Abstract
Place, practice and status have played significant and interacting roles in the complex history of primatology during the early to mid-twentieth century. This paper demonstrates that, within the emerging discipline of primatology, the field was understood as an essential supplement to laboratory work. Founders argued that only in the field could primates be studied in interaction with their natural social group and environment. Such field studies of primate behavior required the development of existing and new field techniques. The practices and sites developed by American primatologist Clarence Ray Carpenter were used to demonstrate that scientific standards could be successfully applied to the study of primates in the field. In an environment in which many field biologists fought for higher scientific status, Carpenter gradually adopted increasingly interventionist techniques. These techniques raised epistemological problems for studies whose value rested on the naturalness of the behaviors observed. Thus, issues of status shaped field practices and subsequently altered Carpenter’s criteria for what constituted natural primate behavior.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arthur, A Allen (1937) ArticleTitle“Hunting with a Microphone the Voices of Vanishing Birds” National Geographic 71 IssueID6 697–723
Allen Garland E. (1979) ArticleTitle“Naturalists and Experimentalists: The Genotype and the Phenotype.” Studies in the History of Biology 3 179–209
Jeanne Altmann (1974) ArticleTitle“Observational Study of Behavior: Sampling Methods” Behaviour XLIX 227–265
Stuart Altmann (1959) ArticleTitle“Field Observations on a Howling Monkey Society” Journal of Mammalogy 40 IssueID3 317–330
Stuart Altmann (1962) ArticleTitle“A Field Study of the Sociobiology of Rhesus Monkeys, Macca mulatta” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 102 IssueID2 338–435
Altmann, Stuart. (ed.). 1967. Social Communication Among Primates. University of Chicago Press
Altmann, Stuart. 2005. “Clarence Ray Carpenter (1905–1975).” Birk, H. James (ed.), Encyclopedia of Anthropology. Sage Publications
Harold C Bingham (1931) ArticleTitle“Gorillas in a Native Habitat” Carnegie Institution of Washington Publication 426 3–66
Richard, W. Burkhardt SuffixJr. (1981) ArticleTitle“On the Emergence of Ethology as a Scientific Discipline” Conspectus of History 1 62–81
Richard, W. Burkhardt SuffixJr. (1987) ArticleTitle“The Journal of Animal Behavior and the Early History of Animal Behavior Studies in America” Journal of Comparative Psychology 101 IssueID3 223–230 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0735-7036.101.3.223
Richard, W. Burkhardt SuffixJr. (1988. ) Charles Otis Whitman, Wallace Craig, and the Biological Study of Animal Behavior in the United States, 1898–1925 Ronald Rainger R. Keith Benson Jane Maienschein (Eds) The American Development of Biology Rutgers University Press New Brunswick and London 185–219
Richard, W. Burkhardt SuffixJr. (1999) ArticleTitle“Ethology, Natural History, the Life Sciences, and the Problem of Place” Journal of the History of Biology 32 489–508
Burkhardt Jr., Richard, W. 2005. Patterns of Behavior: Konrad Lorenz, Niko Tinbergen and the Founding of Ethology. University of Chicago Press
Carpenter, C.R. 1931. The Effect of Complete and Incomplete Gonadectomy on the Behavior and Morphological Characters of the Male Pigeon. Ph.D. Dissertation, Stanford University
C.R. Carpenter (1932) ArticleTitle“Relation of the Male Avian Gonad to Responses Pertinent to Reproductive Phenomena” Psychological Bulletin 29 IssueID7 509–527
C.R. Carpenter (1933a) ArticleTitle“Pyschobiological Studies of Social behavior in Aves. I. The Effect of Complete and Incomplete Gonadectomy on the Primary Sexual Activity of the Male Pigeon” Journal of Comparative Psychology 16 25–57
