Abstract
We investigate the nexus between mental health outcomes in nursing home residents and the use of physical restraints. Previous studies in this area used limited statistical tests such as correlations and t-tests, that could not account for potential biases, such as residents who become mentally disturbed may be most likely to be restrained. We use propensity matching models that are less susceptible to this bias and data from the Minimum Data Set, representing approximately 2,000 residents over a period of 6 years. Our results clearly show that restrained residents are more likely to become more impaired with respect to cognitive performance, depression, and social engagement. We conclude that if facilities reduce restraint use then the prevalence of resident mental health problems will also likely decline.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Achterberg, W. P., van Campen, C., Pot, A. M., Kerkstra, A., & Ribbe, M. W. (1999). Effects of the resident assessment instrument on the care process and health outcomes in nursing homes. A review of the literature. Scandinavian Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 31, 131–137.
Berg, K., Mor, V., Morris, J., Murphy K. M., Moore, T., & Harris, Y. (2002). Identification and evaluation of existing nursing homes quality indicators. Health Care Financing Review, 23, 19–36.
Burns, B. J., Wagner, H. R., Taube, J. E., Magaziner J., Permutt, T., & Landerman, L. R. (1993). Mental health service use by the elderly in nursing homes. American Journal of Public Health, 83, 331–337.
Burrows, A. B., Morris, J. N., Simon, S. E., Hirdes, J. P., & Phillips, C. (2000). Development of a minimum data set-based depression rating scale for use in nursing homes. Age Ageing, 29, 165–172.
Burton, L. C., German, P. S., Rovner, B. W., & Brant, L. J. (1992). Physical restraint use and cognitive decline among nursing home residents. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 40, 811–816.
Castle, N. G. (2000). Nursing homes increasing and decreasing restraint use.Medical Care, 38, 1154-1163.
Castle N. G., & Mor V. (1998). The use of physical restraints in nursing homes: A review of the literature since the Nursing Home Reform Act of 1987.Medical Care Research and Review, 55, 139–170.
Cherry, R. L. (1991). Agents of nursing home quality of care: Ombudsmen and staff rations revisited. The Gerontologist, 31, 302–308.
Coleman, B. (1991). The Nursing Home Reform Act of 1987: Provisions, policy, prospects. Boston, MA: University of Massachusetts at Boston Gerontology Institute.
Coleman E.A. (1993). Physical restraint use in nursing home patients with dementia. Journal of the American Medical Association, 270, 2114–2115.
D’Agostino, R. B. (1998). Propensity score methods for bias reduction in the comparison of a treatment to a non-randomized control group. Statistics in Medicine, 17, 2265–2281.
Emerson-Lombardo, N. B., Fogel, B. S., Robinson, G. K., & Weiss, H. P. (1995). Achieving mental health of nursing home residents: Overcoming barriers to mental health care. Journal of Mental Health and Aging, 1, 165–203.
Evans, L. K., & Strumpf, N. E. (1989). Tying down the elderly: A review of the literature on physical restraint. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 37, 65–74.
Field, T. S., Gurwitz, J. H., Avorn, J., McCormick D., Jain S., Eckler, M., Benser, M., & Bates D. W. (2001). Risk factors for adverse drug events among nursing home residents.Archives of Internal Medicine, 161, 1629–1634.
Folmar, S., & Wilson H. (1989). Social behavior and physical restraints. The Gerontologist, 29, 650–653.
Frederiksen, K., Tariot, P., & De Jonghe, E. (1996). Minimum Data Set Plus (MDS+) scores compared with scores from five rating scales. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 44, 305–309.
Fries, B. E., Schneider, D. P., Foley, W. J., Gavazzi, M., Burke, R., & Cornelius, E. (1994). Refining a case-mix measure for nursing homes: Resource Utilization Groups (RUG-III). Medical Care, 32, 668–685.
Gruber-Baldini, A. L., Zimmerman, S. I., Mortimore, E., & Magaziner, J. (2000). The validity of the minimum data set in measuring the cognitive impairment of persons admitted to nursing homes. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 48, 1601–1606.
Gurwitz, J. H., Field, T. S., Avorn, J., McCormick, D., Jain, S., Eckler, M., Benser, M., Edmondson, A. C., & Bates, D. W. (2000). Incidence and preventability of adverse drug events in nursing homes. The American Journal of Medicine, 109, 87–94.
Hartmaier, S. L., Sloane, P. D., Guess, H.A., Koch, G. G., Mitchell, C. M., & Phillips, C. D. (1995). Validation of the minimum data set cognitive performance scale: Agreement with the Mini-Mental State Examination. Journal of Gerontology, 50A, M128–M133.
