Abstract
One of the major challenges of conducting operations of unmanned aircraft, especially operations beyond visual line-of-sight (BVLOS), is to make a realistic and sufficiently detailed risk assessment. An important part of such an assessment is to identify the risk of fatalities, preferably in a quantitative way since this allows for comparison with manned aviation to determine whether an equivalent level of safety is achievable. This work presents a method for quantifying the probability of fatalities resulting from an uncontrolled descent of an unmanned aircraft conducting a BVLOS flight. The method is based on a standard stochastic model, and employs a parameterized high fidelity ground impact distribution model that accounts for both aircraft specifications, parameter uncertainties, and wind. The method also samples the flight path to create an almost continuous quantification of the risk as a function of mission flight time. The methodology is exemplified with a 180 km flight in Danish airspace with a Penguin C aircraft.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Scale, A.A.A.M.: (AIS) abbreviated injury manual. Technical report, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, 2005 (2005)
Arterburn, D., Ewing, M., Prabhu, R., Zhu, F., Francis, D.: FAA UAS center of excellence task A4: UAS ground collision severity evaluation. Technical report, ASSURE (2017)
Atkins, E.M., Portillo, I.A., Strube, M.J.: Emergency flight planning applied to total loss of thrust. J. Aircr. 43(4), 1205–1216 (2006)
Bertrand, S, Raballand, N, Viguier, F, Muller, F: Ground risk assessment for long-range inspection missions of railways by UAVs. In: proceedings of ICUAS 2017, pp. 1343–1351 (2017)
Bir, C.A., Viano, D.C.: Design and injury assessment criteria for blunt ballistic impacts. J. Trauma Injury, Infection, and Critical Care 57, 1218–1224 (2004)
Clare, V.R., Mickiewicz, A.P., Lewis, J.H., Sturdiven, L.M.: Blunt trauma data correlation technical report report may EB-TR-75016 Edgewood Arsenal (1975)
Clothier, R., Walker, R., Fulton, N., Campbell, D.: A casualty risk analysis for unmanned aerial system (UAS) operations over inhabited areas. In: 2nd Australasian unmanned air vehicle conference, pp. 1–15 (2007)
Clothier, R., Williams, B., Washington, A.: Development of a Template Safety Case for Unmanned Aircraft Operations Over Populous Areas. In: SAE 2015 AeroTech Congress & Exhibition, pp. 10 (2015)
Clothier, R.A., Walker, R.A.: The safety risk management of unmanned aircraft systems. In: Valavanis, K.P., Vachtsevanos, G.J. (eds.) Handbook of unmanned aerial vehicles, p 37. Springer Science + Business Media B.V., Dordrecht (2013)
Clothier, R.A., Williams, B.P., Fulton, N.L.: Structuring the safety case for unmanned aircraft system operations in non-segregated airspace. Saf. Sci. 79, 213–228 (2015)
Coombes, M., Chen, W.-H., Render, P.: Landing site reachability in a forced landing of unmanned aircraft in wind journal of aircraft, pp. 1–13 (2017)
Dalamagkidis, K., Valavanis, K.P., Piegl, L.A.: On unmanned aircraft systems issues, challenges and operational restrictions preventing integration into the national airspace system. Prog. Aerosp. Sci. 44(7-8), 503–519 (2008)
Denney, E., Pai, G.: Architecting a safety case for UAS flight operations. In: 34th international system safety conference, pp. 12 (2016)
Denney, E., Pai, G., Habli, I.: Perspectives on software safety case development for unmanned aircraft Proceedings of the international conference on dependable systems and networks (2012)
Freeman, P., Gary J Balas.: Actuation failure modes effects analysis for a small UAV. In: actuation failure American control conference, pp. 1292–1297. IEEE (2014)
Freeman, P.M.: Reliability assessment for low-cost unmanned aerial vehicles. PhD thesis, University of Minneota (2014)
Guglieri, G., Ristorto, G.: Safety assessment for light remotely piloted aircraft systems. In: 2016 INAIR - international conference on air transport, pp. 1–7 (2016)
