Abstract
This paper examines how the 19th-century British naturalist Alfred Russel Wallace used biogeographical mapping practices to draw a boundary line between Malay and Papuan groups in the colonial East Indies in the 1850s. Instead of looking for a continuous gradient of variation between Malays and Papuans, Wallace chose to look for a sharp discontinuity between them. While Wallace’s “human biogeography” paralleled his similar project to map plant and animal distributions in the same region, he invoked distinctive “mental and moral” features as more decisive than physical ones. By following Wallace in the field, we can see his field mapping practices in action – how he conquered the problem of local particularity in the case of human variation. His experiences on the periphery of expanding European empires, far from metropolitan centers, shaped Wallace’s observations in the field. Taking his cues from colonial racial categories and his experiences collaborating with local people in the field, Wallace constructed the boundary line between the Malay and Papuan races during several years of work in the field criss-crossing the archipelago as a scientific collector. This effort to map a boundary line in the field was a bold example of using the practices of survey science to raise the status of field work by combining fact gathering with higher-level generalizing, although the response back in the metropole was less than enthusiastic. Upon his return to Britain in the 1860s, Wallace found that appreciation for observational facts he had gathered in the field was not accompanied by agreement with his theoretical interpretations and methods for doing human biogeography.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
1854. “A Manual of Ethnological Inquiry.” Journal of the Ethnological Society 3: 193–208.
1857. “Proceedings of Natural-History Collectors in Foreign Countries.” Zoologist 15: 5414–5416.
1869. “Reviews.” Journal of the Ethnological Society 1 (n.s.): 82.
1869. “Wallace’s Malay Archipelago.” Anthropological Review 7: 310–323.
L Agassiz (1854) Sketch of the Natural Provinces of the Animal World and their Relation to the Different Types of Man J.C. Nott Geo. R. Glidden (Eds) Types of Mankind Lippincott, Grambo Philadelphia lviii–lxxvi
H Barth (1860) ArticleTitle“A General Historical Description of the State of Human Society in Northern Central Africa” Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 30 112–128
Henry Walter Bates (1863) The Naturalist on the River Amazons Murray London
Barbara G. Beddall (1988) ArticleTitle“Darwin and Divergence” Journal of the History of Biology 21 1–68
C.C Blake (1864) ArticleTitle“Report on the Anthropological Papers” Journal of the Anthropological Society 2 i–v
Peter J Bowler (1984) ArticleTitle“Wallace and Darwinism” Science 224 277–278
Arnold C Brackman (1980) A Delicate Arrangement Times Books New York
B.C Brodie (1856) ArticleTitle“Address to the Ethnological Society of London Delivered at the Anniversary Meeting on 27 May 1853” Journal of the Ethnological Society 4 98–103
John Langdon Brooks (1984) Just Before the Origin Columbia University Press New York
Janet Browne (1983) The Secular Ark: Studies in the History of Biogeography Yale University Press New Haven
Jane Camerini (1993) ArticleTitle“Evolution, Biogeography, and Maps: An Early History of Wallace’s Line” Isis 84 700–727 Occurrence Handle10.1086/356637
Jane Camerini (1996) ArticleTitle“Wallace in the Field” Osiris 11 44–65 Occurrence Handle10.1086/368754
Jane Camerini (1997) Remains of the Day: Early Victorians in the Field B. Lightman (Eds) Victorian Science in Context University of Chicago Press Chicago 354–377
Jane Camerini (Eds) (2002) Alfred Russel Wallace Reader Johns Hopkins University Press Baltimore
Susan Feye Cannon (1978) Science in Culture: The Early Victorian Period Science History Publications New York
L.L. Cavalli-Sforza P. Menozzi A Piazza (1994) The History and Geography of Human Genes Princeton University Press Princeton
Robert Chambers (1844) Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation Churchill London
John Cleghorn (1867–69) ArticleTitle“Is the Character of the Scotch the Expression of the Soil of Scotland?” Memoirs of the Anthropological Society 3 167–181
James Clifford (1997) Spatial Practices: Fieldwork, Travel, and the Disciplining of Anthropology Akhil Gupta James Ferguson (Eds) Anthropological Locations: Boundaries and Grounds of a Field Science University of California Press Berkeley 185–222
