Conclusions
The foregoing analysis of behavioral sleep phenomenology shows that the most significant factual and theoretical aspects of sleep can be logically organized only according to several criteria, it being impossible to choose a singli one as truly paradigmatic. For this reason an ordinal classification of sleep phases was preferred. This fact does not detract from the usefulness of classifications based consistently on 1 criterion at a time (e.g.: synchronized-desynchronized; quiet-active; orthodoxical-paradoxical; NREM-REM; homeostatic-poikilostatic; spindle wave-slow wave-fast wave; external appetitive-internal appetitive-internal consummatory; and so on). In this respect, the bioelectrical classification is surely the best as it allows an analytical subdivision of the evolution of sleep with high resolving power137–139. In particular, the electroencephalographic activity of late phase II (stage 4 in man139 and slow wave11 or deep slow wave140 sleep in the cat) appears to be related to the triggering mechanisms and to the quantitative regulation of the circadian amount of phase III3,5,11,140. However, in extending the field of functional implications of sleep phenomenology other criteria may be more significant. In fact, the somatic and vegetative events of sleep also lend themselves to an analysis according to the behavioral model of ethology6,141–144 and the theory of homeostasis3–5, 145, respectively. As an example, a number of classifying criteria are indicated in the table, where others, particularly neurochemical ones146,147, could be added. At any rate, the difficulty of organizing sleep events into a satisfactory operational scheme is due to the fact that sleep is still an open problem as far as its mechanisms and functional significance are concerned.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
N. Kleitman, Sleep and Wakefulness. University of Chicago Press, Chicago 1963.
W. P. Koella, Sleep: its Nature and Physiological Organization. Thomas, Springfield, Ill. 1967.
P. L. Parmeggiani, Brain Research7, 350 (1968).
P. L. Parmeggiani, in: The Sleeping Brain, vol. 1, p. 108. Ed. M. H. Chase. Brain Information Services, UCLA, Los Angeles 1972.
P. L. Parmeggiani, Waking Sleeping1, 123 (1977).
P. L. Parmeggiani, in: Sleep: Physiology, Biochemistry, Psychology, Pharmacology, Clinical Implications p. 210. Ed. W. P. Koella and P. Levin, Karger, Basel 1973.
J. Bert, in: Sleep: Physiology, Biochemistry, Psychology, Pharmacology Clinical Implications p. 446. Ed.. W. P. Koella and P. Levin, Karger, Basel 1973.
T. Allison and D. V. Cicchetti, Science194, 732 (1976).
W. R. Hess, Helv. physiol. pharmac. Acta2, 305 (1944).
P. L. Parmeggiani, Helv. physiol. pharmac. Acta20, 347 (1962).
P. L. Parmeggiani and C. Rabini, Archs ital. Biol.108, 369 (1970).
P. L. Marchiafava and O. Pompeiano, Archs ital. Biol.102, 500 (1964).
R. Hodes and J.-I. Suzuki, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.18, 239 (1965).
C. Batini, J. Fressy and H. Gastaut, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.16, 412 (1964).
A. Fujiki, A. Shimizu, Y. Yamada, J. Yamamoto and Z. Kaneko, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.31, 610 (1971).
C. von Euler and U. Söderberg, Experientia12, 278 (1956).
C. von Euler and U. Söderberg, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.9, 391 (1957).
C. von Euler and U. Söderberg, Acta physiol. scand.42, 112 (1958).
J. S. Buchwald and E. Eldred, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.13, 243 (1961).
T. Hongo, K. Kubota and H. Shimazu, J. Neurophysiol.26, 568 (1963).
M. M. Gassel and O. Pompeiano, Archs ital. Biol.103, 347 (1965).
K. Kubota and R. Tanaka, Brain Res.3, 198 (1966).
K. Kubota, R. Tanaka and T. Tsuzuki, Jap. J. Physiol.17, 613 (1967).
P. L. Parmeggiani and L. Sabattini, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.33, 1 (1972).
M. A. M. Lee and N. Kleitman, Am. J. Physiol.67, 141 (1923).
W. W. Tuttle, Am. J. Physiol.68, 345 (1924).
R. Hodes and W. C. Dement, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.17, 617 (1964).
Y. Hishikawa, N. Sumitsuji, K. Matsumoto and Z. Kaneko, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.18, 487 (1965).
P. Bard, and M. B. Macht, in: Neurological Basis of Behaviour, p. 55. Ed. G. E. W. Wolstenholme and C. M. O'Connor. Ciba Found. Symp., Churchill, London 1958.
