Abstract
During the 1930s, Aleksandr Promptov—a student of the founder of Russian population genetics Sergei Chetverikov—developed an elaborate concept of speciation in birds. He conducted field investigations aimed at giving a naturalistic content to the theoretical formulations and laboratory models of evolutionary processes advanced within the framework of population genetics, placing particular emphasis on the evolutionary role of bird behavior. Yet, although highly synthetic in combining biogeographical, taxonomic, genetic, ecological, and behavioral studies, Promptov’s speciation concept was ignored by the architects of the 1930s and 1940s evolutionary synthesis, including Theodosius Dobzhnasky, Ernst Mayr, and Julian Huxley. In this article, I argue that the story of Promptov’s concept and its reception by other evolutionists challenges the traditional presentation of the synthesis as a singular, international process of the unification of biology, which led to the creation of a universal synthetic theory of evolution. It suggests that during the same time period, within largely the same theoretical framework, there were multiple, intrinsically local, attempts at creating synthetic evolutionary concepts. These concepts were often quite particular—in their taxonomic applicability, in their explanations of various evolutionary factors, and in the range of disciplines unified in the synthesis. Apparently, these concepts ran contrary to the universal aspirations of the synthesis architects, and as a result, they were disregarded, first by the architects and later by historians of the evolutionary synthesis.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams Mark. B. 1968. The Founding of Population Genetics: Contributions of the Chetverikov School, 1924–1934. Journal of the History of Biology 1: 23–39
Adams, Mark. B. 1970. Towards a Synthesis: Population Concepts in Russian Evolutionary Thought, 1925–35. Journal of the History of Biology 3: 107–129
Adams, Mark. B. 1979. “From ‚Gene Fund’ to ‚Gene Pool’: on the Evolution of Evolutionary Language.” William Coleman and Camille Limoges (eds.), Studies in History of Biology, Vol. 3. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, pp. 241–285
Adams, Mark. B. 1980a. “Sergei Chetverikov, the Kol’tsov Institute, and the Evolutionary Synthesis.” Mayr and Provine (eds.), The Evolutionary Synthesis, pp. 242–278
Adams, Mark. B. 1980b. Science, Ideology, and Structure: The Kol’tsov Institute, 1900–1970 In: Lubrano Linda L., Solomon Susan G. (eds) The Social Context of Soviet Science. Westview Press, Boulder, CO, pp. 173–204
Adams, Mark. B. 1980c. “Severtsov and Schmalhauzen: Russian Morphology and the Evolutionary Synthesis.” Mayr and Provine (eds.), The Evolutionary Synthesis, pp. 193–228
Adams, Mark. B. 1988. A Missing Link in the Evolutionary Synthesis. Isis 79: 281–284
Adams, Mark. B. 1990. La génétique des populations était-elle une génétique évolutive? In: Fischer Jean-Louis, Schneider W. H. (eds) Histoire de la génétique. A.R.P.E.M., Paris, pp. 153–171
Adams, Mark B. (ed.) 1994. The Evolution of Theodosius Dobzhansky: Essays on his Life and Thought in Russia and America. Princeton: Princeton University Press
Adams, Mark B. 2002. “Little Evolution, Big Evolution” (unpublished manuscript)
Allen, Garland E. 1979. “Naturalists and Experimentalists: The Genotype and the Phenotype.” Coleman and Limoges (eds.), Studies in History of Biology, 3: 179–209
Babkov V. V. 1985. Moskovskaia shkola evolutsionnoi genetiki. Nauka, Moscow
Baldwin J. M. 1896. “A New Factor in Evolution.” American Naturalist 30: 441–451, 536–553
Beliaeva V. N., Golovinskaia, K. A., and N. B. Chefras. 1975. “D. D. Romashov i ego rol’ v razvitii genetiki,” Iz istorii biologii. Moscow: Nauka, 5: 76–91
