Abstract
Valves are widely used in various working conditions for their flow control functions, and the cavitation inside valves has been investigated owing to its harm to the valve itself and the connecting downstream parts. This paper presents a comprehensive review of the progress that has been achieved in the past years about cavitation in valves including both mechanical heart valves and control valves. The review is divided in the following parts, namely the location where there is a high possibility of the occurrence of cavitation, the parameters that affect cavitation intensity, and the methods to minimize cavitation intensity. It should be noticed that although simulation has been widely used, advanced experiments are still needed in order to obtain accurate analysis of cavitation in valves and the cavitation model still needs to be improved.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- MMHVs:
-
Monoleaflet mechanical heart valves
- BMHVs:
-
Bileaflet mechanical heart valves
- BS valve:
-
Björk–Shiley valve
- CFD:
-
Computational fluid dynamics
- CM valve:
-
CarboMedies valve
- FSI:
-
Fluid–structure interaction
- LES:
-
Large eddy simulation
- MS:
-
Minisac
- VCO:
-
Valve-covered orifice
- CT:
-
Computed tomography
- RANS:
-
Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes equations
- SJM valve:
-
St. Jude Medical valve
References
Zakaria MS, Ismail F, Tamagawa M, Aziz AFA, Wiriadidjaja S, Basri AA, Ahmad KA (2017) Review of numerical methods for simulation of mechanical heart valves and the potential for blood clotting. Med Biol Eng Comput 55(9):1519–1548
Jin ZJ, Chen FQ, Qian JY, Zhang M, Chen LL, Wang F, Fei Y (2016) Numerical analysis of flow and temperature characteristics in a high multi-stage pressure reducing valve for hydrogen refueling station. Int J Hydrogen Energy 41(12):5559–5570
Jin ZJ, Gao ZX, Chen MR, Qian JY (2018) Parametric study on Tesla valve with reverse flow for hydrogen decompression. Int J Hydrogen Energy 43(18):8888–8896
Qian JY, Wei L, Zhang M, Chen FQ, Chen LL, Jiang WK, Jin ZJ (2017) Flow rate analysis of compressible superheated steam through pressure reducing valves. Energy 135:650–658
Qian JY, Wei L, Jin ZJ, Wang JK, Zhang H (2014) CFD analysis on the dynamic flow characteristics of the pilot-control globe valve. Energy Convers Manag 87:220–226
Thorley ARD (1989) Check valve behavior under transient flow conditions: a state-of-the-art review. ASME J Fluids Eng 111(2):178–183
Petherick PM, Birk AM (1991) State-of-the-art review of pressure relief valve design, testing and modeling. J Press Vessel Technol 113(1):46–54
Abd Fatah AY, Mazlan SA, Koga T, Zamzuri H, Zeinali M, Imaduddin F (2015) A review of design and modeling of magnetorheological valve. Int J Mod Phys B 29(04):1530004
Luo XW, Bin JI, Tsujimoto Y (2016) A review of cavitation in hydraulic machinery. J Hydrodynam B 28(3):335–358
Kumar P, Saini RP (2010) Study of cavitation in hydro turbines—a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 14(1):374–383
Gohil PP, Saini RP (2014) Coalesced effect of cavitation and silt erosion in hydro turbines—a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 33:280–289
Johansen P, Travis BR, Paulsen PK, Nygaard H, Hasenkam JM (2003) Cavitation caused by mechanical heart valve prostheses-a review. APMIS Suppl 109:108–112
Andersen TS, Johansen P, Christensen BO, Paulsen PK, Nygaard H, Hasenkam JM (2006) Intraoperative and postoperative evaluation of cavitation in mechanical heart valve patients. Ann Thorac Surg 81(1):34–41
Lee HS, Hwang SW, Yamamoto K (2003) Examination of cavitation-induced surface erosion pitting of a mechanical heart valve using a solenoid-actuated apparatus. KSME Int J 17(9):1339–1348
