The Effect of Child Benefit Policies on Fertility and Female Labor Force Participation in Canada
Received: 03 February 2003 Accepted: 21 April 2004 DOI:
Cite this article as: Mcnown, R. & Ridao-cano, C. Rev Econ Household (2004) 2: 237. doi:10.1007/s11150-004-5646-6 Abstract.
This paper presents an analysis of the effects of Canadian child benefit policies on fertility and female labor supply. Canada has adopted a variety of child benefit policies since 1918 that are incorporated into an economic model of fertility. This model is estimated and tested with time series data on fertility, female labor force participation, female wages, male incomes, female education, and child benefits. Cointegration methods are employed to accommodate problems of nonstationarity and endogeneity that characterize time series models of fertility and female labor supply. Two cointegrating relations are found, and these are identified as a fertility relation and a female labor supply function. All economic variables, including child benefits, have statistically significant and appropriately signed coefficients. The estimates are used to evaluate the effects of policy and other economic changes on fertility.
Keywords fertility child benefits time series models cointegration
This research was funded by grant # SES-9910662 from the National Science Foundation. The authors appreciate the comments of three anonymous referees and those of James Alm, Editor of this special issue.
References Abeysinghe, Tilak 1993 “Time Cost, Relative Income, And Fertility In Canada” Journal of Population Economics 6 189 198 Google Scholar Bailey, Roy, Chambers, Marcus 1993 “Long Term Demographic Interactions In Precensus England” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A 156 339 362 Google Scholar Beaudry, Paul, Lemieux, Thomas, Parent, Daniel 2000 “What is Happening in the Youth Labor Market in Canada” Canadian Public Policy 36 S59 S83 Google Scholar Becker, Gary 1981A Treatise on the Family Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA Google Scholar Butz, William, Ward, Michael 1979 “The Emergence Of Countercyclical Fertility” American Economic Review 69 318 328 Google Scholar Cheung, Yin-Wong, Lai, Kong 1993 “Finite-Sample Sizes of Johansen’s Likelihood Ratio Tests for Conintegration” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 55 13 28 Google Scholar Dickey, David, Pantula, Sastry 1987 “Determining the Order of Differencing in Autoregressive Processes” Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 5 455 461 Google Scholar Devaney, Barbara 1983 “An Analysis Of Variations In US Fertility And Female Labor Force Participation Trends” Demography 20 147 161 Google Scholar Ermisch, John 1988 “Econometric Analysis Of Birth Rate Dynamics In Britain” Journal of Human Resources 23 563 576 Google Scholar Gonzalo, Jesus 1994 “Five Alternative Methods of Estimating Long-Run Equilibrium Relationships” Journal of Econometrics 60 203 233 Google Scholar Hansen, Hendrik, Juselius, Katerina 1995CATS in RATS: Cointegration Analysis of Time Series. Estima Evanston, Illinois Google Scholar Hyatt, Douglas, Milne, William 1991 “Countercyclical Fertility in Canada: Some Empirical Results” Canadian Studies in Population 18 1 16 Google Scholar Soren, Johansen 1991 “Estimation and Hypothesis Testing of Cointegrating Vectors in Gaussian Vector Autoregressive Models” Econometrica 59 1551 1580 Google Scholar Johansen, Soren, Juselius, Katerina 1994 “Identification of the Long-Run and the Short-Run Structure: An Application to the ISLM Model” Journal of Econometrics 63 7 36 Google Scholar Johansen, Soren 1995Likelihood Based Inference in Cointegrated Vector Autoregressive Models Oxford University Press Oxford Google Scholar Johansen, Soren 1997 “Likelihood Analysis of the I(2) Model” Scandinavian Journal of Statistics 24 433 462 Google Scholar Lehrer, Evelyn, Nerlove, Marc 1986 “Female Labor Force Behavior and Fertility in the United States” American Review of Sociology 12 181 204 Google Scholar Macunovich, Diane 1996 “Relative Income And Price Of Time: Exploring Their Effects On US Fertility And Female Labor Force Participation” Population and Development Review 22(suppl) 223 257 Google Scholar McNown, Robert. 2003 “A Cointegration Model of Age-Specific Fertility and Female Labor Supply in the United States” Southern Economic Journal 70 344 358 Google Scholar McNown, Robert, Rajbhandary, Sameer 2003 “Time Series Analysis of Fertility and Female Labor Market Behavior” Journal of Population Economics 16 501 523 Google Scholar Masih, Abul, Masih, Rumi 1999 “Is a Significant Socio-Economic Structural Change a Prerequisite of ‘Initial’ Fertility Decline in The LDCs Evidence from Thailand Based on a Multivariate Cointegration/Vector Error Correction Modelling Approach” Journal of Population Economics 12 463 487 Google Scholar Rahbek, Anders, Kongsted, Hans Christian, Jørgensen, Clara 1999 “Trend Stationarity in the I(2) Cointegration Model” Journal of Econometrics 90 265 289 Google Scholar Ridao-Cano, Cristobal, McNown, Robert 2003The Effect of Tax-Benefit Policies on Fertility and Labor Force Participation in the United States University of Colorado Mimeo Google Scholar Shapiro, Morton 1988 “Socio-Economic Effects Of Relative Income And Relative Cohort Size” Social Science Research 17 362 383 Google Scholar Sprague, Alison 1988 “Post-War Fertility And Female Labor Force Participation Rates” The Economic Journal 98 682 700 Google Scholar Leslie, Whittington, Alm, James, Peters, H. Elizabeth 1990 “Fertility and the Personal Exemption: Implicit Pronatalist Policy in the US” American Economic Review 80 545 556 Google Scholar Willis, Robert 1973 “A New Approach To The Economic Theory Of Fertility Behavior” Journal of Political Economy 81 S14 S164 Google Scholar Winegarden, Calman 1984 “Women’s Fertility, Market Work And Marital Status: A Test Of The New Household Economics With International Data” Economica 51 447 456 Google Scholar Zhang, Junsen, Quan, Jason, Meerbergen, Peter 1994 “The Effect of Tax-Transfer Policies on Fertility in Canada, 1921–88” Journal of Human Resources 29 181 201 Google Scholar Copyright information
© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004