M. Jouvet, Archs ital. Biol.100, 125 (1962).
J. Islas-Marroquin, Archs Sci. physiol.20, 219 (1966).
B. Duron, J. Physiol. (Paris)61, Suppl. 2, 282 (1969).
M. M. Gassel, P. L. Marchiafava and O. Pompeiano, Archs ital. Biol.102, 471 (1964).
M. M. Gassel, P. L. Marchiafava and O. Pompeiano, Archs ital. Biol.103, 25 (1965).
S. Giaquinto, O. Pompeiano and I. Somogyi, Archs ital. Biol.102, 245 (1964).
S. Giaquinto, O. Pompeiano and I., Somogyi, Archs ital. Biol.102, 282 (1964).
A. R. Morrison and O. Pompeiano, Archs ital. Biol.103, 497. (1965).
F. Baldissera, G. Broggi and M. Mancia, Archs ital. Biol.104, 112 (1966).
K. Kubota, Y. Iwamura and Y. Niimi, J. Neurophysiol.28 125 (1965).
K. Kubota and Y. Kidokoro, Jap. J. Physiol.16, 217 (1966).
R. Granit and B. R. Kaada, Acta physiol. scand.27, 130 (1952).
W. J. Freeman and D. D. Davis, Am. J. Physiol.197, 145 (1959).
J. A. Hobson, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.19, 41 (1965).
W. W. Roberts and T. C. L. Robinson, Exp. Neurol.25, 282 (1969).
W. W. Roberts, E. H. Bergquist and T. C. L. Robinson, J. comp. physiol. Psychol.67, 182 (1969).
A. L. R. Findlay and J. N. Hayward, J. Physiol. (London)201, 237 (1969).
P. L. Parmeggiani and C. Franzini, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.34, 495 (1973).
M. M. Gassel, P. L. Marchiafava and O. Pompeiano, Archs ital. Biol.102, 449 (1964).
O. Pompeiano and A. R. Morrison, Archs ital. Biol.103, 569 (1965).
O. Pompeiano and A. R. Morrison, Archs ital. Biol.104, 231 (1966).
A. R. Morrison and O. Pompeiano, Archs ital. Biol.104, 214 (1966).
E. Aserinsky and N. Kleitman, Science118, 273 (1953).
E. Aserinsky and N. Kleitman, J. appl. Physiol.8, 1 (1955).
W. Baust, G. Berlucchi and G. Moruzzi, Archs ital. Biol.102, 657 (1964).
O. Pompeiano, in: Handbook of Sensory Physiology, vol. 6-I, p. 583. Ed. H. H. Kornhuber, Springer, Berlin 1974.
A. Shimizu, Y. Yamada, J. Yamamoto, A. Fujiki and Z. Kaneko, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.20, 337 (1966).
W. R. Hess, Helv. physiol. pharmac. Acta5, Suppl. 4 (1947)
G. Berlucchi, G. Moruzzi, G. Salvi and P. Strata, Archs ital. Biol.102, 230 (1964).
O. Candia, E. Favale, A. Giussani and G. F. Rossi, Archs ital. Biol.100, 216 (1962).
E. Kanzow, D. Krause and H. Kühnel, Pflügers Arch. ges. Physiol.274, 593 (1962).
F. Snyder, A. J. Hobson and F. Goldfrank, Science142, 1313 (1963).
F. Snyder, A. J. Hobson, D. F., Morrison and F. Goldfrank, J. appl. Physiol.19, 417 (1964).
M. M. Gassel, B. Ghelarducci, P. L. Marchiafava and O. Pompeiano, Archs ital. Biol.102, 530 (1964).
D. W. Richardson, A. J. Honour, G. W. Fenton, F. H. Stott and G. W. Pickering, Clin. Sci.26, 445 (1964).
M. Guazzi and A. Zanchetti, Archs ital. Biol.103, 789 (1965).
F. Snyder, Res. Publ. Ass., nerv. ment. Dis.45, 469 (1967).
I. M. Khatri and E. D. Freis, J. appl. Physiol.22, 867 (1967).
W. Baust and B. Bohnert, Exp. Brain Res.7, 169 (1969).
J. D. Bristow, A. J. Honour, T. G. Pickering and P. Sleight, Cardiovasc. Res.4, 476 (1969).
G. Coccagna, M. Mantovani, F. Brignani, A. Manzini and E. Lugaresi, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.31, 277 (1971).