Lim WL, Chew YT, Low HT, Foo WL (2003) Cavitation phenomena in mechanical heart valves: the role of squeeze flow velocity and contact area on cavitation initiation between two impinging rods. J Biomech 36(9):1269–1280
Lo CW, Chen SF, Li CP, Lu PC (2010) Cavitation phenomena in mechanical heart valves: studied by using a physical impinging rod system. Ann Biomed Eng 38(10):3162–3172
Lo CW, Liu JS, Li CP, Lu PC, Hwang NH (2008) Cavitation behavior observed in three monoleaflet mechanical heart valves under accelerated testing conditions. ASAIO J 54(2):163–171
Avrahami I, Rosenfeld M, Einav S, Eichler M, Reul H (2000) Can vortices in the flow across mechanical heart valves contribute to cavitation? Med Biol Eng Comput 38(1):93–97
Lukic B, Zapanta CM, Griffith KA, Weiss WJ (2005) Effect of the diastolic and systolic duration on valve cavitation in a pediatric pulsatile ventricular assist device. ASAIO J 51(5):546–550
Lee H, Akagawa E, Homma A, Tsukiya T, Tatsumi E, Taenaka Y (2007) Estimation of mechanical heart valve cavitation in a pneumatic ventricular assist device. J Artif Organs 10(3):181–185
Lee H, Homma A, Tatsumi E, Taenaka Y (2010) Observation of cavitation pits on mechanical heart valve surfaces in an artificial heart used in in vitro testing. J Artif Organs 13(1):17–23
Lee CS, Chandran KB, Chen LD (1996) Cavitation dynamics of medtronic hall mechanical heart valve prosthesis: fluid squeezing effect. J Biomech Eng 118:97–105
Bachmann C, Kini V, Deutsch S, Fontaine AA, Tarbell JM (2002) Mechanisms of cavitation and the formation of stable bubbles on the Bjork-Shiley Monostrut prosthetic heart valve. J Heart Valve Dis 11(1):105–113
Kini V, Bachmann C, Fontaine A, Deutsch S, Tarbell JM (2000) Flow visualization in mechanical heart valves: occluder rebound and cavitation potential. Ann Biomed Eng 28(4):431–441
Chandran KB, Aluri S (1997) Mechanical valve closing dynamics: relationship between velocity of closing, pressure transients, and cavitation initiation. Ann Biomed Eng 25(6):926–938
Zapanta CM, Stinebring DR, Sneckenberger DS, Deutsch S, Geselowitz DB, Tarbell JM, Snyder AJ, Rosenberg G, Weiss WJ, Pae WE, Pierce WS (1996) In vivo observation of cavitation on prosthetic heart valves. ASAIO J 42(5):M550–M555
Herbertson LH, Manning KB, Reddy V, Fontaine AA, Tarbell JM, Deutsch S (2005) The effect of dissolved carbon dioxide on cavitation intensity in mechanical heart valves. J Heart Valve Dis 14(6):835–842
Herbertson LH, Reddy V, Manning KB, Welz JP, Fontaine AA, Deutsch S (2006) Wavelet transforms in the analysis of mechanical heart valve cavitation. J Biomech Eng 128(2):217–222
Takiura K, Chinzei T, Abe Y, Isoyama T, Saito I, Ozeki T, Imachi K (2003) A new approach to detection of the cavitation on mechanical heart valves. ASAIO J 49(3):304–308
Takiura K, Chinzei T, Abe Y, Isoyama T, Saito I, Mochizuki S, Imachi K (2004) A temporal and spatial analysis of cavitation on mechanical heart valves by observing faint light emission. ASAIO J 50(3):285–290
Lee H, Taenaka Y (2006) Mechanism for cavitation phenomenon in mechanical heart valves. J Mech Sci Technol 20(8):1118–1124
Lee H, Tsukiya T, Homma A, Kamimura T, Tatsumi E, Taenaka Y, Kitamura S (2004) A study on the mechanism for cavitation in the mechanical heart valves with an electrohydraulic total artificial heart. JSME Int J Ser C 47(4):1043–1048
Eichler MJ, Reul HM (2004) Mechanical heart valve cavitation: valve specific parameters. Int J Artif Organs 27(10):855–867
Lee H, Homma A, Taenaka Y (2007) Hydrodynamic characteristics of bileaflet mechanical heart valves in an artificial heart: cavitation and closing velocity. Artif Organs 31(7):532–537
Li CP, Chen SF, Lo CW, Lu PC (2012) Role of vortices in cavitation formation in the flow at the closure of a bileaflet mitral mechanical heart valve. J Artif Organs 15(1):57–64
