Abstract
The yearly aggregated tax income data of all, more than 8000, Italian municipalities are analyzed for a period of five years, from 2007 to 2011, to search for conformity or not with Benford’s law, a counter-intuitive phenomenon observed in large tabulated data where the occurrence of numbers having smaller initial digits is more favored than those with larger digits. This is done in anticipation that large deviations from Benford’s law will be found in view of tax evasion supposedly being widespread across Italy. Contrary to expectations, we show that the overall tax income data for all these years is in excellent agreement with Benford’s law. Furthermore, we also analyze the data of Calabria, Campania and Sicily, the three Italian regions known for strong presence of mafia, to see if there are any marked deviations from Benford’s law. Again, we find that all yearly data sets for Calabria and Sicily agree with Benford’s law whereas only the 2007 and 2008 yearly data show departures from the law for Campania. These results are again surprising in view of underground and illegal nature of economic activities of mafia which significantly contribute to tax evasion. Some hypothesis for the found conformity is presented.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
L. Francis, V.R. Prevosto, Data and disaster: the role of data in the financial crisis, in Proceedings Casualty Actuarial Society E-Forum, 2010, p. 62
S. Newcomb, Am. J. Math. 4, 39 (1881)
F. Benford, Proc. Am. Phil. Soc. 78, 551 (1938)
A. Berger, T.P. Hill, Math. Intell. 33, 85 (2011)
E. Canessa, Physica A 328, 44 (2003)
N. Gauvrit, J.-P. Delahaye, Math. Sci. Hum. Math. Soc. Sci. 182, 7 (2008)
N. Gauvrit, J.-P. Delahaye, Math. Sci. Hum. Math. Soc. Sci. 186, 5 (2009)
T.P. Hill, Proc. Am. Math. Soc. 123, 887 (1995)
T.P. Hill, Stat. Sci. 10, 354 (1995)
R.S. Pinkham, Ann. Math. Stat. 32, 1223 (1961)
L. Pietronero, E. Tosatti, V. Tosatti, A. Vespignani, Physica A 293, 297 (2001)
T.A. Mir, Physica A 391, 792 (2012)
T.A. Mir, Physica A 408, 1 (2014)
T.A. Mir, arXiv:1201.3432 (2012)
J.C. Pain, Phys. Rev. E 77, 012102 (2008)
L. Shao, B.Q. Ma, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 24, 3275 (2009)
M. Sambridge, H. Tkalčić, A. Jackson, Geo. Phys. Res. Lett. A 37, L22301 (2010)
G. Judge, L. Schechter, J. Human Resources 44, 1 (2009)
W.R. Mebane Jr., Presp. Polit. 2, 525 (2004)
B.F. Roukema, J. Appl. Stat. 41, 164 (2014)
W.K.T. Cho, B.J. Gaines, Am. Statist. 61, 218 (2007)
P. Clippe, M. Ausloos, Physica A 15, 6556 (2012)
E. den Heijer, A.E. Eiben. Using aesthetic measures to evolve art, in IEEE Congress on Evolutionary Computation (CEC 2010), Barcelona, Spain, 2010 (IEEE Press)
F. Sandron, Population-E 57, 755 (2002)
T. Alexopoulos, S. Leontsinis, J. Astrophys. Astron. (2014), DOI:10.1007/s12036-014-9303-z
M. Ausloos, C. Herteliu, B. Ileanu, Physica A, in press, DOI:10.1016/j.physa.2014.10.041
T.P. Hill, A. Berger, Benford Online Bibliography, http://www.benfordonline.net/
C. Durtschi, W. Hillison, C. Pacini, J. Forensic Account. 1, 17 (2004)
M.J. Nigrini, J. Am. Tax. Assoc. 18, 72 (1996)
M.J. Nigrini, L.J. Mittermaier, J. Pract. Theory 16, 52 (1997)
M.J. Nigrini, Benford’s law: applications for forensic accounting, auditing and fraud detection (Wiley Publications, New Jersey, 2012)