D. Hawkins, H. Puryear, C. Wallace, W. Deal and E. Thomas, Science136, 321 (1962).
T. Satoh, T. Ogawa and K. Takagi, Jap. J. Physiol.15, 523 (1965).
E. H. Geschickter, P. A. Andrews and R. W. Bullard, J. appl. Physiol.21, 623 (1966).
T. Ogawa, T. Satoh and K. Takagi, Jap. J. Physiol.17, 135 (1967).
Y. Niimi, K. Kubota and Y. Iwamura, Jap. J. Physiol.18, 190 (1968).
C. M. Shapiro, A. T. Moore, D. Mitchell and M. L. Yodaiken, Experientia30, 1279 (1974).
W. Baust, in: Ermüdung, Schlaf und Traum, p. 99. Ed. W. Baust. Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft MBH, Stuttgart 1970.
C. A. Tassinari, G. Coccagna, M. Mantovani, B. Dalla Bernardina, J. P. Spire, D. Mancia, A. Velta and P. Vallicioni, in: The Nature of Sleep, p. 55. Ed. U. J. Jovanović. Fischer, Stuttgart 1973.
J. F. Hiatt and D. F. Kripke, Psychosom. Med.37, 320 (1975).
W. Baust and W. Rohrwasser, Pflügers Arch. ges. Physiol.305, 229 (1969).
G. Stacher and G. Fink, in: The Nature of Sleep, p. 59. Ed. U. J. Jovanović. Fischer, Stuttgart 1973.
G. Stacher, B. Presslich and H. Stärker, Gastroenterology68, 1449 (1975).
J. A. Yaryura-Tobias, J. S. Hutcheson and L. White, Behav. Neuropsych.2, 22 (1970).
J. E. Remmers, D. Bartlett, Jr, and M. D. Putnam, Respir. Physiol.28, 227 (1976).
J. Orem, A. Netick and W. Dement, Respir. Physiol.30, 265 (1977).
E. A., Phillipson, E. Murphy and L. F. Kozar, J. appl. Physiol.40, 688 (1976).
K. Bülow and D. H. Ingvar, Acta physiol. scand.51, 230 (1961).
B. Duron, Bull. Physiopathol. Respir. (Nancy)8, 1031 (1972).
E. Lugaresi, G. Coccagna, M. Mantovani and R. Lebrun, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.32, 701 (1972).
E. A. Phillipson, A. Rev. Physiol.40, 133 (1978).
P. L. Parmeggiani and C. Rabini, Brain Res.6, 789 (1967).
P. L. Parmeggiani, C. Franzini, P. Lenzi and G. Zamboni, Brain Res.52, 189 (1973).
P. L. Parmeggiani, C. Franzini and P. Lenzi, Brain Res.111, 253 (1976).
P. L. Parmeggiani, G. Zamboni, T. Cianci and M. Calasso, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.42, 372 (1977).
S. F. Glotzbach and H. C. Heller, Am. J. Physiol.228, 1880 (1975).
S. F. Glotzbach and H. C. Heller, Science194, 537, (1976).
H. T. Hammel, D. C. Jackson, J. A. J. Stolvijk, J. D. Hardy and S. B. Strømme, J. appl. Physiol.18, 1146 (1963).
P. L. Parmeggiani, L. F. Agnati, G. Zamboni and T. Cianci, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.38, 589 (1975).
H. C. Heller and S. F. Glotzbach, in: Environmental Physiology II, vol. 15, p. 147. Ed., D. Robertshaw. University Park Press, Baltimore 1977.
