Abstract
Lack of consideration of the complex European scientific scene from the late 18th century to the mid-decades of the 19th century has produced partial and often biased reconstructions of priorities, worries, implicit and explicit philosophical and at times political agendas characterizing the early debates on species. It is the purpose of this paper firstly to critically assess some significant attempts at broadening the historiographic horizon concerning the immediate context to Darwin’s intellectual enterprise, and to devote the second part to arguing that a multi-faceted European debate on the transformation of life forms had already occurred in Europe around 1800. Of this debate, contrary to long cherished views, Lamarck’s was only one voice, amongst many. Naturalists active in different national contexts elaborated solutions and proposed doctrines that shared several viewpoints, yet clearly stemmed from a variety of disciplinary traditions and problematic contexts.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Elena Agazzi (1999) “La passione per la cultura tedesca di due medici nella Goethezeit: Giuseppe Gautieri e Giovanni Rasori.” G Cusatelli (Eds) Gelehrsamkeit in Deutschland und Italien im 18. Jahrhundert Max Niemeyer Verlag Tübingen 79–89
Christian Bange Pietro Corsi Pascal Duris (2000) ArticleTitle“Les médecins auditeurs du cours professé par Lamarck au Muséum (1795–1823): premier bilan d’une recherche.” Histoire des sciences médicales 34 395–407
Christian Bange Raphae¨l Bange Pietro Corsi (2002) ArticleTitle“Des pharmaciens assistant au cours des animaux sans vertèbres professé par Lamarck au Muséum (1795–1823).” Revue d’histoire de la pharmacie 50 95–110 Occurrence Handle10.3406/pharm.2002.5326
Luca Ciancio (1995) Autopsie della Terra. Illuminismo e geologia in Alberto Fortis (1741–1803) Leo S. Olschki Florence
Pietro Corsi (1978) ArticleTitle“The Importance of French Transformist Ideas for the Second Volume of Lyell’s Principles of Geology.” The British Journal for the History of Science 9 222–244
Pietro Corsi (1985) “Recent Studies of French and Italian Reactions to Darwin.” David Kohn (Eds) The Darwinian Heritage Princeton University Press Princeton 711–729
Pietro Corsi (1988) Science and Religion. Baden Powell and the Anglican Debate, 1800–1860 Cambridge University Press Cambridge Occurrence Handle10.1017/CBO9780511598494
Pietro Corsi (1988) The Age of Lamarck. Evolutionary Theories in France, 1790–1830 University of California Press Berkeley and Los Angeles
Pietro Corsi (1997) “Les élèves de Lamarck: un projet de recherche” Goulven Laurent (Eds) Jean-Baptiste Lamarck 1744–1829 Éditions du CTHS Paris 515–526
Pietro Corsi (2001) Lamarck. Genèse et enjeux du transformisme 1770–1830 Éditions du CNRS Paris
Jean-André Deluc (1798) Lettres sur l’histoire physique de la terre, adressées à M. le Professeur Blumembach, Renfermant de nouvelles Preuves géologiques et historiques de la Mission divine de Moyse Nyon Paris
Adrian Desmond (1989) The Politics of Evolution: Morphology, Medicine, and Reform in Radical London Chicago University Press Chicago
M. Duchet (1995) Anthropologie et histoire au siècle des lumières Albin Michel Paris
Gautieri, Giuseppe. 1805. Slancio sulla genealogia della terra e sulla costruzione dinamica della organizzazione, seguito da una ricerca sull’origine dei vermi abitanti le interiora degli animali. Jena in Sassonia
Gérard, Frédéric. 1843. “Espèce,” “Génération spontanée,” “Géographie zoologique.” Dictionnaire universel d’Histoire naturelle 5: 428a–452a; 6: 536a–571b, 112a–192b
Giacomoni, Paola. Le forme e il vivente. Morfologia e filosofia della natura in J. W. Goethe. Naples: Guida Editori
