Abstract
Modic change (MC) is considered an independent risk factor for low back pain (LBP) but its aetiology remains unclear. In this cross-sectional, large-scale population-based study we sought to characterise associations between endplate defect (ED) and MC in a population sample of broad age range. The study population consisted of 831 twin volunteers (including 4155 discs and 8310 endplates) from TwinsUK. Lumbar T2-weighted MR images were coded for ED and MC. Total endplate (TEP) score was calculated at each intervertebral disc while receiver operating curves (ROC) were calculated to define critical endplate values predictive of MC. MC was detected in 32.1% of the subjects, with a significantly higher prevalence at lower lumbar levels (3.5% at L1/2-L3/4 vs. 15.9% at L4/5-L5/S1, p < 0.001). TEP score was strongly and independently associated with MC at each lumbar level (risk estimates from 1.49 to 2.44; all p ≤ 0.001) after adjustment for age, sex, BMI and twin pairing. ROC analysis showed a TEP score cut-off of 6 above which there was a significantly higher prevalence of MC. In conclusion, ED were strongly associated with MC at every lumbar level. These findings support the hypothesis that endplate defect is a major initiating factor for the cascade of events that may include disc degeneration (DD) and MC.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Globally, low back pain (LBP) is among the leading causes of disability1 and is considered the largest single cause of disability in Western society, with lifetime prevalence of non-specific LBP estimated at 60–70% in industrialized countries2. With increasing patient demand in secondary and tertiary care, requesting appointments with rheumatologists, physical and rehabilitation medicine specialists and surgeons, LBP represents a highly relevant public health issue with enormous healthcare and socioeconomic costs3. The precise causes of such a burden have still not been clearly defined.
Modic change (MC) describes MR image signal change in subchondral and vertebral bone marrow adjacent to a vertebral body endplate. As visualized on T1- and T2-weighted MR imaging, MC can be divided into three different subtypes: Type 1, 2 and 34,5,6. MC is rarely observed adjacent to a healthy disc7 and tends to be associated with structural change such as disc degeneration (DD)7,8,9, disc herniation7,8,10, Schmorl’s nodes7 and vertebral endplate defect11. Similar to association of intervertebral DD with LBP12,13, also MC is associated with it14,15, and is now considered to be an independent risk factor for LBP16.
Different theories have been suggested regarding the aetiology of these conditions, but the pathophysiology of MC is still not fully understood, and the role of structural bony defects as an initiating factor for MC is not confirmed. Lately, clinical studies have focused attention on endplate defects as having a possible role in the aetiopathogenesis of MC17,18.
Rajasekaran et al.19 have reported that the presence of endplate defect was associated with DD in a clinical sample of 47 patients and 26 volunteers. Endplate defect evaluated on T1-weighted MR scans was classified into six categories according to severity of damage (type 1 to type 6), and total endplate (TEP) score was derived. Strong correlation between progressive grades of endplate defect and disc degeneration was shown, but unfortunately MC was not considered independently in the statistical analysis.
In a previous study from TwinsUK we have shown a strong association between endplate defect and DD in a large population based sample of volunteer twins20. As the association between endplate defect and DD was strong across the age spectrum, and as the endplate is positioned exactly between the intervertebral disc and the vertebral body, we sought to explore whether an additional association exists between endplate defect and MC.
Methods
Study population
The study population was part of the TwinsUK register of King’s College London (www.twinsuk.ac.uk)12. Clinical information on sex, body mass index (BMI), and lumbar DD had been collected previously. All subjects have signed an informed consent form. The study was approved by St. Thomas’ Hospital Ethics Committee and is in accordance with Declaration of Helsinki.
Magnetic resonance imaging and grading
Details of the MR scans, and grading of MRI findings, have been described previously21. Briefly, T2-weighted MR scans were performed on volunteer subjects unselected for LBP, using a Siemens (Munich, Germany) 1.0-T superconducting magnet. Sagittal T2-weighted images were obtained using a fast spin-echo sequence of time to recovery (TR)/time to echo (TE) 5000–4500/112 msec, with a slice thickness of 4 mm. Grading was performed on T2-weighted images.
Grading of endplate defect
As reported previously20, authors JHM and MR coded endplate defects in the baseline MRI scans from all 831 subjects (including 4155 discs and 8310 endplates). Endplate defect was evaluated on a scale of 1–6 (Table 1, Fig. 1) according to Rajasekaran et al.19 and total endplate scores for each disc were constructed by summing the endplate defect score of both rostral and caudal endplates in each functional spine unit19. Inter-rater agreement for the coding of endplate defect was calculated using Cohen’s weighted kappa and Pearson’s correlation.