Beatty John. 1986. The Synthesis and the Synthetic Theory. In: Bechtel W. (eds) Integrating Scientific Disciplines. Nijhoff, Dordrecht, pp. 125–135
Borrello Mark E. 2003. Synthesis and Selection: Wynne-Edwards’ Challenge to David Lack. Journal of the History of Biology 36: 531–566
Cain Joseph A. 1993. Common Problems and Cooperative Solutions: Organization Activity in Evolutionary Studies, 1936–1947. Isis 84: 1–25
Cain, Joseph A. 1994. Ernst Mayr as Community Architect: Launching the Society for the Study of Evolution and the Journal Evolution. Biology and Philosophy 9: 287–427
Cain, Joseph A. 1999. Regular Contact with Anyone Interested: Documents of the Society for the Study of Speciation, 1941. Riverside Press, Winona, MN
Cain, Joseph A. 2000. Towards a ‚Greater Degree of Integration’: The Society for the Study of Speciation, 1939–1941. British Journal for the History of Science 33: 85–108
Cain, Joe (ed.) 2004. Exploring the Borderlands. Documents of the Committee on Common Problems of Genetics, Paleontology, and Systematics, 1943–1944. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society
Chetverikov S. S. 1926. O nekotorykh momentakh evolutsionnogo protsessa s tochki zreniia sovremnnoi genetiki. Zhurnal Eksperimental’noi Biologii 2(1): 3–54
Chetverikov S. S. 1927. Teoreticheskaia predposylka genotipicheskogo analiza vidov roda Drozophila. In: Severtsov A. N., Matveev B. S. (eds) Trudy Vtorogo Sezda Zoologov, Anatomov i Gistologov SSSR. Glavnauka, Moscow, pp. 163–164
Chetverikov S. S. 1961. Concerning certain aspects of the evolutionary process from the standpoint of modern genetics. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 105: 167–195
Cushing J. E. 1941. Non-Genetic Mating Preference as a Factor in Evolution. Condor 43: 233–236
Cushing J. E. 1944. The Relation of Non-Heritable Food-Habits to Evolution. Condor 46: 265–271
Dietrich Michael R. 1995. Richard Goldschmidt’s ‚Heresies’ and the Evolutionary Synthesis. Journal of the History of Biology 28: 431–461
Diver, C. 1940. “The Problem of Closely Related Species Living in the Same Area.” Huxley (ed.), The New Systematics, pp. 303–328
Dobzhansky Th. 1935. A Critique of the Species Concept in Biology. Philosophy of Science, 2: 344–355
Dobzhansky Th. 1937. Genetics and the Origin of Species. 2nd ed. Columbia University Press, New York, p. 1941
Dobzhansky Th. 1980. “The Birth of the Genetic Theory of Evolution in the Soviet Union in the 1920s.” Mayr and Provine (eds.), The Evolutionary Synthesis, pp. 229–242
Eldridge N. 1985. Unfinished Synthesis: Biological Hierarchies and Modern Evolutionary Thought. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Elton Charles. 1930. Animal Ecology and Evolution. Claredon Press, Oxford
Formozov, A. A. 1999. “Promptov, Aleksandr Nikolaevich.” Moskovskie ornitologi. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo Universiteta, pp. 375–399
Gall Ia. M. 1997. G. F. Gauze: Ekolog i evoliutsionist. Almanakh, St. Petersburg
Grinnell John. 1924. Geography and Evolution. Ecology 5: 225–229
Haffer Jürgen. 1994. The Genesis of Erwin Stresemann’s ‚Aves’ (1923–1934) in the ‚Handbuch der Zoologie,’ and His Contribution to the Evolutionary Synthesis. Archives of Natural History 21: 201–216
Harwood Jonathan. 1994. Metaphysical Foundations of the Evolutionary Synthesis: A Historiographical Note. Journal of the History of Biology 27: 1–20
Huxley, Julian. (ed.) 1940. The New Systematics. London: Oxford University Press
Huxley, Julian. 1942. Evolution: The Modern Synthesis. Allen and Unwin, London
Huxley, Julian. 1945. Evolutionary Biology and Related Subjects. Nature 156: 254–256
Huxley, Julian, Hardy, A. C. and E. B. Ford (eds.) 1954. Evolution as a Process. London: Allen and Unwin
Junker Thomas, Uwe Hossfeld 2002. The Architects of the Evolutionary Synthesis in National Socialist Germany: Science and Politics. Biology and Philosophy 17(2): 223–249