John Crawfurd (1848) ArticleTitle“On the Malayan and Polynesian Languages and Races” Journal of the Ethnological Society 1 330–374
John Crawfurd (1861) ArticleTitle“On the Effects of Comixture, Locality, Climate, and Food on the Races of Man” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 1 76–92
John Crawfurd (1865) ArticleTitle“On the Early Migrations of Man” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 3 335–350
John Crawfurd (1866) ArticleTitle“On the Physical and Mental Characteristics of the Negro” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 4 212–239
John Crawfurd (1868) ArticleTitle“On the Malayan Race of Man and its Prehistoric Career” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 7 119–133
C.J Crittenden (1849) ArticleTitle“Memoir on the Western or Edoor Tribes, Inhabiting the Somali Coast of N.-E. Africa” Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 19 49–76
L.P Curtis (1968) Anglo-Saxons and Celts: A Study of Anti-Irish Prejudice in Victorian England Conference on British Studies Bridgeport, Conn
Charles Darwin (1839) Journal of Researches into the Natural History and Geology of the Countries Visited during the Voyage of the H.M.S. Beagle Murray London
J. Bernard Davis (1870) ArticleTitle“Oceanic Races, their Hair, etc., and the Value of Skulls in the Classification of Man” Anthropological Review 8 183–196
E Dieffenbach (1848) ArticleTitle“The Study of Ethnology” Journal of the Ethnological Society 1 15–26
B Douglas (1999) ArticleTitle“Science and the Art of Representing ‘Savages’: Reading ‘Race’ in Text and Image in South Seas Voyaging Literature” History and Anthropology 11 157–201
John R Durant (1979) ArticleTitle“Scientific Naturalism and Social Reform in the Thought of Alfred Russel Wallace” British Journal for the History of Science 12 31–58
William Henry Edwards (1847) A Voyage Up the Amazon Murray London
J Endersby (2003) ArticleTitle“Escaping Darwin’s Shadow” Journal of the History of Biology 36 385–403 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1024442921798
M Fichman (1977) ArticleTitle“Wallace: Zoogeography and the Problem of Land Bridges” Journal of the History of Biology 10 45–63 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00126094
M Fichman (1981) Alfred Russel Wallace Twayne Boston
M Fichman (2004) An Elusive Victorian: The Evolution of Alfred Russel Wallace University of Chicago Press Chicago
Adm Fitzroy (1861) ArticleTitle“Outline Sketch of the Principal Varieties and Early Migrations of the Human Race” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 1 1–11
J.S Furnivall (1948) Colonial Policy and Practice: A Comparative Study of Burma and Netherlands India Cambridge University Press Cambridge
J.H.F. Sollewijn Gelpke (1993) ArticleTitle“On the Origin of the Name Papua” Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde 149 318–332
Ann Gibbons (2001) ArticleTitle“The Peopling of the Pacific” Science 291 1735–1737
Wilma George (1981) Wallace and His Line T.C. Whitmore (Eds) Wallace’s Line and Plate Tectonics Clarendon Oxford 3–8
T Hodgkin (1848) ArticleTitle“The Progress of Ethnology” Journal of the Ethnological Society 1 27–45
Reginald Horsman (1976) ArticleTitle“Origins of Racial Anglo-Saxonism in Great Britain before 1850” Journal of the History of Ideas 37 387–410
T.H Huxley (1865) ArticleTitle“On the Methods and Results of Ethnology” Fortnightly Review 1 257–277
T.H Huxley (1870) ArticleTitle“The Geographical Distribution of the Chief Modifications of Mankind” Journal of the Ethnological Society 2 411–412
John Inglis (1854) ArticleTitle“Report of a Missionary Tour in the New Hebrides” Journal of the Ethnological Society 3 53–85
Greta Jones (2002) ArticleTitle“Alfred Russel Walace, Robert Owen, and the Theory of Natural Selection” British Journal for the History of Science 35 73–96
M.P Kinch (1980) ArticleTitle“Geographical Distribution and the Origin of Life: The Development of Early Nineteenth-century British Explanations” Journal of the History of Biology 13 91–119 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00125355
Robert Knox (1850) The Races of Men: A Fragment Lea & Blanchard Philadelphia
Robert E Kohler (2002a) Landscapes and Labscapes: Exploring the Lab-Field Boundary University of Chicago Press Chicago
Robert E Kohler (2002b) ArticleTitle“Place and Practice in Field Biology” History of Science 40 189–210