Agreement phase: An initial training phase was held in which an inter-rater agreement on endplate defect detection and grading of ≥0.85 was reached on at least 100 subjects and 1000 endplates, as reported previously20. Disagreements on coding scores were settled by discussion and consensus.
Grading of Modic change
The coding of MC was performed previously and has been described in detail elsewhere22. Briefly, a single observer (JHM) assessed all images without any prior knowledge of the clinical status. Inter-rater reliability was calculated when the second reader (SW) assessed randomly selected subset of images (n = 50). For the purpose of this study, MC was coded as absent (grade 0) or present (grade 1) for vertebral bone marrow adjacent to each endplate separately. MC detected only in one sagittal slice was not included. MC was considered to affect a lumbar disc if at least one of its endplates were affected.
Grading of disc degeneration
Disc degeneration has been evaluated earlier using Pfirrmann classification23. The classification consists of progressive evaluation of disc degeneration, assessed from grade 1 (homogeneous disc with bright hyperintense white signal intensity and normal disc height) to grade 5 (inhomogeneous disc with hypotense black signal intensity and no more detectable difference between the nucleus and annulus). In accordance with previous studies19,20, grade 4 or greater was considered an indicator of a degenerate disc.
Statistical analysis
Inter-rater agreement for the coding of endplate defects was calculated using Pearson’s correlation and Cohen’s weighted kappa as reported previously20. Critical scores were calculated for MC on the same lumbar level using Receiver Operating Curves (ROC)-analysis. Cumulative link mixed models and linear mixed models were used to analyse association between endplate defects and MC, adjusting for covariates and family structure. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis and Cox proportional hazards models analysis were carried out to infer any age-dependent relationship between endplate defect and MC. All calculations were performed in R using packages “psych”, “survival”, “ordinal”, “lme4”, and “OptimalCutpoints”.
Results
Table 2 summarises the twin sample and its characteristics. In total, there were 831 subjects (mean age 54 ± 8 years, 95.8% female) in the study. Male subjects in the sample were similar to females as regards age and prevalence of MC, but they had significantly higher TEP scores in the lumbar spine compared to females (median [IQR] 29 [20, 36] vs 22 [19, 28], p = 0.001 respectively).
Endplate defects and Modic change
The prevalence and distribution of endplate defect are presented in Table 3. In summary, grade 2 was the most prevalent grade and grade 6 was significantly more prevalent at the lower lumbar levels than upper (p < 0.001).
MC was present in 267 (32.1%) subjects. Of all the endplates being evaluated, we found 646 (7.8%) MC in total. Figure 2 shows the prevalence of MC by individual endplate levels. The prevalence of MC was significantly higher at the lower (L4-S1) compared to upper (L1-L4) lumbar levels (p < 0.001).
Relationship between TEP score and MC
The prevalence of MC showed a significant correlation with increasing TEP score. Using multivariate linear mixed models to allow for covariates, TEP score was found to be strongly and independently associated with MC (risk estimates from 1.49 to 2.44 and p-values p < 0.001, at all lumbar levels, Table 4). Associations with other factors in the final multivariate models (including age, sex and BMI) were significant only at a few lumbar levels. ROC analysis indicated a critical TEP score of 6, above which there was a significantly higher likelihood of MC. Considering each lumbar level, similar cut-off points were found throughout the lumbar spine; TEP score of seven for L2/L3, and six for each of L1/L2, L3/L4, L4/L5, and L5/S1. Of all MC, 287 (81.3%) were at lumbar levels with TEP score ≥6 (Table 5).
Regarding more precise endplate risk evaluation, the probability of having MC adjacent to the endplate having TEP score ≥6 was 6.4% at L1/L2, 12.2% at L2/L3, 21.9% at L3/L4, 48.5% at L4/L5, and 45.1% at L5/S1. Pearson’s correlation between TEP score and MC was statistically significant for every disc level. Considering the whole lumbar spine, if TEP score was ≥6 at any level, the probability of having MC at any level was 81.3%. At each lumbar level, there was a highly statistical significance in MC (p < 0.001) between those with and without TEP score ≥6 (except for L2/L3 TEP score ≥7).