Kashkarov D. N. 1939. Adaptivna li evolutsiia i chto takoe vidovye priznaki? Zoologicheskii zhurnal 18(4): 612–630
Khosfel’d U., Iunker T., Kolchinskii E. 2000. Protagonisty i glavnye nauchnye trudy po evoliutsionnomu sintezu v nemetskom iazykovom prostranstve. Voprosy istorii estestvoznaniia i tekhniki 1: 69–95
Kingsland Sharon E. 1985. Modeling Nature: Episodes in the History of Population Ecology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press
Kirpichnikov V. S. 1935. Rol’ nenasledstvennoi izmenchivosti v processe estestvennogo otbora (gipoteza o ‚kosvennom otbore’). Biologicheskii Zhurnal 4(5): 775–800
Kirpichnikov V. S. 1944. O gipotezakh nasledstvennogo zakrepleniia modifikatsii. Uspekhi Sovremennoi Biologi 18(3): 314–339
Kirpichnikov V. S. 1947. The Problem of Non-hereditary Adaptive Modifications (Coincident or Organic Selection). Journal of Genetics 48: 164–175
Kleinman Kim. 1999. His Own Synthesis: Corn, Edgar Anderson, and Evolutionary Theory in the 1940s. Journal of the History of Biology 32: 293–320
Kohler Robert E. 2002. Landscapes and Labscapes: Exploring the Lab-Field Border in Biology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press
Krementsov, N. L. 1989. “Chelovek i zhivotnoe: k istorii povedencheskikh sopostavlenii.” Povedenie Zhivotnykh i Cheloveka: Skhodstvo i Razlichiia. Pushchino: 6–28
Krementsov Nikolai. 1992. W. A. Wagner and the Origin of Russian Ethology. International Journal of Comparative Psychology 6: 61–70
Krementsov Nikolai. 1994. “Th. Dobzhansky and Russian Entomology: The Origin of His Ideas on Species and Speciation.” Adams (ed.), The Evolution of Theodosius Dobzhansky: 31–48
Krementsov Nikolai. 1996. A ‚Second Front’ in Soviet Genetics: The International Dimension of the Lysenko Controversy. Journal of the History of Biology 29: 229–250
Krementsov Nikolai. 1997. Stalinist Science. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
Krementsov Nikolai. 2005. International Science Between the World Wars: The Case of Genetics. London: Routledge
Lack David. 1933. Habitat selection in birds. Journal of Animal Ecology 2: 239–262
Lack David. 1937. Psychological Factors in Bird Distribution. British Birds 31: 130–136
Lack David. 1940. Habitat Selection and Speciation in Birds. British Birds 34: 80–84
Lack David. 1944. Ecological Aspects of Species Formation in Passerine Birds. Ibis 86: 260–286
Lack David. 1949. “The Significance of Ecological Isolation.” Jepsen, G. L., Mayr, E. and G. G. Simpson (eds.), Genetics, Paleontology, and Evolution. Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp. 299–308
Lack David. 1971. Ecological Isolation in Birds. Oxford: Claredon Press
Malinovskii A. A. 1939. Rol’ geneticheskikh i phenogeneticheskikh iavlenii v evoluitsii vida. Izvestiia AN SSSR Seriia Biologicheskaia 4: 575–614
Malinovskii A. A. 1947. “Khromosomnye inversii kak factor nakopleniia razlichii. Uchet migratsii v eksperimentakh v prirode. Vid kak evolutsionnoe tseloe.” Referaty nauchno-issledovatel’skikh rabot. Otdelenie biologicheskikh nauk AN SSSR za 1945 god. Moscow-Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR: 283–287
Mayr Ernst. 1940. Speciation Phenomena in Birds. American Naturalist 74: 249–278
Mayr Ernst. 1942. Systematics and the Origin of Species. New York: Columbia University Press
Mayr Ernst. 1947. Ecological Factors in Speciation. Evolution 1: 263–288
Mayr Ernst. 1980a. “Prologue.” Mayr and Provine (eds.), The Evolutionary Synthesis: 1–48
Mayr, Ernst and William Provine (eds) 1980. The Evolutionary Synthesis: Perspectives on the Unification of Biology. Cambridge: Harvard University Press
McDougall William. 1911. Body and Mind. New York: Macmillan
Mikulinskii, S. R. and Kolchinskii, E. I. (eds) 1983. Ravitie evolutsionnoi teorii v SSSR (1917–1970–e gody). Leningrad: Nauka
