Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to formally evaluate whether odds of entry into self-employment decrease as skin tone darkens for Blacks in the United States. Extending past work on inter-group differences in Black-White self-employment, based on data from National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1997, with darker skin tone the odds of self-employment decline. Having spent more time in labor force further decreases the likelihood of self-employment for darker skin tone Blacks, and being a high-school graduate, scoring high on Armed Services Vocational Aptitude Battery (ASVAB), or higher past year income are not associated with self-employment of darker skin tone Blacks. While darker skin tone Blacks who are self-employed derive lower income, those who are self-employed and with more human capital (longer time spent in the labor force, scoring high on ASVAB or being a high school graduate) have a higher income.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Differences in wealth gap also exist among other races. A broad range of studies across different racial groups have shown that skin tone is negatively associated with economic outcomes. In a study of Latino men in Boston, Gómez, C. The continual significance of skin color: An exploratory study of Latinos in the Northeast. Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences. 2000;22(1):94–103. found that that after “controlling for traditional human capital variables, differences in hourly wages persisted between dark-skinned men and the remainder of the male sample” (page 100). Puerto Ricans, who generally have darker skin, made $5427 less than Cubans, who generally have lighter skin. Similarly, Vietnamese, generally known to have darker skin tone had lower income than Chinese, generally known for lighter skin tone Burton, L.M., Bonilla-Silva, E., Ray, V., Buckelew, R., Hordge Freeman, E. Critical race theories, colorism, and the decade’s research on families of color. Journal of Marriage and Family. 2010;72(3):440–459.
In the US, compared to 11.6% of the Whites engaged in self-employment only 3.8% of Blacks are involved in self-employment [Fairlie, R.W., Robb, A. Families, human capital, and small business: Evidence from the characteristics of business owners survey. Industrial & Labor Relations Review. 2007a;60(2):225–245, Fairlie, R.W., Robb, A.M. Why are Black-owned businesses less successful than White-owned businesses? The role of families, inheritances, and business human capital. Journal of Labor Economics. 2007b;25(2):289–323.]. Black owned business are more likely to fail and the gaps in rate and success in self-employment among Blacks have continued to increase in the past decades [Fairlie, R.W., Meyer, B.D. Trends in self-employment among white and black men during the twentieth century. Journal of human resources. 2000;35(4):643–669.]. However, variations in self-employment outcomes based on skintone differences among Blacks remain largely unexplored.
Contrary to the linear probability model, where the coefficients are treated as the marginal effects, our estimates obtained using logit model represents the incremental effects on the natural log of odds ratio. The coefficients of our Logit model shows the incremental effects of natural log of odds ratio, i.e., \( \beta =\frac{\delta \ln \left(\frac{P}{1- P}\right)}{\delta X} \), where P is the probability of self-employment. We then find the change in odds ratio as \( \frac{\delta \left(\frac{P}{1- P}\right)}{\delta X}={e}^{\beta}-1 \). All estimates reported in the text are expressed as change in odds ratio.
As a robustness test, we also use college degree as control instead of high school in our Model 3 of Table 3 and Model 2 of Table 7. The effects of skin tone on self-employment were similar in both cases. For the Model 2 of Table 7, being a college graduate though positive had no significant association with the likelihood of self-employment.
In addition, to these factors that are known to influence self-employment, as discussed earlier, social networks could mitigate the negative effects of darker skin tone on self-employment. In NLSY 1997, based on past works on employment related social networks in NLSY 1979 [Wheeler, C.H. Cities and the growth of wages among young workers: Evidence from the NLSY. Journal of Urban Economics. 2006;60(2):162–184.], we identified two social network proxies: (i) whether someone recommended for the job; and (ii) the count of non-family members who recommended for the job. While the sample size for the first indicator was 8053 observations, and for the second indicator was 3268 observations f, controlling for whether someone recommended for the job, skin tone as negatively associated with the likelihood of self-employment (β = −0.0758, p < 0.01). Similarly, with increasing count of non-family members who recommended for the job, skin tone as negatively associated with the likelihood of self-employment (β = −0.206, p < 0.01). These findings, suggesting persistent effects of skintone in self-employment, when darker skin tone individuals have more connections in the traditional employment market, they have a lower preference for self-employment.
References
Adams EA, Kurtz-Costes BE, Hoffman AJ. Skin tone bias among African Americans: antecedents and consequences across the life span. Dev Rev. 2016;40:93–116.
