Abstract
Key legislations in many countries emphasize the importance of involving children in decisions regarding their own health at a level commensurate with their age and capacities. Research is engaged in developing tools to assess capacity in children in order to facilitate their responsible involvement. These instruments, however, are usually based on the cognitive criteria for capacity assessment as defined by Appelbaum and Grisso and thus ill adapted to address the life-situation of children. The aim of this paper is to revisit and critically reflect upon the current definitions of decision-making capacity. For this purpose, we propose to see capacity through the lens of essential contestability as it warns us against any reification of what it means to have capacity. Currently, capacity is often perceived of as a mental or cognitive ability which somehow resides within the person, obscuring the fact that capacity is not just an objective property which can be assessed, but always operates within a dominant cultural framework that “creates” that same capacity and defines the threshold between capable and incapable in a specific situation. Defining capacity as an essentially contested concept means using it in a questioning mode and giving space to alternative interpretations that might inform and advance the debate surrounding decision-making.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Appelbaum, P.S. 1988. Assessing Patients’ capacities to consent to treatment. New England Journal of Medicine 319 (25): 1635–1638.
Appelbaum, P.S. 2007. Assessment of patients’ competence to con-sent to treatment. New England Journal of Medicine 357: 1834–1840.
Baines, P. 2011. Assent for children’s participation in research is incoherent and wrong. Archives of Disease in Childhood 96 (10): 960–962.
Banner, N.F. 2013. Can procedural and substantive elements of decision-making be reconciled in assessments of mental capacity. International Journal of Law in Context 9 (1): 71–86.
Berghmans, R., D., Dickenson, and R., Ter Meulen. 2004. Mental capacity: In search of alternative perspectives. Health Care Analysis 12 (4): 251–263.
Bielby, P. 2005. The conflation of competence and capacity in English medical law: A philosophical critique. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 8 (3): 357–369.
Breden, T.M., and J., Vollmann.. 2004. The cognitive based approach of capacity assessment in psychiatry. A philosophical critique of the MacCAT-T. Health Care Analysis 12 (4): 273–283.
Bridgeman, J. 2007. Parental responsibility, young children and healthcare Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Buchanan, A. E., and D.W., Brock. 1989. Deciding for others: The ethics of surrogate decision making. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Charland, L.C. 1998. Is Mr Spock mentally competent? Competence to consent and emotion. Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology 5 (1): 67–81.
Charland, L.C. 2015. Decision-making capacity. The stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Fall 2015 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.). http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2015/entries/decision-capacity/>.
Clarke, B. 1979. Eccentrically contested concepts. British Journal of Political Science 9: 122–126.
Collier, D., F.D., Hidalgo, and A.O., Maciuceanu. 2006. Essentially contested concepts: Debates and applications. Journal of Political Ideologies 11 (3): 211–246.
Coyne, I. 2008. Children’s participation in consultations and decision-making at health service level: A review of the literature. International Journal of Nursing Studies 45 (11): 1682–1689.
David-Hillel, R., and W.B., Gallie. 2010. Essentially Contested Concepts. Philosophical Papers 39 (2): 257–270.
De Clercq, E., D.O, Badarau, K.M., Ruhe, and T., Wangmo. 2015. Body matters: Rethinking the ethical acceptability of non-beneficial clinical research with children. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 18 (3):421–431.
de Vries, M. C., J.W., Wit, D.P., Engberts, G.J., Kaspers, and E. van Leeuwen, 2010. Norms versus practice: Pediatric oncologists’ attitudes towards involving adolescents in decision-making concerning research participation. Pediatric Blood and Cancer 55 (1): 123–128.
de Vries, M. C., M., Houtlosser, J.W., Wit, D.P., Engberts, D., Bresters, G.J., Kaspers, and E., van Leeuwen. 2011. Ethical issues at the interface of clinical care and research practice in pediatric oncology: A narrative review of parents’ and physicians’ experiences. BMC Medical Ethics. doi:10.1186/1472-6939-12-18.
Dekkers, W.J.M. 2001. Autonomy and dependence: Chronic physical illness and decision-making capacity. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 4 (2): 185–192.
Donnelly, M. 2010. Healthcare decision-making and the law. Autonomy, capacity and the limits of liberalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dunn, L., M., Nowrangi, B., Palmer, D., Jeste, and E. Saks. 2006. Assessing decisional capacity for clinical research or treatment: A review of instruments. American Journal of Psychiatry 163: 1323–1334.