Mohammadi H, Klassen RJ, Wan WK (2008) A finite element model on effects of impact load and cavitation on fatigue crack propagation in mechanical bileaflet aortic heart valve. Proc IMechE Part H 222(7):1115–1125
Johansen P, Andersen TS, Hasenkam JM, Nygaard H, Paulsen PK (2014) Mechanical heart valve cavitation in patients with bileaflet valves. In: International conference of the IEEE engineering in medicine and biology society, pp 5655–5658
Johansen P, Manning KB, Tarbell JM, Fontaine AA, Deutsch S, Nygaard H (2003) A new method for evaluation of cavitation near mechanical heart valves. J Biomech Eng 125:663–670
Dexter EU, Aluri S, Radcliffe RR, Zhu H, Carlson DD, Heilman TE, Chandran KB, Richenbacher WE (1999) In vivo demonstration of cavitation potential of a mechanical heart valve. ASAIO J 45(5):436–441
Wu C, Liu JS, Hwang NH (2005) Statistical correlation between transient pressure drop and cavitation at closure of a mechanical heart valve. ASAIO J 51(1):11–16
Yu AA, White JA, Hwang NHC (1998) Time-frequency analysis of transient pressure signals for a mechanical heart valve cavitation study. ASAIO J 44(5):M475–M479
Wu ZJ, Slonin JH, Hwang NHC (1996) Transient pressure signals in mechanical heart valve cavitation. ASAIO J 42(5):M555–M560
Adamkowski A, Lewandowski M (2014) Consideration of the cavitation characteristics of shut-off valves in numerical modelling of hydraulic transients in pipelines with column separation. Procedia Eng 70:1027–1036
Adamkowski A, Lewandowski M (2014) Cavitation characteristics of shutoff valves in numerical modeling of transients in pipelines with column separation. J Hydraul Eng 141(2):04014077
Couzinet A, Gros L, Pinho J, Chabane S, Pierrat D (2014) Numerical modeling of turbulent cavitation flows in safety relief valves. In: ASME pressure vessels piping conference, pp 1–10
Hong SH, Kim KW (2016) The validity of the Reynolds equation in spool valve analysis considering cavitation. Friction 4(3):266–276
Longhitano M, Chighine M, Murrenhoff H (2017) Cavitation and turbulence modelling for valve flows: an application to a pilot stage of a servo valve. In: ASME/BATH symposium on fluid power motion control, pp 1–10
Wang G, Cao S, Zuo Z, Zhao L (2001) Vortex structures and cavitation aspects around a hollow-jet valve. In: Proceedings, congress of the international association of hydraulic research, pp 623–629
Guoyu W, Shujun LIU, Shintani M, Ikohagi T (1999) Study on cavitation damage characteristics around a hollow-jet valve. JSME Int J, Ser B 42(4):649–657
Liu X, He J, Zhao J, Long Z, Li W, Li B (2016) Biofluid flow through a throttle valve: a computational fluid dynamics study of cavitation. J Mech Med Biol 16(3):1650034
Li B, Li W, Jiao M, Wang B, Liu X (2017) Analysis of cavitation characteristics in throttle valve with different structure parameters. J Mech Med Biol 17(03):1750047
Washio S, Kikui S, Takahashi S (2010) Nucleation and subsequent cavitation in a hydraulic oil poppet valve. Proc IMechE Part C 224(4):947–958
Li S, Aung NZ, Zhang S, Cao J, Xue X (2013) Experimental and numerical investigation of cavitation phenomenon in flapper–nozzle pilot stage of an electrohydraulic servo-valve. Comput Fluids 88:590–598
Qu WS, Tan L, Cao SL, Xu Y, Huang J, Xu QH (2015) Experiment and numerical simulation of cavitation performance on a pressure-regulating valve with different openings. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 72(4):042035
Saito S, Shibata M, Fukae H, Outa E (2007) Computational cavitation flows at inception and light stages on an axial-flow pump blade and in a cage-guided control valve. J Therm Sci 16(4):337–345