Akee, R., Yuksel, M. Skin Tone’s decreasing importance on employment: evidence from a Longitudinal dataset, 1985–2000. 2010.
Allen WD. Social networks and self-employment. J Socio-Econ. 2000;29(5):487–501.
Allen W, Telles E, Hunter M. Skin color, income and education: a comparison of African Americans and Mexican Americans. National Journal of Sociology. 2000;12(1):129–80.
Åstebro T, Thompson P. Entrepreneurs, jacks of all trades or hobos? Res Policy. 2011;40(5):637–49.
Barkley, C. Who’s afraid of a large black man? Penguin; 2005.
Bates T. Self-employment entry across industry groups. J Bus Ventur. 1995;10(2):143–56.
Bates, T. Race, self-employment, and upward mobility: an illusive American dream Woodrow Wilson Center press; 1997.
Bell D. Property rights in whiteness: their legal legacy, their economic costs. Critical race theory: The cutting edge. 2000;2:71–9.
Belletti, N.E., Wade, T.J. Racial characteristics and female facial attractiveness perception among United States university students springer; 2008.
Bertrand M, Mullainathan S. Are Emily and Greg more employable than Lakisha and Jamal? A field experiment on labor market discrimination. Am Econ Rev. 2004;94(4):991–1013.
Biehl AM, Gurley-Calvez T, Hill B. Self-employment of older Americans: do recessions matter? Small Bus Econ. 2014;42(2):297–309.
Blair IV, Judd CM, Sadler MS, Jenkins C. The role of Afrocentric features in person perception: judging by features and categories. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2002;83(1):5.
Blaker NM, Rompa I, Dessing IH, Vriend AF, Herschberg C, Van Vugt M. The height leadership advantage in men and women: testing evolutionary psychology predictions about the perceptions of tall leaders. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations. 2013;16(1):17–27.
Blanchflower, D.G. Self-employment: more may not be better. 2004.
Blanchflower DG, Oswald AJ. What makes an entrepreneur? J Labor Econ. 1998;16(1):26–60.
Blanchflower DG, Levine PB, Zimmerman DJ. Discrimination in the small-business credit market. Review of Economics and Statistics. 2003;85(4):930–43.
Borjas, G.J. The self-employment experience of immigrants. 1986.
Borjas GJ, Bronars SG. Consumer discrimination and self-employment. J Polit Econ. 1989;97(3):581–605.
Borrell LN, Kiefe CI, Williams DR, Diez-Roux AV, Gordon-Larsen P. Self-reported health, perceived racial discrimination, and skin color in African Americans in the CARDIA study. Soc Sci Med. 2006;63(6):1415–27.
Bowman PJ, Muhammad R, Ifatunji M. Skin tone, class, and racial attitudes among African Americans. In: Herring C, Keith VM, Horton H, editors. Skin deep: how race and complexion matter in the “color-blind” era. Urbana-Champaign: University of Illinois Press; 2004. p. 128–57.
Boyd B. Corporate linkages and organizational environment: a test of the resource dependence model. Strateg Manag J. 1990a;11(6):419–30.
Boyd RL. Black and Asian self-employment in large metropolitan areas: a comparative analysis. Soc Probl. 1990b;37(2):258–74.
Boyd RL. A contextual analysis of black self-employment in large metropolitan areas, 1970–1980. Soc Forces. 1991;70(2):409–29.
Brown KT, Ward GK, Lightbourn T, Jackson JS. Skin tone and racial identity among African Americans: a theoretical and research framework. Advances in African American Psychology. 1999:191–214.
Burke M, Embrich DG. Colorism. International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. 2008;2:17–8.
Burton LM, Bonilla-Silva E, Ray V, Buckelew R, Hordge Freeman E. Critical race theories, colorism, and the decade's research on families of color. J Marriage Fam. 2010;72(3):440–59.
Butler JS, Herring C. Ethnicity and entrepreneurship in America: toward an explanation of racial and ethnic group variations in self-employment. Sociol Perspect. 1991;34(1):79–94.
Caliendo M, Kopeinig S. Some practical guidance for the implementation of propensity score matching. J Econ Surv. 2008;22(1):31–72.
Celious A, Oyserman D. Race from the inside: an emerging heterogeneous race model. J Soc Issues. 2001;57(1):149–65.