Dworkin, R. 1972. The Jurisprudence of Richard Nixon. The New York Review of Books 18 (8): 27–35.
Ehrenberg, K.M. 2011. Law is not (best considered) an essentially contested concept. Journal of Law in Context 7 (2): 209–232.
Gabe, J., G., Olumide, and M. Bury. 2004. 'It takes three to tango': A framework for understanding patient partnership in paediatric clinics. Social Science & Medicine 59: 1071.
Gallie, W.B. 1956. Essentially contested concepts. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, New Series 56: 167–198.
Gallie, W.B. (1964) Philosophy and the Historical Understanding. London: Chatto and Windus.
Ganzini, L., L., Volicer, W.A., Nelson, E., Fox, and A.R. Derse, 2004. Ten myths about decision-making capacity. Journal of the American Medical Directors Association 5 (4): 263–267.
Harrison, C., N.P., Kenny, M., Sidarous, and M., Rowell, 1997. Bioethics for clinicians: 9. Involving children in medical decisions. Canadian Medical Association Journal 156 (6): 825–828.
Hein, I., P., Troost, R., Lindeboom, M., de Vries, C., Zwaan, and R., Lindauer, 2012. Assessing children’s competence to consent in research by a standardized tool: A validity study. BMC Pediatrics 12: 156–163.
Hein, I., P., Troost, R., Lindeboom, M.A., Benninga, C.M., Zwaan, J.B., Van Goudoever, and R.J. Lindauer, 2014. Accuracy of the macarthur competence assessment tool for clinical research (MacCAT-CR) for measuring children’s competence to consent to clinical research. JAMA Pediatr 168 (12): 1147–1153.
Hein, I. M., P.W., Troost, A., Broersma, M.C., de Vries, J.G., Daams, and R.J., Lindauer, 2015a. Why is it hard to make progress in assessing children’s decision-making competence? BMC Medical Ethics. doi:10.1186/1472-6939-16-1.
Hein, I.M., P.W., Troost, R., Lindeboom, M.A., Benninga, C.M., Zwaan, J.B., Van Goudoever, and R.J. Lindauer, 2015b. Key factors in children’s competence to consent to clinical research. BMC Medical Ethics. doi:10.1186/s12910-015-0066-0.
Hein, I. M., M.C., de Vries, P.W., Troost, G., Meynen, J.B., Van Goudoever, and R.J., Lindauer. 2015c. Informed consent instead of assent is appropriate in children from the age of twelve: Policy implications of new findings on children’s competence to consent to clinical research. BMC Medical Ethics. doi:10.1186/s12910-015-0067-2.
Hermann, H., 2016. Emotion and value in the evaluation of medical decision-making capacity: A narrative review of arguments. Frontiers in Psychology 7: 765.
Jennings, B. 2016. Reconceptualizing autonomy: A relational turn. Hastings Center Report 46 (3):11–16.
Kilkelly, U., and M., Donnelly. 2006. The child’s right to be heard in the health care setting. Perspectives of children, parents and health professionals. Office of the Minister for Children. http://www.dcya.gov.ie/documents/research/The_Childs_Right_to_be_Heard_in_the_Healthcare_Setting.pdf. Assessed 17 May 2016.
Kodish, E. 2003. Informed consent for pediatric research: Is it really possible? The Journal of Pediatrics 42 (2): 89–90.
Lalumera, E. 2014. On the explanatory value of the concept-conception distinction. Rivista Italiana di Filosofia del Linguaggio 8 (3): 73–81.
Lansdown, G. 2005. The evolving capacities of the child. Sienna: UNICEF.
Mackenzie, C. 2010. Conceptions of the body and conceptions of autonomy in Bioethics. In Feminist Bioethics: At the Center, On the Margins, eds. J. L. Scully, L. Baldwin-Ragaven, and P. Fitzpatrick, 71–90. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Mackenzie, C., and N., Stoljar. 2000. Relational autonomy. Feminist perspectives on autonomy, agency and the social self. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Mahr, G. 2015. Narrative Medicine and decision-making capacity. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 21: 503–507.
Matthews, G., and A., Mullin 2015. The Philosophy of Childhood. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Accessed 12 July 2016. Retrieved from: http://www.plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2015/entries/childhood/.
