Abstract
The demand for adaptable structures is steadily increasing in contemporary architectural practice. Deployable structures, characterized by their flexibility and versatility, offer innovative solutions across demanding engineering and architectural contexts. Among the various types of deployable structures, two main categories emerge: lattice deployable structures and continuous surface deployable structures. This paper explores the creation of hybrid deployable vaulted structures by incorporating kinetic elements from both deployable structure categories. A combination of rigid thick origami surfaces and retractable structural frames composed of four-bar and scissor-hinged linkages is examined, while both direct and inverse design methodologies are explored. To facilitate the parameterization and kinematic study of the proposed structures, an algorithm is developed within the Rhino Grasshopper visual programming environment, which is then utilized for form-finding and design optimization of the generated deployable vaults. The present study aims to contribute to the evolution of lightweight, kinetic elements for versatile architectural applications. The proposed hybrid deployable structures are designed to adjust to evolving spatial and functional requirements while maintaining structural integrity.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
Contemporary architecture frequently addresses the demand for dynamic structures capable of spatial transformation to accommodate ephemeral or changing needs. The rapidly emerging field of deployable structures provides solutions for adaptive and sustainable architectural applications. Deployable structures are defined as structures capable of large morphological changes in an autonomous way, due to their geometric, material, and mechanical properties [1,2,3]. They embody characteristics such as flexibility, transportability, and reconfigurability, offering innovative solutions across various scenarios requiring spatial adaptation to climatic conditions, natural disasters, or changes in use.
Upon reviewing the various existing classifications of deployable structure types in literature [4], it becomes evident that two general categories emerge: strut structures and surface structures, as proposed by Merchan [5]; or lattice structures and continuous structures, as identified by Hanaor and Levy [6]. The category of lattice deployable structures includes scissor-hinged, reciprocal, four-bar linkages, and tensegrity structures, among others. Conversely, the classification of continuous surface deployable structures comprises rigid origami, pneumatic structures, tensioned membranes, and similar thin-shell elements.
In the application of lattice deployable structures for architectural solutions there is typically a need to cover the space they enclose, often addressed by integrating external surface elements when fully deployed. On the other hand, continuous surface deployable structures are generally not characterized by high mechanical strength and usually require attachment to fixed lattice supports in their deployed configurations.
The present study, part of an ongoing research effort by the authors, addresses the kinematic coupling of topologically related kinetic elements from the two aforementioned categories. The main objective is to develop hybrid deployable structures that ensure structural integrity and space enclosure, and also maintain their transformability as kinematically paired mechanisms.
Earlier research conducted by the authors [7,8,9] has explored the coupling of origami folded surfaces, utilized as space-covering elements, with planar scissor linkages serving as structural retractable frames. Figure 1 illustrates the deployment sequences of selected physical models of the previously proposed coupled mechanisms.
This paper builds upon earlier research by the authors, extending it to explore and develop hybrid deployable structures characterized by vaulted geometry. The proposed structures utilize rigid thick origami surfaces in conjunction with a combination of planar scissors and four-bar linkage retractable frames. The aim is to provide novel solutions for adaptable and sustainable architectural applications, contributing to the advancement in the field of deployable structures.
2 Methodology
The methodological approach utilized for developing the hybrid deployable vaulted structures proposed in this paper involves a series of sequential steps. Firstly, the origami Crease Pattern (CP) is selected from existing ones, by considering the desired vaulted deployed configuration of the covering surfaces. Subsequently, the unit geometry and kinematic equations of the selected CP are parameterized within the Grasshopper visual programming environment. To enhance the rigidity and functionality of the origami plates, the tapered panels' thickness accommodating technique, as outlined in prior research [10], is employed and embedded in the algorithm. The following step involves the development of a retractable linkage frame mechanism that mirrors the geometry and motion path of the origami surface in space. Establishing precise relations between the dependent variables of the rigid origami surfaces and the corresponding linkages is crucial in this phase for achieving seamless integration between the two components. The developed Grasshopper algorithm is then utilized to generate several morphological variations of the proposed hybrid deployable vault structure, by iteratively adjusting selected parameters. Throughout this form-finding process, derivative variations of the CP are explored, leveraging the origami inverse design method to optimize the developed vaulted structures in terms of compactness, optimal deployed form, and stability criteria. An integral part of this process is the construction of small-scale physical models, which are subject to kinematic and loading tests, providing valuable insights into the practical feasibility and performance of the proposed hybrid deployable vaulted structures.
