Abstract
This paper sheds new light on the prevalence of evolutionary ideas in Scotland in the early nineteenth century and establish what connections existed between the espousal of evolutionary theories and adherence to the directional history of the earth proposed by Abraham Gottlob Werner and his Scottish disciples. A possible connection between Wernerian geology and theories of the transmutation of species in Edinburgh in the period when Charles Darwin was a medical student in the city was suggested in an important 1991 paper by James Secord. This study aims to deepen our knowledge of this important episode in the history of evolutionary ideas and explore the relationship between these geological and evolutionary discourses. To do this it focuses on the circle of natural historians around Robert Jameson, Wernerian geologist and professor of natural history at the University of Edinburgh from 1804 to 1854. From the evidence gathered here there emerges a clear confirmation that the Wernerian model of geohistory facilitated the acceptance of evolutionary explanations of the history of life in early nineteenth-century Scotland. As Edinburgh was at this time the most important center of medical education in the English-speaking world, this almost certainly influenced the reception and development of evolutionary ideas in the decades that followed.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Anon. 1826. “Observations on the Nature and Importance of Geology”. Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 1: 293–302.
Anon. 1827. “On the Changes Which Life has Experienced on the Globe”. Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 3: 298–301.
Anon. 1829a. “Science: Académie des Sciences. Séance du lundi 23 mars 1829”. Le Globe 7 (26): 207–208.
Anon. 1829b. “Of the Continuity of the Animal Kingdom by Mean of Generation from the First Ages of the World to the Present Times: On the Relations of Organic Structure and Parentage that may Exist Between Animals of the Historic Ages and Those at Present Living, and the Antediluvian and Extinct Species”. Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 7: 152–155.
Anon. 1830. “Remarks on the Ancient Flora of the Earth”, Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 8: 112–131.
Ashworth, J. H. 1935. “Charles Darwin as a Student in Edinburgh, 1825–1827.” Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 55: 97–113.
Baxter, Paul. 1993. “Deism and Development: Disruptive Forces in Scottish Natural Theology.” Stewart J. Brown, Michael Fry (eds.), Scotland in the Age of the Disruption. Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press, pp. 99–114.
Boué, Ami. 1826. “Geological observation, – 1. On Alluvial Rocks: 2. On Formations: 3. On the Changes that Appear to have Taken Place During the Different Periods of the Earth’s Formation on The climate of our Globe, and in the Nature and the Physical and the Geographical Distribution of Its Animals and Plants.” Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 1: 82–92.
Boué, Ami. 1834. Bulletin de la Société Géologique de France: Résumé des Progrès de Sciences Géologiques pendant l’année 1833. Paris:La Société Géologique de France.
Boué, Ami. 1876. Autobiographie pour mes amis. Vienna.
Brewster, David. 1845. “Review of [Robert Chambers] Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation.” North British Review 3(6): 470–515.
Buckland, William. 1836. Geology and Mineralogy Considered with Reference to Natural Theology, 2 vols. London:William Pickering.
Burkhardt, Richard W. Jr. 1977. The Spirit of System: Lamarck and Evolutionary Biology. Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
Cheek, Henry. 1830. “Suggestions on the relation between Organized Bodies, and the Conditions of their Existence.” Edinburgh Journal of Natural Geographical Science 2: 65.
Corsi, Pietro. 1988. The Age of Lamarck: Evolutionary Theories in France, 1790–1830. Berkeley, CA:University of California Press.
Corsi, Pietro. 2011. “The revolutions of evolution: Geoffroy and Lamarck, 1825–1840”. http://hsmt.history.ox.ac.uk/staff/documents/Corsi_Lamarckinthe1830s_Oct2011. pdf. Accessed 6 May 2014.
Corsi, Pietro. 2012. “Idola Tribus: Lamarck, Politics and Religion in the Early Nineteenth Century.” Aldo Fasolo (ed.), The Theory of Evolution and its Impact. Milan:Springer, pp. 11–39.
Cunningham, Robert James Hay. 1838. “On the Geology of the Lothians.” Memoirs of the Wernerian Natural History Society 7: 3–160.
Cuvier, Georges. 1825. Discours sur les Révolutions de la Surface du Globe. Paris : G. Dufour et Ed. D’Ocagne.
Cuvier, Georges. 1827. Essay on the Theory of the Earth, trans. Robert Jameson. 5th edn. Edinburgh: William Blackwood.