A survival analysis paired with Cox proportional hazards model analysis provided the probabilities of having MC in the presence of TEP score <6 or ≥6, by age subgroups (Fig. 3). The probabilities increased significantly in TEP score ≥6 for all age strata.
Discussion
This is the first large, population-based study examining the association between vertebral endplate defect and MC in the lumbar spine. Results showed that the presence of vertebral endplate defect in the lumbar spine was strongly associated with MC in the bone marrow adjacent to the endplate. When analysed by ROC, we found that a TEP ≥6 strongly predicted risk of MC.
Interestingly, our previous findings from the same sample from TwinsUK registry showed TEP ≥ 5 to be predictive for disc degeneration20 which may indicate that endplate defect, disc degeneration and MC are strongly associated with each other and it is highly likely that the same pathological process is involved. Moreover, our results are also in accord with the findings from another experiment in which endplate defect was correlated with DD in a clinical sample of 47 patients and 26 volunteers19. A cut-off score of 6 was found to be predictive of DD, after which a rapid response with a great increase of likelihood of DD for each unit increase in TEP score was shown, exactly as in our study with MC.
In a clinical study with 1-year follow-up, MC type 1 was associated with both decreasing the disc height and increasing the size of endplate defects17. In another longitudinal clinical study sample DD, endplate defects and MC were found to be significantly associated with each other. Endplate defect grade ≥4 was found to be a risk factor for both DD and MC progression, with MC being the last MR feature to develop in this process18. All these results seem to build on the same line of thoughts (Fig. 4).
With regards to the motion segment in the spine, the cartilaginous endplate is considered to be a mechanically vulnerable structure24, which helps to equalize loading between the vertebral body and the disc25. At surgery, herniated disc material is reported to be found to contain cartilage endplate more frequently in those patients also manifesting MC26. Moreover, cartilage endplate stripping increases the permeability of the endplate and thus facilitates passage between the vertebral body and the intervertebral disc26.
That endplate defect may lead to both MC and DD can be explained by the physical location of the endplate; being positioned between the disc and vertebral body. Biomechanical studies suggest that microfractures at the vertebral endplate27 allow inflammatory cytokines to pass from the intervertebral disc to the bone marrow to initiate MC28, while any physical defect in endplate may allow transport of pro-inflammatory mediators from the disc to the vertebral body, leading to the oedema characteristically seen in MC29.
It is also plausible that an endplate defect creates the basis for low-grade virulent anaerobic bacteria (Propionibacterium acnes, P. acnes) to enter the disc from the vertebral body and give rise to slowly developing infection28. In this context, intervertebral disc infected with anaerobic bacteria have been shown to be more likely to develop adjacent vertebral body MC than those without30.
Biomechanically, endplate defect has been shown to lead to decompression of the adjacent intervertebral disc nucleus, which in turn could drive the degeneration of the disc through several mechanisms by (i) increase of shear forces acting on the annulus31; (ii) decrease of stability at that spinal level32 inducing disruptive changes in the annulus; (iii) altered matrix synthesis33; and (iv) vascularisation of the nucleus pulposus with autoimmune changes30.
There are some limitations we would like to highlight in this study. The TwinsUK sample shows a marked female predominance, for historical reasons. For that reason, every trait was examined separately by gender to determine how best to account for differences in the analysis. TwinsUK participants have been shown to be representative of singletons for a wide range of lifestyle and demographic traits34. For historical and funding reasons, only T2-weighted scans were available and, therefore, the evaluation of MC types was not possible. This study is cross-sectional by design, and our results support the hypothesis that endplate defect may be the initiating factor for MC and intervertebral disc degeneration. As a suggestion for further improvement we suggest designing a longitudinal study of endplates, DD and MC to unequivocably confirm the direction of such causality. Another relevant strength is the thorough training phase undergone by the two evaluators (JHM and MR) leading to almost perfect inter-rater agreement for endplate defect: kappa value of 0.86, Pearson correlation 0.864, with correlation and kappa being employed in conjunction to uncover nonrandom examiner error, as in Hunt35.
Conclusions
To conclude, this study performed on a large population-based sample confirmed that endplate defect is strongly and independently associated with DD and MC, and that this relationship is evident in adults across the age spectrum and at all lumbar levels. As the same conclusions were reported for ED and DD in our previous study in the same population using the same methods, we imply that causal effects can occur between ED, DD and MC. A longitudinal study of twins’ MR spine scans and endplate is currently under way to better confirm the order of events.
