Abstract
The method of loci (MoL) is a well-known mnemonic technique in which visuospatial spatial environments are used to scaffold the memorization of non-spatial information. We developed a novel virtual reality-based implementation of the MoL in which participants used three unique virtual environments to serve as their “memory palaces.” In each world, participants were presented with a sequence of 15 3D objects that appeared in front of their avatar for 20 s each. The experimental group (N = 30) was given the ability to click on each object to lock it in place, whereas the control group (N = 30) was not afforded this functionality. We found that despite matched engagement, exposure duration, and instructions emphasizing the efficacy of the mnemonic across groups, participants in the experimental group recalled 28% more objects. We also observed a strong relationship between spatial memory for objects and landmarks in the environment and verbal recall strength. These results provide evidence for spatially mediated processes underlying the effectiveness of the MoL and contribute to theoretical models of memory that emphasize spatial encoding as the primary currency of mnemonic function.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Astur, R. S., Purton, A. J., Zaniewski, M. J., Cimadevilla, J., & Markus, E. J. (2016). Human sex differences in solving a virtual navigation problem. Behavioural Brain Research, 308, 236–243. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbr.2016.04.037.
Balch, W. R. (2005). Elaborations of introductory psychology terms: effects on test performance and subjective ratings. Teaching of Psychology, 32, 29–34.
Bandura, A. (1993). Perceived self-efficacy in cognitive development and functioning. Educational Psychologist, 28, 117–148. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15326985ep2802_3.
Bellmund, J. L. S., Gärdenfors, P., Moser, E. I., & Doeller, C. F. (2018). Navigating cognition: spatial codes for human thinking. Science, 362, eaat6766. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aat6766.
Benjamini, Y., & Hochberg, Y. (1995). Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B: Methodological, 57, 289–300. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2517-6161.1995.tb02031.x.
Benn, Y., Bergman, O., Glazer, L., Arent, P., Wilkinson, I. D., Varley, R., et al. (2015). Navigating through digital folders uses the same brain structures as real world navigation. Scientific Reports, 5, 14719. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep14719.
Bjork, R. A. (1994). Memory and metamemory considerations in the training of human beings. In J. Metcalfe & A. P. Shimamura (Eds.), Metacognition Knowing about knowing, (pp 185–205). Cambridge: The MIT Press.
Black, J. B., Turner, T. J., & Bower, G. H. (1979). Point of view in narrative comprehension, memory, and production. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 18, 187–198. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-5371(79)90118-X.
Bouffard, N., Stokes, J., Kramer, H. J., & Ekstrom, A. D. (2018). Temporal encoding strategies result in boosts to final free recall performance comparable to spatial ones. Memory & Cognition, 46, 17–31. https://doi.org/10.3758/s13421-017-0742-z.
Bower, G. H. (1970). Analysis of a mnemonic device: modern psychology uncovers the powerful components of an ancient system for improving memory. American Scientist, 58, 496–510.
Bower, G. H., & Reitman, J. S. (1972). Mnemonic elaboration in multilist learning. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 11, 478–485.
Brainard, D. H. (1997). The psychophysics toolbox. Spatial Vision, 10, 433–436.
Brehmer, Y., Li, S.-C., Straube, B., Stoll, G., von Oertzen, T., Müller, V., et al. (2008). Comparing memory skill maintenance across the life span: preservation in adults, increase in children. Psychology and Aging, 23, 227.
Briggs, G. G., Hawkins, S., & Crovitz, H. F. (1970). Bizarre images in artificial memory. Psychonomic Science, 19, 353–354. https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03328856.
Brooks, J. O., Friedman, L., & Yesavage, J. A. (1993). A study of the problems older adults encounter when using a mnemonic technique. International Psychogeriatrics, 5, 57–65.
Bush, D., Barry, C., Manson, D., & Burgess, N. (2015). Using grid cells for navigation. Neuron, 87, 507–520. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2015.07.006.
Carney, R. N., & Levin, J. R. (1998). Mnemonic strategies for adult learners. In M. C. Smith & T. Pourchot (Eds.), Adult Learning and Development: Perspectives from Educational Psychology, (pp 159–175). Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers.
Chen, H.-Y., Gilmore, A. W., Nelson, S. M., & McDermott, K. B. (2017). Are there multiple kinds of episodic memory? An fMRI investigation comparing autobiographical and recognition memory tasks. Journal of Neuroscience: The Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience, 37, 2764–2775. https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1534-16.2017.
Cohen, J., & Cohen, J. (2003). In N. J. Mahwah (Ed.), Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavioral sciences. Mahwah: L. Erlbaum Associates.