Darwin, Charles. 1985–. The Correspondence of Charles Darwin. 30 vols. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Darwin, Charles. 2002. “1876 May 31 – Recollections of the Development of My Mind and Character.” Charles Darwin (ed.), Autobiographies. London:Penguin.
Desmond, Adrian. 1984. “Robert E Grant: The Social Predicament of a Pre-Darwinian Transmutationist.” Journal of the History of Biology 17(2): 189–223.
Desmond, Adrian. 1989. The Politics of Evolution: Morphology, Medicine, and Reform in Radical London. Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
Desmond, Adrian, Parker, Sarah E. 2006. “The Bibliography of Robert Edmond Grant (1793–1874): Illustrated with a Previously Unpublished Photograph.” Archives of Natural History 33(1): 202–213.
Duns, John. 1859. “Memoir.’ John Fleming (ed.), The Lithology of Edinburgh. Edinburgh:William P. Kennedy.
Eiseley, Loren. 1958. Darwin’s Century: Evolution and the Men Who Discovered It. New York:Garden City.
Esmark, Jens. 1826. “Remarks Tending to Explain the Geological History of the Earth.” Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 2: 107–121.
Fleming, John. 1822. The Philosophy of Zoology; Or a General View of the Structure, Functions, and Classification of Animals. 2 vols. Edinburgh: Archibald Constable & Co.
Fleming, John. 1828. A History of British Animals, Exhibiting the Descriptive Characters and Systematical Arrangement of the Genera and Species of Quadrupeds, Birds, Reptiles, Fishes, Mollusca, and Radiata of the United Kingdom. Edinburgh:Bell & Bradfute.
Fleming, John. 1829. “Review of J.E.’ Bichino, On Systems and Methods in Natural History, The Quarterly Review 42: 302–327.
Fleming, John. 1851. “Natural science”. In Inauguration of the New College of the Free Church, Edinburgh, November, M.DCCC.L. with Introductory Lectures on Theology, Philosophy and Natural Science. Edinburgh: Johnstone and Hunter.
Forbes, Edward. 1854. “Professor Forbes’s inaugural lecture”. The Scotsman (17 May 1854): 4.
Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire, Étienne. 1825. “Recherches sur l’organisation des gavials; Sur les affinitÉs naturelles desquelles rÉsulte la nÉcessitÉ d’une autre distribution gÉnÉrique, Gavialis, Teleosaurus et Steneosaurus; et sur cette question, si les Gavials (Gavialis), aujourd’hui rÉpandus dans les parties orientales de l’Asie, descendent, par voie non interrompue de gÉnÉration, des Gavials antidiluviens, soit des Gavials fossiles, dits Crocodiles de Caen (Teleosaurus), soit des Gavials fossiles du Havre et de Honfleur (Stenosaurus).” Memoires du MusÉum d’Histoire Naturelle 12: 97–155.
Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire, Étienne. 1828. “MÉmoire: Où l’on propose de rechercher dans quelles rapports de structure organique et de parentÉ sont entre eux les animaux des âges historiques, et vivant actuellement, et les espèces antÉdiluviennes et perdues”. MÉmoires du MusÉum d’Histoire Naturelle 26
Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire, Étienne. 1831. “Quatrième mÉmoire, lu à l’acadÉmie des sciences, le 28 mars 1831”, Recherches sur de Grands Sauriens TrouvÉs à l’État Fossile vers les Confins Maritimes de la Basse Normandie, AttribuÉs d’abord au Crocodile, puis DÉterminÉs sous les Noms de TÉlÉosaurus et StÉnosaurus. Paris.
Grant, Robert. 1826a. “On the Structure and Nature of the Spongilla friabilis.” Edinburgh Philosophical Journal 14: 270–284.
Grant, Robert. 1826b. “Observations on the Structure of Some Silicious Sponges.” Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 1: 341–351.
Grierson, James. 1823–1824. “General Observations on Geology and Geognosy, and the Nature of These Respective Studies”. Memoirs of the Wernerian Natural History Society 5: 401–410.
Hodge, M.J.S. 2014. “On Darwin’s Science and Its Contexts.” Endeavour 38(3–4): 169–178.
Hutton, James. 1788. “Theory of the Earth; or an Investigation of the Laws Observable in the Composition, Dissolution and Restoration of Land Upon the Globe.” Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 1: 209–304.
