Abstract
Background, Goal, and Scope
Currently, only 40%, or 44.5 million metric tons, of coal combustion products (CCPs) generated in the United States each year by electric utilities are diverted from disposal in landfills or surface impoundments and recycled. Despite promising economic and environmental savings, there has been scant attention devoted to assessing life cycle impacts of CCP disposal and beneficial use. The objective of this paper is to present a life cycle inventory considering two cases of CCP management, including the stages of coal mining and preparation, coal combustion, CCP disposal, and CCP beneficial use. Six beneficial uses were considered: concrete production, structural fills, soil amendments, road construction, blasting grit and roofing granules, and wallboard.
Methods
Primary data for raw material inputs and emissions of all stages considered were obtained from surveys and site visits of coal-burning utilities in Florida conducted in 2002, and secondary data were obtained from various published sources and from databases available in SimaPro 5.1 (PRé Consultants, Amersfoort, The Netherlands).
Results
Results revealed that 50 percent of all CCPs produced, or 108 kg per 1,000 kg of coal combusted, are diverted for application in a beneficial use; however, the relative amounts sold by each utility is dependent on the process operating parameters, air emission control devices, and resulting quality of CCP. Diversion of 50% of all CCPs to beneficial use applications yields a decrease in the total raw materials requirements (with the exception of gravel and iron) and most emissions to air, water, and land, as compared to 100% disposal.
Discussion
The greatest reduction of raw materials was attributed to replacing Portland cement with fly ash, using bottom ash as an aggregate in concrete production and road construction in place of natural materials, and substituting FGD gypsum for natural gypsum in wallboard. The use of fly ash as cementitious material in concrete also promised significant reductions in emissions, particularly the carbon dioxide that would be generated from Portland cement production. Beneficial uses of fly ash and gypsum showed reductions of emissions to water (particularly total dissolved solids) and emissions of metals to land, although these reductions were small compared to simply diverting 50% of all CCPs from landfills or surface impoundments.
Conclusions
This life cycle inventory (LCI) provides the foundation for assessing the impacts of CCP disposal and beneficial use. Beneficial use of CCPs is shown here to yield reductions in raw material requirements and various emissions to all environmental compartments, with potential tangible savings to human health and the environment.
Recommendations and Perspectives
Extension of this life cycle inventory to include impact assessment and sensitivity analysis will enable a determination of whether the savings in emissions reported here actually result in significant improvements in environmental and human health impacts.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
American Coal Ash Association (2003): 2001 Coal Combustion Product Production and Use. Alexandria, VA
Halverson RR, Boggs B, Enyart J, Madden G (2001): Accelerated Nonpozzolanic Reactions of High Volume Coal Fly Ash Concrete. Proceedings of the 14th International Symposium on Management and Use of Coal Combustion Products. American Coal Ash Association, Alexandria, VA
Stewart BR (1999): Coal Combustion Product (CCP) Production and Use. Biogeochemistry of Trace Elements in Coal and Coal Combustion Byproducts. Sajwan KS, Alva AK, Keefer RF (eds), Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York, NY
Gainer K (1996): Commercial Use of Coal Combustion Byproducts: Technologies and Markets, Report E-78. Business Communications Company, Inc., Norwalk, CT
Iyer RS, Scott, JA (2001): Power Station Fly Ash — A Review of Value-Added Utilization Outside of the Construction Industry. Resources, Conservation, and Recycling 31(3) 217–228
Dienhart GJ, Stewart BR, Tyson SS (eds) (1998): Coal Ash: Innovative Applications of Coal Combustion Products. American Coal Ash Association, Alexandria, VA
Joshi RC, Lohtia RP (1997): Fly Ash in Concrete: Production Properties and Uses. Gordon and Breach Science Publishers, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Mills RH (1990): The Practitioner’s View of Fly Ash Utilization. Fly Ash and Coal Conversion By-Products: Characterization, Utilization and Disposal VI. Day RL, Glasser FP (eds), Materials Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA
Pratt PL (1990): The Use of Fly Ash in Concrete: A European View. Fly Ash and Coal Conversion By-Products: Characterization, Utilization and Disposal VI. Day RL, Glasser FP (eds), Materials Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA
Gadalla AM, Saylak D, Lindner AS (1990): Comparison of Strength Development in Waste Industrial Gypsum Produced by the Hemihydrate and Dihydrate Processes. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 73(8) 2255–2260
Ferguson G, Levorson SM (1999): Soil and Pavement Base Stabilization with Self-Cementing Coal Fly Ash. Alexandria, VA: American Coal Ash Association