References
Vos, T. et al. Global, regional, and national incidence, prevalence, and years lived with disability for 310 diseases and injuries, 1990–2015: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015. Lancet 388, 1545–1602 (2016).
Duthey, B. Priority Medicines for Europe and the World “A Public Health Approach to Innovation”, Background Paper 6.24 Low back pain. World Health Organization (2013).
Dagenais, S., Caro, J. & Haldeman, S. A systematic review of low back pain cost of illness studies in the United States and internationally. Spine J. 8, 8–20 (2008).
De Roos, A., Kressel, H., Spritzer, C. & Dalinka, M. MR imaging of marrow changes adjacent to end plates in degenerative lumbar disk disease. Am. J. Roentgenol. 149, 531–534 (1987).
Modic, M. T., Steinberg, P. M., Ross, J. S., Masaryk, T. J. & Carter, J. R. Degenerative disk disease: Assessment of changes in vertebral body marrow with MR imaging. Radiology 166, 193–199 (1988).
Modic, M. T., Masaryk, T. J., Ross, J. S. & Carter, J. R. Imaging of degenerative disk disease. Radiology 168, 177–186 (1988).
Määttä, J. H., Karppinen, J. I., Luk, K. D. K., Cheung, K. M. C. & Samartzis, D. Phenotype profiling of Modic changes of the lumbar spine and its association with other MRI phenotypes: A large-scale population-based study. Spine J. 15, 1933–1942 (2015).
Jensen, T. S. et al. Predictors of new vertebral endplate signal (Modic) changes in the general population. Eur. Spine J. 19, 129–135 (2010).
Mok, F. P. S. et al. Modic changes of the lumbar spine: Prevalence, risk factors, and association with disc degeneration and low back pain in a large-scale population-based cohort. Spine J. 16, 32–41 (2016).
Albert, H. B. & Manniche, C. Modic changes following lumbar disc herniation. Eur Spine J. 16, 977–982 (2007).
Luoma, K., Vehmas, T., Grönblad, M., Kerttula, L. & Kääpä, E. MRI follow-up of subchondral signal abnormalities in a selected group of chronic low back pain patients. Eur. Spine J. 17, 1300–1308 (2008).
Livshits, G. et al. Lumbar disc degeneration and genetic factors are the main risk factors for low back pain in women: The UK Twin Spine Study. Ann. Rheum. Dis. 70, 1740–1745 (2011).
Takatalo, J. et al. Does lumbar disc degeneration on magnetic resonance imaging associate with low back symptom severity in young finnish adults? Spine 36, 2180–2189 (2011).
Määttä, J. H., Wadge, S., MacGregor, A., Karppinen, J. & Williams, F. M. K. ISSLS prize winner: Vertebral endplate (modic) change is an independent risk factor for episodes of severe and disabling low back pain. Spine 40, 1187–1193 (2015).
Brinjikji, W. et al. MRI findings of disc degeneration are more prevalent in adults with low back pain than in asymptomatic controls: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Am. J. Neuroradiol. 36, 2394–2399 (2015).
Kjaer, P., Korsholm, L., Bendix, T., Sorensen, J. S. & Leboeuf-Yde, C. Modic changes and their associations with clinical findings. Eur. Spine J. 15, 1312–1319 (2006).
Kerttula, L., Luoma, K., Vehmas, T., Grönblad, M. & Kääpä, E. Modic type I change may predict rapid progressive, deforming disc degeneration: a prospective 1-year follow-up study. Eur. Spine J. 21, 1135–1142 (2012).
Farshad-Amacker, N. A., Hughes, A., Herzog, R. J., Seifert, B. & Farshad, M. The intervertebral disc, the endplates and the vertebral bone marrow as a unit in the process of degeneration. Eur. Radiol. 27, 2507–2520 (2017).
Rajasekaran, S., Venkatadass, K., Naresh Babu, J., Ganesh, K. & Shetty, A. P. Pharmacological enhancement of disc diffusion and differentiation of healthy, ageing and degenerated discs: Results from in-vivo serial post-contrast MRI studies in 365 human lumbar discs. Eur. Spine J. 17, 626–643 (2008).
Rade, M. et al. Vertebral endplate defect as initiating factor in intervertebral disc degeneration: Strong association between endplate defect and disc degeneration in the general population. Spine 43, 412–419 (2018).
Sambrook, P. N., MacGregor, A. J. & Spector, T. D. Genetic influences on cervical and lumbar disc degeneration: A magnetic resonance imaging study in twins. Arthritis Rheum. 42, 366–372 (1999).