Lee WG, Reitz RD (2010) A numerical investigation of transient flow and cavitation within minisac and valve-covered orifice diesel injector nozzles. J Eng Gas Turbines Power 132(5):052802
Deng J, Pan D, Xie F, Shao X (2015) Numerical investigation of cavitation flow inside spool valve with large pressure drop. J Phys Conf Ser 656(1):012067
Zheng Z, Ou G, Jin H (2017) Numerical-experimental study on the erosion-cavitation wear of coal oil slurry valve. In ASME pressure vessels piping conference, pp 1–7
Carlson B (2001) Avoiding cavitation in control valves. ASHRAE J 43(6):58–63
Singhal AK, Athavale MM, Li H, Jiang Y (2002) Mathematical basis and validation of the full cavitation model. ASME J Fluids Eng 124(3):617–624
Schnerr GH, Sauer J (2001) Physical and numerical modeling of unsteady cavitation dynamics. In: 4th international conference on multiphase flow, New Orleans, USA
Zwart PJ, Gerber AG, Belamri T (2004) A two-phase flow model for predicting cavitation dynamics. In: 5th international conference on multiphase flow, Yokohama, Japan, May, vol 152
Gholami H, Yaghoubi H, Alizadeh M (2014) Numerical analysis of cavitation phenomenon in a vaned ring-type needle valve. J Energy Eng 141(4):04014053
Du XW, Fu X, Yang HY (2009) The effect of pressure distribution on high speed cavitation flow inside throttling valve. In: Proceedings of the 7th international conference on fluid power transmission and control, pp 178–182
Han M, Liu Y, Wu D, Zhao X, Tan H (2017) A numerical investigation in characteristics of flow force under cavitation state inside the water hydraulic poppet valves. Int J Heat Mass Transf 111:1–16
Nie S, Huang G, Li Y, Yang Y, Zhu Y (2006) Research on low cavitation in water hydraulic two-stage throttle poppet valve. Proc IMechE Part E 220(3):167–179
Gavaises M (2008) Flow in valve covered orifice nozzles with cylindrical and tapered holes and link to cavitation erosion and engine exhaust emissions. Int J Engine Res 9(6):435–447
Ko S, Song S (2015) Effects of design parameters on cavitation in a solenoid valve for an electric vehicle braking system and design optimization. J Mech Sci Technol 29(11):4757–4765
Lee MG, Lim CS, Han SH (2016) Shape design of the bottom plug used in a 3-way reversing valve to minimize the cavitation effect. Int J Precis Eng Manuf 17(3):401–406
Jin ZJ, Gao ZX, Qian JY, Wu Z, Sunden B (2018) A parametric study of hydrodynamic cavitation inside globe valves. ASME J Fluids Eng 140(3):031208
Liu Y, Ji X (2009) Simulation of cavitation in rotary valve of hydraulic power steering gear. Sci China Ser E Technol Sci 52(11):3142–3148
Zheng Z, Ou G, Ye H, Jin H (2016) Numerical analysis on cavitation erosion of a high pressure differential control valve. In: ASME pressure vessels piping conference, pp 1–6
Ou GF, Xu J, Li WZ, Chen B (2015) Investigation on cavitation flow in pressure relief valve with high pressure differentials for coal liquefaction. Procedia Eng 130:125–134
Bernad S, Susan-Resiga R, Muntean S, Anton I (2007) Cavitation phenomena in hydraulic valves. Numerical modelling. Proc Rom Acad Ser A 8(2):1–10
Liang J, Luo X, Liu Y, Li X, Shi T (2016) A numerical investigation in effects of inlet pressure fluctuations on the flow and cavitation characteristics inside water hydraulic poppet valves. Int J Heat Mass Transf 103:684–700
Wang C, Li GX, Sun ZY, Wang L, Sun SP, Gu JJ, Wu XJ (2016) Effects of structure parameters on flow and cavitation characteristics within control valve of fuel injector for modern diesel engine. Energy Convers Manag 124:104–115
Gao H, Lin W, Tsukiji T (2006) Investigation of cavitation near the orifice of hydraulic valves. Proc IMechE Part G 220(4):253–265
Qian JY, Liu BZ, Jin ZJ, Wang JK, Zhang H (2016) Numerical analysis of flow and cavitation characteristics in a pilot-control globe valve with different valve core displacements. J Zhejiang Univ Sci A 17(1):54–64
