Abstract
Developing models of biological mechanisms, such as those involved in respiration in cells, often requires collaborative effort drawing upon techniques developed and information generated in different disciplines. Biochemists in the early decades of the 20th century uncovered all but the most elusive chemical operations involved in cellular respiration, but were unable to align the reaction pathways with particular structures in the cell. During the period 1940–1965 cell biology was emerging as a new discipline and made distinctive contributions to understanding the role of the mitochondrion and its component parts in cellular respiration. In particular, by developing techniques for localizing enzymes or enzyme systems in specific cellular components, cell biologists provided crucial information about the organized structures in which the biochemical reactions occurred. Although the idea that biochemical operations are intimately related to and depend on cell structures was at odds with the then-dominant emphasis on systems of soluble enzymes in biochemistry, a reconceptualization of energetic processes in the 1960s and 1970s made it clear why cell structure was critical to the biochemical account. This paper examines how numerous excursions between biochemistry and cell biology contributed a new understanding of the mechanism of cellular respiration.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allchin Douglas., (1997) A Twentieth-century Phlogiston: Constructing Error and Differentiating Domains.Perspectives on Science 5: 81–127
Allchin Douglas., (2002) To Err and Win a Nobel Prize: Paul Boyer, ATP Synthase and the Emergence of Bioenergetics Journal of the History of Biology 35: 149–172
Altmann Richard., (1890) Die Elementaroganismen und ihre Beziehungen zu den Zellen von Veit, Leipzig
Baldwin Ernest., (1947) Dynamic Aspects of Biochemistry Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Bechtel William., (1984) Reconceptualization and Interfield Connections: The Discovery of the Link between Vitamins and Coenzymes Philosophy of Science 51: 265–292
Bechtel William., (1986) Building Interlevel Pathways: The Discovery of the Embden-Meyerhof Pathway and the Phosphate Cycle. In: Dorn J., Weingartner P., (Eds) Foundations of Biology. Holder-Picklert-Tempsky, Vienna
Bechtel William., (2006) Discovering Cell Mechanisms: The Creation of Modern Cell Biology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Bechtel William., Abrahamsen Adele., (2005) Explanation: A Mechanist Alternative Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 36: 421–441
Bechtel William., Richardson Robert C., (1993) Discovering Complexity: Decomposition and Localization as Strategies in Scientific Research. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Benda, Carl. 1899. “Weitere Mitteilungen über die Mitochondria.” Archiv für Anatomie und Physiologie (Physiologische Abteilung): 376–383
Buchner Eduard., (1897) Alkoholische Gärung ohne Hefezellen (Vorläufige Mittheilung) Berichte der deutschen chemischen Gesellschaft 30: 117–124
Chance Britton., Williams G. R., (1956) The respiratory chain and oxidative phosphorylation Advances in Enzymology 17: 65–134
Claude Albert., (1948) Studies on Cells: Morphology, Chemical Constitution, and Distribution of Biochemical Functions Harvey Lectures 43: 121–164
Claude Albert., Fullam Ernest F., (1945) An Electron Microscope Study of Isolated Mitochondria Journal of Experimental Medicine 81: 51–61
Craver, Carl and Bechtel, William. (In press). “Top-Down Causation without Top-Down Causes.” Biology and Philosophy
Darden Lindley., Craver Carl., (2002) Strategies in the Interfield Discovery of the Mechanism of Protein Synthesis Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 33: 1–28
Darden Lindley., Maull Nancy., (1977) Interfield Theories Philosophy of Science 43:44–64
Embden Gustav., Deuticke H. J., Kraft G., (1933) Über die intermediaren Vorgänge bei der Glykolyse in der Muskulatur Klinische Wochenschrift 12: 213–215
Fernández-Morán Humberto., (1962) Cell-membrane Ultrastructure: Low-temperature Electron Microscopy and X-ray Diffraction Studies of Lipoprotein Components in Lamellar Systems Circulation 26: 1039–1065
Fernández-Morán Humberto., Oda T., Blair P. V., Green David E., (1964) A Macromolecular Repeating Unit of Mitochondrial Structure and Function: Correlated Electron Microscopic and Biochemical Studies of Isolated Mitochondria and Submitochondrial Particles of Beef Heart Muscle The Journal of Cell Biology 22: 63–100
Fruton Joseph S., (1972) Molecules and Life: Historical Essays on the Interplay of Chemistry and Biology. Wiley Interscience, New York
