Background

In the context of the market launch of a novel food for special medical purposes (FSMP), applicable for the special dietary management of allergy patients, Bencard Allergie GmbH invited medical doctors specialised in allergy from Austria and Germany to a multidisciplinary expert discussion. Physicians specialised in paediatrics, ENT, pulmonology, clinical immunology, dermatology and occupational medicine were represented. The aim of this expert panel meeting, which was conducted as a video conference, was to have an open discussion on possible areas of application of the food for special medical purposes based on the published scientific evidence. At the beginning of the meeting, the inventor, Prof. Erika Jensen-Jarolim from Vienna, gave a summarising scientific introduction, followed by Prof. Karl-Christian Bergmann (Charité & ECARF Institute, Berlin) presenting current clinical study data. The discussion was chaired by Dr. Sonja Guethoff (Bencard Allergie GmbH, Munich). This publication summarises the contents of the expert panel meeting.

Introduction

The prevalence of atopic diseases is constantly increasing worldwide [1]. About one third of the population in Europe is affected by allergic rhinoconjunctivitis (ARC) [1]. The current guideline-based recommendations for the standard therapy of ARC [2, 3] essentially include oral H1 antihistamines, nasal glucocorticoids, nasal H1 antihistamine/glucocorticoids as a combination therapy and allergen-specific immunotherapy (AIT). AIT has a special role as it represents the only causal therapeutic option for the treatment of ARC to date [2, 3].

However, ARC is often still treated insufficiently [1, 2]. Therefore, there is a high demand for substances, which support the actual therapy such as food supplements or foods for special medical purposes (FSMP), which are available without prescription as over-the-counter (OTC) products. As the current notification procedure for registering food supplements and FSMP on the market does not require documentation of efficacy [4, 5], evidence-based food supplements or FSMP are a rare exception on the OTC market [6, 7].

The recently launched product was registered as a food for special medical purposes for the dietary management of allergic rhinitis and is available in pharmacies in Austria and Germany as an OTC product since the beginning of 2021.

The protective farm effect as the basis for developing a lozenge

Epidemiological studies have described the influence of environmental and nutritional factors on the development of allergic diseases and their symptom burden for many years. A prominent example of this is the so-called “farm effect”. This term describes the allergy-protective effect, which is characterised both by the general living conditions on farms with dairy farming and by the protective effects of the consumption of raw milk [8, 9]. The latter effect, however, is limited to unprocessed milk only and cannot be demonstrated for consumption of commercially available cow’s milk. One explanation is the industrial milk processing step, which leads to denaturation of potentially immune-modulating proteins [10]. This also affects bovine beta-lactoglobulin (BLG), representing more than 50% of whey protein. BLG belongs to the protein family of lipocalins and acts as a transport protein for micronutrients [11]. It was recently demonstrated that BLG, associated with zinc, is also detectable in stable dust, in the mattress dust of the families living on farms with dairy farming and, depending on distance, in the surrounding air of cattle stables. In these instances, BLG is dispersed via aerosols and can be detected in the area around the stable [12]. Further studies proved that BLG associated with zinc reduces T‑cell proliferation in vitro and induces an allergy-protective Th1 milieu [12].

Holo-BLG—targeted micronutrition of immune cells leads to immune resilience

The immune-modulating effect of BLG is based on targeted micronutrition of immune cells, whereby the loading state of the bovine BLG plays a central role [11, 13, 14]. If BLG is loaded with micronutrients, this is referred to as holo-BLG. The micronutrients iron, zinc and vitamin A in the holo-BLG lozenge are bound as ligands in the central binding pocket of the BLG molecule and thus contribute to the overall effect. The micronutrient iron seems to play a central role here, which can be attributed to two pathophysiological aspects of atopic diseases. On the one hand, there is an epidemiological and experimental correlation between functional iron deficiency and atopy or allergy [15]. On the other hand, reduced levels of human lipocalin‑2 (LCN-2) have been described in allergic patients [16]. LCN‑2 is a transport protein and, among other things, fulfils the function to transport complexed iron (Fe3+) specifically to critical cell populations such as immune cells [17]. The combination of these two pathophysiological conditions results in a functional iron deficiency in allergic patients, meaning the body’s own depot of iron is limited for cellular functions. An intracellular iron deficiency causes an increased degranulation of mast cells and the promotion of a Th2 milieu as a decisive immunological switch in atopic diseases [17].

