Abstract
During the mid-18th century, when electricity was coming into its own, natural philosophers began to entertain the possibility that electricity is the mysterious nerve force. Their attention was first drawn to several species of strongly electric fish, namely torpedoes, a type of African catfish, and a South American “eels.” This was because their effects felt like those of discharging Leyden jars and could be transmitted along known conductors of electricity. Moreover, their actions could not be adequately explained by popular mechanical theories. Many of the early documents supportive of the hypothesis of animal electricity were associated with the Dutch colonies in South America. This article presents and examines those documents, and shows how Dutch scientists on both sides of the Atlantic conducted experiments and communicated with each other in the 1750s and 1760s. It reveals the important roles played by inquisitive physicians and lovers of nature in South America, and by natural philosophers and collectors of exotic specimens in the Netherlands—learned men who began to make a credible case for animal electricity in some exciting places at a pivotal moment in time.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Académie des Sciences. 1761. Histoire de l’Académie royale des sciences. Année MDCCLX. Paris:Imprimerie Royale.
Adanson, Michel. 1757. Histoire Naturelle du Sénégal. Paris:J.B.Bauche.
Allamand, Jean N.S. 1754. ‹Bericht der Geneezinge van een Meisken, met een zeker soort van beroerdheid bezet, dewelke door hulp van electriciteit hersteld is.’ Verhandelingen Hollandsche Maatschappye der Weetenschappen Haarlem 1: 485–497.
Allamand, Jean N.S. 1756. ‹Kort verhaal van de uitwerkzelen, welke een Americaanse vis veroorzaakt op de geenen die hem aanraaken.’ Verhandelingen Hollandsche Maatschappye der Weetenschappen Haarlem 2: 372–379.
—— 1768. “Kurzer Bericht von den Wirkungen, welche ein americanischer Fisch bey denenjenigen verursacht, die denselben anrühren.” Neues Hamburgisches Magazin Band 4., 20. Stück: 178–183.
—— 1775. “Von den sonderbaren Wirkungen welche die Berührung eines gewissen amerikanischen Fisches verursachet.” Abhandlungen aus der Naturgeschichte, praktischen Arzneykunst und Chirurgie aus den Schriften der Harlemer und anderer holländischen Gesellschaften… Band I: 99–104.
Anonymous. (but Allamand). 1756. “Kurze Erzählung der Würkungen, welche ein gewisser amerikanischer Fisch denen verursachet, welche ihn berühren.” Nützliche Samlungen 2: 429–432.
Anon, 1762. ‹Extrait d’une lettre sur le congre, écrite de Rio Essequebo le 7 Juin 1761 par M. Van der Lott, qui est Chirurgien.’ Bibliothèque des sciences, et des beaux arts 17: 386–388.
Anon. 1902. Herdenking van het honderdvijftigjarig bestaan van de Hollandsche Maatschappij der Wetenschappen op 7 juni 1902. ‹s Gravenhage:Nijhoff.
Arago, François J. 1854. “Éloge historique d’Alexandre Volta lu à la sÉance publique du 26 juillet 1831.” J.-A. Barral, (ed.), OEuvres Complètes, Vol. 1. Paris: Gide and J. Baudry: pp. 187–240.
Bancroft, Edward. 1769. An Essay on the Natural History of Guiana in South America. London: Becket and De Hondt.
Beccari, Camillo. 1903–1917. Rerum aethiopicarum scriptores occidentales inediti a saeculo XVI ad XIX. 15 voll. Romae: C. de Luigi.
Behn, Aphra. 1688/2000. Oroonoko; or, The royal slave. New York: Bedford/St. Martin’s Press.
Bertholon, Pierre. 1786. De l’electricite du corps humain dans l’etat de sante et de maladie, etc. 2 vols. Paris:Croulbois.
Bertucci, Paola. 2007. Viaggio nel paese delle meraviglie. Scienza e curiosità nell’Italia del Settecento. Torino:Bollati-Boringhieri.
Bertucci, Paola, and Pancaldi, Giuliano. (eds.). 2001. Electric Bodies. Bologna:Università di Bologna.
