Environmental Management

, Volume 36, Issue 4, pp 535–550

Economic Valuation of a Mangrove Ecosystem Threatened by Shrimp Aquaculture in Sri Lanka

RESEARCH

Abstract

Mangrove ecosystems in Sri Lanka are increasingly under threat from development projects, especially aquaculture. An economic assessment is presented for a relatively large (42 ha) shrimp culture development proposed for the Rekawa Lagoon system in the south of Sri Lanka, which involved an extended cost–benefit analysis of the proposal and an estimate of the “total economic value” (TEV) of a mangrove ecosystem. The analysis revealed that the internal benefits of developing the shrimp farm are higher than the internal costs in the ratio of 1.5:1. However, when the wider environmental impacts are more comprehensively evaluated, the external benefits are much lower than the external costs in a ratio that ranges between 1:6 and 1:11. In areas like Rekawa, where agriculture and fisheries are widely practiced at subsistence levels, shrimp aquaculture developments have disproportionately large impacts on traditional livelihoods and social welfare. Thus, although the analysis retains considerable uncertainties, more explicit costing of the environmental services provided by mangrove ecosystems demonstrates that low intensity, but sustainable, harvesting has far greater long-term value to local stakeholders and the wider community than large shrimp aquaculture developments.

Keywords

Shrimp aquaculture Mangroves Total economic value and extended cost–benefit analysis Sri Lanka 

Literature Cited

  1. Adger, W. N., Brown, K., Cervigini, R., Moran, D. 1995Total economic value of forests in MexicoAmbio24286296Google Scholar
  2. Alagarswami, K. 1995Status of aquaculture in India. Annex 11-12 in Regional study and workshop on the environmental assessment and management of aquaculture development (TCP/RAS/2253), NACA Environment and Aquaculture Series No. 1Network of Aquaculture Centres in Asia-PacificBangkok, ThailandGoogle Scholar
  3. Amarasinghe, M. D. 1988Socio-economic status of human communities for selected mangrove areas on the west coast of Sri LankaMangrove Ecosystems Occasional Papers15119Google Scholar
  4. Armitage, D. 2002Socio-institutional dynamics and the political ecology of mangrove forest conservation in Central Sulawesi, IndonesiaGlobal Environmental Change-Human and Policy Dimensions12203217Google Scholar
  5. Aylward, B., Barbier, E. B. 1992Valuing environmental functions in developing countriesBiodiversity and Conservation13450CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bandaratillake, H. M. 1995

    Use of non wood forest products by village communities in Sri Lanka

    Durst, P. B.Bishop, A. eds. Beyond timber: social, economic and cultural dimensions of non wood forest products in Asia and the PacificRAP Publication 1995/13. FAO Regional Office for Asia and the PacificBangkok, Thailand291298
    Google Scholar
  7. Barbier, E. B. 2003Habitat-fishery linkages and mangrove loss in ThailandContemporary Economic Policy215977CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bateman, I. J., Turner, R. K. 1993

    Valuation of the environment, methods and techniques: the contingent valuation method

    Turner, R. K. eds. Sustainable environmental economics and management: principles and practiceBelhaven PressLondon120191
    Google Scholar
  9. Bateman, I. J. 1995

    Environment and economic appraisal

    O’Riordan, T. eds. Environmental science for environmental managementLongmanHarlow, UK4565
    Google Scholar
  10. Bennett, E. L., Reynolds, C. J. 1993The value of a mangrove area in SarawakBiodiversity and Conservation2359375CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Beveridge, M. C. M., Phillips, M. J., Macintosh, D. J. 1997Aquaculture and the environment: the supply of and the demand for environmental goods and services by Asian aquaculture and the implications for sustainabilityAquaculture Research28797807CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Carpenter, R. A., Maragos, J. E. 1989How to assess environmental impacts on tropical islands and coastal areasEnvironment and Policy Institute East-West CentreHonolulu345Google Scholar
  13. CCD. 1997. Revised coastal zone management plan. Coast Conservation Department, Coastal Resources Management Project, Colombo, Sri Lanka, 128 ppGoogle Scholar
  14. Chan, H. T., Ong, J. E., Gong, W. K., Sasekumar, A. 1993

    The socio-economic, ecological and environmental values of mangrove ecosystems in Malaysia and their present state of conservation

