Modelling the effects of alternative nutrient control policies — the example of Slapton Ley, Devon, UK

Abstract

In the period since 1945, Slapton Ley, a small, coastal lake in Southwest England, has been eutrophccated by nutrient inputs generated both by the intensification of agriculture, and the discharge of sewage effluent. Two simple models have been used to identify the main sources of catchment outputs, and to evaluate historical changes in land use, and their likely effect on lake trophic status.

Restoration strategies may also be evaluated using the same models. They suggest that in order to reduce loads upon the Ley to within OECD permissible limits, not only will all sewage and phosphate detergent inputs need to be prevented, but also losses from agricultural land must be reduced. This could take the form of the zoning of the catchment so that riparian zones are used, not as at present, for the grazing of livestock, but are converted to woodland, and more particularly eg to buffer strips sensu Mander (1985, 1992).

This policy, if implemented comprehensively, would reduce external phosphorus loads to within permissible limits. Eventually, however, some kind of internal control, such as manipulation of the fish populations, may also have to be attempted, in order to remove the ‘memory’ of five decades of eutrophication.