David Kohn (1981) ArticleTitle“On the Origin of the Principle of Diversity” Science 213 1105–1108
Malcolm Jay Kottler (1974) ArticleTitle“Alfred Russel Wallace, the Origin of Man, and Spiritualism” Isis 65 145–192 Occurrence Handle10.1086/351256
Henrika Kuklick (1991) The Savage Within: The Social History of British Anthropology, 1885–1945 Cambridge University Press New York
Henrika Kuklick (1994) The Color Blue: From Research in the Torres Strait to an Ecology of Human Behavor Roy MacLeod Philip F. Rehbock (Eds) Darwin’s Laboratory: Evolutionary Theory and Natural History in the Pacific University of Hawaii Press Honolulu 339–367
Henrika Kuklick (1996) ArticleTitle“Islands in the Pacific: Darwinian Biogeography and British Anthropology” American Ethnologist 23 611–638 Occurrence Handle10.1525/ae.1996.23.3.02a00090
Henrika Kuklick (1997) After Ishmael: The Fieldwork Tradition and Its Future Akhil Gupta James Ferguson (Eds) Anthropological Locations: Boundaries and Grounds of a Field Science University of California Press Berkeley 47–65
Henrika Kuklick Robert E Kohler (1996) ArticleTitle“Introduction [to Science in the Field” Osiris 11 1–14 Occurrence Handle10.1086/368752
Labuan, Lord Bishop of. 1863. “On the Wild Tribes of the North-west Coast of Borneo.” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 2: 24–34.
James Larson (1986) ArticleTitle“Not without a Plan: Geography and Natural History in the Late Eighteenth Century” Journal of the History of Biology 19 447–488 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00138287
Robert Gordon Latham (1850) The Natural History of the Varieties of Man Voorst London
Robert Gordon Latham (1861) ArticleTitle“On the Pagan (Non-Mahometan) Populations of the Indian Archipelago” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 1 202–211
William Lawrence (1823) Lectures on Physiology, Zoology, and the Natural History of Man EditionNumber3 Smith London
Edward Lurie (1954) ArticleTitle“Louis Agassiz and the Races of Man” Isis 45 227–242 Occurrence Handle10.1086/348335
Thomas Lysaght (1849) ArticleTitle“Report on the River Nunez, its Trade and Resources” Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 19 29–31
D Mackintosh (1861) ArticleTitle“Results of Ethnological Observations Made during the Last Ten Years in England and Wales” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 1 211–221
D Mackintosh (1866) ArticleTitle“Comparative Anthropology of England and Wales” Anthropological Review 4 47–61
H. Lewis McKinney (1966) ArticleTitle“Alfred Russel Wallace and the Discovery of Natural Selection” Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 201 333–357
H. Lewis McKinney (1969) ArticleTitle“Wallace’s Earliest Observations on Evolution: 28 December 1845” Isis 60 370–373 Occurrence Handle10.1086/350505
H. Lewis McKinney (1972) Wallace and Natural Selection Yale University Press New Haven
James Moore (1997) Wallace’s Malthusian Moment Bernard Lightman (Eds) Victorian Science in Context University of Chicago Press Chicago 290–311
M. Henri Mouhot (1862) ArticleTitle“Notes on Cambodia, the Lao Country, &c” Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 32 142–149
Friedrich Müller (1870) ArticleTitle“The Chief Races of Mankind” Anthropological Review 8 93–94
C.O. Groom Napier (1867) ArticleTitle“Table of Human Races, Classed in Accordance with the Moral and Intellectual Characteristics” Journal of the Anthropological Society 5 clx–clxviii
Gareth Nelson (1978) ArticleTitle“From Candolle to Croizat: Comments on the History of Biogeography” Journal of the History of Biology 11 269–305 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00389302
Malcolm Nicolson (1987) ArticleTitle“Alexander von Humboldt, Humboldtian Science, and the Origins of the Study of Vegetation” History of Science 25 167–194
Alex Soojung-Kim Pang (1996) ArticleTitle“Gender, Culture, and Astrophysical Fieldwork: Elizabeth Campbell and the Lick Observatory–Crocker Eclipse Expeditions” Osiris 11 15–43 Occurrence Handle10.1086/368753
L. Owen Pike (1865–66) ArticleTitle“On the Psychical Characteristics of the English People” Memoirs of the Anthropological Society 2 163–188
James Cowles Prichard (1813) Researches into the Physical History of Man Arch London
James Cowles Prichard (1843) The Natural History of Man Bailliere London
James Cowles Prichard (1848) ArticleTitle“On the Relations of Ethnology with the Other Branches of Knowledge” Journal of the Ethnological Society 1 301–329