Yuzawa S, Okutsu R, Hashizume T (1998) Cavitation erosion features in industrial control valves at an inlet pressure of 20 MPa. JSME Int J, Ser B 41(4):1105–1113
Ou GF, Li WZ, Xiao DH, Zheng ZJ, Dou HS, Wang C (2015) Numerical investigation on cavitation in pressure relief valve for coal liquefaction. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 72(4):042039
Liu B, Zhao J, Qian J (2017) Numerical analysis of cavitation erosion and particle erosion in butterfly valve. Eng Failure Anal 80:312–324
Zou J, Fu X, Du XW, Ruan XD, Ji H, Ryu S, Ochiai M (2008) Cavitation in a non-circular opening spool valve with U-grooves. Proc IMechE Part A 222(4):413–420
Okita K, Kajishima T (2000) G213 Numerical investigation of unsteady cavitating flow around a rectangular prism. prism (Fluid machinary-1). In: Proceedings of the fourth JSME-KSME thermal engineering conference, Kobe, Japan, vol 2
Chen Y, Heister SD (1995) Two-phase modeling of cavitated flows. Comput Fluids 24(7):799–809
Pinho J, Rambaud P, Chabane S (2013) Experimental study of two-phase flow induced by cavitation through a safety relief valve. In: ASME pressure vessels piping conference, pp 1–10
Amirante R, Distaso E, Tamburrano P (2014) Experimental and numerical analysis of cavitation in hydraulic proportional directional valves. Energy Convers Manag 87:208–219
Shirazi NT, Azizyan GR, Akbari GH (2012) CFD analysis of the ball valve performance in presence of cavitation. Life Sci J 9(4):1460–1467
Tabrizi AS, Asadi M, Xie G, Lorenzini G, Biserni C (2014) Computational fluid-dynamics-based analysis of a ball valve performance in the presence of cavitation. J Eng Thermophys 23(1):27–38
Ferrari J, Leutwyler Z (2008) Fluid flow force measurement under various cavitation state on a globe valve model. In: ASME pressure vessels piping conference, pp 157–165
Yi D, Lu L, Zou J, Fu X (2015) Interactions between poppet vibration and cavitation in relief valve. Proc IMechE Part C 229(8):1447–1461
Caillaud S, Gibert RJ, Moussou P, Cohen J, Millet F (2006) Effects on pipe vibrations of cavitation in an orifice and in globe-style valves. In: ASME pressure vessels piping conference, pp 573–582
Okita K, Miyamoto Y, Kataoka T, Takagi S, Kato H (2015) Mechanism of noise generation by cavitation in hydraulic relief valve. J Phys Conf Ser 656(1):012104
Osterman A, Hočevar M, Širok B, Dular M (2009) Characterization of incipient cavitation in axial valve by hydrophone and visualization. Exp Therm Fluid Sci 33(4):620–629
Brett G, Riveland M, Jensen TC, Heindel TJ (2011) Cavitation from a butterfly valve: comparing 3D simulations to 3D X-ray computed tomography flow visualization. In: ASME-JSME-KSME joint fluids engineering conference, January, pp 161–169
Jazi AM, Rahimzadeh H (2009) Detecting cavitation in globe valves by two methods: characteristic diagrams and acoustic analysis. Appl Acoust 70(11):1440–1445
Jazi AM, Rahimzadeh H (2009) Waveform analysis of cavitation in a globe valve. Ultrasonics 49(6):577–582
Kudźma Z, Stosiak M (2015) Studies of flow and cavitation in hydraulic lift valve. Arch Civ Mech Eng 15(4):951–961
Lu L, Zou J, Fu X (2012) The acoustics of cavitation in spool valve with U-notches. Proc IMechE Part G 226(5):540–549
Ai-Fang YAN, Yang ZHAO (2016) Judgment criteria for cavitation based on jet flow field of V-type valve port. DEStech Trans Eng Technol Res 1–9
Hympendahl O (2003) Simulation einer kavitierenden Strömung um moderne Propeller mit Feldmethoden, M.S. thesis, Technical University of Hamburg, Germany (in German)
Aung NZ, Li S (2014) A numerical study of cavitation phenomenon in a flapper-nozzle pilot stage of an electrohydraulic servo-valve with an innovative flapper shape. Energy Convers Manag 77:31–39