T.P. Hill, Chance 12, 27 (1999)
H. Varian, Am. Statist. 23, 65 (1972)
C. Carslaw, Accounting Rev. 63, 321 (1988)
J. Kinnunen, M. Koskela, J. Int. Acc. Res. 2, 39 (2003)
R.M. Abrantes-Metz, G. Judge, S. Villas-Boas, Appl. Econ. Lett. 10, 893 (2011)
T. Michalski, G. Stoltz, Rev. Econ. Stat. 95, 591 (2013)
B. Rauch, M. Göttsche, G. Brähler, S. Engel, German Econ. Rev. 12, 243 (2011)
C.A. Holz, The Quality of China’s GDP Statistics, Stanford University, SCID Working Paper 487 (2013)
J. Nye, C. Moul, BE Journal of Macroeconomics 7, 17 (2007)
A.H. Haynes, Scripps Senior Theses., Paper 42 (2012), http://scholarship.claremont.edu/scripps˙theses/42
G.G. Johnson, J. Weggenmann, Academy of Accounting and Financial Studies Journal 17, 31 (2013)
J. Costa, J. Santos, S. Travassos, R. Cont. Fin. – USP, Sao Paulo 23, 187 (2012)
D. Bartolini, R. Santolini, Ann. Reg. Sci. 49, 213 (2012)
E. Padovani, E. Scorsone, Measuring financial health of local governments a comparative framework, Year Book of Swiss Administrative Sciences (2011)
F. Schneider, The increase of the size of the shadow economy of 18 OECD countries: some preliminary explanations, IFO Working Paper 306 (2006)
G. Jones, Italy approves decree to stave off bankruptcy for Rome council (2014), http://www.reuters.com/assets/print?aid=USBREA1R1OD20140228
G. Brosio, A. Cassone, R. Ricciuti, Public Choice 112, 259 (2002)
F. Calderoni, Glob. Crime 12, 41 (2011)
F. Schneider, The value added of underground activities: size and measurement of the shadow economies of 110 countries all over the world, World Bank Working Paper Washington D.C. (2000)
P. Di Caro, G. Nicotra, Knowing the unknown across regions: spatial tax evasion across Italy (2014), DOI:10.2139/ssrn.2446803
M.R. Marino, R. Zizza, The personal income tax evasion in Italy: an estimate by taxpayer’s type, in Tax Evasion and the Shadow Economy, edited by M. Pickhardt, A. Prinz, (Edward Elgar Pub., Cheltenham, 2011)
C.V. Fiorio, F. D’Amuri, Giornale degli Economisti e Annali di Economia 64, 247 (2005)
R. Galbiati, G. Zanella, J. Pub. Econ. 96, 485 (2012)
P. Missier, G. Lalk, V. Verykios, F. Grillo, T. Lorusso, P. Angeletti, Distributed Parallel Databases 13, 135 (2003)
J. Boyle, Am. Math. Month. 101, 879 (1994)
P.D. Scott, M. Fasli, Benford’s law: An empirical investigation and a novel explanation, CSM Technical Report 349 (2001), http://repository.essex.ac.uk
M. Alexeev, E. Janeba, S. Osborne, J. Comp. Econ. 32, 375 (2004)
B. Geys, G. Daniele, Organized Crime, Institutions and political quality: empirical evidence from Italian municipalities. Workshop Paper, https://politicalscience.stanford.edu/sites/default/files/workshop-materials/Paper˙Ginmarco˙0.pdf
M.A. Sergi, Ndrangheta and gangster politics in Calabria. The local side of a global threat, http://www.ecpr.eu/Filestore/PaperProposal/3f185089-adf3-4dee-8c11-000088f2fedc.pdf
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mir, T.A., Ausloos, M. & Cerqueti, R. Benford’s law predicted digit distribution of aggregated income taxes: the surprising conformity of Italian cities and regions. Eur. Phys. J. B 87, 261 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1140/epjb/e2014-50525-2
Received:
Revised:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjb/e2014-50525-2