Constantinescu, A. O., O’Reilly, J. X., & Behrens, T. E. (2016). Organizing conceptual knowledge in humans with a gridlike code. Science, 352, 1464–1468.
Crovitz, H. F. (1971). The capacity of memory loci in artificial memory. Psychonomic Science, 24, 187–188. https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03335561.
Cui, X., Jeter, C. B., Yang, D., Montague, P. R., & Eagleman, D. M. (2007). Vividness of mental imagery: individual variability can be measured objectively. Vision Research, 47, 474–478. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.visres.2006.11.013.
Dalgleish, T., Navrady, L., Bird, E., Hill, E., Dunn, B. D., & Golden, A.-M. (2013). Method-of-loci as a mnemonic device to facilitate access to self-affirming personal memories for individuals with depression. Clinical Psychological Science: A Journal of the Association for Psychological Science, 1, 156–162. https://doi.org/10.1177/2167702612468111.
Dennett, D. C. (1993). Consciousness explained. In Penguin Adult.
Eichenbaum, H. (2004). Hippocampus: cognitive processes and neural representations that underlie declarative memory. Neuron, 44, 109–120. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2004.08.028.
Eichenbaum, H., & Cohen, N. J. (2014). Can we reconcile the declarative memory and spatial navigation views on hippocampal function? Neuron, 83, 764–770.
Ericsson, K. A., & Kintsch, W. (1995). Long-term working memory. Psychological Review, 102, 211.
Ericsson, K. A., Cheng, X., Pan, Y., Ku, Y., Ge, Y., & Hu, Y. (2017). Memory skills mediating superior memory in a world-class memorist. Memory, 25, 1294–1302. https://doi.org/10.1080/09658211.2017.1296164.
Fellner, M.-C., Volberg, G., Wimber, M., Goldhacker, M., Greenlee, M. W., & Hanslmayr, S. (2016). Spatial mnemonic encoding: theta power decreases and medial temporal lobe BOLD increases co-occur during the usage of the method of loci. eNeuro, 3. https://doi.org/10.1523/ENEURO.0184-16.2016.
Fisher, N. J., & Deluca, J. W. (1997). Verbal learning strategies of adolescents and adults with the syndrome of nonverbal learning disabilities. Child Neuropsychology, 3, 192–198. https://doi.org/10.1080/09297049708400642.
Foer, J. (2011). Moonwalking with Einstein: the art and science of remembering everything. New York: Penguin Press.
Fox, J., Bailenson, J., & Binney, J. (2009). Virtual experiences, physical behaviors: the effect of presence on imitation of an eating avatar. Presence Teleoperators Virtual Environ., 18, 294–303. https://doi.org/10.1162/pres.18.4.294.
Hafting, T., Fyhn, M., Molden, S., Moser, M.-B., & Moser, E. I. (2005). Microstructure of a spatial map in the entorhinal cortex. Nature, 436, 801–806. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature03721.
Hamann, S. (2001). Cognitive and neural mechanisms of emotional memory. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 5, 394–400. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1364-6613(00)01707-1.
Harnadek, M. C., & Rourke, B. P. (1994). Principal identifying features of the syndrome of nonverbal learning disabilities in children. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 27, 144–154. https://doi.org/10.1177/002221949402700303.
Harris, P. A., Taylor, R., Thielke, R., Payne, J., Gonzalez, N., & Conde, J. G. (2009). Research Electronic Data Capture (REDCap)—a metadata-driven methodology and workflow process for providing translational research informatics support. Journal of Biomedical Informatics, 42, 377–381. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbi.2008.08.010.
Hassabis, D., & Maguire, E. A. (2007). Deconstructing episodic memory with construction. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 11, 299–306.
Hassabis, D., & Maguire, E. A. (2009). The construction system of the brain. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences, 364, 1263–1271.
Hebscher, M., Levine, B., & Gilboa, A. (2017). The precuneus and hippocampus contribute to individual differences in the unfolding of spatial representations during episodic autobiographical memory. Neuropsychologia, 110, 123–133. Chicago.
Herrmann, D. J., Geisler, F. V., & Atkinson, R. C. (1973). The serial position function for lists learned by a narrative-story mnemonic. Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, 2, 377–378. https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03334418.
Horner, A. J., Bisby, J. A., Wang, A., Bogus, K., & Burgess, N. (2016). The role of spatial boundaries in shaping long-term event representations. Cognition, 154, 151–164.
Hu, Y., & Ericsson, K. A. (2012). Memorization and recall of very long lists accounted for within the long-term working memory framework. Cognitive Psychology, 64, 235–266.