    Clough, B. F. eds. The economic and environmental values of mangrove forests and their present state of conservation in the South-East Asia/Pacific Region. Vol 1International Society for Mangrove EcosystemsOkinawa4181
    Google Scholar
  15. Choudhury, A. M., Quadir, D. A., Islam, M. J. 1994Study of Chokoria Sundarbans using remote sensing techniquesISME Mangrove Ecosystems Technical Report4122Google Scholar
  16. Corea, A. S. L. E., Jayasinghe, J. M. P. K., Ekaratne, S. U. K., Johnstone, R. 1995Environmental impact of prawn farming on Dutch Canal: The main water source for the prawn culture industry in Sri LankaAmbio24815827Google Scholar
  17. Costanza, R., d’Arge, R., Groot, R., Farber, S., Grasso, M., Hannon, B., Limburg, K., Naeem, S., O’Neill, R. V., Paruelo, J., Raskin, R. G., Sutton, P., den Belt, M. 1997The value of the world’s ecosystem services and natural capitalAmbio387253260Google Scholar
  18. Daly, H. E., Farley, J. 2003Ecological economics: principles and applicationsIsland PressLondonGoogle Scholar
  19. Davenport, J., Ekaratne, S. U. K., Walgama, S. A., Lee, D., Hills, J. M. 1999Successful stock enhancement of a lagoon prawn fishery at Rekawa, Sri Lanka using cultured post-larvae of penaeid shrimpAquaculture1806578CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. la Cruz, A. A. 1979The function of mangrovesBiotrop Special Publication10125138Google Scholar
  21. Silva bA, S. 2003Culture-based fisheries: an underutilised opportunity in aquaculture developmentAquaculture221221243CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. DFAR (Department of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources. 1998. Census of marine fisheries in Sri Lanka. UNDP/FAO/SRL/91022. DFAR, Colombo, Sri LankaGoogle Scholar
  23. Dierberg, F., Kiattisimkul, E. W. 1996Issues, impacts and implications of shrimp aquaculture in ThailandEnvironmental Management20649666CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  24. Dixon bA, J. 1989Valuation of mangrovesTropical Coastal Area Management Newsletter43Google Scholar
  25. Ediriweera, S. 2000. Analysis of cost and earnings of selected fishing crafts and gear in Sri Lanka. Department of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources, Colombo, Sri LankaGoogle Scholar
  26. EIAR. 1993. Environmental Impact Assessment Report for a Proposed Shrimp Culture Project in Madilla, Rekawa, 75 pp. Unpublished Environmental StatementGoogle Scholar
  27. Flaherty, M., Karnjanakesorn, C. 1995Marine shrimp aquaculture and natural resource degradation in ThailandEnvironmental Management192737Google Scholar
  28. Foell, J., and E. Harrison. 1999. Participatory mechanisms for sustainable development of coastal ecosystems. DFID Project R6977, Sri Lanka, 44 ppGoogle Scholar
  29. Funge-Smith, S. J., and M. R. P. Briggs. 1994. Development of strategies for sustainable shrimp farming. Final Report to the Overseas Development Administration, Research Project R4751. Institute of Aquaculture, University of Stirling, 31 ppGoogle Scholar
  30. Glasson, J., Therivel, R., Chadwick, A. 1999Introduction to environmental impact assessment: principles and procedures, process, practice and prospects, 2nd edUCL PressLondonGoogle Scholar
  31. Goldburg, R. 1997Shrimp aquacultureEnvironment393739Google Scholar
  32. Gujja, B., Finger-Stich, A. 1996What price prawn? Shrimp aquaculture’s impact in AsiaEnvironment381239Google Scholar
  33. Gunawardena, M. 2001. A critical review of ecological impact assessment in Sri Lanka: with particular reference to the shrimp aquaculture industry. PhD thesis, University of LancasterGoogle Scholar
  34. Gunetilleke, N. 2000. Basic MIMAP poverty profile (draft). Sri Lanka Institute of Policy Studies, Colombo, Sri Lanka, 51 ppGoogle Scholar
  35. Hamilton, L., Dixon, J., Miller, G. 1989Mangroves: An undervalued resource of the land and seaOcean Yearbook8254288Google Scholar
  36. Hein, L. 2002Toward improved environmental and social management of Indian shrimp farmingEnvironmental Management29349359CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  37. Hutchinson, W. G., Chilton, S. M., Davis, J. 1995Measuring non-use values of environmental goods using the contingent valuation method: problems of information and cognition and the application of cognitive questionnaire design methodsAgricultural Economics4697112Google Scholar
  38. Jayakody, D. S., and J. M. P. K. Jayasinghe. 1992. Report of the development potential of Rekawa lagoon. NARA, Colombo, Sri Lanka, 64 ppGoogle Scholar
  39. Jayasinghe, J. M. P. K. 1995Status of aquaculture in Sri Lanka. Annex II-15 in Regional study and workshop on the environmental assessment and management of aquaculture development (TCP/RAS/2253), NACA Environment and Aquaculture Series No. 1Network of Aquaculture Centres in Asia-PacificBangkok, ThailandGoogle Scholar
  40. Johansson, P. 1990Valuing environmental damageOxford Review of Economic Policy63450Google Scholar
  41. Jolliffe, F. R. 1983Survey design and analysisEllis HorwoodChichesterGoogle Scholar
  42. Khor, M. 1995Protests over shrimp farms spread throughout IndiaThird World Resurgence591112Google Scholar
  43. Lal, P. N. 1990. Ecological economic analysis of mangrove conservation, a case study from Fiji. ISME Mangrove Ecosystems Occasional Papers No. 6. UNDP/UNESCO Regional Mangroves Project RAS/86/120, 46 ppGoogle Scholar
  44. Lebel, L., Tri, N. H., Saengnoree, A., Pasong, S., Buatama, U., Thoa, L. K. 2002Industrial transformation and shrimp aquaculture in Thailand and Vietnam: Pathways to ecological, social, and economic sustainability?Ambio31311323PubMedGoogle Scholar
  45. Lee, N.George, C. eds. 2000Environmental assessment in developing and transitional countriesJohn Wiley & SonsChichesterGoogle Scholar
  46. Lowry, K., Pallewatte, N., Dainis, A. P. 1999Policy-relevant assessment of community-level coastal management projects in Sri LankaOcean and Coastal Management42717745CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Matthes, H., and J. M. Kapetsky. 1988. Worldwide compendium of mangrove associated aquatic species of economic importance. FAO, Rome, FAO Fishery Circular No. 814. FAO, RomeGoogle Scholar
  48. McKinnon, A. D., Trott, L. A., Alongi, D. M., Davidson, A. 2002Water column production and nutrient characteristics in mangrove creeks receiving shrimp farm effluentAquaculture Research33119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Moberg, F., Rönnbäck, P. 2003Ecosystem services of the tropical seascape: interactions, substitutions and restorationOcean and Coastal Management46746CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Nickerson, D. J. 1999Trade-offs of mangrove area development in the PhilippinesEcological Economics28279298CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Paez-Osuna, F. 2001The environmental impact of shrimp aquaculture: Causes, effects, and mitigating alternativesEnvironmental Management28131140CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  52. Pauly, D., Ingles, J. 1986The relationship between shrimp yields and intertidal (mangrove) areas: A reassessment. in Workshop on recruitment in tropical coastal demersal communitiesIOC-FOA, UNESCOParis227284Google Scholar
  53. Pearce, D. W., Turner, R. K. 1990The economics of natural resources and the environmentHarvester WheatsheafHemel Hempstead, UKGoogle Scholar
  54. Primavera, J. H. 1991Intensive prawn farming in the Philippines: Ecological, social, and economic implicationsAmbio202833Google Scholar
  55. Primavera, J. H. 1997Socio-economic impacts of shrimp cultureAquaculture Research28815827CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Ranaweera, B. R., A. Premaratne, and I. Ranasinghe. 1994. People, resources and development potentials in the Rekawa SAMP area. Coast Conservation Department, Colombo, Sri Lanka, 43 ppGoogle Scholar
  57. Robertson, A. I., Blaber, S. J. M. 1992