Hawes, C., Morris, J. N., Phillips, C. D., Mor, V., Fries, B. E., & Nonemaker, S. (1995). Reliability estimates for the minimum data set for nursing homes residents assessment and care screening. Gerontologist, 35, 172–178.
Kane, R. L., Williams, C. C., Williams, T. F., & Kane, R. A. (1993). Restraining restraints: Changes in a standard of care. Annual Review of Public Health, 14, 545–584.
Krauss, N. A., & Altman, B. M. (1998). Characteristics of nursing home residents—1996. MEPS Research Findings No. 5. AHCPR; Rockville, MD.
Ljunggren, G., Phillips, C.D., & Sgadari, A. (1997). Comparisons of restraint use in nursing homes in eight countries. Age and Ageing, 26, Suppl 2, 43–47.
Lofgren, R. P., MacPherson, D. S., Granieri, K., Myllenbeck, S., & Sprafka, J. M. (1989). Mechanical restraints on the medical wards: Are protective devices safe? American Journal of Public Health, 79, 735–758.
Marks, W. (1992). Physical restraints in the practice of medicine: Current concepts. Archives of Internal Medicine, 15, 2203–2206.
Mor, V., Branco, K., Fleishman, J., Hawes, C., Phillips, C., Morris, J. N., & Fries, B. (1995). The structure of social engagement among nursing home residents. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 50B, P1–P8.
Morris, J. N., Fries, B. E., Mehr, D. R., Hawes, C., Phillips, C., Mor, V., & Lipsitz, L. A. (1994). MDS Cognitive Performance Scale. Journal of Gerontology: Medical Sciences, 49, M174–M182.
Morris, J. N., Hawes, C., Fries, B. E., Phillips, C. D., Mor, V., & Katz, S. (1990). Designing the national resident assessment instrument for nursing homes. Gerontologist, 30, 293–307.
Moss, R. J., & La Puma, J. (1991). The ethics of mechanical restraints. Hastings Center Report, 21(1), 22–26.
Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1987. P.L. 100–203. Subtitle C. The Nursing Home Reform Act. 42 U.S.C. 1395i-3(a)–(h)(Medicare); 1396r (a)–(h)(Medicaid).
Online Survey, Certification And Recording. (1991–2003). Health Care Financing Administration: Arlington, VA.
Payne, S. M., DiGiuseppe, D. L., & Tilahun, N. (2002). The relationship of post-acute home care use to Medicaid utilization and expenditures. Health Services Research, 37(3), 683–710.
Porell, F., Caro, F. G., Silva, A., & Monane, M. (1998). A longitudinal analysis of nursing home outcomes. Health Services Research, 33(4), 835–865.
Rosenbaum, P.R., & Rubin, D.B. (1985). Constructing control groups using multivariate matched sampling methods that incorporate the propensity score. The American Statistician, 39(1), 33–38.
Rosenheck, R., Stolar, M., & Fontana, A. (2000). Outcomes monitoring and the testing of new psychiatric treatments: Work therapy in the treatment of chronic post-traumatic stress disorder. Health Services Research, 35(1), 133–151.
Ruths, S., Straand, J., & Nygaard, H.A. (2003). Multidisciplinary medication review in nursing home residents: What are the most significant drug-related problems? The Bergen District Nursing Home (BEDNURS) study. Quality and Safety in Health Care, 12(3), 176–180.
Shea, D. G., Russo, P. A., & Smyer, M. A. (2000). Use of mental health services by persons with a mental illness in nursing facilities: Initial impacts of OBRA87. Journal of Aging and Health, 12(4), 560–578.
Snowden, M., McCormick, W., Russo, J., Srebnik, D., Comtois, K., Bowen, J., Teri, L., & Larson, E. B. (1999). Validity and responsiveness of the Minimum Data Set. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 47(8), 1000–1004.
Streim, J. E., Beckwith, E. W., Arapakos, D., Banta P., Dunn, R., & Hoyer, T. (2002). Regulatory oversight, payment policy, and quality improvement in mental health care in nursing homes. Psychiatric Services, 53(11), 1414–1418.
Unützer J. & Bruce M. L. (2002). The elderly. Mental Health Services Research, 4(4), 245–247.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Castle, N.G. Mental Health Outcomes and Physical Restraint Use in Nursing Homes {Private}. Adm Policy Ment Health 33, 696–704 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10488-006-0080-0
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10488-006-0080-0