Hu, Y., Ericsson, K. A., Yang, D., & Lu, C. (2009). Superior self-paced memorization of digits in spite of a normal digit span: the structure of a memorist’s skill. Journal of Experimental Psychology. Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 35, 1426.
Jacobs, L. F., & Schenk, F. (2003). Unpacking the cognitive map: the parallel map theory of hippocampal function. Psychological Review, 110, 285–315. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.110.2.285.
Karpicke, J. D., Butler, A. C., & Roediger, H. L., III. (2009). Metacognitive strategies in student learning: do students practise retrieval when they study on their own? Memory, 17, 471–479.
Kliegl, R., Smith, J., & Baltes, P. B. (1990). On the locus and process of magnification of age differences during mnemonic training. Developmental Psychology, 26, 894.
Kondo, Y., Suzuki, M., Mugikura, S., Abe, N., Takahashi, S., Iijima, T., et al. (2005). Changes in brain activation associated with use of a memory strategy: a functional MRI study. NeuroImage, 24, 1154–1163. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2004.10.033.
Kosslyn, S. M., Brunn, J., Cave, K. R., & Wallach, R. W. (1984). Individual differences in mental imagery ability: a computational analysis. Cognition, 18, 195–243. https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-0277(84)90025-8.
Lawton, C. A. (1994). Gender differences in way-finding strategies: relationship to spatial ability and spatial anxiety. Sex Roles, 30, 765–779.
Lee, I. A., & Preacher, K. J (2013). Calculation for the test of the difference between two dependent correlations with one variable in common. Available at: http://quantpsy.org. Accessed March 18 2018.
Legge, E. L. G., Madan, C. R., Ng, E. T., & Caplan, J. B. (2012). Building a memory palace in minutes: equivalent memory performance using virtual versus conventional environments with the method of loci. Acta Psychologica, 141, 380–390. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actpsy.2012.09.002.
Levin, J. R. (1983). Pictorial strategies for school learning: practical illustrations. In Cognitive Strategy Research Springer Series in Cognitive Development (pp. 213–237). New York, NY: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4612-5519-2_8.
Llinás, R. R. (2001). I of the vortex: from neurons to self. Cambridge, MA: MIT press.
Llinas, R., & Ribary, U. (2001). Consciousness and the brain. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 929, 166–175.
Maguire, E. A., & Mullally, S. L. (2013). The Hippocampus: a manifesto for change. Journal of Experimental Psychology. General, 142, 1180–1189. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0033650.
Maguire, E. A., Valentine, E. R., Wilding, J. M., & Kapur, N. (2003). Routes to remembering: the brains behind superior memory. Nature Neuroscience, 6, 90.
Martell, R. F., & Willis, C. E. (1993). Effects of observers′ performance expectations on behavior ratings of work groups: memory or response bias? Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 56, 91–109. https://doi.org/10.1006/obhd.1993.1046.
McCabe, J. A. (2015). Location, location, location! Demonstrating the mnemonic benefit of the method of loci. Teaching of Psychology, 42, 169–173. https://doi.org/10.1177/0098628315573143.
McCabe, J. A., Osha, K. L., Roche, J. A., & Susser, J. A. (2013). Psychology students’ knowledge and use of mnemonics. Teaching of Psychology, 40, 183–192.
Merriman, N. A., Ondřej, J., Roudaia, E., O’Sullivan, C., & Newell, F. N. (2016). Familiar environments enhance object and spatial memory in both younger and older adults. Experimental Brain Research, 234, 1555–1574.
Moè, A., & De Beni, R. (2005). Stressing the efficacy of the loci method: oral presentation and the subject-generation of the loci pathway with expository passages. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 19, 95–106.
Moscovitch, M., Cabeza, R., Winocur, G., & Nadel, L. (2016). Episodic memory and beyond: the hippocampus and neocortex in transformation. Annual Review of Psychology, 67, 105–134.
Mullally, S. L., & Maguire, E. A. (2014). Memory, imagination, and predicting the future: a common brain mechanism? The Neuroscientist, 20, 220–234. https://doi.org/10.1177/1073858413495091.
Murray, E. A., Wise, S. P., & Graham, K. S. (2018). Representational specializations of the hippocampus in phylogenetic perspective. Neuroscience Letters, 680, 4–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neulet.2017.04.065.
Nelson, D. L., Reed, V. S., & Walling, J. R. (1976). Pictorial superiority effect. Journal of Experimental Psychology [Human Learning and Memory], 2, 523–528.