C.R. Carpenter (1933b) ArticleTitle“Psychobiological Studies of Social Behavior in Aves. II. The Effect of Complete and Incomplete Gonadectomy on the Secondary Sexual Activity with Histological Studies” Journal of Comparative Psychology 16 59–97
C.R. Carpenter (1934) ArticleTitle“A Field Study of the Behavioral and Social Relations of Howling Monkeys (Alouatta palliata)” Comparative Psychology Monographs 10 IssueID2 1–168
C.R. Carpenter (1939) ArticleTitle“Behavior and Social Relations of Free-Ranging Primates” Scientific Monthly, April XLVIII 319–325
C.R. Carpenter (1940a) ArticleTitle“A Field Study in Siam of the Behavioral and Social Relations of the Gibbon (Hylobates lar)” Comparative Psychology Monographs 16 IssueID5 1–206
C.R. Carpenter (1940b) ArticleTitle“Rhesus Monkeys (Macaca mulatta) for American Laboratories” Science 92 IssueID2387 284–286
C.R. Carpenter (1942a) ArticleTitle“Societies of Monkeys and Apes” Biological Symposia 8 177–204
C.R. Carpenter (1942b) ArticleTitle“Sexual Behavior of Free Ranging Rhesus Monkeys (Macaca mulatta). I. Specimens, Procedures and Behavioral Characteristics of Estrus” Journal of Comparative Psychology 33 IssueID1 113–143
C.R. Carpenter (1950) ArticleTitle“General Plans and Methodology for Field Studies of the Naturalistic Behavior of Animals.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 51 IssueID6 1006–1008
C.R. Carpenter (1950–1952) ArticleTitle“Social behavior of non-human primates” Physiologie des Societies Animals 34 IssueID3 227–246
Carpenter C.R. 1964. Naturalistic Behavior of Nonhuman Primates. The Pennsylvania State University Press
C.R. Carpenter (1965) The Howlers of Barro Colorado Island DeVore (Eds) Primate behavior: Field Studies of Monkeys and Apes Reinhart and Winston Holt 250–292
Carpenter C.R. 1969. “Approaches to Studies of the Naturalistic Communicative Behavior in Nonhuman Primates.” Seboek and Ramsey (eds.), Approaches to Animal Communication. Mouton: 40–70
Carpenter C.R. 1972. “Breeding Colonies of Macaques and Gibbons on Santiago Island, Puerto Rico.” W.I.B. Beveridge (ed.), Breeding Primates, Proceedings of the International Symposium on Breeding Non-Human Primates for Laboratory Use, Berne, 28–30 June 1971, Generva. S. Karger, pp. 76–87
Chapman, Frank. 1929. My Tropical Air Castle: Nature Studies in Panama. D. Appleton-Century
Cittadino, Eugene. 1990. Nature as the Laboratory: Darwinian Plant Ecology in the German Empire, 1880–1900. Cambridge University Press
Clarke, Adele and Joan Fujimura, 1992. The Right Tools for the Job: At Work in Twentieth Century Life Sciences. Princeton University Press
Clarke, Adele E. 1998. Disciplining Reproduction: Modernity, American Life Sciences, and The Problems of Sex. University of California Press
Ros Clubb Mason Georgia (2003) ArticleTitle“Captivity Effects on Wide-Ranging Carnivores” Nature 425 473 Occurrence Handle10.1038/425473a
Wallace Craig (1908) ArticleTitle“The Voices of Pigeons Regarded as a Means of Social Control.” American Journal of Sociology 14 86–100 Occurrence Handle10.1086/211646
De Laguna, Grace. 1927. Speech: Its Function and Development. Yale University Press and Oxford University Press
Diamond, Jared. 1986. “Laboratory Experiments, Field Experiments, and Natural Experiments.” Diamond and Ted. J. Case (eds.), Community Ecology. Harper and Row Publishers. pp. 3–22
Eimerl, Sarel and Irven DeVore. (eds.), 1965. The Primates, Time-Life Books
J.T. Emlen (1950) ArticleTitle“Techniques for Observing Bird Behavior under Natural Conditions.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 51 IssueID6 1103–1111
Joel Hagen (1984) ArticleTitle“Experimentalists and Naturalists in Twentieth Century Botany: Experimental Taxonomy, 1920–1950” Journal of the History of Biology 17 249–270 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00143734
