Abstract
The world’s second largest maritime disaster occurred on September 26th 2002, the sinking of the Senegal’s state run ferry Le Joola, killing 1863 passengers. In the wake of the sinking, it became clear that the state of Senegal held liability for the ferry’s failure; the government readily admitted its errors and several ministers either stepped down or were removed from their positions. In many ways, this case, at least on the surface, looks like a classic example of a state crime – illegal activities carried out by the state or state agencies. However, despite unequivocal governmental responsibility, we suggest that this was not simply a case of state crime. Rather, a thorough investigation and analysis of the reasons and forces behind the Le Joola sinking suggest that international institutions, primarily the World Bank, bear culpability for the disaster due to the way in which their policies and economic development demands altered Senegal’s social, economic and political structures. In conclusion, we offer a criminological analysis of the catalysts leading to the reinstatement of the state run ferry to the coastal waters and the subsequent actions taken by the State of Senegal and of International Society.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Afrol News (2003a). Senegalese Ferry Victims to Get Compensation. 2/3/2003. A1
Afrol News (2003b). President Abdoulaye. 10/1/2003. A1
Barak G. (2000). Foreword. In: Ross J.I. (ed). Varieties of State Crime and Its Control. Monsey, New York. Criminal Justice Press. i–ix
Barak G. (1991). Crimes by the Capitalist State: An Introduction to State Criminality. Albany: State University of New York Press
BBC News (2003). Senegal Ferry Disaster Probed 4/14/2003 At <news.bbc.co.uk.go.pr.fr/2/hi/world/africe/2947745.stm>
Briggs J. (2004). The IMF/World Bank HIPC Initiative: Debt Freedom or Disguised Bondage?. Washington, D.C.: Council on Hemispheric Affairs
Chambliss W. (1989). State organized crime. Criminology 27(2): 183–208
Chambliss W. (1995). Commentary by William J. Chambliss. Society of Social Problems Newsletter 26:1–9
Chambliss W, Zatz M. (1993). Making Law: The State, the Law, and Structural Contradictions. Bloomington: Indiana University Press
Chomsky N. (2000) Rogue States: The Rule of Force in World Affairs. Cambridge, MA: South End Press
Creevey L., Vengroff R., Gaye I. (1995). Devaluation of the CFA Franc in Senegal: The reaction of small businesses. Journal of Modern African Studies 33(4): 669–683
Dakar Inquiry (2002). Le Messager (Dakar). At <www.lemessager.net/details_ articles>
Danaher, K. (2004). Ten Reasons to Abolish the IMF and World Bank Open Media Pamphlet Series
Ewens, G. (2002). The Tragedy of Le Joola: Graeme Ewens Reports on the Possible Causes of Africa’s Worst Ever Shipwreck and the Political Fallout in Senegal. African Business, December 2002, p. 44–45
Falk P. (1993). Global Visions: Beyond the New World Order. Boston: South End Press
Friedrichs, D. (2004). White-Collar Crime in a Globalized World. Presentation at Western Michigan University
Friedrichs D.O., Friedrichs J. (2002) The World Bank and Crimes of Globalization: A Case Study. Social Justice 29(1–2): 1–12
Hockels, L. (2002). Maritime Report. Ed Paul Redfern in The East African Report. At. <<www.nationaudio.com/News/EastAfrican/21102002/Maritime/Maritime18. html>
International Monetary Fund (2000). Press Release No 00/36. 6/23/2000
International Monetary Fund (2004). “Senegal Reports”. Online. <www.imf.org/external/np/sect/
Kramer R. (1994). State violence and violent crime. Peace Review 2: 171–175
Kramer R. (1995). Exploring state criminality: The invasion of panama. Journal of Criminal Justice and Popular Culture 3(2): 43–52
Kramer R., Michalowski R., Rothe D. (2005). The supreme international crime: How the US war in Iraq threatens the rule of law. Social Justice. 32:2
