The Perceived Impact of Eight Systemic Factors on Scientific Capital Accumulation


In the global academic capitalist race, academics, institutions and countries’ symbolic power results from the accumulation of scientific capital. This paper relies on the perspectives of system actors located at the institutional, national and international levels to assess the perceived importance of eight systemic factors in contributing to the comparative advantage of social-democratic regimes, namely Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden. A deductive thematic analysis performed on 56 transcripts and a one-way repeated-measure ANOVA (and pairwise post-hoc t-tests) performed on 324 questionnaires confirmed the hypotheses regarding the positive influence of academic traditions and internationalization. This study contributes to the development of a varieties of academic capitalism (VoAC) approach to apprehend how political-economies condition higher education systems’ (HES) comparative advantage.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

Access options

Buy single article

Instant unlimited access to the full article PDF.

US$ 39.95

Price includes VAT for USA

Subscribe to journal

Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.

US$ 99

This is the net price. Taxes to be calculated in checkout.


  1. Aarrevaara, Timo, Ian R. Dobson, and Camilla Elander. 2009. Brave new world: Higher education reform in Finland. Higher Education Management and Policy 21: 89–106.

  2. Aarrevaara, Timo, and Elias Pekkola. 2010. A comparative perspective on the work content of the academic profession. In Higher Education in Finland, eds. Sakari Ahola and David M. Hoffman, 251–269. Jyväskylä: University of Jyväskylä.

  3. Academy of Finland. 2014. Report: Finnish universities face strategic choices, should focus on their strengths and seize new initiatives. Helsinki: Academy of Finland. Accessed 26 Aug 2014.

  4. Aghion, Philippe, Mathias Dewatripont, Caroline M. Hoxby, Andreu Mas-Colell, and André Sapir. 2009. The governance and performance of research universities: Evidence from Europe and the U.S. NBER Working Paper No. 14851. Accessed 14 Apr 2014.

  5. Angermuller, Johannes. 2017. Academic careers and the valuation of academics. A discursive perspective on status categories and academic salaries in France as compared to the U.S., Germany and Great Britain. Higher Education 73(6): 963–980.

  6. Ahola, Sakari, Tina Hedmo, Jens-Peter Thomsen, and Agnete Vabø. 2014. Organizational features of higher education; Denmark, Finland, Norway & Sweden. NIFU Working Paper, 14/2014. Accessed 28 Oct 2014.

  7. Arter, David. 2008. Scandinavian Politics Today. 2nd eds. New York: Manchester University Press.

  8. ARWU – Academic Ranking of World Universities. 2018. Academic Ranking of World Universities 2017. Accessed 27 June 2018.

  9. Askling, Berit. 2012. Integration and/or diversification: The role of structure in meeting expectations on higher education. HEIK Working Paper Series 2012/4. Oslo: University of Oslo.

  10. Becker, Howard S., Blanche Geer, and Everett C. Hughes. 2003. Making the Grade: The Academic Side of College Life. New Brunswick: Wiley.

  11. Bégin-Caouette, Olivier. 2017. Small Mighty Centers in the Global Academic Capitalist Race: A Study of Systemic Factors Contributing to Scientific Capital Accumulation in Nordic Higher Education Systems. Unpublished doctoral thesis. University of Toronto.

  12. Bégin-Caouette, Olivier, Tanja Askvik, and Bian Cui. 2016. Interplays between welfare regimes typology and academic research systems in OECD countries. Higher Education Policy 29(3): 287–313.

  13. Benner, Mats. 2011. In search of excellence? An international perspective on governance of university research. In Universities in transition: The changing role and challenges for academic institutions, eds. Bo Göransson and Claes Brundenius, 11–25. Ottawa: Springer.

  14. Bleiklie, Ivar, and Maurice Kogan. 2007. Organization and governance of universities. Higher Education Policy 20(4): 477–493.

  15. Bloch, Roland, and Alexander Mitterle. 2017. On stratification in changing higher education: the “analysis of status” revisited. Higher Education 73(6): 929–946.