3 Thick origami surface development
Folding gives structure to matter [11]. A thin sheet of paper acquires mechanical strength and load-carrying capacity when properly folded, as illustrated in Fig. 2. Origami, the ancient Japanese art of paper folding, can be described as the sequential creasing of paper into various geometric forms without stretching or cutting. Folding techniques inspired by origami can be applied to sheets of other materials with similar properties to paper, notably significantly high in-plane stiffness compared to out-of-plane stiffness. The rapidly developing field of structural origami investigates the correlation between forms emerging from sheet folding and their structural performance [12]. Numerous pioneers have made substantial contributions to the field of structural origami, including mathematicians [13], computer scientists [14], physicists [15], astrophysicists [16], architects and engineers [17, 18], as well as origami artists and designers [19, 20].
A thin sheet of paper (a) acquires mechanical strength and load-carrying capacity when properly folded (b) [21]
Two distinct approaches are commonly employed in designing origami structures: the direct design method, which involves applying existing CPs to address particular design challenges, and the inverse design method, which involves modifying existing CPs or creating new ones to solve more demanding design problems [22]. Through the utilization of origami design methodologies and thickness accommodating techniques [10], rigid and thick origami structures can be manufactured for architectural applications requiring adaptability to changing needs in space configuration [23, 24]. Rigid origami structures are characterized as scalable mechanisms composed of stiff plates and hinges, capable of deploying and retracting with a unified and synchronous movement of all creases [17].
3.1 Crease pattern
The rigid-foldable Miura-ori and its derivative CPs are commonly employed in structural origami applications owing to their unique property of representing an overconstrained case of a general 4-degree vertex with only one degree of freedom (DOF) [25]. Moreover, they possess useful characteristics such as flat-foldability, where panels are co-planar when fully folded, and developability, which allows them to be folded from a continuous flat sheet of material [26]. For the direct origami design phase of this research, the Arc Pattern CP is selected, which is a Miura-ori first-level derivative CP, as outlined in reference [25]. This pattern is chosen for its ability to achieve single-curvature geometries, particularly vaulted surfaces.
The basic unit of the Arc Pattern CP, depicted in Fig. 3a, consists of four identical trapezoidal plates and can be geometrically defined by three parameters: side lengths a1 and b, and sector angle φ. Two more dependent parameters, side length a2, and panel width w, are derived to describe the CP base unit geometry. Their values are determined by Eqs. (1) and (2), with the constraint that a1 < a2.
Unit geometry of the Arc Pattern CP [25]
Four additional parameters, namely the dihedral angles ηA and ηZ, as well as the edge angles θA and θZ, are essential in determining any specific folded configuration of a rigid unit, as illustrated in Fig. 3b. The values of these parameters vary according to the folding state of the CP unit and can be algebraically calculated using Eqs. (3)–(5), provided any one of the four parameters is treated as an input variable for the folding motion. Furthermore, the varying folded width parameter \(\overline{w}\), obtained from Eq. (6), is also significant in this context.
As shown in Fig. 3c, the vertices of a partially folded Arc Pattern CP unit lie along an arc profile characterized by a radius R, which can be determined using Eqs. (7) - (9). Here, ξ1 and ξ2 denote the central angles formed by creases a1 and a2 of the CP unit, respectively.
In a rigid Arc Pattern tessellation with m straight and n zigzag CP lines (rows and columns), the precise position of all vertices can be determined using a 3D cylindrical coordinate system. This coordinate system, depicted with its specified orientation and origin in Fig. 3c, serves as the essential framework for accurately specifying the location of each vertex in any folded configuration of the CP. By employing kinematic Eqs. (10) and (11), every Vi,j vertex of an Arc Pattern tessellation can be defined.
To summarize, an Arc Pattern tessellation can be geometrically and kinematically defined using fifteen parameters. Seven of these parameters (a1, a2, b, φ, w, m, n) maintain constant values regardless of the folded state of the CP. Conversely, the remaining eight parameters (θA, θZ, ηA, ηZ,\(\overline{w}\), ξ1, ξ2, R) vary for each distinct folded configuration of the same CP. The spatial deployment of a rigid CP is depicted in Fig. 4 for an Arc Pattern tessellation with parameters a1 = 1.4, b = 3.2, φ = 30°, m = 13, n = 6, and a sequence of variable edge angles θA = 180°, 125°, 75°, 20° as input.