Charles, C.A. Skin bleaching and the self-hate polemic. 2013.
Coard SI, Breland AM, Raskin P. Perceptions of and preferences for skin color, black racial identity, and self-esteem among African Americans1. J Appl Soc Psychol. 2001;31(11):2256–74.
Couch, K.A., Fairlie, R.W., Xu, H. Racial Differences in Labor Market Transitions and the Great Recession. 2016.
Darity WA Jr, Dietrich J, Hamilton D. Bleach in the rainbow: Latin ethnicity and preference for whiteness. Transform Anthropol. 2005;13(2):103–9.
De Wit G, Van Winden FA. An empirical analysis of self-employment in the Netherlands. Econ Lett. 1990;32(1):97–100.
Dehejia RH, Wahba S. Propensity score-matching methods for nonexperimental causal studies. Rev Econ Stat. 2002;84(1):151–61.
Diette TM, Goldsmith AH, Hamilton D, Darity W. Skin shade stratification and the psychological cost of unemployment: is there a gradient for black females? Rev Black Pol Econ. 2015;42(1–2):155–77.
Dixon TL, Maddox KB. Skin tone, crime news, and social reality judgments: priming the stereotype of the dark and dangerous black criminal1. J Appl Soc Psychol. 2005;35(8):1555–70.
Dunn T, Holtz-Eakin D. Financial capital, human capital, and the transition to self-employment: evidence from intergenerational links. J Labor Econ. 2000;18(2):282–305.
Eberhardt JL, Davies PG, Purdie-Vaughns VJ, Johnson SL. Looking deathworthy: perceived stereotypicality of black defendants predicts capital-sentencing outcomes. Psychol Sci. 2006;17(5):383–6.
Edwards K, Carter-Tellison K, Herring C. For richer, for poorer, whether dark or light: skin tone, marital status, and spouse’s earnings. Urbana: University of Illinois Press; 2004. pp. 65–81.
Evans DS, Leighton LS. The determinants of changes in US self-employment, 1968–1987. Small Bus Econ. 1989;1(2):111–9.
Fairlie RW. The absence of the African-American owned business: an analysis of the dynamics of self-employment. J Labor Econ. 1999;17(1):80–108.
Fairlie RW, Meyer BD. Trends in self-employment among white and black men during the twentieth century. J Hum Resour. 2000;35(4):643–69.
Fairlie RW, Robb A. Families, human capital, and small business: evidence from the characteristics of business owners survey. Ind Labor Relat Rev. 2007a;60(2):225–45.
Fairlie RW, Robb AM. Why are black-owned businesses less successful than white-owned businesses? The role of families, inheritances, and business human capital. J Labor Econ. 2007b;25(2):289–323.
Fairlie, R., Robb, A., Robinson, D.T. Black and white: access to capital among minority-owned startups. 2015.
Fears D. Race divides Hispanics, report says. Washington Post. 2003;A03
Forman TA, Lewis AE. Beyond prejudice? Young whites’ racial attitudes in post–civil rights America, 1976 to 2000. Am Behav Sci. 2015;0002764215588811
Georgellis Y, Wall HJ. Gender differences in self-employment. Int Rev Appl Econ. 2005;19(3):321–42.
Goldsmith AH, Hamilton D, Darity W. Shades of discrimination: skin tone and wages. Am Econ Rev. 2006;96(2):242–5.
Goldsmith AH, Hamilton D, Darity W. From dark to light: skin color and wages among African-Americans. J Hum Resour. 2007;42(4):701–38.
Gómez C. The continual significance of skin color: an exploratory study of Latinos in the northeast. Hisp J Behav Sci. 2000;22(1):94–103.
Grogger J. Speech patterns and racial wage inequality. J Hum Resour. 2011;46(1):1–25.
Gullickson A. The significance of color declines: a re-analysis of skin tone differentials in post-civil rights America. Soc Forces. 2005;84(1):157–80.
Hagiwara N, Kashy DA, Cesario J. The independent effects of skin tone and facial features on Whites' affective reactions to blacks. J Exp Soc Psychol. 2012;48(4):892–8.
Harris CI. Whiteness as property. Harv Law Rev. 1993:1707–91.
Hartog J, Van Praag M, Van Der Sluis J. If you are so smart, why aren't you an entrepreneur? Returns to cognitive and social ability: entrepreneurs versus employees. J Econ Manag Strateg. 2010;19(4):947–89.