Kramer R. and Michalowski R. (2006). State-Corporate Crime: Wrongdoing at The Intersection of Business And Government. In Ron Kramer and Raymond J. Michalowski (eds), Piscataway, N.J.: Rutgers University Press
Kramer R., Michalowski R (2005). War, aggression, and state crime: A criminological analysis of the invasion and occupation of Iraq. British Journal of Criminology 45 (No. 4, June): 446–469
Kauzlarich D., Kramer R.C. (1993). State-corporate crime in the U.S. Nuclear weapons production complex. The Journal of Human Justice 5(1): 1–26
Kauzlarich D., Kramer R.C. (1998). Crimes of the American Nuclear State: At Home and Abroad. Boston: Northeastern University Press
Kauzlarich D., Mullins C., Matthews R.A. (2003). A complicity continuum of state crime. Contemporary Justice Review. 6(3): 241–254
Kauzlarich D., Matthews R.A., Miller W.J. (2001). Toward A victimology of state crime. Critical Criminology: An International Journal 10(3): 173–194
Knight D. (1994). A Burning Hunger. London: Panos Publications, Ltd
Lagos This Day (2002). “Senegal Report” Ed Barbara Slaughter. “Senegal ferry disaster kills close to a thousand passengers”. 2/10/2002. At <www.wsws.org/articles/2002/oct2002/sene-o02.shtml>
Le Sud Quotidien (2002). Journal d’informations générales du Sénégal At <www.lequotidien.sn>
Mullins C.W., Kauzlarich D. (2000) The ghost dance: A criminological examination. Social Pathology 6(4): 264–283
Ross J., (1995). Controlling State Crime: An Introduction. New York: Garland
Ross J. (2000a). Introduction: Protecting democracy by controlling state crime in advanced industrialized countries. In: Ross J. (ed). Varieties of State Crime and its Control. Monsey, New York. Criminal Justice Press. pp 1–10
Ross J. (2000b). What have we learned and what is the next step. In: Ross J. (ed). Varieties of State Crime and its Control. Monsey, New York. Criminal Justice Press. pp 199–206
Rothe, D. and Friedrichs, D. (2006). The State of the Criminology State of the Crimes of the State. Social Justice 33:1
Senegal Government (2002). “Government Senegal Inquiry Board Report” At www.gouv.sn/
Somerville C.M. (1991). The impact of the reforms on the urban population: How the Dakarois view the crisis. In: Christopher L.D., Jammeh S.C. (eds.), The Political Economy of Senegal under Structural Adjustment. New York: Praeger Publishers
Sutherland E. (1939). White collar criminality. Presidential address to the American society of sociology. Reprinted 1940. American Sociological Review 5: 1–12
Sutherland E. (1949). White Collar Crime. New York: Holt, Rhinehart and Winston
Taipei Times (2003). “Senegal Mourns Victims of Horror” 9/28/2003. At <www.taipeitimes.com/News/world/>
Tunnell K. (1993). Political Crime in Contemporary America: A Critical Approach. New York: Garland
United Nations Development Programme (2000). “Senegal”. 10/2003. At www.un.org
United Nations Development Programme (2003). Press Release. Senegal
United Nations Development Programme (1999) “For Better or Worse: The Euro and CFA Franc” African Recovery On-Line. At http://www.un.org/ecosocdevgeninfo/afrec/subjindx/124euro3.htm
Weissman S.R. (1990). Structural adjustment in Africa: Insights from the experiences of Ghana and Senegal. World Development 18(12): 1621–1635
Wilkopedia (2004). “World Bank”. Online. <en.wikipedia.org/> Retrived 10/2004
World Bank (2004). Senegal Reports. Online www.worldbank.org Retrived 9/2004
Acknowledgements
We wish to thank David Friedrichs, the anonymous reviewer at Critical Criminology, and Barb Sims for insightful suggestions and comments on earlier versions of this paper.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rothe, D., Muzzatti, S. & Mullins, C.W. Crime on the High Seas: Crimes of Globalization and the Sinking of the Senegalese Ferry Le Joola. Crit Crim 14, 159–180 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-006-9003-3
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-006-9003-3