3.2 Thickness accommodation
The selected technique for accommodating the thickness of the origami surfaces in this study is the layered tapered panels’ technique [10]. This method is chosen primarily because it maintains the kinematics of an ideal zero-thickness model while also being easily fabricated using laser cutting or 2-axis CNC routing methods.
In order to achieve the desired total thickness, an equal amount of thickness is added to each side of the ideal origami surface, as illustrated in Fig. 5a. To avoid self-intersection, the necessary taper length T for each panel in the CP is calculated using Eq. (12), where t represents the half thickness of the panel, and η the dihedral angle (ηA/ηZ) of the embedded zero-thickness surface at the maximum retracted folded state. It’s important to note that to maintain a non-zero panel thickness, the maximum fold angle of the thick origami mesh cannot reach 180°. Employing the described technique, thickness is applied to both sides of the Arc Pattern tessellation, as depicted in a darker tone in Fig. 5b, for both the convex and concave sides of the origami surface.
Layered tapered panels’ thickness accommodating technique: a taper detail, b thickness addition to the convex and concave sides of the CP [9]
4 Linkage retractable frame development
We observe that by constraining the boundary edges of folded surfaces, their stability and load-carrying ability can be enhanced [21], as illustrated in Fig. 6. This can be achieved by integrating a complementary mechanism whose motion aligns with the deployment path in space of the origami surface edges. An essential criterion for this mechanism is its capability to be constrained or locked into selected configurations.
The stability and load-carrying ability of folded surfaces can be enhanced by constraining their boundary edges [21]
Previous studies by the authors [7, 8] have investigated planar scissor-hinged linkages as a suitable mechanism for this purpose. However, due to the variable curvature of this specific CP during deployment, a different linkage type is needed to address the curvilinear boundary edges of the Arc pattern. Therefore, a modified linkage is proposed for the retractable frame mechanism of the developed origami vaults, as shown in Fig. 7. This frame consists of two pairs of distinct linkages: one scissor-hinged rectilinear linkage (lengthwise), and one four-bar curvilinear linkage (widthwise). The geometric construction and parameterization, tailored to the Arc Pattern CP, of these two types of linkages constituting the developed retractable frame mechanism are elaborated upon in the subsequent sections.
4.1 Scissor-hinged linkages
For the lengthwise rectilinear boundary edges pair of the Arc Pattern CP, a translational scissors linkage of two distinct bar lengths is utilized, as depicted in Fig. 8b, showcasing three deployment configurations. The longer bar length of the scissors linkage corresponds to side length b of the Arc Pattern CP and is aligned with the lengthwise opposite boundary edges of the CP. Conversely, deliberately shorter lengths are chosen for half of the scissor bars of this linkage to hinder the unfolding of the origami surface, thereby limiting its mobility. This shorter length is set equal to half the folded width \(\overline{w}\) parameter in the desired fully deployed configuration of the Arc Pattern CP, as depicted in Fig. 7. This design decision guarantees that the hybrid mechanism achieves and maintains the intended space-covering configuration upon deployment.
4.2 Four-bar linkages
To address the widthwise curvilinear boundary edges pair of the Arc Pattern CP, a customized four-bar linkage with specific sliding joints is implemented, as depicted in Fig. 7 in red and Fig. 8a in three deployment configurations. This linkage is specifically designed to align with the geometry and folding motion of the Arc Pattern CP, comprising bars with lengths equivalent to the CP side lengths a1 and a2. The pivots situated at the intersecting points of the linkages feature sliding capability to adapt to the variable curvature of the widthwise opposing edges of the CP, while also preventing the origami surface from further unfolding at the desired deployed configuration.
5 Form-finding
In order to facilitate the kinematic study, form-finding and design optimization of the proposed hybrid deployable vaulted structures, an algorithm was developed within the Rhino Grasshopper visual programming environment. The developed parametric model utilizes the equations and methods described in Sects. 3 and 4 of this paper for the generation of the CP tessellation, thickness accommodation, and the creation of the complementary linkage frame mechanism. The algorithm performs necessary computations based on the provided input and offers a visual representation of the hybrid vault model and its deployment in space. Parameterization of the geometry and motion of the elements of the proposed vaulted structure enables the creation of diverse morphological variations, each possessing unique characteristics, through the manipulation of input parameters. Analyzing the resultant morphologies enables the assessment of crucial aspects such as compactness, structural integrity, performance, as well as form and aesthetic qualities.