Yang Q, Aung NZ, Li S (2015) Confirmation on the effectiveness of rectangle-shaped flapper in reducing cavitation in flapper–nozzle pilot valve. Energy Convers Manag 98:184–198
Liu YS, Huang Y, Li ZY (2002) Experimental investigation of flow and cavitation characteristics of a two-step throttle in water hydraulic valves. Proc IMechE Part 216(1):105–111
Chern MJ, Hsu PH, Cheng YJ, Tseng PY, Hu CM (2012) Numerical study on cavitation occurrence in globe valve. J Energy Eng 139(1):25–34
Gardellin D (1996) Minimize valve cavitation by proper system design. Chem Eng Prog 92(8):52–57
Ogawa K (2007) Cavitation noise reduction around a butterfly valve by semi-circular fins. In: ASME/JSME joint fluids engineering conference, pp 397–402
Weijie S, Shuping C, Xiaohui L, Zuti Z, Yuquan Z (2017) Experimental research on the cavitation suppression in the water hydraulic throttle valve. J Press Vessel Technol 139(5):051302
Wilson J, Boelen EL (2003) Preventing cavitation requires proper design and operation of feed-water valves. Power Eng 107(11):94–98
Ogawa K, Hisada K (2002) Reduction of cavitation noise around a butterfly valve. ISA Tech Conf 477–484
Feng J, Bole J, Jian C (2001) Study on cavitation characteristics of valve stand with drop step and lateral offsets. In: Proceedings of the congress-international association for hydraulic research, pp 639–644
Kim DH, Kim HW, Ghal SH, Ha JS (2005) A design modification of the delivery valve and the constant pressure valve in a medium speed diesel engine fuel injection system for the prevention of cavitation damage and secondary injection. In: ASME international mechanical engineering congress and exposition, pp 237–243
Xu Q, Xuan G (1998) The new methods for preventing cavitation of high-lift ship lock valves in hydro-power projects. Water Resour Eng 98:1757–1762
Trivedi V, Farah A, Harvel G (2013) Effects of cavitation damage on the hydraulic characteristics of a gate valve. In: ASME power conference, pp 1–7
Guoyi P, Shimizu S (2013) Progress in numerical simulation of cavitating water jets. J Hydrodyn Ser B 25(4):502–509
Peng G, Shimizu S, Fujikawa S (2011) Numerical simulation of cavitating water jet by a compressible mixture flow method. J Fluid Sci Technol 6(4):499–509
Shi Y, Zhao Y, Yeo TJ, Hwang NH (2003) Numerical simulation of opening process in a bileaflet mechanical heart valve under pulsatile flow condition. J Heart Valve Dis 12(2):245–255
Li CP, Lu PC (2012) Numerical comparison of the closing dynamics of a new trileaflet and a bileaflet mechanical aortic heart valve. J Artif Organs 15(4):364–374
Choi CR, Kim CN (2009) Numerical analysis on the hemodynamics and leaflet dynamics in a bileaflet mechanical heart valve using a fluid-structure interaction method. ASAIO J 55(5):428–437
Acknowledgements
This work is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China through Grant No. 51805470, the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities through Grant No. 2018QNA4013, and the Youth Funds of the State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power and Mechatronic Systems (Zhejiang University) through Grant No. SKLoFP-QN-1801.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Human and animal rights
This article does not contain any studies with human or animal subjects performed by any of the authors.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Qian, Jy., Gao, Zx., Hou, Cw. et al. A comprehensive review of cavitation in valves: mechanical heart valves and control valves. Bio-des. Manuf. 2, 119–136 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s42242-019-00040-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s42242-019-00040-z