Compensation of this functional iron deficiency is achieved by BLG loaded with iron–polyphenol complexes: In mouse studies, the comparison of holo-BLG with the unloaded form (apo-BLG) showed that holo-BLG leads to an improved iron status of the immune cells. In addition, when treated with holo-BLG, a reduced antigen presentation was observed by masking B‑ and T‑cell epitopes. Furthermore, supplementation with holo-BLG reduced IgE binding and mast cell degranulation in the effector phase [11]. The additional loading of BLG with vitamin A and zinc [12, 13] could further support the immune-modulating effects and was incorporated into the development of the holo-BLG lozenge.

In addition to in vitro experiments and mouse models [11, 18], the efficacy of holo-BLG in allergic patients has so far been investigated in two clinical pilot trials. In a first randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, a total of 20 female patients with birch pollen allergy were enrolled and received holo-BLG or placebo daily for 6 months (including the birch pollen season). In the holo-BLG group, the daily symptom load during the birch pollen season was significantly lower than in the placebo group. Furthermore, immune cells of the patients supplemented with holo-BLG had higher intracellular iron compared to placebo [19]. These promising results are currently being investigated in a larger cohort.

Another proof-of-concept study investigated the effect of holo-BLG in patients with house dust mite allergy in a standardised and validated allergen exposure chamber. Supplementation with holo-BLG achieved a significant improvement of 60% (p = 0.0034) in the primary endpoint (total nasal symptom score) [20].

Overall, both studies demonstrated an excellent tolerability of the holo-BLG lozenge.

In summary, the available study results [19, 20] and the associated immunological effects [11] indicate that supplementation with holo-BLG can lead to immune resilience in patients with allergic rhinitis, whereby this phenomenon is not allergen-specific. The preclinical data could now be supported accordingly by early clinical data. Further clinical studies are being planned.

In which situations could holo-BLG be recommended?

Overall, the causal treatment of allergic patients with AIT remains undisputed. However, the expert panel agreed that the holo-BLG lozenge generally represents an innovative option for many patients with type I allergies due to its allergen-unspecific, immune-modulating mode of action. The application is considered in a variety of clinical scenarios.

Due to the allergen-unspecific mode of action of holo-BLG, its use in patients with multiple allergies was discussed. It is often not possible to achieve satisfactory symptom control despite guideline-compliant causal (AIT) and drug therapy in this specific patient group, so that holo-BLG could be a supportive option.

This also applies to patients with allergies to rare allergens, where no suitable AIT preparations are available. In this context, the use of holo-BLG in occupational allergies (as tertiary prevention), or possibly already in secondary prevention of sensitisation to occupational allergens in allergic or atopic patients was highlighted as a conceivable possibility.

Patients with tree pollen-associated food allergies (oral allergy syndrome) are not often treated efficiently with available therapies. For patients who suffer a lot and claim limited quality of life, it seems possible to apply holo-BLG as a supportive product.

The use of the holo-BLG lozenge was also discussed as an option in the context of difficult treatment situations in everyday practice. An important group are patients allergic to animal dander who want to keep their pet.

In addition, situations arising due to the presence of a contraindication or rejection of clinically indicated AIT were mentioned. For these patient groups, the optional use of holo-BLG was endorsed by the expert panel.

The application of holo-BLG has been primarily discussed for adolescents and adults. The use of the holo-BLG lozenge is possible from the age of three years, given that the child can reliably suck a lozenge without swallowing it.

Regarding the application in children, sufficient clinical data for a final conclusive evaluation is pending. However, an observational study of the application is currently being conducted in four sites in Germany. Clinical effects and tolerability of the holo-BLG lozenge in adults, but also in children and adolescents will be documented.

The extension of clinical studies across subject demographics and its mode of action is desirable, especially given the fact of a potential allergy-preventive application of holo-BLG.

Limitations for the use are based on the composition of the lozenge. Supplementation is contraindicated in the presence of a confirmed milk protein allergy. In addition, according to the expert panel, they would prefer that patients inform their treating physician about the intake of holo-BLG.

Conclusion

The expert panel rates the supplementation of the lozenge, with holo-BLG, as an important innovation that could enable the farm effect and thus might represent a new and additional option for allergic patients. Based on the published evidence, holo-BLG might represent a supportive approach for allergic patients.