Bierens de Haan, Joannes Abraham. 1952. De Hollandsche Maatschappij der Wetenschappen. 1752–1952 (with a summary in English). Haarlem, Societ. Scient. Batavo. Harlemens.
Bloch, Marcus Elieser. 1786–1787. Naturgeschichte der ausländischen Fische. Berlin: Aus Kosten der Verfassers, und in Commission in der Buchhandlung der Realschule.
Bonnet, Charles. 1764. Contemplation de la Nature. 2 tomes, I ed. Amsterdam:Marc-Michel Rey.
Bonnet, Charles. 1769. Contemplation de la Nature. 2 tomes, II ed. Amsterdam:Marc-Michel Rey.
Bonnet, Charles. 1779–1783. Collection complète des oeuvres d’histoire naturelle et de philosophie de Ch. Bonnet. 8 Tomes. Neuchâtel: Samuel Fauche.
Borelli, Giovanni Alfonso. 1680–1681. De motu animalium. 2 vols. Roma: Bernabò.
Brazier, Mary A.B. 1984. A History of Neurophysiology in the 17th and 18th Centuries. New York:Raven Press.
Bredekamp, Horst. 1995. The Lure of Antiquity and the Cult of the Machine: The Kunstkammer and the Evolution of Nature, Art and Technology (transl. Allison Brown). Princeton:Marcus Weiner.
Bresadola, Marco. 1998. ‹Medicine and Science in the Life of Luigi Galvani (1737–1798).’ Brain Research Bulletin 46: 367–380.
Buursma, J.H. 1978. Nederlandse geleerde genootschappen opgericht in de 18e eeuw. (Discom, no.7). Nijmegen:Bibliografische bijdragen.
Cavazza, Marta. 1997. ‹La recezione della teoria halleriana dell’irritabilità nell’Accademia delle Scienze di Bologna.’ Nuncius 12: 359–377.
Cavendish, Henry. 1776. ‹An Account of Some Attempts to Imitate the Effects of the Torpedo by Electricity.’ Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 66: 196–225.
Clower, William T. 1998. ‹The Transition from Animal Spirits to Animal Electricity: A Neuroscience Paradigm Shift.’ Journal of the History of the Neurosciences 7: 201–218.
Copenhaver, Brian P. 1991. ‹A Tale of Two Fishes: Magical Objects in Natural History from Antiquity through the Scientific Revolution.’ Journal of the History of Ideas 52: 373–398.
De Asúa, Miguel. 2008. ‹The experiments of Ramón M. Termeyer SJ on the electric eel in the River Plate Region (c. 1760) and other early accounts of Electrophorus electricus.’ Journal of the History of the Neurosciences 17: 160–174.
Debru, Armelle. 1966. ‹The Power of Torpedo Fish as a Pathological Model to the Understanding of Nervous Transmission in Antiquity.’ Comptes-Rendus de Biologie 329: 298–302.
de La Condamine, Charles-Marie. 1745. Relation Abrégée d’un Voyage fait dans l’Intérieur de l’Amérique Méridionale. Paris:Veuve Pissot.
Delbourgo, James. 2006. A Most Amazing Scene of Wonders: Electricity and Enlightenment in Early America. Cambridge:Harvard University Press, pp. 186–187.
Den Heijer, Henk. 2002. De geschiedenis van de WIC, 3rd ed. Zutphen:Walburg.
de Villiers, J.A.J. 1920. Storm van’s Gravesande. Zijn werk en Zijn Leven. Uit Zijne Brieven Opgebouwd. ‹s Gravenhage:Nijhoff.
Duchesneau, François. 1982. La physiologie des lumières. Empirisme, modèles et théories. The Hague:Nijhoff.
Fabri, Giacinto Bartolomeo (ed.). 1757. Sulla insensitività ed irritabilità halleriana. Opuscoli di vari autori raccolti da Giacinto Bartolomeo Fabri, 2 vols. Bologna:Girolamo Corciolani.
Fermin, Philippe. 1769. Déscription Générale, Historique, Géographique et Physique de la Colonie de Surinam, 2 vols. Amsterdam:E. van Harrevelt.