King, D.W., Bertapelle, A., Moses, C.: UAV failure rate criteria for equivalent level of safety. In: International helicopter safety symposium, pp. 9, Montreal (2005)
la Cour-Harbo, A.: Ground impact probability distribution for small unmanned aircraft in ballistic descent. Reliability engineering and system safety Submitted (2017)
la Cour-Harbo, A.: Mass threshold for ’harmless’ drones. International Journal of Micro Air Vehicles, pp. 11 (2017)
la Cour-Harbo, A.: Quantifying risk of ground impact fatalities of power line inspection BVLOS flight with small unmanned aircraft. In: 2017 International Conference on Unmanned Aircraft Systems (ICUAS), pp. 1352–1360 (2017)
Lin, X., Fulton, N.L., Horn, M.E.T.: Quantification of high level safety criteria for civil unmanned aircraft systems. In: IEEE aerospace conference proceedings, pp. 13 (2014)
Murtha, J.F.: An evidence theoretic approach to design of reliable low-cost UAVs. PhD thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute (2009)
Office of the Secretary of Defence: Unmanned aerial vehicle reliability study. Technical report february, Department of defense (2003)
Radi, A.: Human injury model for small unmanned aircraft impacts. Technical report, Civil aviation safety authority, Australia (2013)
Reimann, S., Amos, J., Bergquist, E., Cole, J., Phillips, J., Shuster, S.: UAV for reliability technical report december AEM 4331 aerospace vehicle design (2013)
Reimann, S., Amos, J., Bergquist, E., Cole, J., Phillips, J., Shuster, S.: UAV for Reliability Build. University of Minnesota, Technical report (2014)
Larry, M., Viano, S.C., Champion, H.R.: Analysis of injury criteria to assess chest and abdominal injury risks in blunt and ballistic impacts. J. Trauma 56(3), 651–663 (2004)
Twisdale, L.A., Vickery, P.J.: Comparison of debris trajectory models for explosive safety hazard analysis. In: 25th DoD Explosive Safety Seminar Anaheim, California, pp. 513–526 (1992)
Venkataraman, R.: Reliability assessment of actuator architectures for unmanned aircraft. University of Minnesota, PhD thesis (2015)
Venkataraman, R., Lukȧtsi, M., Vanek, B., Seiler, P.: Reliability assessment of actuator architectures for unmanned aircraft. IFAC-PapersOnLine 48(21), 398–403 (2015)
Viano, D.C., Lau, I.A.N.V.: A viscous tolerance criterion for soft tissue injury assessment. J. Biomech. 21(5), 387–399 (1988)
Warren, M., Mejias, L., Kok, J., Yang, X., Gonzalez, F., Upcroft, Ben: An automated emergency landing system for fixed-wing aircraft: Planning and control. J. Field Rob. 32(8), 1114–1140 (2015)
Warren, M., Mejias, L., Yang, X., Arain, B., Gonzalez, F., Ben Upcroft.: Enabling aircraft emergency landings using active visual site detection. In: Field and Service Robotics, pp. 167–181 Springer Tracts in Advanced Robotics, pp. 105 (2015)
Paul, W.U., Clothier, R.: The development of ground impact models for the analysis of the risks associated with unmanned aircraft operations over inhabited areas: Inproceedings of the 11th Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management Conference (PSAM11) and the Annual European Safety and Reliability Conference (ESREL 2012), pp. 14 (2012)
Acknowledgements
This work is supported by the BVLOS FastTrack project between the Danish Transport Construction and Housing Authority, University of Southern Denmark, Aalborg University, UAS Test Center Denmark, and Heliscope. We wish to thank the partners for providing information and data for this work.
A short version of this paper was presented in ICUAS 2017 [21].
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
la Cour-Harbo, A. Quantifying Risk of Ground Impact Fatalities for Small Unmanned Aircraft. J Intell Robot Syst 93, 367–384 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10846-018-0853-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10846-018-0853-1