  16. Bloch, Carter, and Mads P. Sørensen. 2014. The size of research funding: Trends and implications. Science and Public Policy 42: 30–43.

  17. Bourdieu, Pierre. 1988. Homo Academicus. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

  18. Braun, Virginia, and Victoria Clarke. 2006. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3: 77–101.

  19. Brundenius, Claes, Bo Göransson, and Jan Ågren. 2011. The role of academic institutions in the national system of innovation and the debate in Sweden. In Universities in Transition: The Changing Role and Challenges for Academic Institutions, eds. Bo Göransson and Claes Brundenius, 307–325. Ottawa: International Development Research Centre.

  20. Clark, Burton. 1983. The Higher Education System: Academic Organization in Cross-National Perspective. Berkeley: University of California Press.

  21. Clark, Burton. 1998. Creating Entrepreneurial Universities: Organizational Pathways of Transformation. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing.

  22. Cleophas, Ton J., and Aeilko H. Zwinderman. 2012. Statistics Applied to Clinical Studies. 5th ed. Dordrecht: Springer.

  23. Creswell, John W., and Vicky Plano Clark. 2011. Designing and conducting mixed methods research. 2nd eds. Thousand Oaks: Sage.

  24. Corbin, Juliet, and Anselm Strauss. 2008. Basics of Qualitative Research. 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks: Sage.

  25. DiMaggio, Paul J., and Walter W. Powell. 1983. The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review 48: 147–160.

  26. European Commission. 2010. Science and technology -report. Special Eurobarometer 340(73.1). Brussels: TNS Opinion & Social.

  27. Esping-Andersen, Gøsta. 1990. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Cambridge: Polity Press.

  28. Esping-Andersen, Gøsta. 1999. Social Foundations of Postindustrial Economies. Oxford: Oxford Press.

  29. Field, Andy. 2013. Discovering statistics using IBM SPSS Statistics. Thousand Oaks: Sage.

  30. Finnish Ministry of Education and Culture. 2013. Kota-Tientokanta—Database. Retrieved from Accessed 15 July 2014.

  31. Fukuyama, Francis. 1995. Trust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity. New York: Free Press Paperbacks.

  32. Glimell, Hans. 2004. Restored scientific authority and orchestrated deliberation – A review of the current S&T policies. In Re-Purifying Scientific Authority: The Counter-Intuitive Case of Sweden – STS Research Report 7, ed. Hans Glimell, 5–14. Göteborg: Göteborg University.

  33. Gregersen, Brigitte, and Jorgen Gulddahl Rasmussen. 2011. Developing universities: The evolving role of academic institutions in Denmark. In Universities in Transition: The Changing Role and Challenges for Academic Institutions, eds. Bo Göransson and Claes Brundenius, 11–24. Ottawa: International Development Research Centre.

  34. Groves, Robert M., Floyd J. Fowler, Mick P. Couper, James M. Lepkowski, Eleanor Singer, and Roger Tourangeau. 2009. Survey Methodology. 2nd ed. Hoboken: Wiley.

  35. Guest, Greg, Arwen Bunce, and Laura Johnson. 2006. How many interviews are enough? An experiment with data saturation and variability. Field Methods 18(1): 59–82.

  36. Hall, Peter A., and David Soskice. 2004. Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  37. Hazelkorn, Ellen. 2013. World-class universities or world-class systems? Rankings and higher education policy choices. In Rankings and Accountability in Higher Education: Uses and Misuses, eds. Mmantsetsa Marope, Peter J. Wells, and Ellen Hazelkorn, 71–94. Paris: UNESCO.

  38. Holmes, Brian. 1981. Comparative Education: Some Considerations of Method. Boston: George Allen.

  39. ISI Web of Knowledge. 2013. ISI Web of Knowledge. Accessed 10 Apr 2014.

  40. Jessop, Bob. 2017. Varieties of academic capitalism and entrepreneurial universities. Higher Education 73(6): 853–870.