M. Guazzi, G. Baccelli and A. Zanchetti, Science153, 206 (1966).
M. Guazzi, G. Baccelli and A. Zanchetti, Am. J. Physiol.214, 969 (1968).
Y. Iwamura, Y. Uchino, S. Ozawa and S. Torii, Proc. Jap. Acad.42, 837 (1966).
Y. Iwamura, Y. Uchino, S. Ozawa and S. Torii. Brain Res.3, 381 (1966).
W. Baust, H. Weidinger and F. Kirchner, Archs ital. Biol.106, 379 (1968).
D. J. Reis, D. Moorhead and G. F. Wooten, Neurology18, 282 (1968).
G. Mancia, D. B. Adams, G. Baccelli and A. Zanchetti, Experientia25, 48 (1969).
G. Mancia, G. Baccelli, D. B. Adams and A. Zanchetti, Am. J. Physiol.220, 1086 (1971).
G. Baccelli, M. Mancia and A. Zanchetti, Eur. J. clin. Invest.1, 125 (1970).
G. Baccelli, R. Albertini, G. Mancia and A. Zanchetti Circulation Res.35, 625 (1974).
T. Kumazawa, G. Baccelli, M. Guazzi, G. Mancia and A. Zanchetti, Experientia23, 1021 (1967).
R. Henane, A. Buguet, B. Roussel and J. Bittel, J. appl. Physiol.42, 50 (1977).
I. Oswald, Sleeping and Waking: Physiology and Psychology. Elsevier, Amsterdam 1962.
G. Fisher, J. Gross and J. Zuch, Arch. gen. Psychiat.12, 29 (1965).
R. H. Armstrong, D. Burnap, A. Jacobson, A. Kales, S. Ward and J. Golden, New Physician14, 241 (1965).
W. C. Orr, W. H. Hall, M. L. Stahl, M. G. Durkin and T. L. Whitsett, Arch. intern. Med.136, 655 (1976).
D. J. Henderson-Smart and D. J. C. Read, in: Sleep Apnea Syndromes, vol. 11, p. 93. Ed. C. Guilleminault and W. C. Dement. Kroc Foundation Series, A. R. Liss, New York 1978.
K. Tusiewicz, H. Moldofsky, A. C. Bryan and M. H. Bryan, J. appl. Physiol.43, 600 (1977).
Parmeggiani P. L., in: The Regulation of Respiration during Sleep and Anesthesia, p. 47. Ed. R. S. Fitzgerald, H. Gautier and S. Lahiri. Plenum Press, New York 1978.
K. Bülow, Acta physiol. scand.59, Suppl. 209 (1963).
E. Aserinsky, Science150, 763 (1965).
R. H. Wurtz and J. J. O'Flaherty, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.22, 30 (1967).
M. Guazzi and E. D. Freis, Am. J. Physiol.217, 1623 (1969).
S. A. Fagenholz, K. O'Connell and D. C. Shannon, Pediatrics58, 31 (1976).
M. H. Bryan, R. Hagan, G. Gulston and A. C. Bryan, Clin. Res.24, A689 (1976).
E. A. Phillipson, L. F. Kozar, A. S. Rebuck, and E. Murphy, Am. Rev. respir. Dis.115, 251 (1977).
D. P. G. Bolton and S. Herman, J. Physiol. (London)240, 67 (1974).
E. A. Phillipson, C. E. Sullivan, D. J. C. Read, E. Murphy and L. F. Kozar, J. appl. Physiol.44, 512 (1978).
J. P. Farber and T. A. Marlow, Respir. Physiol.27, 73 (1976).
N. N. Finer, I. F. Abroms and H. W. Taeusch, Jr., J. Pediatr.89, 100 (1976).
J. A. Hobson, R. W. McCarley, R. T. Pivik and R. Freedman, J. Neurophysiol.38, 497 (1974).
R. W. McCarley and J. A. Hobson, J. Neurophysiol.18, 751 (1975).
A. Netick, J. Orem and W. Dement, Brain Res.120, 197 (1977).
J. Orem in: Sleep Apnea Syndromes, vol. 11, p. 65. Ed. C. Guilleminault and W. C. Dement. Kroc Foundation Series, A. R. Liss, New York 1978.
J. M. Affanni, E. Lisogorsky and A. M. Scaravilli, Experientia28, 1046 (1972).
H. Twyver van and T. Allison, Brain Behav. Evol.9, 107 (1974).
P. L. Parmeggiani and C. Franzini, Brain Res.29, 347 (1971).
R. Hess, Jr., Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.16, 44 (1964).
W. Dement and N. Kleitman, Electroenceph. clin. Neurophysiol.9, 673 (1957).
A. Rechtschaffen and A. Kales (eds.), A Manual of Standardized Terminology, Techniques and Scoring System for Sleep Stages of Human Subjects. Public Health Service, Publication No. 204. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington D. C. 1968.
R. Ursin, Brain Res.20, 91 (1970).
M. Holzapfel, Naturwissenschaften28, 273 (1940).
H. Hediger, Med. Klin.20, 938 (1959).
H. Hediger, Proc. Roy. Soc. Med.62, 153 (1969).
G. Moruzzi, Archs ital. Biol.107, 175 (1969).
W. B. Cannon, Physiol. Rev.9, 399, (1929).
M. Jouvet, Physiol. Rev.47, 117 (1967).
M. Jouvet, Ergebn. Physiol.64, 166 (1972).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Parmeggiani, P.L. Behavioral phenomenology of sleep (somatic and vegetative). Experientia 36, 6–11 (1980). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02003941
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02003941