Abstract
The perceived need for the regulation of the medical profession is rooted in the nature and history of medicine. This paper summarizes theories of professional regulation and explores recent developments in medical regulation in Ireland, through description of background theories of professional regulation and analysis of recent developments in Ireland. Medical self-regulation is the subject of ongoing controversy owing to (1) the complex nature of medical practice; (2) informed service users; (3) identification of alleged anti-competitive practices; (4) apparent restrictions on entry to the profession; (5) the public/private mix in Irish healthcare; and (6) high-profile cases that resulted in enquiries into standards of practice. Measures being implemented to address these challenges include reforms in medical education, a new contract of employment for consultants, and enhanced schemes for continuing medical education. Broader societal trends are presenting new challenges that highlight the need for flexible regulatory frameworks in medicine.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Gladstone D (2000) Introduction: regulation, accountability and health care. In: Gladstone D (ed) Regulating doctors (Civil Society). Civitas, Institute for the Study of Civil Society, London, pp 1–8
Davies M (2007) Medical self-regulation: crisis and change (Medical Law and Ethics). Ashgate Publishing Limited, Aldershot
Hardy B (2007) The GMC’s quality of justice. Guardian 7 (December)
Scott F (2007) The GMC’s quality of justice. Guardian 7 (December)
Walker S (2007) The GMC’s quality of justice. Guardian 7 (December)
Harding Clark M (2006) The Lourdes hospital inquiry: an inquiry into peripartum hysterectomy at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda. Report of Judge Maureen Harding Clark SC. The Stationery Office, Dublin
Burke S (2007) The health service: a catalogue of crises and failures. Village 132:24–32
Donnellan E (2007) Will I ever have a system that I could put my hand over my heart and say there would be no missed cancer? The answer is I won’t. Ir Times 15 (December). Weekend Review
Ó’Cionnaith F, Vize E (2007) IHCA rejects reports of detailed HSE offer. Med Wkly 12 (December)
Pearsall J, Trumble B (eds) (1996) The Oxford english reference dictionary, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Parkin M, Powell M, Matthews K (2003) Economics, 5th edn. Addison-Wesley, Harlow
Lemieux P (2004) The public choice revolution. Regulation 27:22–29
Mulreany M, Weir S (2007) Regulation and governance. Administration 55:181–194
Bemelmans-Videc ML, Rist RC, Vedung E (1998) Carrots, sticks and sermons: policy instruments and their evaluation. Transaction Publications, London
Friedman M (1962) Capitalism and freedom. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Johnson J (2000) Self-regulation and the role of the general medical council. In: Gladstone D (ed) Regulating doctors (Civil Society). Civitas, Institute for the Study of Civil Society, London, pp 40–46
Youngson RM, Schott I (1996) Medical blunders: amazing true stories of mad bad, and dangerous doctors. New York University Press, New York
Baker R (2001) Harold Shipman’s clinical practice 1974–1998: a review commissioned by the Chief Medical Officer. Department of Health, London
Department of Health (2001) Learning from Bristol: the Report of the Public Inquiry into Children’s Heart Surgery at the Bristol Royal Infirmary 1984–1995 (Command Paper). The Stationery Office, London
Corrigan J, Kohn LT, Donaldson MS (2000) To err is human: building a safer health system. National Academy Press, Washington DC
Gawande A (2002) Complications: a surgeon’s notes on an imperfect science. Picador, New York
Montgomery K (2006) How doctors think: clinical judgement and the practice of medicine. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Gawande A (2007) Better: a surgeon’s notes on performance. Metropolitan Books, New York
Groopman J (2007) How doctors think. Houghton Mifflin, New York
Allsop J, Mulcahy L (1996) Regulating medical work: formal and informal controls. Open University Press, Buckingham
Mulcahy R (2006) Is the health service for healing? A doctor’s defence of medicine’s Samaritan role. Liberties Press, Dublin
Wren M-A (2003) Unhealthy state: analysis of a sick society. New Island, Dublin
Tussing AD, Wren M-A (2005) How Ireland cares: the case for health care reform. New Island, Dublin
Tyrrell F (2006) Authors criticize failings in healthcare system. Ir Times 13 (June)
O’Sullivan T (2007) Book review: how Ireland cares. Administration 54:112–114
Commission on Financial Management, Control Systems in the Health System (2003) Report of the Commission on Financial Management and Control Systems in the Health System. The Stationery Office, Dublin
Wall M (2007) End of the road for the contract debacle? Ir Times 18 (December)
Dowie J, Elstein A (eds) (1988) Professional judgement: a reader in clinical decision making. Open University/Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Chen PW (2007) Do no harm. New York Times, 22 April
Rosenfeld I (2002) Power to the patient. Time Warner International, New York
Hogg C (1999) Patients, power and politics: from patients to citizens. Sage Publications Limited, London
Irish Times (2007) Editorial: regulating solicitors. Ir Times 10 (December)