Fermin, Philippe. 1770. Dissertation sur la question, s’il est permis d’avoir en sa possession des esclaves, & de s’en servir comme tels, dans les colonies de l’Amerique. Maestricht: Chez Jacques Lekens.
Figuier, Louis. 1868. Les poissons, les reptiles et les oiseaux. Paris:Hachette.
Finger, Stanley. 2006. Doctor Franklin’s Medicine. Philadelphia:University of Pennsylvania Press.
Finger, Stanley. 2009. “Edward Bancroft’s (1769) Torporific eels.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 52: 61–79.
Finger, Stanley, and Zaromb, F. 2006. ‹Benjamin Franklin and Shock-Induced Amnesia.’ American Psychologist 61: 240–248.
Galilei, Galileo. 1623. Il Saggiatore, nel quale con bilancia esquisita e giusta. Rome:Mascardi.
Galilei, Galileo. 1632. Dialogo di Galileo Galilei sopra i due massimi sistemi del mondo tolomaico e copernicano. Florence: Landini. (English translation by S. Drake in Dialogue concerning the two chief world systems, Ptolemaic and Copernican 2nd edition, 1967, with a foreword by Albert Einstein. Berkeley: University of California Press).
Galvani, Luigi. 1791. ‹De viribus electricitatis in motu musculari commentarius.’ De Bononiensi Scientiarum et Artium Instituto atque Academia commentarii 7: 363–418.
Garn, Johann Andreas. 1778. Dissertatio inauguralis medica de torpedine recentiorum genere Anguilla. Præside G. A. Langguth. Wittenberg: Litteris Caroli Christ. Dürrii.
Godinho, Nicolao. 1615. De Abassinorum rebus: Deque ÆthiopiÆ Patriarchis Ioanne Nonio Barreto, & Andrea Oviedo, libri tres. Lugduni:Sumptibus Horatij Cardon.
Gronov, Laurens Theodore. 1754–1756. Museum ichthyologicum, sistens piscium indigenorum & quorundam exoticorum… 2 vols. Leyden: T. Haak.
Gronov, Laurens Theodore. 1758. ‹Brief van D. Laurens Theodorus Gronovius aan C. N. over niew-ontdekte Zeediertjes en Byzonderheden van den Siddervis of Beef-Aal (uit het Latyn vertaald) (Leide October 1758).’ Uitgezogte verhandelingen uit de nieuwste werken van de societeiten der wetenschappen in Europa en van andere geleerde mannen 3: 464–478.
Gronov, Laurens Theodore. 1760. ‹Gymnoti tremuli descriptio, atque experimenta cum eo instituta.’ Acta Helvetica physico-mathematico-anatomico-botanico-medica … in usus publicos exarata 4: 27–35.
—— 1763–1764. Zoophylacii Gronoviani fasciculi…. Lugduni Batavorum: Sumptibus auctoris.
Gronov, Laurens Theodore. 1781. Zoophylacium Gronovianum. Lugduni Batavorum:Sumptibus auctoris.
—— 1854. John Edward Gray (ed), Calaloque of fish collected and described by Laurence Theodore Gronow Now in the British Museum. London: Published by order of the trustees.
Hales, Stephen. 1733. Statical Essays, Containing Haemastaticks, or, an Account of Some Hydraulick and Hydrostatical Experiments, 2 vols. London:W. Innys and R. Manby.
Heilbron, John L. 1978. “Volta’s path to the battery.” G. Dubpernell and J.H. Westbrook (eds), Proceedings of the symposium on selected topics in the history of electrochemistry. Princeton: The Electrochemical Society, pp. 39–65.
Heilbron, John L. 1979. Electricity in the 17th and 18th Centuries. A Study of Early Modern Physics. Berkeley:University of California Press.
Hodgkin, Alan L. 1964. The Conduction of the Nervous Impulse. Liverpool:Liverpool University Press.
Home, Roderick W. 1970. ‹Electricity and the Nervous Fluid.’ Journal of the History of Biology 3: 235–251.
Hunter, John. 1773. ‹Anatomical Observations on the Torpedo.’ Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 63: 481–488.
Hunter, John. 1775. ‹An Account of the Gymnotus electricus.’ Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 65: 395–407.