Miller, J. 2003. Never Too Young: How young children can take responsibility and make decisions. London: Save the Children Fund.
Moore, L., and S., Kirk. 2010. A Literature review of children’s and young people’s participation in decisions relating to health care. Journal of Clinical Nursing 19: 2215–2225.
Munro, N. 2013. The social construction of decision-making capacity. Mental Health and Mental Capacity Law. https://mentalhealthandcapacitylaw.wordpress.com/author/llzpm/.
Mutcherson, K.M. 2005. whose body is it anyway—an updated model of healthcare decision-making rights for adolescents. Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy 14 (2): 251–325.
Peleg, N. 2013. Reconceptualising the child’s right to development: children and the capability approach. s Rights 21: 523–542.
Pinxten, W., H., Nys, and K., Dierickx. 2008. Regulating trust in pediatric clinical trials. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 11 (4): 439–444.
Rawls, J. 1971. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Rodriguez, P.A. 2015. Human dignity as an essentially contested concept. Cambridge Review of International Affairs 28 (4): 743–756.
Ross, L.F. 2004. Children in medical research: Balancing protection and access: Has the pendulum swung too far? Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 47 (4): 519–536.
Ross, L.F. 2016. Theory and practice of pediatric bioethics. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 58 (3): 267–280.
Roth, L., A., Meisel, and C., Lidz, 1977. Tests of competency to consent to treatment. American Journal of Psychiatry 134: 279–284.
Ruben, D.H., and W.B., Gallie. 2010. Essentially contested concepts. Philosophical Papers 39 (2): 257–270. and .
Ruhe, K., T., Wangmo, D.O., Badarau, B.E., Elger, and F., Niggli. 2015. Decision-making capacity of children and adolescents—suggestions for advancing the concept’s implementation in pediatric healthcare. European Journal of Pediatrics 174: 775–782.
Ruhe, K., E., De Clercq, T., Wangmo, and B.S. Elger. 2016. Relational capacity: Broadening the notion of decision-making capacity in paediatric healthcare. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry. doi:10.1007/s11673-016-9735-z.
Runeson, I., I., Hallström, G., Elander, and G. Hermerén. 2002. Children’s participation in the decision-making process during hospitalization: An observational study. Nursing Ethics 9 (6): 583–598.
Secker, B. 1990. Labelling patient (in)competence: A feminist analysis of medico-legal discourse. Journal of Social Philosophy 30 (2): 295–314.
Shirkey, H. 1968. Therapeutic orphans. Journal of Pediatrics 72 (1): 119–120.
Sibley, A., A.J., Pollard, R., Fitzpatrick, and M., Sheehan. 2016. Developing a new justification for assent. BMC Medical Ethics. doi:10.1186/s12910-015-0085-x.
Sjöstrand, M., K., Petter, L., Sandman, G., Helgesson, S., Eriksson, and N., Juth. 2015. Conceptions of decision-making capacity in psychiatry: interviews with Swedish psychiatrists. BMC Medical Ethics: 16–34.
van der Burg, W. 2016. Law as a second-order essentially contested concept. Erasmus Working Paper Series on Jurisprudence and Socio-Legal Studies 16. SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2783292.
Waldron, J. 2002. Is the rule of law an essentially contested concept (in Florida)? Law and Philosophy 21 (2): 137–164.
Waligora, M., J., Rózyńska, and J., Piasecki. 2016. Child’s objection to non-beneficial research: capacity and distress based models. Medicine Health Care and Philosophy 19: 65–70.
Wangmo, T., E., De Clercq, K., Ruhe, M., Beck-Popovic, J., Rischewski, R., Angst, M., Ansari and B.S., Elger. (2016). Better to know than to imagine: Including children in their health care. The American Journal of Bioethics. doi:10.1080/23294515.2016.1207724.
Weithorn, L.A., and S.B., Campbell. 1982. The competency of children and adolescents to make informed treatment decisions. Early Adolescence 53 (6): 1589–1598.
Funding
The authors acknowledge the financial support provided by the Käthe-Zingg-Schwichtenberg-Fonds (Schweizerische Akademie der Medizinischen Wissenschaften—SAMW) and by the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNF NRP-67 Grant Number 406740 139283/1).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
De Clercq, E., Ruhe, K., Rost, M. et al. Is decision-making capacity an “essentially contested” concept in pediatrics?. Med Health Care and Philos 20, 425–433 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-017-9768-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-017-9768-z