Morgan C. Lloyd. 1896. On Modification and Variation. Science 4: 733–740
Morgan T. 1924. Strukturnye osnovy nasledstvennosti. Moscow: GIZ
Pavlov I. P. 1923. New Research on Conditioned Reflexes. Science 58: 359–361
Pavlov I. P. 1925. Dvadtsatiletni Opyt Obektivnogo Izucheniia Vysshei Nervnoi Deiatel’nosti (Povedeniia) Zhivotnykh, 2d ed. Moscow-Leningrad: Gosizdat
Promptov A. N. 1924. Anikovskaia geneticheskaia stantsiia. Chelovek i Priroda 11: 873–882
Promptov A. N. 1926. “Genetika stroeniia taza kur.” A. S. Serebrovskii (ed.), Genetika domashnei kuritsy. Moscow
Promptov A. N. 1927a. Abberatsii i izmenchivost’ pesni ptits kak kriterii v izuchenii postoianstva obitaniia osobi. Uragus 2: 2–3
Promptov A. N. 1927b. Zhizn’ zimnikh ptits Zvenigorodskogo uezda. Biulleten’ Zvenigorodskogo obshchestva po izucheniiu mestnogo kraia 1–2: 7–17
Promptov A. N. 1927c. Izmenchivost’ i postoianstvo pesni u ptits. Estestvoznanie v shkole 1: 61–67
Promptov A. N. 1927d. Fauna pevchikh ptits. Trudy Gidrofiziologicheskoi stantsii Instituta Eksperimental’noi Biologii Narkomzdrava 1: 1–32
Promptov A. N. 1928a. Gibridizatsia v’iurkov. Soobshchenie I. Zhurnal Eksperimental’noi biologii 4(1): 30–64
Promptov A. N. 1928b. Inheritance of structural types in the dorsacrum of domestic poultry. Journal of Genetics 20(1): 29–51
Promptov A. N. 1929. Pleotropnaia genovariztsiia ‚polimorfa’ u Drosophila funeberis. Zhurnal Eksperimental’noi Biologii 5(3–4): 149–181
Promptov A. N. 1930a. Geograficheskaia izmenchivost’ pesni ziablika (Fringilla coelebs L.) v sviazi s obshchimi voprosami sezonnykh pereletov ptits. Russkii Zoologicheskii Zhurnal 10(3): 17–42
Promptov A. N. 1930b. Die geographische Variablitiat des Buchfinkenschlags (Fringilla coelebs L.) in Zussammenhang mitt etlichen allgemeinen Fragen der Saisonvogelzuge. Biologishche Zentralblatt 50: 478–503
Promptov A. N. 1931. Vliianie zhestkikh ul’trafioletovykh luchei na poiavlenie nasledstvennykh izmenenii u Drosophila. Zhurnal Eksperimental’noi Biologii 7(5–6): 552–569
Promptov A. N. 1932a. The effect of short ultra-violet rays on the appearance of hereditary variation in Drosophila melanogaster. Journal of Genetics 26(1): 59–74
Promptov A. N. 1932b. Kachestvennyi i kolichestvennyi uchet fauny ptits Izmailovskogo parka pod Moskvoi. Zoologicheskii zhurnal 11(1): 143–185
Promptov A. N. Biologiia dubrovnika (Emberizia aureola Pall.) v sviazi s voprosom o rasselenii ptits. Zoologicheskii zhurnal, 13(3): 523–539
Promptov A. N. 1934b. Gen i priznak v ontogeneze. Uspekhi Sovremennoi Biologii 13(2): 145–180
Promptov A. N. 1934c. Ob ekologicheskikh faktorakh izoliatsii u ptits. Zoologicheskii zhurnal 13(4): 616–628
Promptov A. N. 1934d. Evolutsionnoe znachenie migratsii ptits. Zoologicheskii zhurnal 13(3): 409–436
Promptov A. N. 1936a. Gibridizatsiia v’iurkov. Soobshchenie III Zoologicheskii zhurnal 15(4): 640–656
Promptov A. N. 1936b. Ekologo-geneticheskie factory evoliutsionnoi divergentsii u ptits. Biologicheskii Zhurnal 5(6): 1001–1010
Promptov A. N. 1936c. Obshchaia Biologiia. Moscow: Biomedgiz
Promptov A. N. 1937. Ptitsy v prirode: Rukovodstvo dlia opredeleniia i izucheniia ptits v prirodnykh usloviiakh. Moscow: GIZ
Promptov A. N. 1938a. L A. Portenko. Fauna ptits vnepoliarnoi chasti Severnogo Urala. Vestnik AN SSSR 3–4: 122–124
Promptov A. N. 1938b. Eksperimenty po izucheniiu ekologicheskoi plastichnosti nekotorykh vidov ptits. Zoologicheskii zhurnal 17(3): 533–539
Promptov A. N. 1940. Vidovoi stereotip povedeniia i ego formirovanie u dikikh ptits. Doklady AN SSSR 27(2): 171–175
Promptov A. N. 1941. Sezonnye migratsii ptits. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR
Promptov A. N. 1944. Golosovaia imitatsiia vorob’inykh ptits kak odno iz spetsificheskikh svoistv ikh vysshei nervnoi deiatel’nosti. Doklady AN SSSR 45(6): 278–281