The primary parameters influencing the geometry of the proposed vault structure include the initial input values of the Arc Pattern a1, b, φ, m, and n. These parameters not only define the vault's overall shape but also influence the ratio between its retracted and deployed states. This ratio denotes the proportional relationship between its dimensions when it is in a compact state compared to when it is fully expanded. For example, the hybrid vault variation shown in Fig. 8 is generated with a1 = 2, b = 2, φ = 45°, m = 9, and n = 4, resulting in a compact design with minimum moving parts. In contrast, the vault variation shown in Fig. 9, with a1 = 1.5, b = 1, φ = 35°, m = 41, and n = 6, exhibits a larger span and greater curvature changes upon deployment. The same set of parameters defines the kinetic physical model depicted in Fig. 10, with the only difference being m = 21 in this case.
Small-scale kinetic physical model of a hybrid vault variation in retracted (left) and deployed (right) configurations [9]
During experimentation with different input parameter values, we encountered self-intersection occurrences between the opposing rectilinear edges of the origami surface under certain conditions. The probability of self-intersection instances rises with an increase in the number of n counts or the value of the φ angle. Through a process of trial and error, we observed that improved variations of the developed hybrid vaults could be achieved by modifying some aspects of the original origami CP. Utilizing the origami inverse design methodology, we redesigned the CP to enable retraction into a more compact configuration while avoiding self-intersection. Another objective of this form-finding process was to ensure that the "wall" surfaces of the vault when fully deployed, meet the ground at a 90° angle to enhance its stability. The proposed modification of the CP, depicted in Fig. 11, includes six distinct widthwise side lengths a instead of two, and two different lengthwise side lengths b instead of one. The kinematic simulation of the new CP was conducted using the rigid-folding motion solver provided by the Crane plugin for Grasshopper [27]. Subsequently, thickness was added to the origami plates following the method outlined in Sect. 3.2.
The design of the linkage frame for the new CP follows a similar approach to the previous case, with the only difference being that the lengthwise scissor-hinged linkages comprise equal-length bars in this instance, forming a truss base when fully deployed. The hybrid deployable vault depicted in Fig. 12 is generated through the inverse design methodology described above and can retract into a packed configuration while avoiding self-intersection. Its deployed configuration offers enhanced structural integrity, since the origami plates meet the ground vertically and the pair of scissor-hinged linkages act as truss bases.
Through iterative refinement of the design via this process, it becomes feasible to generate origami CP variations that best suit the requirements of specific architectural applications. This method of form-finding and optimization streamlines the decision-making process, enabling the development of structures that effectively meet the criteria of each unique usage scenario.
6 Conclusion and future research
The research presented in this paper investigates the development of hybrid vaulted structures that integrate topologically related kinetic elements from lattice and continuous surface deployable structures. The developed hybrid deployable vault variations are comprised of thick origami surfaces and retractable structural frames consisting of four-bar and scissor-hinged linkages.
The methods employed for developing the proposed hybrid deployable vaults presented in this study include both the direct design process, wherein an existing CP is employed and the inverse design process, wherein the CP is redesigned to fulfill specific requirements. In both cases, thickness is incorporated into the surfaces using one of the existing thickness accommodating techniques. The kinematically paired linkage retractable frames are specifically designed to align with the geometric and kinematic characteristics of the origami surfaces.
Future research will focus on developing a unified and generalized algorithm for inverse origami design and form-finding, capable of accommodating various and complex target geometries of such hybrid deployable structures. Additionally, further research and experimentation can build upon the findings of this work by focusing on joint design and materials selection, which are pivotal for ensuring structural integrity, ease of construction, and functionality of the kinematically coupled mechanisms. Furthermore, the utilization of finite element analysis can assess stress distribution and deformation across varying loading scenarios, offering valuable insights into structural performance and potential design optimizations.
The hybrid deployable structures described in this paper could find application in challenging architectural scenarios where flexibility, lightweight design, transportability, mechanical strength, and sustainability are essential considerations.
Availability of data and materials
Not applicable.
