Abstract
Coherency phase is often interpreted as a time delay reflecting a transmission delay between spatially separated neural populations. However, time delays estimated from corticomuscular coherency are conflicting and often shorter than expected physiologically. Recent work suggests that corticomuscular coherence is influenced by afferent sensory feedback and bidirectional interactions. We investigated how bidirectional interaction affects time delay estimated from coherency, using a feedback model of the corticomuscular system. We also evaluated the effect of bidirectional interaction on two popular directed connectivity measures: directed transfer function (DTF) and partial directed coherence (PDC). The model is able to reproduce the range of time delays found experimentally from coherency phase by varying the strengths of the efferent and afferent pathways and the recording of sensory feedback in the cortical signal. Both coherency phase and DTF phase were affected by sensory feedback, resulting in an underestimation of the transmission delay. Coherency phase was altered by the recording of sensory feedback in the cortical signals and both measures were affected by the presence of a closed loop feedback system. Only PDC phase led to the correct estimation of efferent transmission delay in all simulated model configurations. Coherency and DTF phase should not be used to estimate transmission delays in neural networks as the estimated time delays are meaningless in the presence of sensory feedback and closed feedback loops.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abbruzzese, G., Berardelli, A., Rothwell, J.C., Day, B.L., Marsden, C.D. (1985). Cerebral potentials and electromyographic responses evoked by stretch of wrist muscles in man. Experimental Brain Research, 58, 544–551.
Akaike, H. (1971). Autoregressive model fitting for control. Annals of the Institute of Statistical Mathematics, 23(2), 163–180.
Astolfi, L., Cincotti, F., Mattia, D., Marciani, M.G., Baccalá, L.A., de Vico Fallani, F., Salinari, S., Ursino, M., Zavaglia, M., Ding, L., Edgar, J.C., Miller, G.A., He, B., Babiloni, F. (2007). Comparison of different cortical connectivity estimators for high-resolution EEG recordings. Human Brain Mapping, 28(2), 143–157.
Baccalá, L.A., & Sameshima, K. (2001). Partial directed coherence: a new concept in neural structure determination. Biological Cybernetics, 84(6), 463–474.
Baker, S.N. (2007). Oscillatory interactions between sensorimotor cortex and the periphery. Current Opinion in Neurobiology, 17(6), 649–655.
Baker, S.N., Chiu, M., Fetz, E.E. (2006). Afferent encoding of central oscillations in the monkey arm. Journal of Neurophysiology, 95(6), 3904–3910.
Brown, P., Salenius, S., Rothwell, J.C., Hari, R. (1998). Cortical Correlate of the Piper Rhythm in Humans. Journal of Neurophysiology, 80, 2911–2917.
Florin, E., Gross, J., Pfeifer, J., Fink, G.R., Timmermann, L. (2010). The effect of filtering on Granger causality based multivariate causality measures. Neuroimage, 50, 577–588.
Fries, P. (2005). A mechanism for cognitive dynamics: neuronal communication through neuronal coherence. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 9(10), 474–480.
Granger, C. (1969). Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods. Econometrica, 37(3), 424–438.
Gross, J., Tass, P. A., Salenius, S., Hari, R., Freund, H.J., Schnitzler, A. (2000). Cortico-muscular synchronization during isometric muscle contraction in humans as revealed by magnetoencephalography. Journal of Physiology, 527(Pt 3), 623–631.
Grosse, P., Guerrini, R., Parmeggiani, L., Bonanni, P., Pogosyan, A., Brown, P. (2003). Abnormal corticomuscular and intermuscular coupling in high-frequency rhythmic myoclonus. Brain, 126(Pt 2), 326–342.
Halliday, D.M., Rosenberg, J.R., Amjad, A.M., Breeze, P., Conway, B.A., Farmer, S.F. (1995). A framework for the analysis of mixed time series/point process data–theory and application to the study of physiological tremor, single motor unit discharges and electromyograms. Progress in Biophysics and Molecular Biology, 64(2–3), 237–278.
Halliday, D.M., Conway, B.A., Farmer, S.F., Rosenberg, J.R. (1998). Using electroencephalography to study functional coupling between cortical activity and electromyograms during voluntary contractions in humans. Neuroscience Letters, 241(1), 5–8.
Haufe, S., Nikulin, V.V., Müller, K.R., Nolte, G. (2013). A critical assessment of connectivity measures for EEG data: a simulation study. NeuroImage, 64, 120–133.
Horwitz, B. (2003). The elusive concept of brain connectivity. Neuroimage, 19(2 Pt 1), 466–470.
Jain, S., Gourab, K., Schindler-Ivens, S., Schmit, B.D. (2012). EEG during pedaling: evidence for cortical control of locomotor tasks. Clinical Neurophysiology.
Kamiński, M., & Blinowska, K.J. (1991). A new method of the description of the information flow in the brain structures. Biological Cybernetics, 65(3), 203–210.