O’Keefe, J., & Nadel, L. (1978). The hippocampus as a cognitive map. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Paivio, A., & Csapo, K. (1973). Picture superiority in free recall: imagery or dual coding? Cognitive Psychology, 5, 176–206. https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-0285(73)90032-7.
Persson, J., Herlitz, A., Engman, J., Morell, A., Sjölie, D., Wikström, J., et al. (2013). Remembering our origin: gender differences in spatial memory are reflected in gender differences in hippocampal lateralization. Behavioural Brain Research, 256, 219–228. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbr.2013.07.050.
Preacher, K. J. (2002). Calculation for the test of the difference between two independent correlation coefficients. Available at: http://quantpsy.org. Accessed March 18, 2018.
Pyc, M. A., & Rawson, K. A. (2009). Testing the retrieval effort hypothesis: does greater difficulty correctly recalling information lead to higher levels of memory? Journal of Memory and Language, 60, 437–447. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jml.2009.01.004.
Qureshi, A., Rizvi, F., Syed, A., Shahid, A., & Manzoor, H. (2014). The method of loci as a mnemonic device to facilitate learning in endocrinology leads to improvement in student performance as measured by assessments. Advances in Physiology Education, 38, 140–144. https://doi.org/10.1152/advan.00092.2013.
R Core Team. (2013). R: a language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing Available at: http://www.R-project.org/.
Rahman, Q., Andersson, D., & Govier, E. (2005). A specific sexual orientation-related difference in navigation strategy. Behavioral Neuroscience, 119, 311–316. https://doi.org/10.1037/0735-7044.119.1.311.
Rapp, S., Brenes, G., & Marsh, A. P. (2002). Memory enhancement training for older adults with mild cognitive impairment: a preliminary study. Aging & Mental Health, 6, (1), 5–11. https://doi.org/10.1080/13607860120101077.
Reggente, N., Essoe, J. K.-Y., Aghajan, Z. M., Tavakoli, A. V., McGuire, J. F., Suthana, N. A., et al. (2018). Enhancing the ecological validity of fMRI memory research using virtual reality. Frontiers in Neuroscience, 12. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnins.2018.00408.
Richardson, J. T. (1995). The efficacy of imagery mnemonics in memory remediation. Neuropsychologia, 33, 1345–1357.
Rissman, J., & Wagner, A. D. (2012). Distributed representations in memory: insights from functional brain imaging. Annual Review of Psychology, 63, 101–128. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-120710-100344.
Robin, J. (2018). Spatial scaffold effects in event memory and imagination. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science, 9, e1462. https://doi.org/10.1002/wcs.1462.
Robin, J., Wynn, J., & Moscovitch, M. (2016). The spatial scaffold: the effects of spatial context on memory for events. Journal of Experimental Psychology. Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 42, 308.
Robin, J., Buchsbaum, B. R., & Moscovitch, M. (2018). The primacy of spatial context in the neural representation of events. Journal of Neuroscience: The Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience. https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1638-17.2018.
Roediger, H. L. (1980). The effectiveness of four mnemonics in ordering recall. Journal of Experimental Psychology [Human Learning], 6, 558–567. https://doi.org/10.1037/0278-7393.6.5.558.
Rogers, T. B., Kuiper, N. A., & Kirker, W. S. (1977). Self-reference and the encoding of personal information. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 35, 677.
Ross, J., & Lawrence, K. A. (1968). Some observations on memory artifice. Psychonomic Science, 13, 107–108. https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03342433.
Rummel, J., & Meiser, T. (2013). The role of metacognition in prospective memory: anticipated task demands influence attention allocation strategies. Consciousness and Cognition, 22, 931–943. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.concog.2013.06.006.
Sandstrom, N. J., Kaufman, J., & Huettel, S. A. (1998). Males and females use different distal cues in a virtual environment navigation task. Brain Research. Cognitive Brain Research, 6, 351–360.
Scoville, W. B., & Milner, B. (1957). Loss of recent memory after bilateral hippocampal lesions. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry, 20, 11–21.
Shimamura, A. P. (1984). A guide for teaching mnemonic skills. Teaching of Psychology, 11, 162–166.
Slater, M., Usoh, M., & Steed, A. (1994). Depth of presence in virtual environments. Presence Teleoperators and Virtual Environments, 3, 130–144. https://doi.org/10.1162/pres.1994.3.2.130.
Slater, M., Usoh, M., & Chrysanthou, Y. (1995a). The influence of dynamic shadows on presence in immersive virtual environments. In Virtual environments’ 95 (pp. 8–21). Berlin: Springer.
Slater, M., Usoh, M., & Steed, A. (1995b). Taking steps: the influence of a walking technique on presence in virtual reality. ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction TOCHI, 2, 201–219.