Jameson, Laurence. 1854. Biographical Memoir of the Late Professor Jameson. Edinburgh:Neill and Company.
Jameson, Robert. 1804. System of Mineralogy. 3 vols. Edinburgh: Archibald Constable & Co.
Jameson, Robert. 1808. Elements of Geognosy: Being Vol. III and Part II of the System of Mineralogy. Edinburgh:William Blackwood.
Jameson, Robert. n.d. (a). Note on the verso of a card bearing the inscription ‘CIVIS Bibliotecae Academiae EDINBURGENAE a die 12 Octobris 1824, ad diem 12 Octobris 1825”. Centre for Research Collections, University of Edinburgh, Gen.1999.2.
Jameson, Robert. n.d. (b). Notes on lectures in natural history. Taken by William Dansey. Centre for Research Collections, University of Edinburgh, Dc.3.33.
Jameson, Robert. 1826. “Syllabus of Lectures on Natural History”. In Scottish Universities Commission, ‘Appendix to No. XIII”, Returns, Papers, and Examinations Printed by Order of the Royal Commissioners for Visiting the Universities and Colleges of Scotland. Edinburgh.
Jameson, Robert. 1830. Notes on lectures in natural history. Taken by W.S. Walker. National Library of Scotland, Ms.14148.
Jameson, Robert. 1835/1836. Lecture notes on ‘Natural History III”. Taken by D.B. Ramsay. Special Collections, University of Glasgow, MS Cullen 283.
Jameson, Robert. 1845. “New Publications Received.” Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 38: 186–188.
Jameson, Robert. 1846. “New Publications Received.” Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 40: 399–401.
Jenkins, Bill. 2015. “Henry H. Cheek and Transformism: New light on Charles Darwin’s Edinburgh Background.” Notes and Records: The Royal Society Journal of the History of Science 69(2): 155–171.
Laurent, Goulven. 1993. “Ami Boué (1794–1881): Sa vie et son œuvre”. Travaux du Comité Français d’Histoire de la Géologie, troisième série T.VIII. http:// www.annales.org/archives/cofrhigeo/ami-boue.html. Accessed 12 March 2013.
Laudan, Rachel. 1993. From Mineralogy to Geology: The Foundations of a Science, 1650–1830. Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
Miller, Hugh. 1841. The Old Red Sandstone; or New Walks in an Old Field. Edinburgh:John Johnstone.
Ogilvy, J. 1806–1807. “On the Huttonian and Neptunian Theories of the Earth”. Royal Medical Society Dissertations 56: 230–48. Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh.
Rehbock, Philip F. 1983. The Philosophical Naturalists: Themes in Early Nineteenth-Century British Biology. Madison, WI:University of Wisconsin Press.
Rudwick, Martin. 2005. Bursting the Limits of Time: The Reconstruction of Geohistory in the Age of Revolution. Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
Rudwick, Martin. 2008. Worlds Before Adam: The Reconstruction of Geohistory in the Age of Reform. Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
Scottish Universities Commission (1826). 1830. Report Relative to the University of Edinburgh. Edinburgh.
Secord, James A. 1991. Edinburgh Lamarckians: Robert Jameson and Robert E. Grant. Journal of the History of Biology 24 (1): 1–18.
Secord, James A. 2000. Victorian Sensation: The Extraordinary Publication, Reception and Secret Authorship of Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation. Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
Sedgwick, Adam. 1834. A Discourse on the Studies of the University, 2nd ed. Cambridge: J. & J.J. Deighton.
Sweet, Jessie M. 1967. “Robert Jameson’s Irish journal, 1797.” Annals of Science 23(2): 97–126.
Sweet, Jessie M, Waterston, Charles D. 1967. “Robert Jameson’s Approach to the Wernerian Theory of the Earth, 1796.” Annals of Science 23(2): 81–95.
Wakley, Thomas. 1850. “Biographical Sketch of Robert Edmond Grant, M.D. F.R.S. L. & E. & c. Professor of Comparative Anatomy and Zoology in University College, London.” The Lancet 56: 686–695.
Wernerian Natural History Society. Minutes of the Wernerian Society, 1808–1858. 2 vols. University of Edinburgh Library, Dc.2.55.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
Jenkins, B. Neptunism and Transformism: Robert Jameson and other Evolutionary Theorists in Early Nineteenth-Century Scotland. J Hist Biol 49, 527–557 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-015-9425-4
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-015-9425-4