    Plankton, epibenthos and fish communities

    Robertson, A. I.Alongi, D. M. eds. Tropical mangrove ecosystems. Coastal and Estuarine Studies No. 41AGUWashington, DC173224
    Google Scholar
  58. Rönnbäck, P. 1999The ecological basis for economic value of seafood production supported by mangrove ecosystemsEcological Economics29235252CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Rönnbäck, P., Primavera, J. H. 2000Illuminating the need for ecological knowledge in economic valuation of magroves under different management regimes—A critiqueEcological Economics35135141CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. RSAMCC. 1996. Rekawa Special Area Management Coordinating Committee. Rekawa Special Area Management Plan for Rekawa Lagoon, Sri Lanka, Coastal Resources Management Project, Coast Conservation Department, Colombo, Sri Lanka, 81 ppGoogle Scholar
  61. Ruitenbeek, H. J. 1994Modelling economy-ecology linkages in mangroves: Economic evidence for promoting conservation in Bintuni Bay, IndonesiaEcological Economics10233247CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Senarath, U., Visvanathan, C. 2001Environmental issues in brackish water shrimp aquaculture in Sri LankaEnvironmental Management27335348CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  63. Singh, H. R., V. C. Chong, A. Sasekumar, and L. K. Lim. 1994. Value of mangroves as nursery and feeding grounds. Pages 105–122 in Proceedings of the Third ASEAN-Australia Symposium on Living Coastal Resources, Vol. 1. Chulalongkorn University, BangkokGoogle Scholar
  64. Siriwardena, P. P. G. S. N. 2000. Draft report on the code of best practices for shrimp culture in Sri Lanka. Working paper of the WB/NACA/WWF/FAO Consortium Programme on Shrimp Farming and the EnvironmentGoogle Scholar
  65. Stevenson, N. J. 1997Disused shrimp ponds: options for redevelopment of mangrovesCoastal Management25425435Google Scholar
  66. Thuoc, P. 1995Status of aquaculture in Vietnam. Annex II-20 in Regional study and workshop on the environmental assessment and management of aquaculture development (TCP/RAS/2253), NACA Environment and Aquaculture Series No. 1Network of Aquaculture Centres in Asia-PacificBangkok, ThailandGoogle Scholar
  67. Turner, R. K. eds. 1993Sustainable environmental economics and management: principles and practiceBelhaven PressLondonGoogle Scholar
  68. Winpenny, J. T. 1991Values for the environment: a guide to economic appraisalHMSOLondonGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Environmental Science DepartmentLancaster UniversityLancasterUnited Kingdom
  2. 2.Environmental Systems Research Group Department of GeographyUniversity of DundeeDundeeUnited Kingdom

Personalised recommendations