Glennan Stuart., (1996) Mechanisms and the Nature of Causation Erkenntnis 44: 50–71
Glennan Stuart., (2002) Rethinking Mechanistic Explanation. Philosophy of Science 69: S342–S353
Green David E., (1951) The Cyclophorase System. In: Edsall J. T., (eds) Enzymes and Enzyme Systems. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Hatefi, Youssef, Haavik, A. G. and Griffiths, David E. 1962. “Studies on the Electron Transfer System. XL. Preparation and properties of mitochondrial DPNH-coenzyme Q reductase.” Journal of Biological Chemistry 237: 1676–1680
Green David E., (1957–1958) Studies in Organized Enzyme Systems Harvey Lectures 53: 177–227
Hogeboom George H., Claude Albert., Hotchkiss Rollin D., (1946) The Distribution of Cytochrome Oxidase and Succinoxidase in the Cytoplasm of the Mammalian Liver Cell Journal of Biological Chemistry 165: 615–629
Hogeboom George H., Schneider Walter C., Palade George E., (1948) Cytochemical Studies of Mammalian Tissues. I. Isolation of Intact Mitochondria from Rat Liver; Some Biochemical Properties of Mitochondria and Submicroscopic Particulate Matter Journal of Biological Chemistry 172: 619–635
Holmes Frederic Lawrence., (1991) Hans Krebs: Vol. 1. The Formation of a Scientific Life 1900–1933. Oxford University Press, New York
Holmes Frederic Lawrence., (1992) Between Biology and Medicine: The Formation of Intermediary Metabolism. Office for History of Science and Technology, University of California at Berkeley, Berkeley, CA
Kalckar Herman M., (1974) Origins of the Concept of Oxidative Phosphorylation Molecular and Cellular Biochemistry 5: 55–62
Keilin David., (1925) On Cytochrome, a Respiratory Pigment, Common to Animals, Yeast, and Higher Plants Proceedings of the Royal Society B 98: 312–339
Keilin David., (1966) The History of Cell Respiration and Cytochrome Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Keilin David., Hartree Edward F., (1939) Cytochrome and Cytochrome Oxidase Proceedings of the Royal Society B 127: 167–191
Kennedy Eugene P., Lehninger Albert L., (1949) Oxidation of Fatty Acids and Tricarboxylic Acid Cycle Intermediaries By Isolated Rat Liver Mitochondria Journal of Biological Chemistry 179: 957–972
Kohler Robert E., (1973) The Background of Otto Warburg’s Conception of the Atmungsferment Journal of the History of Biology 6: 171–192
Kohler Robert E., (1973) The Enzyme Theory and the Origin of Biochemistry Isis 64: 181–196
Krebs Hans A., Schmid Roswitha., (1981) Otto Warburg: Cell Physiologist, Biochemist, and Eccentric. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Krebs Hans Adolf., Johnson William Arthur., (1937) The Role of Citric Acid in Intermediate Metabolism in Animal Tissues Enzymologia 4: 148–156
Lardy Henry A., Elvehjem Conrad A., (1945) Biological Oxidations and Reductions Annual Review of Biochemistry 14: 1–30
Lehninger Albert L., (1951) The Organized Respiratory Activity of Isolated Rat-Liver Mitochondria. In: Edsall J. (eds) Enzymes and Enzyme Systems. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Lehninger Albert L., 1964. The Mitochondrion: Molecular Basis of Structure and Function. W. A. Benjamin, Inc., New York
Lehninger Albert L., Wadkins Charles L., Cooper Cecil., Devlin Thomas M., Gamble James L. Jr., (1958) Oxidative Phosphorylation Science 128: 450–456
Lipmann Fritz., (1941) Metabolic Generation and Utilization of Phosphate Bond Energy Advances in Enzymology 1: 99–160
Lynen Feodor., Reichert Ernestine., (1951) Zur chemischen Struktur der ‚aktivierten Essigsäure’ Angewandte Chemie 63: 47–48
Machamer Peter., Darden Lindley., Craver Carl., (2000) Thinking About Mechanisms Philosophy of Science 67: 1–25
Meyerhof Otto., Kiesslling Wilhelm., (1936) Über den Hauptweg der Milchsäurebildung in der Muskulatur Biochemische Zeitschrift 263: 83–113
Michaelis Leonor., (1899) Die vitale Färbung, eine Darstellungsmethode der Zellgranula Archiv für mikrokopische Anatomie 55:558–575
Mitchell Peter., (1961) Coupling of Phosphorylation to Electron and Hydrogen Transfer By a Chemi-Osmotic Type of Mechanism Nature 191: 144–148
Novikoff Alex B., Holtzman Eric., (1970) Cell and Organelles. Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, Inc., New York
Ochoa Severo., (1943) Efficiency of Aerobic Phosphorylation in Cell-Free Heart Extracts Journal of Biological Chemistry 151: 493–505
Oppenheimer Carl., Stern Kurt G., (1939) Biological Oxidation. W. Junk, The Hague
Palade George E., (1952) The Fine Structure of Mitochondria Anatomical Record 114: 427–451
Palade George E., (1952) A Study of Fixation for Electron Microscopy Journal of Experimental Medicine 9(5): 285–297
Penefsky Harvey S., Pullman Maynard E., Datta Anima., Racker Efraim., (1960) Partial Resolution of the Enzymes Catalyzing Oxidative Phosphorylation. II. Participation of a Soluble Adenosine Triphosphatase in Oxidative Phosphorylation Journal of Biological Chemistry 235: 3330–3336
Pflüger Eduard., (1872) über die Diffusion des Sauerstoffs, den Ort und die Gesetze der Oxydationsprocesse im thierischen Organismus Pflüger’s Archiv für die gesammte Physiologie des Menschen und der Thiere 6: 43–64
Porter Keith R., Blum Joseph., (1953) A Study in Microtomy for Electron Microscopy The Anatomical Record 117: 685–707
Porter Keith R., Claude Albert., Fullam Ernest F., (1945) A Study of Tissue Culture Cells by Electron Microscopy Journal of Experimental Medicine 81: 233–255
Prebble John., (2001) The Philosophical Origins of Mitchell’s Chemiosmotic Concepts: The Personal Factor in Scientific Theory Formulation Journal of the History of Biology 34: 433–460
Prebble John., 2002. Peter Mitchell and the Ox Phos Wars Trends in Biochemical Sciences 27:209–212
Pullman Maynard E., Penefsky Harvey S., Datta Anima., Racker Efraim., (1960) Partial Resolution of the Enzymes Catalyzing Oxidative Phosphorylation. I. Purification and Properties of Soluble Dinitrophenol-Stimulated Adenosine Triphosphatase Journal of Biological Chemistry 235: 3322–3329
Racker Efraim., (1965) Mechanisms in Bioenergetics. Academic Press, New York
Racker Efraim., (1968) The Membrane of the Mitochondrion Scientific American 218: 32–39
Racker Efraim., Tyler D. D., Estabrook Ronald W., Conover Thomas E., Parsons D. F., Chance Britton., (1965) Correlations between Electron-Transport Activity, ATP-ase and Morphology of Submitochrondrial Particles. In: King T. E., Mason H. S., Morrison M. (eds) Oxidases and Related Redox Systems Wiley, New York
Rasmussen Nicolas., (1995) Mitochondrial Structure and the Practice of Cell Biology in the 1950s Journal of the History of Biology 28: 381–429
Rasmussen Nicolas., (1997) Picture Control: The Electron Microscope and the Transformation of Biology in America. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA
Rheinberger Hans-Jörg., (1995) From Microsomes to Ribosomes: ‚Strategies’ of ‚Representation’ Journal of the History of Biology 28: 49–89
Rheinberger Hans-Jörg., 1997. Toward a History of Epistemic Things: Synthesizing Proteins in the Test Tube. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA
Scheffler Immo E., 1999. Mitochondria. Wiley-Liss, New York
Sjöstrand, Fritiof S. 1955. “The Ultrastructure of Mitochondria.” In Fine Structure of Cells. Symposium held at the VIIIth Congress of Cell Biology. Leiden: Interscience Publishers, pp. 16–30
Stern Kurt G., Ochoa Severo., Lynen Feodor., (1952) Enzymatic Synthesis of Citric Acid. V. Reactions of Acetyl Coenzyme A Journal of Biological Chemistry 198: 313–321
Thunberg Torsten Ludvig., (1916) Über die vitale Dehydrierung der Bernsteinsäure bei Abwesenheit von Sauerstoff Zentralblatt fÜr Physiologie 31: 91–93
Wainio W. W., 1970. The Mammalian Mitochondrial Respiratory Chain. Academic, New York
Warburg Otto Heinrich., (1925) Iron, the Oxygen Carrier of the Respiration Ferment Science 61: 575–582
Warburg Otto Heinrich., Christian Walter., (1932) Über ein neues Oxydationsferment und sein Absorptionsspektrum Biochemische Zeitschrift 254: 438–458
Warburg Otto Heinrich., Christian Walter., (1936) Pyridin, der wasserstoffübertragene Bestandteil von Gärungsfermenten Biochemische Zeitschrift 287: 291–328
Warburg Otto Heinrich., Christian Walter., (1938) Bemerkung über gelbe Fermente Biochemische Zeitschrift 298: 368–377
Wieland Heinrich., (1913) Über den Mechanismus der Oxydationsvorgänge Berichte der deutschen chemischen Gesellschaft 46: 3327–3342
Ziegler Daniel M., Linnane Anthony W., Green David E., Dass C. M. S., Ris Hans., (1958) Studies on the Electron Transport System: XI. Correlation of the Morphology and Enzymic Properties of Mitochondrial and Sub-Mitochondrial Particles Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 28: 524–539
Acknowledgements
We thank the editors and two anonymous referees for their extremely helpful suggestions on an earlier version of this paper. One referee proposed the term “interfield excursions,” which well captured our intent. We are also most appreciative of insightful comments on the manuscript provided by Rita Anderson, Lindley Darden, and members of the DC History and Philosophy of Biology Group.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bechtel, W., Abrahamsen, A. In Search of Mitochondrial Mechanisms: Interfield Excursions between Cell Biology and Biochemistry. J Hist Biol 40, 1–33 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-006-9103-7
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-006-9103-7