Abstract
An influential tradition in the philosophy of causation has it that all token causal facts are, or are reducible to, facts about difference-making. Challenges to this tradition have typically focused on pre-emption cases, in which a cause apparently fails to make a difference to its effect. However, a novel challenge to the difference-making approach has recently been issued by Alyssa Ney. Ney defends causal foundationalism, which she characterizes as the thesis that facts about difference-making depend upon facts about physical causation. She takes this to imply that causation is not fundamentally a matter of difference-making. In this paper, I defend the difference-making approach against Ney’s argument. I also offer some positive reasons for thinking, pace Ney, that causation is fundamentally a matter of difference-making.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Baumgartner, M. (ms.). A regularity theoretic approach to actual causation.
Choi S. (2002) Causation and gerrymandered world lines: A critique of Salmon. Philosophy of Science 69: 105–117
Dowe P. (1992) Wesley Salmon’s process theory of causality and the conserved quantity theory. Philosophy of Science 59: 195–216
Dowe P. (2000) Physical causation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Dowe P. (2004) Chance-lowering causes. In: Dowe P., Noordhof P. (eds) Cause and chance: Causation in an indeterministic world. Routledge, London, pp 28–38
Eagle, A. (2007). Pragmatic causation. In H. Price & R. Corry (Eds.), Causation, physics, and the constitution of reality: Russell’s republic revisited (pp. 156–190). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Eells E. (1991) Probabilistic causality. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Elga, A. (2007). Isolation and folk physics. In H. Price & R. Corry (Eds.), Causation, physics, and the constitution of reality: Russell’s republic revisited (pp. 106–119). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Field H. (2003) Causation in a physical world. In: Loux M. J., Zimmerman D. (eds) Oxford handbook of metaphysics. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 435–460
Glymour C., Wimberly F. (2007) Actual causes and thought experiments. In: Campbell J. K., O’Rourke M., Silverstein H. (eds) Causation and explanation. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp 43–67
Glynn L. (2011) A probabilistic analysis of causation. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 62: 343–392
Glynn, L. (ms.) Of miracles and interventions.
Good I. J. (1961a) A causal calculus (I). British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 11: 305–318
Good I.J. (1961b) A causal calculus (II). British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 12: 43–51
Hájek A. (2007) The reference class problem is your problem too. Synthese 156: 563–585
Hall N. (2000) Causation and the price of transitivity. Journal of Philosophy 97: 198–222
Hall, N. (2004a). Two concepts of causation. In J. Collins, N. Hall, & L. A. Paul (Eds.), Causation and counterfactuals (pp. 225–276). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Hall N. (2004b) The intrinsic character of causation. Oxford Studies in Metaphysics 1: 255–300
Hall N., Paul L. A. (2003) Causation and pre-emption. In: Clark P., Hawley K. (eds) Philosophy of science today. Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp 100–130
Halpern, J. Y., & Hitchcock, C. (ms.). Graded causation and defaults.
Halpern J. Y., Pearl J. (2005) Causes and explanations: A structural-model approach. Part I: Causes. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 56: 843–887
Handfield T., Twardy C. R., Korb K. B., Oppy G. (2008) The metaphysics of causal models: Where’s the biff?. Erkenntnis 68: 149–168
Hitchcock C. (1995) Salmon on explanatory relevance. Philosophy of Science 62: 304–320
Hitchcock C. (2001a) The intransitivity of causation revealed in equations and graphs. Journal of Philosophy 98: 273–299
Hitchcock C. (2001b) A tale of two effects. The Philosophical Review 110: 361–396
Hitchcock, C. (2007a). What Russell got right. In H. Price & R. Corry (Eds.), Causation, physics, and the constitution of reality: Russell’s republic revisited (pp. 45–65). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Hitchcock C. (2007b) Prevention, preemption, and the principle of sufficient reason. Philosophical Review 116: 495–532
Hitchcock C. (2009) Problems for the conserved quantity theory: Counterexamples, circularity, and redundancy. Monist 92: 72–93
Hume, D. (1978). A treatise of human nature L. A. Selby-Bigge & P. Nidditch (Eds.), Oxford: Clarendon Press. (First published 1739–1740).