Hagen, Joel. 1988. “Organism and Environment: Frederic Clements’s Vision of a Unified Physiological Ecology”. Ronald Rainger, Keith R. Benson and Jane Maienschein (eds.), The American Development of Biology. Rutgers University Press, pp. 257–277
Joel Hagen (1990) ArticleTitle“Problems in the Institutionalization of Tropical America: The Case of Barro Colorado Island Biological Laboratory” History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 12 225–247
Hanson, Elizabeth. 2005. “How Rhesus Monkeys became Lab Animals.” Centennial History of the Carnegie Institution of Washington v.5. The Department of Embryology, Cambridge University Press: 63–82
Donna Harraway (1983) ArticleTitle“Signs of Dominance: From a Physiology to a Cybernetics of Primate Society, C.R. Carpenter, 1930–1970” Studies in History of Biology 6 129–219
Harraway, Donna. 1989. Primate Visions: Gender, Race, and Nature in the World of Modern Science. Routledge
Higgins, Gladfelter and Elizabeth. 2002. Agassiz’s Legacy: Scientists’ Reflections on the Value of Field Experience. Oxford University Press
Hooton, Earnest. 1946. Man’s Poor Relations. Doubleday & Company, Inc
Huxley, Julian and Ludwig Koch. 1938. Animal Language. Country Life Ltd
Juan Ilerbaig (1999) ArticleTitle“Allied Sciences and Fundamental Problems; C.C. Adams and the Search for Method in Early American Ecology” Journal of the History of Biology 32 439–463 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1004737021541
W.N Kellogg H.N and Robert Kohler Morris (1953) ArticleTitle“Porpoise Sounds as Sonar Signals” Science 117 239–243
W.N Kellogg H.N Robert Kohler Morris (1958) ArticleTitle“Echo Ranging in the Porpoise” Science 128 982–988
Kersey, Ethel, M. 1989. Women Philosophers: A Bio-Critical Sourcebook. Greenwood Press
Sharon Kingsland (1991) ArticleTitle“The Battling Botanist: Daniel Trembly MacDougal, Mutation Theory, and the Rise of Experimental Evolutionary Biology in America, 1900–1912” Isis 82 479–509 Occurrence Handle10.1086/355838
Kohler, Robert E. 2002. Landscapes & Labscapes: Exploring the Lab-Field Border in Biology. The University of Chicago Press
Mayr, Ernst. 1975. “Epilogue: Materials for a History of American Ornithology.” Erwin Stresemann (ed.), Ornithology: From Aristotle to the Present. Harvard University Press, pp. 365–396
Milam, Erika Lorraine. 2003. “Looking for a Few Good Males: Sexual Selection, 1938–1972,” presented at ISHPSSB Conference, Vienna. (Unpublished)
Gregg Mitman (1983) ArticleTitle“Cinematic Nature: Hollywood Technology, Popular Culture, and the American Museum of Natural History” Isis 84 637–661
Gregg Mitman (1990) ArticleTitle“Dominance, Leadership, and Aggression: Animal Behavior Studies during the Second World War” Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 26 3–16
Mitman, Gregg and Richard W. Burkhardt Jr. 1991. “Struggling for Identity: The Study of Animal Behavior in America, 1930–1945.” Ronald Rainger, Jane Maienschein, Keith R. Benson. (eds.), Expansion of American Biology. Rutgers University Press, pp. 164–194
Gregg Mitman (1996) ArticleTitle“When Nature Is the Zoo: Vision and Power in the Art and Science of Natural History” Osiris 11 117–143 Occurrence Handle10.1086/368757
Mitman, Gregg. 1999. Reel Nature: America’s Romance with Wildlife on Film. Harvard University Press
Mitman, Gregg. 2000. “Life in the Field: The Nature of Popular Culture in 1950s America.” Strum, Shirley C. and Linda Marie Fedigan (eds.), Primate Emcounters: Models of Science, Gender, and Society, pp. 421–435
W Nissen Henry (1931) ArticleTitle“A field Study of the Chimpanzee: Observations of Chimpanzees Behavior and Environment in Western French Guinea” Comparative Psychology Monographs 8 IssueID1 1–122
