Advertisement

Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics

, Volume 18, Issue 5, pp 479–493 | Cite as

Integrity and Rights of Plants: Ethical Notions in Organic Plant Breeding and Propagation

  • Edith T. Lammerts Van Bueren
  • Paul C. Struik
Article

Abstract

In addition to obviating the use of synthetic agrochemicals and emphasizing farming in accordance with agro-ecological guidelines, organic farming acknowledges the integrity of plants as an essential element of its natural approaches to crop production. For cultivated plants, integrity refers to their inherent nature, wholeness, completeness, species-specific characteristics, and their being in balance with their (organically farmed) environment, while accomplishing their “natural aim.” We argue that this integrity of plants has ethical value, distinguishing integrity of life, plant-typic integrity, genotypic integrity, and phenotypic integrity. We have developed qualitative criteria to ethically evaluate existing practices and have applied these criteria to assess whether current plant breeding and propagation techniques violate the integrity of crop plants. This process has resulted in a design of a holistic, scientific approach of organic plant breeding and seed production. Our evaluation has met considerable criticism from mainstream (crop) scientists. We respond to the following questions: (1). Can ethics be incorporated into objective crop sciences? (2). What is the nature of the intrinsic value of plants in organic farming? We argue that criteria to take integrity into account can only be assessed from a holistic perspective and we show that a holistic approach is needed to design such ethical notions in a consistent way. The ethical notions have been further elaborated by formulating human responsibility and respect towards crop plants. Responsibility and respect can only be shown by providing crop plants the right to be nurtured and to express natural behavior at all levels of integrity.

Key words:

integrity intrinsic value natural aim naturalness organic breeding organic plant propagation plant rights respect 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Baars, T. 1990Het bosecosysteem als beeld van het bedrijfsorganisme in de biologisch-dynamische landbouwLouis Bolk InstituteDriebergen, The Netherlands[“The forest ecosystem as image of the farm organism in the biological-dynamic agriculture”]Google Scholar
  2. Baars, T., Reconciling scientific approaches for organic agricultural research. PhD dissertation, (Wageningen University, Wageningen, 2002).Google Scholar
  3. Bindraban, P., “Hoe lang nog duurt de biologische hype? Met een blinde vlek voor sociale rechtvaardigheid.”[“How long will the organic hype last? With a blind spot for social justice”], Spil 199–200 (2004) pp. 18–20.Google Scholar
  4. Farm Animal Welfare Council (2004), Farm Animal Welfare. http://www.fawc. org.uk [date accessed: 02/05/2004]
  5. Gremmen, B. 2004Intrinsic Value and Plant GenomicsTavernier, J. H.Aerts, S. eds. Science, Ethics & SocietyKatholieke Universiteit LeuvenLeuven145147. 5th Congress of the European Society for Agricultural and Food EthicsGoogle Scholar
  6. Kallhoff, A. 2002Prinzipien der Pflanzenethik. Die Bewertung pflanzlichen Lebens in Biologie und PhilosophieCampus ForschungFrankfurt (Main) [Principles of plant ethics. The valuation of plant life in biology and philosophy]Google Scholar
  7. Krebs, A. 1999Ethics of Nature – A MapDe GruyterBerlin, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  8. Lammerts van Bueren, E. T. and P. C. Struik, “Integrity of Plants: The Missing Element in a Holistic View on Organic Plant Breeding and Propagation,” in Proceedings Such is Life, Reconciling reductionism and holism. (Louis Bolk Institute, Driebergen, 2005) (in press) Google Scholar
  9. Lammertsvan Bueren, E. T., Struik, P. C., Tiemens-Hulscher, M., Jacobsen, E. 2003The Concepts of Intrinsic Value and Integrity of Plants in Organic Plant Breeding and PropagationCrop Science4319221929Google Scholar
  10. Morito, B. 2003Intrinsic Value: A Modern Albatross for the Ecological ApproachEnvironmental Values12317336Google Scholar
  11. Myskja, B. K. 2004Is There a Moral Difference Between Intragenic and Transgenic Modification of Plants?Tavernier, J. H.Aerts, S. eds. Science, Ethics & SocietyKatholieke Universiteit LeuvenLeuven141144. 5th Congress of the European Society for Agricultural and Food EthicsGoogle Scholar
  12. Pfeiffer, M. W. 1975Die landwirtschafliche Individualität – ein Bild eines Menschen. [The agricultural individuality – an image of man].SelbstverlagBorchen, DeutschlandGoogle Scholar
  13. Plasterk, R., “The Emancipation of Ethics,” in Ethics in Science, 87th Dies Natalis (Wageningen: Wageningen University and Research Centre, 2005) pp. 7–13.Google Scholar
  14. Pretty, J. 2002Agri-culture. Reconnecting People, Land and NatureEarthscan PublicationsLondonGoogle Scholar
  15. Rehmann-Sutter, C. 2001Dignity of Plants and PerceptionHeaf, D.Wirz, J. eds. Intrinsic Value and Integrity of Plants in the Context of Genetic Engineering. Proceedings of WorkshopIfgeneDornachpp 48Google Scholar
  16. Stafleu, F. R., Lauwere, C. C., Greef, K. H. 2004Respect for Functional Determinism. A Farmer’s Interpretation of ‘Respect for Animals’Tavernier, J.H.Aerts, S. eds. Science, Ethics & SocietyKatholieke Universiteit LeuvenLeuven7375. 5th Congress of the European Society for Agricultural and Food EthicsGoogle Scholar
  17. Van Kasteren, J., “Dure reclamecampagne van LNV voor biologische producten. Versterking van taboes belemmert duurzame ontwikkeling,” [“Expensive advertizing campaign of the Ministry of Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality for organic products. Strengthening taboos impedes sustainable development”], Spil 185–186 (2002) pp. 5–8.Google Scholar
  18. Verhoog, H., Matze, M., Lammerts van Bueren, E., Baars, T. 2003The Role of the Concept of the Natural (Naturalness) in Organic FarmingJournal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics162949CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. J. and , WirzLammerts van Bueren, E. eds. 1997The Future of DNA. Proceedings of an International Ifgene Conference on Presuppositions in Science and Expectations in SocietyKluwer Academic PublishersDordrechtGoogle Scholar
  20. Wissenburg, M. L. J., “Mens, natuur en onderwerping. Een humanistisch perspectief op de intrinsieke waarde van de natuur” [“Man, nature and submission. A humanistic perspective on the intrinsic value of nature”], Inaugurele rede (Leerstoelgroep Toegepaste Filosofie, Wageningen Universiteit, Wageningen, 2005).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  • Edith T. Lammerts Van Bueren
    • 1
  • Paul C. Struik
    • 2
  1. 1.Louis Bolk InstituteDriebergenThe Netherlands
  2. 2.Plant Sciences Group, Crop and Weed EcologyWageningen UniversityWageningenThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations