Abstract
This chapter provides a selective survey of dynamic game models of exploitation of natural resources. It covers both renewable resources and exhaustible resources. In relation to earlier surveys (Long, A survey of dynamic games in economics, World Scientific, Singapore, 2010; Long, Dyn Games Appl 1(1):115–148, 2011), the present work includes many references to new developments that appeared after January 2011 and additional suggestions for future research. Moreover, there is a greater emphasis on intuitive explanation.
Notes
- 1.
For a review of the game theoretic approach to water resources, see Dinar and Hogarth (2015). For some recent models of differential games involving water transfer between two countries, see Cabo et al. (2014) and in particular Cabo and Tidball (2016) where countries cooperate in the infrastructure investment stage but play a noncooperative game of water transfer in a second stage. Cabo and Tidball (2016) design a time-consistent imputation distribution procedure to ensure cooperation, along the lines of Jørgensen and Zaccour (2001).
- 2.
Dictionnaire LE ROBERT, Société du Nouveau Littré, Paris: 1979.
- 3.
However, as pointed out by Ostrom (1990), in some societies, thanks to good institutions, the commons are efficiently managed.
- 4.
See Fudenberg and Tirole (1991) on the comparison of the concepts of open-loop equilibrium and feedback or Markov-perfect equilibrium.
- 5.
It has been estimated that about 80 % of fish stocks are exploited at or beyond their maximum sustainable yields. See FAO (2009).
- 6.
We assume that the upper bound constraint on effort is not binding at the steady state.
- 7.
If the amount harvested depends only on the effort level and not on the level of the stock, i.e., h i = γ L i , then in an open-loop equilibrium, there is no dynamic overcrowding production externality. In that case, it is possible that open-loop exploitation is Pareto efficient; see Chiarella et al. (1984).
- 8.
- 9.
For ownership risks, see Bohn and Deacon (2000).
- 10.
In contrast, in the standard models, where all utility functions are concave, it can be shown that the equilibrium trajectory of the state variable must eventually become monotone. See Dutta and Sundaram (1993b).
- 11.
Sundaram and Dutta (1993b) extend this “no tragedy” result to the case with mild discounting: as long as the discount rate is low enough, if players use discontinuous strategies that threaten to make a drastic increase in consumption when the stock falls below a certain level, they may be able to lock each other into a stock level that is dynamically inefficient and greater than the cooperative steady state.
- 12.
Except possibly the cooperative steady state (Dutta and Sundaram 1993b, Theorem 3).
- 13.
Dockner and Sorger (1996), Lemma 1.
- 14.
Dockner and Long (1993) find similar results in a pollution game.
- 15.
- 16.
- 17.
See Salo and Tahvonen (2001) for the modeling of economic exhaustion in a duopoly.
- 18.
See Gaudet (2007) for the theory and empirics related to the Hotelling Rule.
- 19.
- 20.
See also Lewis and Schmalensee (1980).
- 21.
This corresponds to the result that, in a closed economy, the market power of an oil monopolist with zero extraction cost disappears when the elasticity of demand is constant. See, e.g., Stiglitz (1976).
- 22.
This is confirmed in Brander and Djajic (1983), who consider a two-country world in which both countries use oil to produce a consumption good, but only one of them is endowed with oil.
- 23.
- 24.
- 25.
In a stagewise Stackelberg equilibrium, no commitment of any significant length is possible. The leader can only commit to the current period decision.
- 26.
- 27.
Dasgupta and Heal (1979, Ch. 12) consider the open-loop Nash equilibrium of a similar seepage problem, with just two firms, and reach similar results.
- 28.
Sinn (1984) considers a different concept of equilibrium in the seepage model: each firm is committed to achieve a given time path of its stock.
- 29.
Bolle (1980) obtains a similar result, assuming that there is only one common stock that all m firms have equal access.
- 30.
- 31.
This is related to the so-called SLOSS debate in ecology, in which authors disagree as to whether a single large or several small (SLOSS) reserves would be better for conservation.
- 32.
Myerson and Weibull (2015) formalize the idea that “social conventions usually develop so that people tend to disregard alternatives outside the convention.”
- 33.
References
Alvarez-Cuadrado F, Long NV (2011) Relative consumption and renewable resource extraction under alternative property rights regimes. Resour Energy Econ 33(4):1028–1053
Amir R (1987) Games of resource extraction: existence of Nash equilibrium. Cowles Foundation Discussion Paper No. 825
Amir R (1989) A Lattice-theoretic approach to a class of dynamic games. Comput Math Appl 17:1345–1349
Bala V, Long NV (2005) International trade and cultural diversity with preference selection. Eur J Polit Econ 21(1):143–162
Basar T, Olsder GJ (1982) Dynamic non-cooperative game theory. Academic, London
Behringer S, Upmann T (2014) Optimal harvesting of a spatial renewable resource. J Econ Dyn Control 42:105–120
Benchekroun H (2008) Comparative dynamics in a productive asset oligopoly. J Econ Theory 138:237–261
Benchekroun H, Halsema A, Withagen C (2009) On non-renewable resource oligopolies: the asymmetric case. J Econ Dyn Control 33(11):1867–1879
Benchekroun H, Halsema A, Withagen C (2010) When additional resource stocks reduce welfare. J Environ Econ Manag 59(1):109–114
Benchekroun H, Gaudet G, Lohoues H (2014) Some effects of asymmetries in a common pool natural resource oligopoly. Strateg Behav Environ 3:213–235
Benchekroun H, Gaudet G (2015) On the effects of mergers on equilibrium outcomes in a common property renewable asset oligopoly. J Econ Dyn Control 52:209–223
Benchekroun H, Long NV (2006) The curse of windfall gains in a non-renewable resource oligopoly. Aust Econ Pap 45(2):99–105
Benchekroun H, Long NV (2016) Status concern and the exploitation of common pool renewable resources. Ecol Econ 125(C):70–82
Benchekroun H, Withagen C (2012) On price-taking behavior in a non-renewable resource Cartel-Fringe game. Games Econ Bahav 76(2):355–374
Benhabib J, Radner R (1992) The joint exploitation of a productive asset: a game-theoretic approach. Econ Theory 2:155–190
Bergstrom T (1982) On capturing oil rents with a national excise tax. Am Econ Rev 72(1):194–201
Bohn H, Deacon RT (2000) Ownership risk, investment, and the use of natural resources. Am Econ Rev 90(3):526–549
Bolle F (1980) The efficient use of a non-renewable common-pool resource is possible but unlikely. Zeitschrift für Nationalökonomie 40:391–397
Brander J, Djajic S (1983) Rent-extracting tariffs and the management of exhaustible resources. Canad J Econ 16:288–298
Breton M, Keoula MY (2012) Farsightedness in a coalitional great fish war. Environ Resour Econ 51(2):297–315
Breton M, Sbragia L, Zaccour G (2010) A dynamic model of international environmental agreements. Environ Resour Econ 45:25–48
Cabo F, Tidball M (2016) Promotion of cooperation when benefits come in the future: a water transfer case. Resour Energy Econ (to appear)
Cabo F, Erdlenbruch K, Tidball M (2014) Dynamic management of water transfer between two interconnected river basins. Resour Energy Econ 37:17–38
Cave J (1987) Long-term competition in a dynamic game: the Cold Fish War. Rand J Econ 18: 596–610
Chiarella C, Kemp MC, Long NV, Okuguchi K (1984) On the economics of international fisheries. Int Econ Rev 25 (1):85–92
Chichilnisky G (1996) An axiomatic approach to sustainable development. Soc Choice Welf 13:231–257
Chou S, Long NV (2009) Optimal tariffs on exhaustible resources in the presence of Cartel behavior. Asia-Pac J Account Econ 16(3):239–254
Chwe M (1994) Farsighted coalitional stability. J Econ Theory 63:299–325
Clark CW (1990) Mathematical bioeconomics. Wiley, New York
Clark CW, Munro G (1990) The economics of fishing and modern capital theory. J Environ Econ Manag 2:92–106
Clemhout S, Wan H Jr (1985) Dynamic common property resources and environmental problems. J Optim Theory Appl 46:471–481
Clemhout S, Wan H Jr (1991) Environmental problems as a common property resource game. In: Hamalainen RP, Ehtamo HK (eds) Dynamic games and economic analyses. Springer, Berlin, pp 132–154
Clemhout S, Wan H Jr (1995) The non-uniqueness of Markovian strategy equilibrium: the case of continuous time models for non-renewable resources. In: Paper presented at the 5th international symposium on dynamic games and applications, Grimentz
Colombo L, Labrecciosa P (2013a) Oligopoly exploitation of a private property productive asset. J Econ Dyn Control 37(4):838–853
Colombo L, Labrecciosa P (2013b) On the convergence to the Cournot equilibrium in a productive asset oligopoly. J Math Econ 49(6):441–445
Colombo L, Labrecciosa P (2015) On the Markovian efficiency of Bertrand and Cournot equilibria. J Econ Theory 155:332–358
Cornes R, Long NV, Shimomura K (2001) Drugs and pests: intertemporal production externalities. Jpn World Econ 13(3):255–278
Couttenier M, Soubeyran R (2014) Drought and civil war in Sub-Saharan Africa. Econ J 124(575):201–244
Couttenier M, Soubeyran R (2015) A survey of causes of civil conflicts: natural factors and economic conditions. Revue d’Economie Politique 125(6):787–810
Crabbé P, Long NV (1993) Entry deterrence and overexploitation of the fishery. J Econ Dyn Control 17(4):679–704
Dasgupta PS, Heal GM (1979) Economic theory and exhaustible resources. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Dawkins R, Krebs J (1979) Arms races between and within species. Proc R Soc Lond Ser B 10:489–511
de Frutos J, Martín-Herrán G (2015) Does flexibility facilitate sustainability of cooperation over time? A case study from environmental economics. J Optim Theory Appl 165(2):657–677
Deacon R, Bohn H (2000) Ownership risk, investment, and the use of natural resources. Am Econ Rev 90(3):526–549
de Zeeuw A (2008) Dynamic effects on the stability of international environmental agreements. J Environ Econ Manag 55:163–174
Diamantoudi F, Sartzetakis E (2015) International environmental agreements: coordinated action under foresight. Econ Theory 59(3):527–546
Dinar A, Hogarth M (2015) Game theory and water resources: critical review of its contributions, progress, and remaining challenges. Found Trends Microecon 11(1–2):1–139
Dinar A, Zaccour G (2013) Strategic behavior and environmental commons. Environ Develop Econ 18(1):1–5
Dockner E, Long NV (1993) International pollution control: cooperative versus non-cooperative strategies. J Environ Econ Manag 24:13–29
Dockner E, Sorger G (1996) Existence and properties of equilibria for a dynamic game on productive assets. J Econ Theory 71:209–227
Dockner E, Feichtinger G, Mehlmann A (1989) Noncooperative solution for a differential game model of fishery. J Econ Dyn Control 13:11–20
Dockner ESJ, Long NV, Sorger G (2000) Differential games in economics and management science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Dutta PK, Sundaram RK (1993a) How different can strategic model be? J Econ Theory 60:42–91
Dutta PK, Sundaram RK (1993b) The tragedies of the commons? Econ Theory 3:413–426
Fesselmeyer E, Santugini M (2013) Strategic exploitation of a common resource under environmental risk. J Econ Dyn Control 37(1):125–136
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) (2009) The state of world fisheries and aquaculture 2008. FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Department, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome
Frey BS, Stutzer A (2007) Economics and psychology. MIT Press, Cambridge
Fudenberg D, Levine DK (2006) A dual-self model of impulse control. Am Econ Rev 96: 1449–1476
Fudenberg D, Levine DK (2012) Timing and self control. Econometrica 80(1):1–42
Fudenberg D, Tirole J (1991) Game theory. MIT Press, Cambridge
Fujiwara K (2011) Losses from competition in a dynamic game model of renewable resource oligopoly. Resour Energy Econ 33(1):1–11
Fujiwara K, Long NV (2011) Welfare implications of leadership in a resource market under bilateral monopoly. Dyn Games Appl 1(4):479–497
Fujiwara K, Long NV (2012) Optimal tariffs on exhaustible resources: the case of quantity setting. Int Game Theory Rev 14(04):124004-1-21
Gaudet G (2007) Natural resource economics under the rule of hotelling. Canad J Econ 40(4):1033–1059
Gaudet G, Lohoues H (2008) On limits to the use of linear Markov strategies in common property natural resource games. Environ Model Assess 13:567–574
Gaudet G, Long NV (1994) On the effects of the distribution of initial endowments in a non-renewable resource duopoly. J Econ Dyn Control 18:1189–1198
Grafton Q, Kompas T, Long NV (2016) A brave new world? Interaction among Kantians and Nashians, and the dynamic of climate change mitigation. In: Paper presented at the Tinbergen Institute conference on climate change, Amsterdam
Greenberg J (1990) The theory of social situations: an alternative game-theoretic approach. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Gilbert R (1978) Dominant firm pricing policy in a market for an exhaustible resource. Bell J Econ 9(2):385–395
Groot F, Withagen C, de Zeeuw A (2003) Strong time-consistency in a Cartel-versus-Fringe model. J Econ Dyn Control 28:287–306
Hardin G (1968) The tragedy of the commons. Science 162:1240–1248
Haurie M, Tavoni BC, van der Zwaan C (2011) Modelling uncertainty and the climate change: recommendations for robust energy policy. Environ Model Assess 17:1–5
Heal G (2009) The economics of climate change: a post-stern perspective. Clim Change 96: 275–297
Herrmann M, Gaudet G (2009) The economic dynamics of antibiotic efficacy under open access. J Environ Econ Manag 57:334–350
Hoel M (1978) Resource extraction, substitute production, and monopoly. J Econ Theory 19(1): 28–37
Hoel M (2011) The supply side of CO 2 with country heterogeneity. Scand J Econ 113(4):846–865
Jørgensen S, Yeung DWK (1996) Stochastic differential game model of common property fishery. J Optim Theory Appl 90(2):381–404
Jørgensen S, Zaccour G (2001) Time consistent side payments in a dynamic game of downstream pollution. J Econ Dyn Control 25:1973–87
Kagan M, van der Ploeg F, Withagen C (2015) Battle for climate and scarcity rents: beyond the linear-quadratic case. Dyn Games Appl 5(4):493–522
Kahneman D, Tversky A (1984) Choices, values and frames. Am Psychol 39:341–350
Kaitala V, Hamalainen RP, Ruusunen J (1985) On the analysis of equilibria and bargaining in a fishery game. In: Feichtinger G (ed) Optimal control theory and economic analysis II. North Holland, Amsterdam, pp 593–606
Karp L (1984) Optimality and consistency in a differential game with non-renewable resources. J Econ Dyn Control 8:73–97
Karp L, Newbery D (1991) Optimal tariff on exhaustible resources. J Int Econ 30:285–99
Karp L, Newbery D (1992) Dynamically consistent oil import tariffs. Canad J Econ 25:1–21
Katayma S, Long NV (2010) A dynamic game of status-seeking with public capital and an exhaustible resource. Opt Control Appl Methods 31:43–53
Katayama S, Long NV, Ohta H (2014) Carbon tax and comparison of trading regimes in fossil fuels. In: Semmler W, Tragler G, Verliov V (eds) Dynamics optimization in environmental economics. Springer, Berlin, pp 287–314
Kemp MC, Long NV (1979) The interaction between resource-poor and resource-rich economies. Aust Econ Pap 18:258–267
Kemp MC, Long NV (1980) Exhaustible resources, optimality, and trade. North Holland, Amsterdam
Kemp MC, Long NV (1984) Essays in the economics of exhaustible resources. North Holland, Amsterdam
Keutiben O (2014) On capturing foreign oil rents. Resour Energy Econ 36(2):542–555
Khalatbary F (1977) Market imperfections and the optimal rate of depletion of natural resources. Economica 44:409–14
Kolstad CD (1994) Hotelling rents in hotelling space: product differentiation in exhaustible resource markets. J Environ Econ Manag 26:163–180
Krugman P, Obstfeld M, Melitz M (2015) International economics: theory and policy, 10th edn. Pearson, Boston
Kwon OS (2006) Partial coordination in the Great Fish War. Environ Resour Econ 33:463–483
Lahiri S, Ono Y (1988) Helping minor firms reduce welfare. Econ J 98:1199–1202