Imperato, Ferrante. 1599. Dell’Historia Naturale. Napoli:Vitale.
Impey, Oliver, and MacGregor, Arthur (eds.). 2001. The Origins of Museums: The Cabinets of Curiosities in Sixteenth- and Seventeenth-Century Europe, 2nd ed. London:House of Stratus.
Ingram, Dale. 1750a. ‹New Experiments Concerning the Torpedo.’ The Student, or the Oxford Monthly Miscellany 2: 32–49.
Ingram, Dale. 1750b. ‹Von dem Torpedo, oder Krampf-Fisch, aus dem Englischen, des Oxford. Student. N. 2.’ Hannoverische Gelehrte Anzeigen 1: 83–84.
Ingram, Dale. 1770. ‹Von dem Torpedo oder Krampfisch, aus dem Englischen.’ Neue physikalische Belustigungen 6: 288–293.
Jéhan, Louis François. 1852. Dictionnaire ou histoire naturelle de quatre grands embranchement du regne animal… II tome of the Dictionnaire de Théologie Chrétienne. Paris:Mignes aux ateliers catholiques.
Kellaway, Peter. 1946. ‹The Part Played by Electric Fish in the Early History of Bioelectricity and Electrotherapy.’ Bulletin of the History of Medecine 20: 112–137.
Kipnis, Naum. 1986. ‹Luigi Galvani and the Debate on Animal Electricity, 1791–1800.’ Annals of Science 44: 107–142.
Lacepède, Etienne. 1798–1804. Histoire naturelle des poisons. 5 Tomes. Paris: Plassan.
Lindeboom, Gerrit A. 1984. Dutch Medical Biography. A Biographical Dictionary of Dutch Physicians and Surgeons 1475–1975. Amsterdam:Rodopi.
Linnaeus, Carolus. 1766. Systema Naturae… editio XII reformata. Holmiae:Impensis L. Salvii.
Lorenzini, Stefano. 1678. Osservazioni intorno alle torpedini. Firenze:Onofri.
Ludolf, Hiob. 1681. Historia Aethiopica, sive brevis et succincta descriptio regni Habessinorum. Francofurti ad Moenum:Zunner et Wustii.
Martini, Friedrich Heinrich Wilhelm. 1774. Allgemeine Geschichte der Natur in alphabetischer Ordnung, mit vielen Kupfern nach bomarischer Einrichtung. vol. I. Berlin: Joachim Pauli.
McConnell, Anita. 1991. ‹La Condamine’s Scientific Journey down the River Amazon, 1743–1744.’ Annals of Science 48: 1–19.
Moller, Peter. 1995. Electric Fishes, History and Behavior. London:Chapman and Hall.
Müsch, Irmgard. 2005. Introduction to Seba, A. Cabinet of natural curiosities…. Cologne:Taschen.
Newton, Isaac. 1713. Philosophiae naturalis principia mathematica. 2nd ed. Cambridge [s.n.].
Newton, Isaac. 1718. Opticks, or, A treatise of the Reflections, Refractions, Inflections and Colours of Light, 2nd ed. London:W. Innys.
Ochs, Sidney. 2004. A History of Nerve Functions: From Animal Spirits to Molecular Mechanisms. New York:Cambridge University Press.
Olmi, Giuseppe. 1992. L’inventario del mondo: catalogazione della natura e luoghi del sopare nella prima eta moderna. Bologna:il Mulino.
Olmstead, John W. 1942. ‹The Scientific Expedition of Jean Richer to Cayenne.’ Isis 34: 117–128.
Pancaldi, Giuliano. 1990. ‹Electricity and Life. Volta’s Path to the Battery.’ Historical Studies in the Physical and Biological Sciences 21: 123–160.
Piccolino, Marco. 1998. ‹Animal Electricity an the Birth of Electrophysiology. The Legacy of Luigi Galvani.’ Brain Research Bulletin 46: 381–407.
Piccolino, Marco. 2000. ‹The Bicentennial of the Voltaic Battery (1800–2000). The Artificial Electric Organ.’ Trends in Neurosciences 23: 47–51.