References
Pellegrino S (2001) Deployable structures in engineering. Deploy Struct. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-7091-2584-7_1
Rivas-Adrover E (2015) Deployable structures. Laurence King Publishing Ltd
Gantes CJ, Connor JJ, Logcher RD, Rosenfeld Y (1989) Structural analysis and design of deployable structures”. Comput Struct. https://doi.org/10.1016/0045-7949(89)90354-4
Fenci GE, Currie NGR (2017) Deployable structures classification: a review. Int J Space Struct 32(2):112–130. https://doi.org/10.1177/0266351117711290
Merchan CHH (1987) Deployable structures. http://Iibraries.mit.edu/docs
Hanaor A, Levy R (2001) Evaluation of deployable structures for space enclosures. Int J Space Struct. https://doi.org/10.1260/026635101760832172
Vlachaki E, Liapi KA (2021) Folded surface elements coupled with planar scissor linkages: a novel hybrid type of deployable structures. Curv Layered Struct 8(1):137–146. https://doi.org/10.1515/cls-2021-0013
Vlachaki E, Liapi K (2021) Hybrid deployable structures of miura-ori folded surfaces & translational scissors expandable frames. In: Inspiring the next generation—proceedings of the international conference on spatial structures 2020/21 (IASS2020/21-Surrey7), surrey: spatial structures research Centre of the University of Surrey, pp 3283–3292. doi: https://doi.org/10.15126/900337.
Vlachaki E, Liapi KA (2024) A hybrid deployable vault structure by coupling origami folded plates with a scissors–four bar linkage frame, pp 662–671. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-44328-2_69.
Lang RJ, Tolman KA, Crampton EB, Magleby SP, Howell LL (2018) A review of thickness-accommodation techniques in origami-inspired engineering. Appl Mech Rev. doi 10(1115/1):4039314
Kula D, et al (2013) Materiology: the creative industry’s guide to materials and technologies
Tachi T (2019) Introduction to structural origami. J Int Assoc Shell Spatial Struct J. IASS. https://doi.org/10.20898/j.iass.2019.199.004.
Hull T (2003) Counting mountain-valley assignments for flat folds. Ars Combin 67:175–187
Demaine ED. Folding and unfolding.
Lang RJ. A computational algorithm for origami design
Miura K (1989) A note on intrisic geometry of origami. Research of pattern formation, pp 91–102. http://www.scipress.org/e-library/rpf/pdf/chap2/0091.PDF
Tachi T (2016) Rigid-foldable thick origami. In: Origami 5: fifth international meeting of origami science, mathematics, and education. https://doi.org/10.1201/b10971-24
Filipov ET, Tachi T, Paulino GH. Toward optimization of stiffness and flexibility of rigid, flat-foldable origami structures
Jackson P (2011) Folding techniques for designers: from sheet to form. Laurence King Pub
Gardiner MR (2018) ORI* On the aesthetics of folding and technology
Buri HU (2010) Origami—folded plate structures. École Polytechnique Federale De Lausanne
Meloni M et al (2021) Engineering origami: a comprehensive review of recent applications, design methods, and tools. Adv Sci. https://doi.org/10.1002/advs.202000636
Macri S (2015) Practical applications of rigid thick origami in kinetic architecture, pp 1–106
Osorio F, Oliveira S (2017) Origami folded surfaces: kinetic system behind the folding. Kine[SIS]tem—from nature to architectural matter conference proceedings, pp 28–35
Gattas JM, Wu W, You Z (2013) Miura-base rigid origami: parameterizations of first-level derivative and piecewise geometries. J Mech Des Trans ASME. https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4025380
Tachi T (2009) Generalization of rigid foldable quadrilateral mesh origami. In: Proceedings of the international association for shell and spatial structures (IASS) symposium 2009. Valencia, pp 2287–2294
Suto K, Noma Y, Tanimichi K, Narumi K, Tachi T (2022) Crane: an integrated computational design platformfor functional, foldable, and fabricable origami products. ACM Trans Comput-Human Interact. https://doi.org/10.1145/3576856
Funding
Open access funding provided by HEAL-Link Greece. No funding received.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
All authors contributed equally to the study.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Ethical Approval
Not applicable.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Supplementary file1 (MP4 14524 KB)
Supplementary file2 (MP4 40509 KB)
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Vlachaki, E., Liapi, K.A. Hybrid origami-linkage vaulted deployable structures: parametric development and form-finding. Meccanica (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11012-024-01802-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11012-024-01802-5