Lambertini L, Mantovani A (2014) Feedback equilibria in a dynamic renewable resource oligopoly: pre-emption, voracity and exhaustion. J Econ Dyn Control 47:115–122
Laurent-Lucchetti J, Santugini M (2012) Ownership risk and the use of common-pool natural resources. J Environ Econ Manag 63:242–259
Levhari D, Mirman L (1980) The great fish war: an example using a dynamic Cournot Nash solution. Bell J Econ 11:322–334
Lewis T, Schmalensee R (1980) On oligopolistic markets for nonrenewable natural resources. Q J Econ 95:471–5
Liski M, Tahvonen O (2004) Can carbon tax eat OPEC’s rents? J Environ Econ Manag 47:1–12
Long NV (1975) Resource extraction under the uncertainty about possible nationalization. J Econ Theory 10(1):42–53
Long NV (1977) Optimal exploitation and replenishment of a natural resource. Essay 4 in Pitchford JD, Turnovsky SJ (eds) Applications of control theory to economic analysis. North-Holland, Amsterdam, pp 81–106
Long NV (1994) On optimal enclosure and optimal timing of enclosure. Econ Rec 70(221): 141–145
Long NV (2010) A survey of dynamic games in economics. World Scientific, Singapore
Long NV (2011) Dynamic games in the economics of natural resources: a survey. Dyn Games Appl 1(1):115–148
Long NV (2015a) Kant-Nash equilibrium in a dynamic game of climate change mitigations. In: Paper presented at the CESifo area conference on climate and energy, Oct 2015 (CESifo), Munich
Long NV (2015b) The green paradox in open economies: lessons from static and dynamic models. Rev Environ Econ Policies 9(2):266–285
Long NV (2016a) Kant-Nash equilibrium in a quantity-setting oligopoly. In: von Mouche P, Quartieri F (eds) Contributions on equilibrium theory for Cournot oligopolies and related games: essays in Honour of Koji Okuguchi. Springer, Berlin, pp 171–192
Long NV (2016b) Mixed-strategy Kant-Nash equilibria in games of voluntary contributions to a public good. In: Buchholz W, Ruebbelke D (eds) The theory of externalities and public goods. Springer
Long NV, McWhinnie S (2012) The tragedy of the commons in a fishery when relative performance matters. Ecol Econ 81:140–154
Long NV, Sorger G (2006) Insecure property rights and growth: the roles of appropriation costs, wealth effects, and heterogeneity. Econ Theory 28(3):513–529
Long NV, Sorger G (2010) A dynamic principal-agent problem as a feedback Stackelberg differential game. Central Eur J Oper Res 18(4):491–509
Long NV, Soubeyran A (2001) Cost manipulation games in oligopoly, with cost of manipulating. Int Econ Rev 42(2):505–533
Long NV, Staehler F (2014) General equilibrium effects of green technological progress. CIRANO working paper 2014s-16. CIRANO, Montreal
Long NV, Wang S (2009) Resource grabbing by status-conscious agents. J Dev Econ 89(1):39–50
Long NV, Prieur F, Puzon K, Tidball M (2014) Markov perfect equilibria in differential games with regime switching strategies. CESifo working paper 4662. CESifo Group, Munich
Loury GC (1986) A theory of oligopoly: Cournot equilibrium in exhaustible resource market with fixed supplies. Int Econ Rev 27(2):285–301
Martin-Herrán G, Rincón-Zapareto J (2005) Efficient Markov-perfect Nash equilibria: theory and application to dynamic fishery games. J Econ Dyn Control 29:1073–96
Maskin E, Newbery D (1990) Disadvantageous oil tariffs and dynamic consistency. Am Econ Rev 80(1):143–156
McDonald SL (1971) Petroleum conservation in the United States: an economic analysis. Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore
McMillan J, H-W Sinn (1984) Oligopolistic extraction of a common property resource: dynamic equilibria. In: Kemp MC, Long NV (eds) Essays in the economics of exhaustible resources. North Holland, Amsterdam, pp 199–214
McWhinnie SF (2009) The tragedy of the commons in international fisheries: an empirical investigation. J Environ Econ Manag 57:312–333
Mirman L, Santugini M (2014) Strategic exploitation of a common-property resource under rational learning about its reproduction. Dyn Games Appl 4(1):58–72
Myerson R, Weibull J (2015) Tenable strategy blocks and settled equilibria. Econometrica 83(3):943–976