Kvart, I. (2004). Causation: Probabilistic and counterfactual analyses. In J. Collins, N. Hall, & L. A. Paul (Eds.), Causation and counterfactuals (pp. 359–386). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Lewis D. (1973a) Causation. Journal of Philosophy 70: 556–567
Lewis D. (1973b) Counterfactuals. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Lewis D. (1979) Counterfactual dependence and time’s arrow. Noûs 13: 455–476
Lewis, D. (1986a). Postscripts to “causation”. In D. Lewis (Ed.), Philosophical papers (pp. 172–213). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lewis D. (1986b) On the plurality of worlds. Blackwell, Oxford
Lewis D. (2000) Causation as influence. Journal of Philosophy 97: 182–197
Lewis, D. (2004). Causation as influence. In J. Collins, N. Hall, & L. A. Paul (Eds.), Causation and counterfactuals (pp. 75–106). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. (Expanded version of Lewis, D. (2000). Causation as influence. Journal of Philosophy, 97, 182–197.)
Loewer, B. (2007). Counterfactuals and the second law. In H. Price & R. Corry (Eds.), Causation, physics, and the constitution of reality: Russell’s republic revisited (pp. 293–326). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Mackie J. L. (1965) Causes and conditions. American Philosophical Quarterly 2: 245–264
Mackie J. L. (1980) The cement of the universe: A study of causation. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Maudlin, T. (2004). Causation, counterfactuals, and the third factor. In J. Collins, N. Hall, & L. A. Paul (Eds.), Causation and counterfactuals (pp. 419–443). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. (Reprinted in Maudlin, T. (2007). The metaphysics within physics (pp. 143–169). Oxford: Oxford University Press.)
Menzies P. (1989) Probabilistic causation and causal processes: A critique of Lewis. Philosophy of Science 56: 642–663
Menzies P. (1996) Probabilistic causation and the pre-emption problem. Mind 105: 85–117
Mill, J. S. (1973). A system of logic ratiocinative and inductive. In J. M. Robson (Ed.), Collected works of John Stuart Mill (Vol. VII–VIII). Toronto: University of Toronto Press. (First published 1843).
Ney A. (2009) Physical causation and difference-making. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 60: 737–764
Pearl J. (2009) Causality: Models, reasoning, and inference (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Price, H., Corry, R. (eds) (2007) Causation, physics, and the constitution of reality: Russell’s republic revisited. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Psillos, S. (2002). Causation and explanation. Chesham: Acumen.
Ramachandran, M. (2004). A counterfactual analysis of indeterministic causation. In J. Collins, N. Hall, & L. A. Paul (Eds.), Causation and counterfactuals (pp. 387–402). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Reichenbach, H. (1971). The direction of time. M. Reichenbach (Ed.). Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. First published 1956.
Russell B. (1913) On the notion of cause. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 13: 1–26
Salmon W. (1984) Scientific explanation and the causal structure of the world. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Salmon W. (1994) Causality without counterfactuals. Philosophy of Science 61: 297–312
Salmon W. (1997) Causality and explanation: A reply to two critiques. Philosophy of Science 64: 461–477
Schaffer J. (2000a) Trumping preemption. Journal of Philosophy 97: 165–181
Schaffer J. (2000b) Causation by disconnection. Philosophy of Science 67: 285–300
Strevens M. (2004) The causal and unification approaches to explanation unified—causally. Noûs 38: 154–176
Strevens M. (2007) Mackie remixed. In: Campbell J. K., O’Rourke M., Silverstein H. S. (eds) Causation and explanation. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp 93–118
Suppes P. (1970) A probabilistic theory of causality. Acta Philosophica Fennica (Vol. 24). North-Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam
Woodward J. (2003) Making things happen: A theory of causal explanation. Oxford University Press, New York
Woodward, J. (2007). Causation with a human face. In H. Price & R. Corry (Eds.), Causation, physics, and the constitution of reality: Russell’s republic revisited (pp. 66–105). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Yablo S. (2002) De facto dependence. Journal of Philosophy 99: 130–148
Yablo, S. (2004). Advertisement for a sketch of an outline of a prototheory of causation. In J. Collins, N. Hall, & L. A. Paul (Eds.), Causation and counterfactuals (pp. 119–137). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Glynn, L. Causal foundationalism, physical causation, and difference-making. Synthese 190, 1017–1037 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-011-0058-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-011-0058-7