  41. Kauppinen, Ilkka, and Tuukka Kaidesoja. 2014. A Shift towards Academic Capitalism in Finland. Higher Education Policy 27: 23–41.

  42. Kim, So Young. 2013. Government R&D funding in economic downturns: Testing the varieties of capitalism conjecture. Science and Public Policy 41: 107–119.

  43. Kim, Terri. 2017. Academic mobility, transnational identity capital, and stratification under conditions of academic capitalism. Higher Education 73(6): 981–997.

  44. Kvil, Tove. 2004. The Norwegian quality reform. In Reforming Higher Education in the Nordic Countries—Studies of Change in Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden, eds. Ingemar Fägerling and Görel Strömqvist, 89–135. Paris: International Institute for Educational Planning (IIEP) - UNESCO.

  45. Kyvik, Svein, Agnete Vabø and Aina Alvsvag. 2015. The formalization of research groups in higher education. Paper presented at the 2015 CHER Conference, Lisbon, Portugal.

  46. Kwiek, Marek. 2016. The European research elite: a cross-national study of highly productive academics in 11 countries. Higher Education 71(3): 379–397.

  47. Lepori, Benedetto, Emanuela Reale, and Stig Slipersaeter. 2011. The construction of new indicators for science and innovation policies: the case of project funding. In Science and Innovation Policy for the New Knowledge Economy, eds. Massimo G. Colombo, Luca Grilli, Lucia Piscitello, and Cristina Rossi-Lamastra, 37–59. Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.

  48. Li, Eldon Y., Chien Hsiang Liao, and Hsiuju Rebecca Yen. 2013. Co-authorship networks and research impact: A social capital perspective. Research Policy 42: 1515–1530.

  49. Maassen, Peter, Agnete Vabø, and Bjørn Stensaker. 2008. Translation of globalisation and regionalisation in Nordic cooperation in higher education. In Borderless Knowledge: Understanding the “New” Internationalisation of Research and Higher Education in Norway, eds. A. Gornitzka and L. Langfeldt, 125–140. Oslo: Springer.

  50. Mårtensson, Katarina, Torgny Roxå, and Bjørn Stensaker. 2014. From quality assurance to quality practices: An investigation of strong microcultures in teaching and learning. Studies in Higher Education 39(4): 534–545.

  51. Maesse, Jens. 2017. The elitism dispositive: hierarchization, discourses of excellence and organizational change in European economics. Higher Education 77(6): 909–927.

  52. Marginson, Simon. 2006. Putting ‘public’ back into the public university. Thesis Eleven 84: 44–59.

  53. Mendoza, Pilar 2009. Academic capitalism in the Pasteur’s quadrant. Journal of Further and Higher Education 33(3): 301–311.

  54. Münch, Richard. 2014. Academic Capitalism: Universities in the Global Struggle for Excellence. New York: Routledge.

  55. Norden. 2014. Evaluation of two programmes using Nordic Centres of Excellence—The Programme on Food, Nutrition and Health and the Programme on Welfare Research. Oslo: NordForsk.

  56. Nordic Council of Ministers. 2016. Services and Goods Exports from the Nordics: Strongholds and profiles of exporting enterprises. Accessed 25 June 2018.

  57. OECD - Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development. 2013. Main Science and Technology Indicators. Accessed 28 Feb 2014.

  58. Öquist, Gunnar, and Mats Benner. 2015. Why Are Some Nations More Successful Than Others in Research Impact? A Comparison Between Denmark and Sweden. In Incentives and Performance: Governance of Research Organizations, eds. Isabell M. Welpe, Jutta Wollersheim, Stefanie Ringelhan, and Margit Osterloh, 241–257. Dordrecht: Springer.

  59. Olson, Jennifer, and Sheila Slaughter. 2014. Forms of capitalism and creating world-class universities. In The Forefront of International Higher Education: A Festschrift in Honor of Philip G. Altbach, eds. A. Maldonado-Maldonado and R.M. Bassett, 267–280. Dordrecht: Springer.