Ostrom E (1990) Governing the commons: the evolution of institutions for collective actions. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Ray D, Vohra R (2001) Coalitional power and public goods. J Polit Econ 109(6):1355–1384
Roemer JE (2010) Kantian equilibrium. Scand J Econ 112(1):1–24
Roemer JE (2015) Kantian optimization: a microfoundation for cooperation. J Public Econ 127: 45–57
Rubio SJ (2011) On capturing rent from non-renewable resource international monopoly: prices versus quantities. Dyn Games Appl 1(4):558–580
Rubio SJ, Estriche L (2001) Strategic Pigouvian taxation, stock externalities and polluting non-renewable resources. J Public Econ 79(2):297–313
Russell B (1945) A history of western philosophy. George Allen and Unwin, London
Salant S (1976) Exhaustible resources and industrial structure: a Nash-Cournot approach to the World oil market. J Polit Econ 84:1079–94
Salant S, Switzer S, Reynolds R (1983) Losses from horizontal merger: the effects of an exogenous change in industry structure on Cournot Nash equilibrium. Q J Econ 98(2):185–199
Salo S, Tahvonen O (2001) Oligopoly equilibria in nonrenewable resource markets. J Econ Dyn Control 25:671–702
Sethi R, Somanathan E (1996) The evolution of social norms in common property resource use. Am Econ Rev 86(4):766–88
Sidgwick H (1874) The method of ethics, 7th edn. 1907. Macmillan, London. Reprinted by the Hackett Publishing Company (1981)
Sinn H-W (1984) Common property resources, storage facilities, and ownership structure: a Cournot model of the oil market. Economica 51:235–52
Smith A (1776) An inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations. In: Cannan E (ed) The modern library, 1937. Random House, New York
Smith A (1790) The theory of moral sentiments. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. Republished in the series Cambridge texts in the history of philosophy, 2002. Edited by K. Haakonssen
Stiglitz JE (1976) Monopoly power and the rate of extraction of exhaustible resources. Am Econ Rev 66:655–661
Sundaram RK (1989) Perfect equilibria in non-randomized strategies in a class of symmetric games. J Econ Theory 47:153–177
Tahvonen O (1996) Trade with polluting non-renewable resources. J Environ Econ Manag 30:1–17
Tornell A (1997) Economic growth and decline with endogenous property rights. J Econ Growth 2(3):219–257
Tornell A, Lane P (1999) The voracity effect. Am Econ Rev 89:22–46
Ulph A, Folie GM (1980) Exhaustible resources and Cartels: an intertemporal Nash-Cournot model. Canad J Econ 13:645–58
van der Meijden KR, Withagen C (2016) Double limit pricing. In: Paper presented at the 11th Tinbergen Institute conference on climate change, Amsterdam
van der Ploeg R (2010) Rapacious resource depletion, excessive investment and insecure property rights. CESifo working paper no 2981, University of Munich
Veblen TB (1899) The theory of the Leisure class: an economic study of institutions. Modern Library, New York
Watkins GC (1977) Conservation and economic efficiency: Alberta oil proration. J Environ Econ Manag 4:40–56
Wirl F (1994) Pigouvian taxation of energy for flow and stock externalities and strategic non-competitive energy pricing. J Environ Econ Manag 26:1–18
World Trade Organization (2010) World trade report, 2010, Washington, DC
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Section Editor information
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2016 Springer International Publishing AG
About this entry
Cite this entry
Long, N. (2016). Resource Economics. In: Basar, T., Zaccour, G. (eds) Handbook of Dynamic Game Theory. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-27335-8_15-1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-27335-8_15-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-27335-8
eBook Packages: Springer Reference Religion and PhilosophyReference Module Humanities and Social SciencesReference Module Humanities