Greg Radick (2000) ArticleTitle“Morgan’s Canon, Garner’s Phonograph, and the Evolutionary Origins of Language and Reason” British Journal for the History of Science 33 3–23
Rawlins, Richard G. and Matt J. Kessler (eds.) 1986. The Cayo Santiago Macaques: History, Behavior and Biology. State University of New York Press
Robinson, Nancy. 1973. Jungle Laboratory: The Story of Ray Carpenter and the Howling Monkeys. Hastings House Publishers
T.C. Schneirla (1950) ArticleTitle“The Relationship Between Observation and Experimentation in the Field Study of Behavior.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 51 IssueID6 1022–1044
Schaller, George. 1963. Mountain Gorilla: Ecology and Behavior. The University of Chicago Press
J.P Scott (1945) ArticleTitle“Social behavior, Organization and Leadership in a Small Flock of Domestic Sheep” Comparative Psychology Monographs 18 IssueID4 1–29
Scott, J.P. 1958. Animal Behavior. University of Chicago Press
Strum, Shirley C. and Linda M. Fedigan. 2000. “Changing Views on Primate Society: A Situated North American Perspective.” Strum and Fedigan (eds.), Primate Encounters: Models of Science, Gender, and Society. University of Chicago Press, pp. 3–49
Thomas, Marion. 2003. “Rethinking the History of Ethology: French Animal Behavior Studies in the Third Republic (1870–1950).” Doctoral Dissertation, The University of Manchester
Windle, William F. 1958. Neurological and Psychological Deficits of Asphyzia Neonatorum: With Considerations of Use of Primates for Experimental Investigations. Charles C. Thomas, Springfield
Yerkes, Robert M. 1925a. Almost Human. The Century Co
Yerkes, Robert M. and Blanche W. Learned. 1925b. Chimpanzee Intelligence and its Vocal Expressions. The Williams & Wilkins Company
Yerkes, Robert M. and Ada Yerkes. 1929. The Great Apes: A Study of Anthropoid Life. Yale University Press
Robert M Yerkes (1931a) ArticleTitle“Forward” in Bingham, Harold C. Gorillas in a Native Habitat” Carnegie Institution of Washington Publication 246 1–2
Robert M Yerkes (1931b) ArticleTitle“Forward” in Nissen, Henry. A Field Study of the Chimpanzee: Observations of Chimpanzees Behavior and Environment in Western French Guinea” Comparative Psychology Monographs 8 IssueID1 i–vi
Robert M Yerkes (1932) ArticleTitle“Yale Laboratories of Comparative Psychobiology” Comparative Psychology Monographs 8 IssueID3 1–31
Yerkes, Robert M. 1935. “Social Behavior in Infrahuman Primates.” Carl Murchison (ed.), A Handbook of Social Psychology. Oxford University Press, pp. 973–1033
Robert M. Yerkes (1939) ArticleTitle“The American Society of Naturalists: The Life History and Personality of the Chimpanzee” The American Naturalist LXXIII IssueID745 97–112
Yerkes, Robert M. 1943. Chimpanzees: A Laboratory Colony. Yale University, London Humphrey Milford, and Oxford University Press
Young, Chris. 2002. In the Absence of Predators: Conservation and Controversy on the Kaibab Plateau. The University of Nebraska Press
Zuckerman, Solly. 1932. The Social Life of Monkeys and Apes. Kegan Paul, Tench, Trubner & Co
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This article is part of a doctoral dissertation (in progress). This research was supported in part by a Doctoral Dissertation Research Grant and Doctoral Dissertation Fellowship from the University of Minnesota. Georgina (Hoptroff) Montgomery presented earlier versions of this paper at the ISHPSSB conference held in Vienna in July 2003 and at the HSS conference in Boston in November 2003.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Montgomery, G.M. Place, Practice and Primatology: Clarence Ray Carpenter, Primate Communication and the Development of Field Methodology, 1931–1945. J Hist Biol 38, 495–533 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-005-0553-0
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-005-0553-0