Harvey RD, LaBeach N, Pridgen E, Gocial TM. The intragroup stigmatization of skin tone among black Americans. Journal of Black Psychology. 2005;31(3):237–53.
Hersch J. Skin-tone effects among African Americans: perceptions and reality. Am Econ Rev. 2006;96(2):251–5.
Hersch J. Profiling the new immigrant worker: the effects of skin color and height. J Labor Econ. 2008;26(2):345–86.
Hersch J. The persistence of skin color discrimination for immigrants. Soc Sci Res. 2011;40(5):1337–49.
Hughes M, Hertel BR. The significance of color remains: a study of life chances, mate selection, and ethnic consciousness among black Americans. Soc Forces. 1990;68(4):1105–20.
Hundley G. Male/female earnings differences in self-employment: the effects of marriage, children, and the household division of labor. Ind Labor Relat Rev. 2000;54(1):95–114.
Hunter M. The persistent problem of colorism: skin tone, status, and inequality. Sociol Compass. 2007;1(1):237–54.
Hunter, M.L. Race gender and the politics of skin tone Routledge; 2013.
Hurst E, Lusardi A. Liquidity constraints, household wealth, and entrepreneurship. J Polit Econ. 2004;112(2):319–47.
Jackson-Lowman H. An analysis of the impact of Eurocentric concepts of beauty on the lives of African American women. African American Women: Living at the Crossroads of Race, Gender, Class, and Culture. 2013:155–72.
Jarrett O. Doll studies as racial assessments. Celebrating 40 years of play research: connecting our past, present, and. Futures. 2016;13:19.
Johnson JH, Farrell WC, Stoloff JA. The declining social and economic fortunes of African American males: a critical assessment of four perspectives. Rev Black Polit Econ. 1998;25(4):17–40.
Keith VM, Herring C. Skin tone and stratification in the black community. Am J Sociol. 1991;97(3):760–78.
Kim PH, Aldrich HE, Keister LA. Access (not) denied: the impact of financial, human, and cultural capital on entrepreneurial entryin the United States. Small Bus Econ. 2006;27(1):5–22.
Kreisman D, Rangel MA. On the blurring of the color line: wages and employment for black males of different skin tones. Rev Econ Stat. 2015;97(1):1–13.
Kwon S-W, Heflin C, Ruef M. Community social capital and entrepreneurship. Am Sociol Rev. 2013;78(6):980–1008.
Lazear EP. Balanced skills and entrepreneurship. Am Econ Rev. 2004;94(2):208–11.
Le AT. Empirical studies of self-employment. J Econ Surv. 1999;13(4):381–416.
Levinson JD, Young D. Different shades of bias: skin tone, implicit racial bias, and judgments of ambiguous evidence. W Va L Rev. 2009;112:307.
Livingston RW, Brewer MB. What are we really priming? Cue-based versus category-based processing of facial stimuli. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2002;82(1):5.
Lofstrom M, Bates T. African Americans’ pursuit of self-employment. Small Bus Econ. 2013;40(1):73–86.
Maddox KB. Perspectives on racial phenotypicality bias. Personal Soc Psychol Rev. 2004;8(4):383–401.
Maddox KB, Chase SG. Manipulating subcategory salience: exploring the link between skin tone and social perception of blacks. Eur J Soc Psychol. 2004;34(5):533–46.
Maddox KB, Gray SA. Cognitive representations of black Americans: Reexploring the role of skin tone. Personal Soc Psychol Bull. 2002;28(2):250–9.
Marion J. Affirmative action and the utilization of minority-and women-owned businesses in highway procurement. Econ Inq. 2011;49(3):899–915.
Mason PL. Annual income, hourly wages, and identity among Mexican-Americans and other Latinos. Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society. 2004;43(4):817–34.
Monk EP Jr. Skin tone stratification among black Americans, 2001–2003. Soc Forces. 2014;92(4):1313–37.
Montalvo FF, Codina GE. Skin color and Latinos in the United States. Ethnicities. 2001;1(3):321–41.
Moore WE, Williams RM. Stratification in the ante-bellum south. Am Sociol Rev. 1942;7(3):343–51.