Robert Pringle (1970) Rajahs and Rebels: The Ibans of Sarawak under Brooke Rule, 1841–1941 Cornell University Press Ithaca, N.Y
Wm.T Pritchard (1863–64) ArticleTitle“Viti and Its Inhabitants” Memoirs of the Anthropological Society 1 198–209
Peter Raby (2001) Alfred Russel Wallace: A Life Princeton University Press Princeton
Philip F Rehbock (1983) The Philosophical Naturalists: Themes in Early Nineteenth-Century British Biology University of Wisconsin Press Madison
Evellen Richards (1989) ArticleTitle“The ‘Moral Anatomy’ of Robert Knox: The Interplay between Biological and Social Thought in Victorian Scientific Naturalism” Journal of the History of Biology 22 373–436 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00401576
Arthur H Robinson (1982) Early Thematic Mapping in the History of Cartography University of Chicago Press Chicago
Helen M Rozwadowski (1996) ArticleTitle“Small World: Forging a Scientific Maritime Culture for Oceanography” Isis 87 409–429 Occurrence Handle10.1086/357568
Martin Rudwick (1976) ArticleTitle“The Emergence of a Visual Language for Geological Science 1760–1840” History of Science 14 149–195
Martin Rudwick (1996) ArticleTitle“Geological Travel and Theoretical Innovation: the Role of ‘Liminal’ Experience” Social Studies of Science 26 143–159
Spencer St. John (1862) ArticleTitle“Observations on the North-west Coast of Borneo” Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 32 217–234
Spencer St. John (1863) ArticleTitle“Wild Tribes of the North-west Coast of Borneo” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 2 232–243
Lynette Schumaker (1996) ArticleTitle“A Tent with a View: Colonial Officers, Anthropologists, and the Making of the Field in Northern Rhodesia, 1937–1960” Osiris 11 IssueID2nd s. 237–258
Joel S Schwartz (1984) ArticleTitle“Darwin, Wallace, and the Descent of Man” Journal of the History of Biology 17 271–289 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00143735
Joel S Schwartz (1990) ArticleTitle“Darwin, Wallace, and Huxley, and the Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation” Journal of the History of Biology 23 127–153 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00158157
James A Secord (2000) Victorian Sensation The Extraordinary Publication, Reception, and Secret Authorship of Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation University of Chicago Press Chicago
Michael Shermer (2002) In Darwin’s Shadow: The Life and Science of Alfred Russel Wallace; A Biographical Study on the Psychology of History Oxford University Press Oxford
Ross A Slotten (2004) The Heretic in Darwin’s Court: The Life of Alfred Russel Wallace Columbia University Press New York
Roger Smith (1972) ArticleTitle“Alfred Russel Wallace: Philosophy of Nature and Man” British Journal for the History of Science 6 177–199
Charles H Smith (1992) Alfred Russel Wallace on Spiritualism, Man, and Evolution: An Analytical Essay C.H. Smith Torrington, Conn
George W Stocking (1971) ArticleTitle“What’s in a Name? The Origins of the Royal Anthropological Institute (1837–71)” Man 6 369–390
George W Stocking (1973) From Chronology to Ethnology: James Cowles Prichard and British Anthropology, 1800–1850 Stocking (Eds) Researches into the Physical History of Man University of Chicago Press Chicago ix–cx
George W Stocking (1983) The Ethnographer’s Magic: Fieldwork in British Anthropology from Tylor to Malinowski G. Stocking (Eds) Observers Observed: Essays on Ethnographic Fieldwork University of Wisconsin Press Madison 70–120
George W Stocking (1987) Victorian Anthropology Free Press New York
George W Stocking (1995) After Tylor: British Social Anthropology, 1888–1951 University of Wisconsin Press Madison
William Swainson (1835) A Treatise on the Geography and Classification of Animals Longman Rees London
John Edward Terrell Kevin M. Kelly Paul Rainbird (2001) ArticleTitle“Foregone Conclusions? In Search of ‘Papuans’ and ‘Austronesians.’” Current Anthropology 42 97–124 Occurrence Handle10.1086/318436
Nicholas Thomas (1989) ArticleTitle“The Force of Ethnology: Origins and Significance of the Melanesia/Polynesia Division” Current Anthropology 30 27–41, 211–213
Thomas, Nicholas. 1997. “Melanesians and Polynesians: Ethnic Typifications Inside and Outside Anthropology.” In Oceania: Visions, Artifacts, Histories. Durham. N.C.: Duke University Press, pp. 133–155.
