Abstract
Excellence in education has become the watchword in the past decade. This paper describes aspects of research conducted with two secondary mathematics teachers and seven senior students, which explored their perceptions of mathematics as they have experienced it, and their beliefs about personal excellence in school mathematics. Three categories of excellent students are described as identified by the participants. While the teachers endeavoured to extend the meaning of excellence beyond test achievement alone, the system within which they function largely supports a technical (excellence as marks) conception of education. I argue that this has led teachers and students to a restricted view of the potential for excellence in the secondary mathematics classroom. In particular, it limits the possibility for a strong understanding of personal excellence as an inseparable intellectual and moral journey of ‘becoming’, fostered in the environment of a genuine community of mathematics learners.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aoki, T.: 1990, ‘Beyond the half-life of curriculum and pedagogy,’ delta-K 28(2), 5–12.
Arendt, H.: 1958, The Human Condition, University of Chicago, Chicago.
Aristotle: 1980, The Nichomachean Ethics (W.D. Ross, Trans., rev. by J.L. Ackrill and J.O. Urmson), Oxford University, Oxford.
Bond, E.J.: 1983, Reason and Value, Cambridge University, Cambridge.
Broudy, H.S., Smith, B.O. and Burnett, J.R.: 1964, Democracy and Excellence in American Secondary Education, Rand McNally, Chicago.
Burton, L.: 1987, ‘From failure to success: Changing the experience of adult learners of mathematics,’ Educational Studies in Mathematics 18, 305–316.
Council of Ministers of Education, Canada: 1988, Recent Trends in Curriculum Reform at the Elementary and Secondary Levels in Canada, Author, Toronto.
Crittenden, B.: 1973, Education and Social Ideals: A Study in Philosophy of Education, Longman Canada, Don Mills.
Donaldson, G.A. Jr.: 1985, ‘Sisyphus and school improvement: Fulfilling the promise of excellence,’ Educational Leadership 42(6), 4–7.
Doyle, D.P.: 1987, ‘The excellence movement, academic standards, a core curriculum and choice: How do they connect?’, in W.L.Boyd and C.T.Kerchner (eds.), The Politics of Excellence and Choice in Education, Falmer, New York, pp. 13–23.
Drengson, A.R.: 1983, ‘Mastery and masters,’ Philosophy Today 27, 230–246.
Driscoll, M.J.: 1987, Stories of Excellence: Ten Case Studies from a Study of Exemplary Mathematics Programs, National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, Reston.
DuFour, R. and Eaker, R.: 1987. Fulfilling the Promise of Excellence: A Practitioner's Guide to School Improvement, Wilkerson, Westbury, NY.
Ernest, P.: 1991, The Philosophy of Mathematics Education, Falmer, London.
Franks, D.R.: 1992, A Study of the Meanings of Excellence in School Mathematics for Secondary Mathematics Teachers and Students, unpublished dissertation, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
Gardner, J.W.: 1984, Excellence: Can We be Equal and Excellent Too?, (rev. ed.), Norton, New York.
Glazer, N.: 1985, ‘The problem with competence’, in J.H.Bunzel (ed.), Challenge to American Schools: The Case for Standards and Values, Oxford University, New York, pp. 216–231.
Gowin, D.B.: 1981, Educating, Cornell University, Ithaca.
Grant, G.: 1985, ‘Schools that make an imprint: Creating a strong positive ethos’, in J.H.Bunzel (ed.), Challenge to American Schools: The Case for Standards and Values, Oxford University, New York, pp. 127–143.
Greene, M.: 1984, ‘“Excellence”, meanings, and multiplicity’, Teachers College Record 86, 283–297.
Greene, M.: 1989, ‘The question of standards’, Teachers College Record 91, 9–14.
Hale, F.W. Jr.: 1978, ‘An agenda for excellence: You can make the difference’, Phi Delta Kappan 60, 204S-206S.
Howe, H. II.: 1987, ‘Remarks on equity and excellence in education’, Harvard Educational Review 57, 199–202.
Knitter, W.: 1988, ‘The informing vision of the practical: The concepts of character, virtue, vice and privation’, Journal of Curriculum Studies 20, 483–492.
Kvale, S.: 1984, ‘The qualitative research interview: A phenomenological and a hermeneutical mode of understanding’, Journal of Phenomenological Psychology 14, 482–496.
Lyons, D.: 1976, ‘Action, excellence, and achievement’, Inquiry 19, 277–297.
Nathanson, J.: 1974, ‘Individuality, permissiveness, and work’, in J.Nathanson (ed.), Individual Excellence and Social Responsibility, Prometheus, Buffalo, pp. 1–22.
National Commission on Excellence in Education: 1983, ‘A nation at risk: The imperative for educational reform’, Communications of the ACM 26, 467–478.
National Council of Teachers of Mathematics: 1989, Curriculum and Evaluation Standards for School Mathematics, Author, Reston, VA.
National Council of Teachers of Mathematics: 1995, Assessment Standards for School Mathematics, Author, Reston, VA.
Noblit, G.W. and Pink, W.T. (eds.): 1987, Schooling in Social Context: Qualitative Studies, Ablex, Norwood, NJ.
Norton, D.L.: 1980, ‘Equality and excellence in the democratic ideal’, in M.Wohlgelernter (ed.), History, Religion, and Spiritual Democracy, Columbia University, New York, pp. 273–293.
Peters, R.S.: 1975, ‘Education and the educated man’, in R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst and R.S.Peters (eds.), A Critique of Current Educational Aims, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London, pp. 1–16.
Prakash, M.S. and Waks, L.J.: 1985, ‘Four conceptions of excellence’, Teachers College Record 87, 79–101.
Rokeach, M.: 1973, The Nature of Human Value, Free Press, New York.
Romberg, T.A. and Carpenter, T.P.: 1986, ‘Research on teaching and learning mathematics: Two disciplines of scientific enquiry’, in M.C.Wittrock (ed.), Handbook of Research on Teaching, (3rd. ed.), New York, Macmillan, pp. 850–873.
Singleton, W.T.: 1979, ‘Final discussion’, in W.T.Singleton (ed.), Compliance and Excelience, MTP, Lancaster, pp. 306–317.
Sirotnik, K.A. and Goodlad, J.I.: 1985, ‘The quest for reason amidst the rhetoric of reform: Improving instead of testing our schools’, in W.J.Johnston (ed.), Education on Trial: Strategies for the Future, Institute for Contemporary Studies, San Francisco, pp. 277–298.
Stern, A.: 1962, Philosophy of History and the Problem of Values, Mouton, The Hague.
Timar, T.B. and Kirp, D.L.: 1988, Managing Educational Excellence, Falmer, New York.
Von Wright, G.H.: 1963, The Varieties of Goodness, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.
Wilcox, S.K., Schram, P., Lappan, G. and Lanier, P.: 1991, The Role of a Learning Community in Changing Preservice Teachers' Knowledge and Beliefs about Mathematics Education, East Lansing: National Center for Research on Teacher Education, Michigan State University, East Lansing.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Franks, D.R. A situational study of the meanings of personal excellence for secondary mathematics teachers and students. Educ Stud Math 31, 295–317 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00376324
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00376324