Abstract
Using a “psychotherapeutic attitude”, as a criterion and measure of the psychiatrist’s involvement in clinical relationship (with the “trial identification” according to Fliess), some phenomenological and epistemological considerations are offered about diagnostic assessments, as a synchronic and diachronic recognising process. Inspired by Gehlen’s notion of “exoneration” (i.e., the reducing and focusing of the perceptive experience as applied to the wealth of the perceptible), this paper examines how the mind of a skilled diagnostician might work. Three levels are explored: firstly, “the symbolic perception”, where perceptive/emotional data derived by “trial identification” and worked through during one’s professional experience, automatically selects wide fields of allusions (e.g., in the psychopathological prefigurations, suggested by the ‘‘contact’’); then, we consider the “exoneration” of scientific hypothesis, which allows the psychiatrist to give a scientifically recognisable form to the first diagnostic outlines gathered in the interpersonal communication; and thirdly, the holistic reflection is examined, which returns the doctor’s focus to the patient’s individual problems, after going through different and, at times, very high inference levels. It is not a question of phases, but of varyingly interwoven moments in the mind of the skilful clinician, which are based on the dialectics of identification/separation.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
D. Beres J.A. Arlow (1974) ArticleTitle‘Fantasy and Identification in Empathy.’ Psychoanalytic Quarterly 43 26–50 Occurrence Handle4814469
S. Bolognini (1997) ArticleTitle‘Empathy and “Empathism”’ International Journal of Psycho-analysis 78 IssueID2 279–293 Occurrence Handle9152755
P. Curci C. Secchi (2000) ArticleTitle‘L’atteggiamento psicoterapico. Un fondamento per la diagnosi nella pratica psichiatrica.’ NOOS 6 239–256
P. Dubor (1972) Notion de sémiologie J. Bergeret (Eds) Abrégé de psychologie pathologique Masson Paris 117–123
R. Fliess (1942) ArticleTitle‘The Meta-psychology of the Analyst.’ Psycho-analytic Quarterly 1 IssueID2 211–227
Gehlen, A.: 1940, Der Mensch, seine Natur und seine Stellung in der Welt. Wiesbaden: Akademische Verlaggesellschaft Athenaion 1978 (translated by C. Mainoldi, L’uomo, la sua natura e il suo posto nel mondo. Milano: Feltrinelli 1983).
R. Greenson (1960) ArticleTitle‘Empathy and Its Vicissitudes.’ International Journal of Psycho-analysis 41 418–424
J. Grotstein (1994) ArticleTitle‘Projective Identification Reappraised–Part I.’ Contemporary Psycho-analysis 30 708–746
H. Kelman (1987) ArticleTitle‘On Resonant Cognition’ International Revue of Psycho-analysis 14 IssueID1 111–123
A. Kraus (1994) Phenomenological and Criteriological Diagnosis. Different or Complementary? J.Z. Sadler M.A. Schwartz (Eds) Philosophical Perspectives on Psychiatric Diagnostic Classifications The John Hopkins University Press Baltimore, London 148–160
G. Lanteri-Laura (1982) ArticleTitle‘La connaissance clinique: histoire et structure en médecine et en psychiatrie’ L’Evolution Psychiatrique 47 IssueID2 425–469
R. McGuire R. McCabe S. Priebe (2001) ArticleTitle‘Theoretical Frameworks for Understanding and Investigating the Therapeutic Relationships in Psychiatry’ Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 36 557–564 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s001270170007 Occurrence Handle11824851
E. Minkowski (1966a) Avant-propos’ in Traité de psychopathologie PUF Paris XI–XIX
E. Minkowski (1966b) Traité de psychopathologie PUF Paris
R. Schafer (1983) The Analytic Attitude Basic Books New York
M.A. Schwartz O.P. Wiggins (1987) ArticleTitle‘Typifications. The First Step for Clinical Diagnosis in Psychiatry’ The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 175 IssueID1 65–77 Occurrence Handle3806077
H.M. Praag ParticleVan (1992) ArticleTitle‘Reconquest of the Subjective. Against the Waning of Psychiatric Diagnosing’ British Journal of Psychiatry 160 266–271 Occurrence Handle1489370
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Curci, P., Secchi, C. Making diagnoses in psychiatric clinical practice: The point of view of the psychotherapeutic attitude. Med Health Care Philos 8, 63–68 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-004-2427-1
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-004-2427-1