Piccolino, Marco. 2001. ‹Lazzaro Spallanzani e le ricerche sui pesci elettrici nel secolo dei lumi.’ Spallanzani 1984–2003: Part. 4 Opere edite direttamente dall’autore 5: 1782–1791. (t. 3 Supplemento e Carteggi, pp. 359–456).
Piccolino, Marco. 2003a. The Taming of the Ray, Electric Fish Research in the Enlightenment, from John Walsh to Alessandro Volta. Firence:Olschki.
Piccolino, Marco. 2003b. ‹Nerves, Alcohol and Drugs, the Adrian-Kato Controversy on Nervous Conduction: Deep Insights from a “Wrong” Experiment?’ Brain Research Reviews 43: 257–265.
Piccolino, Marco. 2005. ‹From an Ambiguous Torpedo to Animal and Physical Electricity.’ Audiological Medicine 3: 124–132.
Piccolino, Marco. 2006. ‹Luigi Galvani’s Path to Animal Electricity.’ Comptes Rendus Biologie 329: 303–318.
Piccolino, Marco. 2008. ‹Visual Images in Luigi Galvani’s Path to Animal Electricity.’ Journal of the History of the Neurosciences 17: 335–348.
Piccolino, Marco, and Bresadola, Marco. 2002. ‹Drawing a Spark from Darkness: John Walsh and Electric Fish.’ Trends in Neurosciences 25: 51–57.
Piccolino, Marco, and Bresadola, Marco. 2003. Rane, torpedini e scintille, Galvani, Volta e l’elettricità animale. Torino:Bollati-Boringhieri.
Pringle, John. 1775. Discourse on the Torpedo Delivered at the Anniversary Meeting of the Royal Society, November 30th, 1774. London:Printed for the Royal Society.
Réaumur, René A.F. 1717. ‹Des effets que produit le poisson appelé an français torpille, ou trembleur, sur ceux qui le touchents; et de la cause dont ils dépendent.’ Histoire de l’Académie Royale des Sciences pour l’Année 1714: 344–360.
Redi, Francesco. 1671. Esperienze intorno a diverse cose naturali e particolarmente intorno a quelle che ci son portate dall’Indie, scritte al Reverendissimo Padre Atanasio Chircher della Compagnia di Giesù. Firenze:All’insegna della Nave.
Richer, Jean. 1679. “Observations astronomiques et physiques faites en l’Isle de Caienne.” Various authors (1678–1693). Recueil d’observations faites en plusieurs voyages par ordre de sa majesté, pour perfectionner l’astronomie et la géographie. Paris:Imprimerie Royale.
Roberts, Lissa. 1999. ‹Science Becomes Electric. Dutch Interaction with the Electrical Machine During the Eighteenth Century.’ Isis 90: 680–714.
Rowbottom, Margaret, and Susskind, Charles. 1984. Electricity and Medicine. History of Their Interaction. San Francisco:San Francisco University Press.
Schilling, Godfried Willem. 1770. Diatribe de morbo in Europa pene ignoto, quem Americani vocant jaws, adjecta est hecas casuum rariorum […] observatorum, nec non observatio physica de torpedine pisce. Trajecti ad Rhenum:J. C. ten Bosch.
—— 1772. “Sur le phénomène de l’Anguille tremblante.” Nouveaux Mémoires de l’Académie Royale des Sciences et Belles-Lettres de Berlin” 68–74.
Seba, Albertus. 1734–1765. Locupletissimi rerum naturalium thesauri accurata descriptio (4␣Vols.). Amstelodami: Apud Janssonio-Waesbergios et Apud Arksteum & Schouter.
Sundius, Petrus. 1749. Surinamensia grilliana… praeside… Carolo Linnaeo,… speciminis academici loco curiosis examinanda sistit alumnus Oxenstiernianus Petrus Sundius,… in Amoenitates academicae fasc. XVI. Holmiae:apud Cornelium Haak.
Suringar, Gerard C.B. 1867. ‹Het bijeenbrengen eener verzameling van natuurlijke voorwerpen voor het akademisch onderwijs, omstreeks het midden der achttiende eeuw.’ Eerste afzonderlijke lessen over de natuurlijke historie, Nederlands Tijdschrift voor Geneeskunde 11: 265–284.