Promptov A. N. 1956. Ocherki po probleme biologicheskoi adaptatsii povedeniia vorob’inykh ptits. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR
Promptov A. N., Lukina E. V. 1937. Izuchenie osedlosti sinits metodom kol’tsevaniia. Zoologicheskii zhurnal 16(4): 688–699
Promptov, A. and Sungurov, A. 1925. Ocherki iz zhizni pevchikh ptits. Moscow
Reid Robert G. B. 1985. Evolutionary Theory: The Unfinished Synthesis. London: Croom Helm
Reif Wolf-Ernst, Junker Tomas, Hosfeld Uwe 2000. The Synthetic Theory of Evolution: General Problems and the German Contribution to the Synthesis. Theory in Biosciences 119: 41–91
Richards Robert J. 1987. Darwin and the Emergence of Evolutionary Theories of Mind and Behavior. Chicago: University of Chicago Press
Roll-Hansen Nils. 1978. Drosophila Genetics: A Reductionist Research Program. Journal of the History of Biology 11: 159–210
Schloegel Judy Johns. 1999. From Anomaly To Unification: Tracy Sonneborn and the Species Problem in Protozoa, 1954–1957. Journal of the History of Biology 32: 93–132
Smocovitis Vassiliki B. 1992. Unifying Biology: The Evolutionary Synthesis and Evolutionary Biology. Journal of the History of Biology 25: 1–65
Smocovitis Vassiliki B. 1994. Organizing Evolution: Founding the Society for the Study of Evolution (1939–1950). Journal of the History of Biology 27: 241–309
Smocovitis Vassiliki B. 1996. Unifying Biology: The Evolutionary Synthesis and Evolutionary Biology. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
Stanchinskii, V. V. 1927a. “Ekologicheskaia evoliutsiia i formirovanie faun.” Trudy Smolenskogo Obshchestva estestvoispytatelei i vrachei, 189–204
Stanchinskii, V. V. 1927b. Izmenshivost’ organizmov i ee znachenie v evoliutsii. Smolensk
Streseman Erwin. 1943. Oekologische Sippen-, Rassen- und Artunterschiede bei Vogeln. Journal fur Ornitologie 91: 305–324
Thorpe, W. H. 1940. “Ecology and Future of Systematics.” Huxley (ed.) The New Systematics: 341–364
Thorpe, W. H. 1945a. Animal Learning and Evolution. Nature 156: 46
Thorpe, W. H. 1945b. The Evolutionary Significance of Habitat Selection. Journal of Animal Ecology 14: 67–70
Thorpe, W. H. 1974. David Lambert Lack, 1910–1973 Biographical Memoirs of the Fellows of the Royal Society 20: 271–293
Timofeeff-Ressovsky, N. W. 1940. “Mutations and geographical variation.” Huxley (ed.) The New Systematics: 73–136
Waisbren Steven James 1988. The Importance of Morphology in the Evolutionary Synthesis as Demonstrated by the Contributions of the Oxford Group: Goodrich, Huxley, and de Beer. Journal of the History of Biology 21: 291–330
Acknowledgements
I am indebted to many people for their help in my search for relevant materials, particularly, Promptov’s sister, Liubov Promptova, his wife, Elizaveta Lukina, and his nephew, Aleksandr Formozov, who generously shared with me family documents and personal memories. I am profoundly grateful to Mark B. Adams for numerous discussions of Soviet evolutionary studies and an opportunity to read some of his manuscripts on the subject, which helped clarify many issues addressed in this work. I am also grateful to Joe Cain for inviting me to a conference on evolutionary synthesis, which provided a necessary incentive to revisit Promptov’s story and a stimulating environment to rethink some of my earlier interpretations. My thanks also go to Paul Faber and anonymous reviewers for the Journal of the History of Biology, for their encouragement and valuable criticisms.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Krementsov, N. A Particular Synthesis: Aleksandr Promptov and Speciation in Birds. J Hist Biol 40, 637–682 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-007-9123-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-007-9123-y