Morales MC. The ethnic niche as an economic pathway for the dark skinned: labor market incorporation of Latina/o workers. Hisp J Behav Sci. 2008;
Mucherah W, Frazier AD. How deep is skin-deep? The relationship between skin color satisfaction, estimation of body image, and self-esteem among women of African descent. J Appl Soc Psychol. 2013;43(6):1177–84.
Noorderhaven N, Thurik R, Wennekers S. Stel, a.V. The role of dissatisfaction and per capita income in explaining self-employment across 15 European countries. Entrep Theory Pract. 2004;28(5):447–66.
Parker, S.C. The economics of self-employment and entrepreneurship Cambridge University press; 2004.
Parker SC. Entrepreneurship among married couples in the United States: a simultaneous probit approach. Labour Econ. 2008;15(3):459–81.
Peikes DN, Moreno L, Orzol SM. Propensity score matching: a note of caution for evaluators of social programs. Am Stat. 2008;62(3):222–31.
Quinn JF. Labor-force participation patterns of older self-employed workers. Soc Sec Bull. 1980;43:17.
Rashad I. Height, health, and income in the US, 1984–2005. Econ Hum Biol. 2008;6(1):108–26.
Rietveld CA, Hessels J, van der Zwan P. The stature of the self-employed and its relation with earnings and satisfaction. Econ Hum Biol. 2015;17:59–74.
Ronquillo J, Denson TF, Lickel B, Lu Z-L, Nandy A, Maddox KB. The effects of skin tone on race-related amygdala activity: an fMRI investigation. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2007;2(1):39–44.
Seltzer R, Smith RC. Color differences in the afro-American community and the differences they make. Journal of Black Studies. 1991;21(3):279–86.
Shane, S.A. A general theory of entrepreneurship: the individual-opportunity nexus Edward Elgar publishing; 2003.
Silva O. The Jack-of-all-trades entrepreneur: innate talent or acquired skill? Econ Lett. 2007;97(2):118–23.
Simoes, N., Crespo, N., Moreira, S.B. Individual determinants of self-employment entry: What do we really know? Journal of economic surveys. 2015.
Smith CW. Younger blacks are less likely to suggest that discrimination explains racial disparities, tending to ascribe them to blacks’ lack of will to “pull up their bootstraps”. LSE American Politics and Policy. 2014;
Stam W, Arzlanian S, Elfring T. Social capital of entrepreneurs and small firm performance: a meta-analysis of contextual and methodological moderators. J Bus Ventur. 2014;29(1):152–73.
Terkildsen N. When white voters evaluate black candidates: the processing implications of candidate skin color, prejudice, and self-monitoring. Am J Polit Sci. 1993:1032–53.
Uzogara EE, Lee H, Abdou CM, Jackson JS. A comparison of skin tone discrimination among African American men: 1995 and 2003. Psychol Men Masculinity. 2014;15(2):201.
Van der Sluis J, Van Praag M, Vijverberg W. Entrepreneurship selection and performance: a meta-analysis of the impact of education in developing economies. World Bank Econ Rev. 2005;19(2):225–61.
Wagner J. Testing Lazear's jack-of-all-trades view of entrepreneurship with German micro data. Appl Econ Lett. 2003;10(11):687–9.
Waters L, McCabe M, Kiellerup D, Kiellerup S. The role of formal mentoring on business success and self-esteem in participants of a new business start-up program. J Bus Psychol. 2002;17(1):107–21.
Wheeler CH. Cities and the growth of wages among young workers: evidence from the NLSY. J Urban Econ. 2006;60(2):162–84.
Wooldridge, J.M., 2010. Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data [chapter 8]. MIT press, pp 723–776.
Zissimopoulos JM, Karoly LA. Transitions to self-employment at older ages: the role of wealth, health, health insurance and other factors. Labour Econ. 2007;14(2):269–95.
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge excellent suggestions and helpful comments from the anonymous reviewer.
This research was conducted with restricted access to Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data. The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of the BLS.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Pankaj Patel designed the research, study hypothesis and wrote the paper. Srikant Devaraj performed the empirical analysis and interpreted the results.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest and no funding was received.
Disclaimer
This research was conducted with restricted access to geo-coded data from Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of the BLS.
About this article
Cite this article
Devaraj, S., Patel, P.C. Skin Tone and Self-Employment: is there an Intra-Group Variation among Blacks?. Rev Black Polit Econ 44, 137–166 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12114-017-9249-x
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12114-017-9249-x