Määttä, J. H. et al. Vertebral endplate change as a feature of intervertebral disc degeneration: a heritability study. Eur. Spine J. 23, 1856–1862 (2014).
Pfirrmann, C. W. A., Metzdorf, A., Zanetti, M., Hodler, J. & Boos, N. Magnetic resonance classification of lumbar intervertebral disc degeneration. Spine 26, 1873–1878 (2001).
Adams, M. A. & Roughley, P. J. What is intervertebral disc degeneration, and what causes it? Spine 31, 2151–2161 (2006).
Setton, L. A., Zhu, W., Weidenbaum, M., Ratcliffe, A. & Mow, V. C. Compressive properties of the cartilaginous End-Plate of the baboon lumbar spine. J. Orthop. Res. 11, 228–239 (1993).
Shan, Z. et al. Spontaneous resorption of lumbar disc herniation is less likely when modic changes are present. Spine 39, 736–744 (2014).
Adams, M. A., Freeman, B. J. C., Morrison, H. P., Nelson, I. W. & Dolan, P. Mechanical initiation of intervertebral disc degeneration. Spine 25, 1625–1636 (2000).
Albert, H. B. et al. Modic changes, possible causes and relation to low back pain. Med. Hypotheses 70, 361–368 (2008).
Lama, P. et al. Significance of cartilage endplate within herniated disc tissue. Eur. Spine J. 23, 1869–1877 (2014).
Albert, H. B. et al. Does nuclear tissue infected with bacteria following disc herniations lead to Modic changes in the adjacent vertebrae? Eur. Spine J. 22, 690–696 (2013).
Stefanakis, M., Luo, J., Pollintine, P., Dolan, P. & Adams, M. A. ISSLS prize winner: Mechanical influences in progressive intervertebral disc degeneration. Spine 39, 1365–1372 (2014).
Zhao, F., Pollintine, P., Hole, B. D., Dolan, P. & Adams, M. A. Discogenic origins of spinal instability. Spine 30, 2621–2630 (2005).
Tanaka, M., Nakahara, S. & Inoue, H. A pathologic study of discs in the elderly: Separation between the cartilaginous endplate and the vertebral body. Spine 18, 1456–1462 (1993).
Andrew, T. et al. Are twins and singletons comparable? A study of disease-related and lifestyle characteristics in adult women. Twin Res. 4, 464–477 (2001).
Hunt, R. J. Percent agreement, Pearson’s correlation, and kappa as measures of inter-examiner reliability. J. Dent. Res. 65, 128–30 (1986).
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the twins who volunteered to take part in the study and Sam Wadge for his invaluable work in coding the MR scans. The authors would here also like to thank Prof. Michael A. Adams for his invaluable comments on the reporting of this study, and the medical illustrator Dr. Ivan Barun (ivan.i.barun@gmail.com) for providing the excellent illustration presented in Figure 2. This project was funded by the FP7 project Pain_omics. TwinsUK. The study was funded by the Wellcome Trust; European Community’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007–2013). The study also receives support from the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR)- funded BioResource, Clinical Research Facility and Biomedical Research Centre based at Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust in partnership with King’s College London. The department of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine, Kuopio University Hospital, Kuopio, Finland, provided additional funding for travelling.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
J.H.M. and M.R. contributed equally to this work, read the M.R. images, analyzed and interpreted the data and wrote the main manuscript text. M.B.F. analyzed the data. J.H.M., M.R., M.B.F., O.A., J.K. and F.M.K.W. drafted and reviewed the manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing Interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Määttä, J.H., Rade, M., Freidin, M.B. et al. Strong association between vertebral endplate defect and Modic change in the general population. Sci Rep 8, 16630 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-34933-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-34933-3
- Springer Nature Limited
Keywords
This article is cited by
-
Novel Modic grading scoring system and its clinical validation: a preliminary investigation
European Spine Journal (2024)
-
Bone resorption around the annular closure device during a postoperative follow-up of 8 years
Acta Neurochirurgica (2024)
-
Modic changes as seen on MRI are associated with nonspecific chronic lower back pain and disability
Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research (2023)
-
Modic change is associated with increased BMI but not autoimmune diseases in TwinsUK
European Spine Journal (2023)
-
A new immunometabolic perspective of intervertebral disc degeneration
Nature Reviews Rheumatology (2022)