  60. Perez Vico, Eugenia, and Staffan Jacobson. 2012. Identifying, explaining and improving the effects of academic R&D: The case of nanotechnology in Sweden. Science and Public Policy 39: 513–529.

  61. Pestre, Dominique. 2003. Regimes of knowledge production in society: Towards a more political and social reading. Minerva 41: 245–261.

  62. Pinheiro, Rómulo, Lars Geschwind, and Timo Aarrevaara. 2016. Mergers in Higher Education: The Experience from Northern Europe. Dordrecht: Springer.

  63. Potì, Bianca, and Emanuela Reale. 2007. Changing allocation models for public research funding: an empirical exploration based on project funding data. Science and Public Policy 34: 417–430.

  64. Riis, Ulla. 2012. Is the bar quivering? What can we learn about academic career requirements from the 1999 promotion reform? Pedagogisk Forskning I Uppsala 161: 1–42.

  65. Rosser, J. Barkeley, and Marina V. Rosser. 2018. Comparative Economics in a Transforming World Economy. 3rd ed. Cambridge: MIT Press.

  66. Royal Society. 2011. Knowledge, networks and nations: Global scientific collaboration in the 21st century. London: Royal Policy.

  67. Salmi, Jamil. 2009. The Challenge of Establishing World-Class Universities. Paris: World Bank Publications.

  68. Schulze-Cleven, T., and Jennifer R. Olson. 2017. Worlds of higher education transformed: toward varieties of academic capitalism. Higher Education 73(6): 813–831.

  69. Schulze-Cleven, Tobias, T. Reitz, J. Maesse, and J. Angermuller. 2017. The new political economy of higher education: between distributional conflicts and discursive stratification. Higher Education 73(6): 795–812.

  70. Schulze-Cleven, Tobias, and Timo Weishaupt. 2015. Playing Normative Legacies: Partisanship and Employment Policies in Crisis-Ridden Europe. Politics & Society 43: 269–299.

  71. SCImago Journal & Country Rank. 2013. SJR—SCImago Country Rankings. Accessed 28 Feb 2014.

  72. Slaughter, Sheila, and Larry Leslie. 1999. Academic Capitalism: Politics, Policies and the Entrepreneurial University. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

  73. Slaughter, Sheila, and Gary Rhoades. 2004. Academic Capitalism and the New Economy. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

  74. SNAHE – Swedish National Agency for Higher Education. 2012. Swedish Universities & Universities Colleges, Report 2012:18R. Stockholm: SNAHE.

  75. Stensaker, Björn. 2014. European trends in quality assurance: New agendas beyond the search for convergence. In Quality Assurance in Higher Education: Contemporary Debates, eds. Maria João Rosa and A. Amaral, 135–148. Basingstoke: Palgrave.

  76. Stephan, Paula, Giuseppe Scellato, and Chiara Franzoni. 2015. International Competition for PhDs and Postdoctoral Scholars: What Does (and Does Not) Matter. Innovation Policy and the Economy 15: 73–113.

  77. Välimaa, Jussi. 2005. Globalization in the concept of Nordic higher education. RIHE International Publication Series 9: 93–113.

  78. Virtanen, Turo, Charlotte Silander, and Maria Pietilä. 2014. National steering and profiling of academic research in Finland and Sweden. In Higher Education and Research in Academe: Who Should Pay?, eds. Timo Aarrevaara and Elisabeth Berg, 29–40. Lulea: Lulea University of Technology Graphic Production.

Download references

Author information

Correspondence to Olivier Bégin-Caouette.

Additional information

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Electronic supplementary material

Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.

Supplementary material 1 (DOCX 18 kb)

Supplementary material 2 (DOCX 21 kb)

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Bégin-Caouette, O. The Perceived Impact of Eight Systemic Factors on Scientific Capital Accumulation. Minerva (2019) doi:10.1007/s11024-019-09390-5

Download citation


  • Varieties of academic capitalism
  • Social-democratic regimes
  • Nordic higher education systems
  • Scientific capital
  • Mixed-methods