Indecon International Economic Consultants and London Economics (2003) Authority published a report on restrictions in the supply of professional services. Competition Authority, Dublin
Barrett S (2003) The task of Irish health service reform. Ir Bank Rev (December):18–30
Working Group on Undergraduate Medical Education, Training Medical Education in Ireland (2006) A new direction: Report of the Working Group on Undergraduate Medical Education and Training. Department of Health and Children, Dublin
Postgraduate Medical Education and Training Group (2006) Preparing Ireland’s doctors to meet the health needs of the 21st century: Report of the Postgraduate Medical Education and Training Group. Department of Health and Children, Dublin
Ó’Cionnaith F (2007) Private clinics must be regulated—Council. Med Wkly 12 (December)
Carolan M (2007) Court overturns misconduct findings. Ir Times 15 (December)
Ryan C, Shanahan C (2007) Neary ruling sparks crisis for Medical Council. Ir Examiner 15 (December)
Ó’Domhnaill S (2007) GP non-compliance with CA scheme needs questioning. Ir Med Times 14 (December)
Hirst P, Thompson G (1999) Globalization in question: the International Economy and the Possibilities of Governance. Polity, Cambridge
Temin P (1999) Globalization. Ox R Econ Pol 15:76–89. doi:10.1093/oxrep/15.4.76
Economist (2001) Globalisation. Economist/Profile, London
Lee K, Colin J (eds) (2005) Global Change and Health (Understanding Public Health). Open University Press/McGraw–Hill Education, Maidenhead
Cahill D (2007) Migration redefines the nation. Ir Times 21 (November)
Mac Éinrí P (2001) Immigration into Ireland: trends, policy, responses, outlook. Irish Centre for Migration Studies, Cork
Kelly BD (2003) Globalisation and psychiatry. Adv Psychiatr Treat 9:464–474. doi:10.1192/apt.9.6.464
Nicholas S (2004) The challenges of the free movement of health professionals. In: McKee M, MacLehose L, Nolte E (eds) European observatory on health systems and policies series: health policy and European Union Enlargement. McGraw–Hill/Open University Press, Maidenhead, pp 82–108
Salamon LM (2002) Economic Regulation. In: Salamon LM (ed) The tools of government: a guide to the new governance. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 117–155
Mallin CA (2004) Corporate governance. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Medical Council (2006) Performance in practice: maintenance of professional standards. Medical Council, Dublin
Irish College of Psychiatrists (2002) Good psychiatric practice: CPD in Ireland. Irish College of Psychiatrists, Dublin
Swage T (2000) Clinical governance in health care practice. Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford
Hooghe L, Marks G (2001) Multi-level governance and European integration. Rowman and Littlefield, Oxford
McSherry R, Pearce P (2002) Clinical governance: a guide to implementation for health care professionals. Blackwell, Oxford
Rachlis MM (2004) Moving forward with public health in Canada. Can J Public Health 95:405–406
Wilson K (2004) The complexities of multi-level governance in public health. Can J Public Health 95:409–412
James A, Worrall A, Kendall T (eds) (2005) Clinical governance in mental health and learning disability services: a practical guide. Gaskell Press, London
Sale D (2005) Understanding clinical governance and quality assurance: making it happen. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke
Kelly BD (2006) Governance, policy and global change. Ir Psychiatrist 7:199–200
Powers M, Faden R (2006) The moral foundations of public health and health policy. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Barrington R (1987) Health, medicine and politics in Ireland 1900–1970. Institute of Public Administration, Dublin
Bowe C (2007) Walk-in clinics help cure US healthcare ills. Financial Times 6 (December)
Mulcahy R (2006) Privatization will increase health inequalities. Med Wkly 19 (July)
Donnellan E (2008) IMO hospital consultants vote to accept new HSE contracts. Ir Times 4 (June)
Department of Health (1987) Shaping a healthier future: a strategy for effective healthcare in the 1990s. The Stationery Office, Dublin
Department of Health and Children (2001) Quality and fairness: a health system for you. The Stationery Office, Dublin
Department of Health (1984) The psychiatric services—planning for the future. The Stationery Office, Dublin
Expert Group on Mental Health Policy (2006) A vision for change: report of the expert group on mental health policy. The Stationery Office, Dublin
Kelly BD (2004) Mental health policy in Ireland, 1984–2004: theory, overview and future directions. Ir J Psychol Med 21:61–68
Inspector of Mental Health Services (2005) Report of the Inspector of Mental Health Services 2004. The Stationery Office, Dublin
Guruswamy S, Kelly BD (2006) A change of vision? Mental health policy. Ir Med J 99:164–166
O’Regan E, Cunningham G (2008) We must learn from this—cancer doctor. Ir Indep 13 (September)
O’Donoghue N, Mulholland P (2008) Regionalisation plans get mixed reviews. Ir Med Times 25 (August)
Conflict of interest statement
There is no conflict of interest to declare.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kelly, B.D. Changing governance, governing change: medical regulation in Ireland. Ir J Med Sci 179, 3–7 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11845-009-0357-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11845-009-0357-x