Carl A Trocki (1999) Political Structures in the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries Nicholas Tarling (Eds) The Cambridge History of Southeast Asia, Volume 3: From c. 1800 to the 1930s Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Urry, James. 1972. “Notes and Queries on Anthropology and the Development of Field Methods in British Anthropology, 1870–1920.” Proceedings of the Royal Anthropological Institute (1972): 45–57, reprinted in Urry, 1993, pp. 17–40.
James Urry (1982) ArticleTitle“From Zoology to Ethnology: A. C. Haddon’s Conversion to Anthropology” Canberra Anthropology 5 58–85
James Urry (1984) Englishmen, Celts, and Iberians: The Ethnographic Survey of the United Kingdom, 1892–1899 George W. Stocking (Eds) Functionalism Historicized: Essays on British Social Anthropology University of Wisconsin Press Madison 83–105
James Urry (1993) Before Social Anthropology: Essays on the History of British Anthropology Harwood Chur, Switzerland
Jeremy Vetter (2004) ArticleTitle“Science along the Railroad: Expanding Field Work in the US Central West” Annals of Science 61 187–211
Alfred Russel Wallace (1853) A Narrative of Travels on the Amazon and Rio Negro, with an Account of the Native Tribes, and Observations on Climate, Geology, and Natural History of the Amazon Valley Reeve London
Alfred Russel Wallace (1855) ArticleTitle“On the Law which Has Regulated the Introduction of New Species” Annals and Magazine of Natural History 16 IssueID2nd s. 184–196
Alfred Russel Wallace (1856) ArticleTitle“Notes of a Journey up the Sadong River, in North-West Borneo” Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society 1 193–205
Alfred Russel Wallace (1858) ArticleTitle“On the Arru Islands” Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society 2 163–170
Alfred Russel Wallace (1859) ArticleTitle“On the Tendency of Varieties to Depart Indefinitely from the Original Type” Journal of the Proceedings of the Linnean Society, Zoology 3 53–62
Alfred Russel Wallace (1860) ArticleTitle“Notes of a Voyage to New Guinea” Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 30 127–177
Wallace, Alfred Russel 1863a. “On the Varieties of Man in the Malay Archipelago.” Report of the 33rd Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, pp. 147–148.
Alfred Russel Wallace (1863b) ArticleTitle“Varieties of Man in the Malay Archipelago” Anthropological Review 1 441–444
Alfred Russel Wallace (1864) ArticleTitle“The Origin of Human Races and the Antiquity of Man Deduced from the Theory of ‘Natural Selection’” Journal of the Anthropological Society 2 clviii–clxxxvii
Alfred Russel Wallace (1865) ArticleTitle“On the Varieties of Man in the Malay Archipelago” Transactions of the Ethnological Society 3 196–215
Alfred Russel Wallace (1867) ArticleTitle“The Polynesians and their Migrations” Quarterly Journal of Science 4 161–166
Alfred Russel Wallace (1869) The Malay Archipelago: The Land of the Orang-utan and the Bird of Paradise; A Narrative of Travel with Studies of Man and Nature Macmillan London
Alfred Russel Wallace (1876) ArticleTitle“Review of The Races of Man and their Geographical Distribution, by Oscar Peschel, 1876” Nature 15 174–176
Alfred Russel Wallace (1879) ArticleTitle“New Guinea and Its Inhabitants” Contemporary Review 34 421–441
Alfred Russel Wallace (1880) ArticleTitle“New Guinea” Nature 23 175–178
Alfred Russel Wallace (1905) My Life: A Record of Events and Opinions NumberInSeries2 Chapman & Hall London
Kentwood D Wells (1971) ArticleTitle“Sir William Lawrence (1783–1867): A Study of Pre-Darwinian Ideas on Heredity and Variation” Journal of the History of Biology 4 319–361 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00138316
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Vetter, J. Wallace’s Other Line: Human Biogeography and Field Practice in the Eastern Colonial Tropics. J Hist Biol 39, 89–123 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-005-6543-4
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-005-6543-4