Shirazi H, Eck RW (1999): Field and Laboratory Evaluation of the Use of Lime Fly Ash to Replace Soil Cement as a Base Course. Transportation Research Record 1652(1) 270–275
Butalia TS, Wolfe WE (2000): Market Opportunities for Utilization of Ohio Flue Gas Desulfurization and Other Coal Combustion Products. The Ohio State University; Dept of Civil and Environmental Engineering and Geodetic Science, Columbus, OH
Butalia TS, Wolfe WE, Lee JW (2001): Evaluation of a Dry FGD Material as a Flowable Fill. Fuel 80(6) 845–850
Taha R, Seals R, Tittlebaum M, Saylak D (1995): Environmental Characteristics of By-product Gypsum. Transportation Research Record 1486(10) 21–26
Srivastava RK, Jozewicz W, Singer C (2001): SO2 Scrubbing Technologies: A Review. Environmental Progress 20(4) 219–226
National Gypsum Company (2003): 〈www.nationalgypsum.com/about/howmade.html〉 (accessed April 14, 2003)
Bretz EA (1991): Innovation Key to Finding Unusual Ash Disposal Options. Electrical World 205, 56–57
Demir I, Hughes RE, DeMaris PJ (2001): Formation and Use of Coal Combustion Residues from Three Types of Power Plants Burning Illinois Coals. Fuel 80(11) 1659–1673
Babbitt CW, Lindner AS (2005): A Life Cycle Inventory of Coal Used for Electricity Production in Florida. Journal of Cleaner Production 13(9) 903–912
Woodward-Clyde Consultants (1994): Report on Combustion By-Products in Florida. Provided courtesy of the Florida Electric Utility Coordinating Group, Tallahassee, FL
Adriano DC, Page AL, Elseewi AA, Chang AC, Straughan I (1980): Utilization and Disposal of Fly ash and Other Coal Residues in Terrestrial Ecosystems: A Review. Journal of Environmental Quality 9, 333–344
Khandekar MP, Bhide AD, Sajwan KS (1999): Trace Elements in Indian Coal and Coal Fly Ash. Biogeochemistry of Trace Elements in Coal and Coal Combustion Byproducts. Sajwan KS, Alva AK, Keefer RF (eds), Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York, NY
Mukherjee AB, Kikuchi R (1999): Coal Ash from Thermal Power Plants in Finland. Biogeochemistry of Trace Elements in Coal and Coal Combustion Byproducts. Sajwan KS, Alva AK, Keefer RF (eds), Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York, NY
Benetto E, Rousseaux P, Blondin J (2004): Life Cycle Assessment of Coal By-products Based Electric Power Production Scenarios. Fuel 83(7/8) 957–970
International Organization of Standardization (ISO) (1997): Environmental Management — Life Cycle Assessment — Principles and Framework. International Organization of Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland (International Standard ISO 14040:1997(E)). [26a] Goal and scope definition and inventory analysis. [26b] Lifecycle impact assessment. [26c] Life cycle interpretation
Goedkoop M, Oele M (2001): SimaPro Database Manual. PRé Consultants, Amersfoot, The Netherlands
Ekvall T, Finnveden G (2001): Allocation in ISO 14041 — A Critical Review. Journal of Cleaner Production 9(3) 197–208
Spath PL, Mann, MK, Kerr DR (1999): Life Cycle Assessment of Coalfired Power Production. National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO
Gagnon L, Bélanger C, Uchiyama Y (2002): Life Cycle Assessment of Electricity Generation Options: The Status of Research in the Year 2001. Energy Policy 30(14) 1267–1278
Nomura N, Inaba A, Tonooka Y, Akai M (2000): Life-cycle Emission of Oxidic Gases from Power Generation Systems. Applied Energy 68(2) 215–227
Castellanos-Barzaga L, Neufert R, Kayser G, Markert B (2001): Life Cycle Assessment of the Selective Catalytic Reduction Process for Power Plants. Int J LCA 4(6) 329–339
Kim S, Dale D (2005): Life Cycle Inventory Information of the United States Electricity System. Int J LCA 10(4) 294–304
Di X, Nie Z, Yuan B, Zuo T (2007): Life Cycle Inventory for Electricity Generation in China. Int J LCA 12(4) 217–224
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) (2003a): Emissions Data and Compliance Reports. Clean Air Markets-Progress and Results. Washington, DC, 〈http://www.epa.gov/airmarkets/emissions/index.html〉 (accessed March 3, 2003)
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) (2003b): Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) Program. Washington, DC, 〈http://www.epa.gov/tri/〉 (accessed March 16, 2003)
May J, Brennan D (2003): Application of Data Quality Assessment Methods to an LCA of Electricity Generation. Int J LCA 8(4) 214–225
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) (2003): Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks: 1990–2001. U.S. Emissions Inventory 2003, Washington, D.C. 〈http://yosemite.epa.gov/oar/globalwarming.nsf/content/ResourceCenterPublicationsGHG EmissionsUSEmissionsInventory 2003.html〉 (accessed February 19, 2003)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
ESS-Submission Editor: Prof. Walter Klöpffer, PhD
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Babbitt, C.W., Lindner, A.S. A life cycle comparison of disposal and beneficial use of coal combustion products in Florida. Int J Life Cycle Assess 13, 202–211 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1065/lca2007.07.353
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1065/lca2007.07.353