Slater, M., McCarthy, J., & Maringelli, F. (1998). The influence of body movement on subjective presence in virtual environments. Human Factors, 40, 469–477.
Squire, L. R. (1992). Memory and the hippocampus: a synthesis from findings with rats, monkeys, and humans. Psychological Review, 99, 195–231.
Squire, L. R., & Zola, S. M. (1996). Structure and function of declarative and nondeclarative memory systems. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 93, 13515–13522.
Steiger, J. H. (1980). Tests for comparing elements of a correlation matrix. Psychological Bulletin, 87, 245–251. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.87.2.245.
Stricker, J. L., Brown, G. G., Wixted, J., Baldo, J. V., & Delis, D. C. (2002). New semantic and serial clustering indices for the California Verbal Learning Test-Second Edition: background, rationale, and formulae. Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society JINS, 8, 425–435.
Susser, J. A., & McCabe, J. (2013). From the lab to the dorm room: metacognitive awareness and use of spaced study. Instructional Science, 41, 345–363.
Sutcliffe, J. S., Marshall, K. M., & Neill, J. C. (2007). Influence of gender on working and spatial memory in the novel object recognition task in the rat. Behavioural Brain Research, 177, 117–125.
Tate, R. L. (1997). Subject review: beyond one-bun, two-shoe: recent advances in the psychological rehabilitation of memory disorders after acquired brain injury. Brain Injury, 11, 907–918.
The Mathworks, Inc. (2012). MATLAB and Statistics Toolbox. Natick, Massachussetts, United States.
Tulving, E. (2002). Episodic memory: from mind to brain. Annual Review of Psychology, 53, 1–25.
Tulving, E., & Markowitsch, H. J. (1998). Episodic and declarative memory: role of the hippocampus. Hippocampus, 8, 198–204. https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1098-1063(1998)8:3<198::AID-HIPO2>3.0.CO;2-G.
Vargha-Khadem, F., Gadian, D. G., Watkins, K. E., Connelly, A., Van Paesschen, W., & Mishkin, M. (1997). Differential effects of early hippocampal pathology on episodic and semantic memory. Science, 277, 376–380.
Verhaeghen, P., Marcoen, A., & Goossens, L. (1992). Improving memory performance in the aged through mnemonic training: a meta-analytic study. Psychology and Aging, 7, 242.
Voss, J. L., Gonsalves, B. D., Federmeier, K. D., Tranel, D., & Cohen, N. J. (2011). Hippocampal brain-network coordination during volitional exploratory behavior enhances learning. Nature Neuroscience, 14, 115. https://doi.org/10.1038/nn.2693.
Werner-Seidler, A., & Dalgleish, T. (2016). The method of loci improves longer-term retention of self-affirming memories and facilitates access to mood-repairing memories in recurrent depression. Clinical Psychological Science: A Journal of the Association for Psychological Science, 4, 1065–1072. https://doi.org/10.1177/2167702615626693.
West, R. L. (1995). Compensatory strategies for age-associated memory impairment. In A. D. Baddeley, B. A. Wilson, & F. N. Watts (Eds.), Handbook of memory disorders (pp. 481–500). Oxford, England: John Wiley & Sons.
Wolpert, D. M., & Ghahramani, Z. (2000). Computational principles of movement neuroscience. Nature Neuroscience, 3, 1212–1217. https://doi.org/10.1038/81497.
Yates, F. A. (1966). The art of memory (6th ed.). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Yesavage, J. A. (1983). Imagery pretraining and memory training in the elderly. Gerontology, 29, 271–275.
Acknowledgments
The authors of this project extend an enormous gratitude to Forde “JubJub” Davidson for his countless hours of virtual scripting and design, without which this current work would not have been possible. A thanks is also sent to Majed Samad, Ph.D., for his assistance with creating PsychToolbox testing materials and to John Dell’Italia for guidance on statistical analyses.
Funding
This work was supported by a Defense Advanced Research Project Agency (DARPA) Research Grant awarded to J.R. (D13AP00057) and National Science Foundation (NSF) Graduate Research Fellowships awarded to N.R. (DGE-1650604) and J.K-Y.E. (DGE-1144087).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic Supplementary Material
ESM 1
(DOCX 17 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Reggente, N., Essoe, J.K.Y., Baek, H.Y. et al. The Method of Loci in Virtual Reality: Explicit Binding of Objects to Spatial Contexts Enhances Subsequent Memory Recall. J Cogn Enhanc 4, 12–30 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s41465-019-00141-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41465-019-00141-8