Studies of heavy metal sorption by Trenton Channel (Detroit River) sediments

Abstract

Sediment resuspension plays a dominant physical role in downstream transport of sediment-bound, or ‘in-place’ pollutants. During resuspension, however, numerous sorption reactions may alter contaminant phase distributions. Previous field resuspension studies on heavily contaminated sediments (Theis et al., 1988, J. Great Lakes Res. 14, 216) showed parallel trends in metal partitioning with pH and time for each of 7 metals (Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb, Zn), when pH was < 7.5 during resuspension. To improve our ability to interpret follow-up laboratory partitioning experiments using sediments from the field sites, we conducted an evaluation of sediment sample storage as a potential factor leading to field-laboratory partitioning differences. Although metal sorption observed in the laboratory differed substantially from that observed in the field, sample storage effects, reported as holding time and changes in solid phase metal fractionation, gave minimal support for the hypothesis that sample storage caused the differences. It appears, rather, than our in vitro batch equilibrium systems incompletely replicated those attributes of a sediment-water system that are relevant to adsorption and desorption of heavy metals during a resuspension event. Accordingly, we conclude that a general improvement in the understanding of contaminant partitioning would result if future studies would assign greater importance to evaluating the effects of relevant physical phenomena on partitioning (e.g. particle interaction and shear stress), in addition to such widely studied chemical determinants as pH, time, and metal species.