Tellez, Balthazar. 1660. Historia geral de Ethiopia a alta ou Preste Ioam e do que nella obraram os padres da Companhia de Iesus. Coimbra:Manoel Diaz.
Treviranus, Gottfried Reinhold. 1802–1822. Biologie, oder Philosophie der lebenden Natur für Naturforscher und Aerzte. Göttingen: J.F. Röwer.
Van Berkel, Karel. 1985. In het voetspoor van Stevin. Geschiedenis van de natuurwetenschap in Nederland 1580–1940. Amsterdam:Boom.
Van der Lott, Frans. 1762. “Kort bericht van den conger-aal, afte drilvisch.” Verhandelingen Hollandsche Maatschappye der Weetenschappen, Haarlem, 6 (2e stuk Berichten aan de Maatschappye gegeeven) 87–94.
Van der Lott, Frans. 1775. ‹Kurzer Auszug eines Briefs aus Rio Issequebo, den Zitterfisch oder sogenannten Kongeraal betreffend.’ Abhandlungen aus der Naturgeschichte, praktischen Arzneykunst und Chirurgie aus den Schriften der Harlemer und anderer holländischen Gesellschaften 1: 105–110.
van Musschenbroek, Petrus. 1762. Introductio ad philosophiam naturalem. Lugduni Batavorum:apud Sam. et Joh. Luchtmans.
Vijselaar, Joost. 2001. De magnetische geest. Het dierlijk magnetisme 1770–1830. Nijmegen:Sun, pp. 40–70.
Visser, R.P.W. 1970. De Nederlandse Geleerde genootschappen in de achttiende eeuw. In: Documentatieblad Werkgroep 18e Eeuw 1–10 (reprint HES, pp. 175–186) Utrecht.
Volta, Alessandro. 1800. ‹On the Electricity Excited by the Mere Contact of Conducting Substances of Different Species. Letter to Sir Joseph Banks, March 20 1800.’ Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London 90: 403–431.
Volta, Alessandro. 1918. Le opere di Alessandro Volta. Edizione nazionale sotto gli auspici della Reale Accademia dei Lincei e del Reale Istituto Lombardo di Scienze e Lettere, 1 vols. Milano:Hoepli.
von Haller, Albrecht. (ed). 1756–1760. Memoires sur la nature sensible et irritable des parties du corps animal… 4 tomes. Lausanne: M.-M. Bousquet.
—— 1757–1768. Elementa physiologiae corporis humani. 8 Vols. Lausannae: Sumptibus Marci-Michael. Bousquet, and Bernae, Sumptibus Societatis Tipographicae.
von Humboldt, Alexander. 1811. ‹Observations sur l’Anguille électrique (Gymnotus electricus, Lin.) du nouveau continent.’ Voyage de Humboldt et Bompland, Deuxième partie, Observations de zoologie et d’anatomie comparée 1: 50–93.
Walker, W. Cameron. 1937. ‹Animal Electricity Before Galvani.’ Annals of science 2: 84–113.
Walsh, John. 1773. ‹On the Electric Property of Torpedo: In a Letter to Ben. Franklin.’ Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 63: 461–479.
Walter, Richard. 1748. A voyage round the world, in the years 1740, 741, 1742, 1743, 1744 Compiled from his papers and materials by Richard Walter. London: Printed for the author by John and Paul Knapton.
Wheeler, Alwyne C. 1958. ‹The Gronovius Fish Collection: A Catalogue and Historical Account.’ Bulletin of the British Museum (Nat. Hist.) 1: 187–249.
Whittaker, Victor P. 1992. “The Torpedo in the Ancient World, Literature and Popular Culture.” The Cholinergic Neuron and Its Target: The Electromotor Innervation of the Electric Ray Torpedo as a Model. Boston:Birkhäuser, pp. 480–489.
Wu, Chau H. 1984. ‹Electric Fish and the Discovery of Animal Electricity.’ American Scientist 72: 598–607.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Koehler, P.J., Finger, S. & Piccolino, M. The “Eels” of South America: Mid-18th-Century Dutch Contributions to the Theory of Animal Electricity. J Hist Biol 42, 715–763 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-009-9186-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-009-9186-z