Gabriel Gohau (1991) A History of Geology Rutgers University Press New Brunswick
William R. Greg (1853) Essays on Political and Social Science, Contributed Chiefly to the Edinburgh Review, 2 vols Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans London
Jon Hodge George Radick (Eds) (2003) The Cambridge Companion to Darwin Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Hoquet, Thierry. 2002. “Buffon: histoire naturelle et philosophie.” Doctoral dissertation. Paris: Université Paris X
Camille Limoges (Eds) (1972) Linné: l’équilibre de la nature J. Vrin Paris
Sven Lindqvist (2002) Exterminate all the Brutes Granta Books London
Jim R. Moore Adrian Desmond (Eds) (2004) Charles Darwin. The Descent of Man Penguin Classics London
Morren, Charles Henri. 1835. “Essai pour déterminer l’influence qu’exerce la lumière sur la manifestation et le développement des êtres végétaux et animaux, dont l’origine avait été attribuée à la génération directe, spontanée ou équivoque.” Annales des sciences naturelles 3: 5–26, 174–187, 224–244; 4: 13–39, 142–166
Jean-Baptiste-Julien Omalius d’Halloy (1831) Eléments de géologie G. Levrault Paris
Jean-Baptiste-Julien Omalius d’Halloy (1846) ArticleTitle“Notes sur la succession des êtres vivants.” Bulletins de l’Académie Royale des Sciences de Belgique 13 581–591
Robert Richards (1992) The Meaning of Evolution. The Morphological Construction and Ideological Reconstruction of Darwin’s Theory The University of Chicago Press Chicago Occurrence Handle10.7208/chicago/9780226712055.001.0001
Robert Richards (2002) The Romantic Conception of Life. Science and Philosophy in the Age of Goethe The University of Chicago Press Chicago Occurrence Handle10.7208/chicago/9780226712185.001.0001
James Secord (2000) Victorian Sensation. The Extraordinary Publication, Reception, and Secret Authorship of Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation The University of Chicago Press Chicago
Phillip R. Sloan (1979) ArticleTitle“Buffon, German Biology, and the Historical of Biological Species.” The British Journal for the History of Science 12 109–153 Occurrence Handle10.1017/S0007087400017027
Daniel P. Todes (1989) Darwin without Malthus: The Struggle for Existence in Russian Evolutionary Thought Oxford University Press New York
Ezio Vaccari (1993) Giovanni Arduino (1714–1795). Il contributo di uno scienziato veneto al dibattito settecentesco sulle scienze della Terra L. S. Olschki Firenze
Ezio Vaccari (1999) “La classificazione delle montagne nel Settecento e la teoria litostratigrafica di Giovanni Arduino Curi Umberto (Eds) Scienza, tecnica e “pubblico bene”. nell’opera di Giovanni Arduino (1714–1795) Accademia di Agricoltura, Scienze e Lettere Verona 47–80
Ezio Vaccari (2003) “The Council of Mines and Geological Research in Italy, at the Start of the 19th Century: Research Perspectives.” Giovan Battista Vai Walter Cavazza (Eds) Four Centuries of the Word ‘Geology’, Ulisse Aldrovandi 1603 in Bologna Minerva Edizioni Bologna 265–269
Julien-Joseph Virey (1800) Histoire naturelle du genre humain, 2 vols Dufart Paris
Julien-Joseph Virey (1803) ArticleTitle“Animal.” Nouveau Dictionnaire d’histoire naturelle 1 419–466
Julien-Joseph Virey (1804) ArticleTitle“Nature.” Nouveau Dictionnaire d’histoire naturelle 15 375–414
Julien-Joseph Virey (1816) ArticleTitle“Animal.” Nouveau Dictionnaire d’histoire naturelle 2 1–81
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Corsi, P. Before Darwin: Transformist Concepts in European Natural History. J Hist Biol 38, 67–83 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-004-6510-5
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-004-6510-5