Sci. 19, 189–190.
Stanhill, G., 1969: A simple instrument for the field measurement of turbulent diffusion flux.J. Appl. Meteor. 8, 509–513.
Szeicz, G., Endrodi, G., Tajchman, S., 1969: Aerodynamic and surface factors in evaporation.Water Resour. Res., 380–394.
Tanner, C. B., 1960: Energy balance approach to evapotranspiration from plants and soils.J. Soil Water Conserv. 12, 221–227.
Thompson, O. E., Pinker, R. T., 1981: An error analysis of the Thornthwaite-Holzman equations for estimating sensible and latent heat fluxes over crop and forest canopies.J. Appl. Meteor. 20, 250–254.
Thorthwaite, C. W., Holzman, B., 1942: Measurement of evaporation from land and water surface.USDA Tech. Bull. 817, 1–75.
Vogt, R., Jaeger, L., 1990: Evaporation from a pine forest — Using the aerodynamic method and Bowen ratio method.Agric. For. Meteorol. 50, 39–54.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
With 7 Figures
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Malek, E. Comparison of the Bowen ratio-energy balance and stability-corrected aerodynamic methods for measurement of evapotranspiration. Theor Appl Climatol 48, 167–178 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00864923
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00864923