Lindemann, M., Raethjen, J., Timmer, J., Deuschl, G., Pfister, G. (2001). Delay estimation for cortico-peripheral relations. Journal of Neuroscience Methods, 111(2), 127–139.
Ljung, L. (1999). System Identification: Theory for the users, 2nd ed. Prentice Hall PTR.
Mima, T., Steger, J., Schulman, A.E., Gerloff, C., Hallett, M. (2000). Electroencephalographic measurement of motor cortex control of muscle activity in humans. Clinical Neurophysiology, 111(2), 326–337.
Mima, T., Matsuoka, T., Hallett, M. (2001). Information flow from the sensorimotor cortex to muscle in humans. Clinical Neurophysiology, 112(1), 122–126.
Nolte, G., Bai, O., Wheaton, L., Mari, Z., Vorbach, S., Hallett, M. (2004). Identifying true brain interaction from EEG data using the imaginary part of coherency. Clinical Neurophysiology, 115(10), 2292–2307.
Nolte, G., Ziehe, A., Nikulin, V.V., Schlögl, A., Krämer, N., Brismar, T., Müller, K.R. (2008). Robustly estimating the flow direction of information in complex physical systems. Physical Review Letters, 100(23), 234–101.
Petersen, T.H., Willerslev-Olsen, M., Conway, B.A., Nielsen, J.B. (2012). The motor cortex drives the muscles during walking in human subjects. Journal of Physiology, 590(Pt 10), 2443–2452.
Pintelon, R., & Schoukens, J. (2001). System identification. A frequency domain approach. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE Press.
Pohja, M., & Salenius, S. (2003). Modulation of cortex-muscle oscillatory interaction by ischaemia-induced deafferentation. Neuroreport, 14(3), 321–324.
Porcaro, C., Coppola, G., Pierelli, F., Seri, S., Di Lorenzo, G., Tomasevic, L., Salustri, C., Tecchio, F. (2013). Multiple frequency functional connectivity in the hand somatosensory network: an EEG study. Clinical Neurophysiology, 124(6), 1216–1224.
Riddle, C.N., & Baker, S.N. (2005). Manipulation of peripheral neural feedback loops alters human corticomuscular coherence. Journal of Physiology, 566(Pt 2), 625–639.
Riddle, C.N., Baker, M.R., Baker, S.N. (2004). The effect of carbamazepine on human corticomuscular coherence. Neuroimage, 22(1), 333–340.
Rosenberg, J.R., Amjad, A.M., Breeze, P., Brillinger, D.R., Halliday, D.M. (1989). The Fourier approach to the identification of functional coupling between neuronal spike trains. Progress in Biophysics and Molecular Biology, 53(1), 1–31.
Rothwell, J.C., Thompson, P.D., Day, B.L., Boyd, S., Marsden, C.D. (1991). Stimulation of the human motor cortex through the scalp. Experimental Physiology, 76, 159–200.
Schneider, T., & Neumaier, A. (2001). Algorithm 808: ARfit—a matlab package for the estimation of parameters and eigenmodes of multivariate autoregressive models. ACM Transactions on Mathematical Software, 27(1), 58–65.
Schouten, A.C., & Campfens, S.F. (2012). Directional coherence disentangles causality within the sensorimotor loop, but cannot open the loop. Journal of Physiology, 590(Pt 10), 2523–2529.
Stam, C.J., & van Straaten, E.C.W. (2012). The organization of physiological brain networks. Clinical Neurophysiology, 123(6), 1067–1087.
Tallon-Baudry, C., Bertrand, O., Fischer, C. (2001). Oscillatory synchrony between human extrastriate areas during visual short-term memory maintenance. Journal of Neuroscience, 21(20), RC177.
Varela, F., Lachaux, J.P., Rodriguez, E., Martinerie, J. (2001). The brainweb: phase synchronization and large-scale integration. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 2(4), 229–239.
Weiss, S., & Mueller, H.M. (2003). The contribution of EEG coherence to the investigation of language. Brain and Language, 85(2), 325–343.
Williams, E.R., Soteropoulos, D.S., Baker, S.N. (2009). Coherence between motor cortical activity and peripheral discontinuities during slow finger movements. Journal of Neurophysiology, 102(2), 1296–1309.
Witham, C.L., Wang, M., Baker, S.N. (2007). Cells in somatosensory areas show synchrony with beta oscillations in monkey motor cortex. The European Journal of Neuroscience, 26(9), 2677–2686.
Witham, C.L., Riddle, C.N., Baker, M.R., Baker, S.N. (2011). Contributions of descending and ascending pathways to corticomuscular coherence in humans. Journal of Physiology, 589(Pt 15), 3789–3800.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Action Editor: Abraham Zvi Snyder
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Campfens, S.F., van der Kooij, H. & Schouten, A.C. Face to phase: pitfalls in time delay estimation from coherency phase. J Comput Neurosci 37, 1–8 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10827-013-0487-z
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10827-013-0487-z