A Possible Conception of Life After Death

Abstract

It has often been assumed that the notion of human survival of bodily death poses a straightforward question, ‘Do we live on after bodily death?’, which rightly expects a straightforward ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ answer. Few have indeed thought that the true answer is easy to come by; but many have thought that the question itself is easy enough to ask. Much of the empirical evidence, in the form of ‘spirit communications’ through mediums, seems at first to support that assumption. A deeper analysis however has opened up more complex possibilities. To a great extent this deeper analysis was achieved in the classic period of parapsychological research towards the end of the nineteenth and early in the present century. The observations, analyses and theorising of some of the workers of that period were of the highest order and have indeed seldom been equalled since. Modern parapsychologists have, of course, at their command greatly superior technology, more sophisticated mathematical techniques, and a more impressive line of jargon; but not often a better, or even an equal, theoretical power and intellectual penetration. In praising those classic contributions I am not referring to work on physical phenomena — spirit materialisation, direct voice mediumship, poltergeists and so on — which does often seem to have fallen far short of the rigorous standards of control, aided by such devices as infra-red photography, that we rightly require today.