Abstract
The levels of selection problem was central to Maynard Smith’s work throughout his career. This paper traces Maynard Smith’s views on the levels of selection, from his objections to group selection in the 1960s to his concern with the major evolutionary transitions in the 1990s. The relations between Maynard Smith’s position and those of Hamilton and G.C. Williams are explored, as is Maynard Smith’s dislike of the Price equation approach to multi-level selection. Maynard Smith’s account of the ‘core Darwinian principles’ is discussed, as is his debate with Sober and Wilson (1998) over the status of trait-group models, and his attitude to the currently fashionable concept of pluralism about the levels of selection.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arnold A.J. and Fristrup K. (1982). The theory of evolution by natural selection: a hierarchical expansion. Paleobiology 8:113–129
Avital E. and Jablonka E. (2000). Animal Traditions: Behavioural Inheritance in Evolution. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Buss L. (1987). The Evolution of Individuality. Princeton, Princeton University Press
Damuth J. and Heisler I.L. (1988). Alternative formulations of multi-level selection. Biol. Philos. 3:407–430
Dawkins R. (1976). The Selfish Gene. Oxford, Oxford University Press
Dawkins R. (1982). The Extended Phenotype. Oxford, Oxford University Press
Dugatkin L.A. and Reeve H.K. (1994). Behavioural ecology and levels of selection: dissolving the group selection controversy. Adv. Study Behav. 23:101–133
Eigen M. and Schuster P. (1979). The Hypercycle, a Principle of Natural Self-Organization. Berlin, Springer-Verlag
Eigen M., Schuster P., Gardiner W. and Winkler-Oswatitsch R. (1981). The Origin of Genetic Information. Sci. Am. 244(4):78–94
Frank S.A. (1995). George Price’s Contribution to Evolutionary Genetics. J. Theor. Biol. 175:373–388
Frank S.A. (1998). Foundations of Social Evolution. Princeton, Princeton University Press
Gould S.J. (2002). The Structure of Evolutionary Theory. Harvard, Harvard University Press
Grafen A. (1985). A Geometric View of Relatedness. Oxf. Surv. Evol. Biol. 2:28–89
Griesemer J. (2000). The units of evolutionary transition. Selection 1:67–80
Hamilton W.D. (1963). The evolution of altruistic behaviour. Am. Nat. 97:354–356, reprinted in Hamilton (1996), 6–8
Hamilton W.D. (1964). The Genetical Evolution of Social Behaviour I. J. Theor. Biol. 7:1–16, reprinted in Hamilton (1996), 31–46
Hamilton W.D. (1970). Selfish and Spiteful Behaviour in an Evolutionary Model. Nature 228:1218–1220, reprinted in Hamilton (1996), 177–182
Hamilton W.D. 1975a. Innate social aptitudes in man: an approach from evolutionary genetics, reprinted in R. Fox (ed.) Biosocial Anthropology. Wiley, New York, pp. 133–155, reprinted in Hamilton (1996), 315–352
Hamilton W.D. (1975b). Gamblers since life began: barnacles, aphids, elms. Q. Rev. Biol. 50:175–180, reprinted in Hamilton (1996), 357–367
Hamilton W.D. (1996). Narrow Roads of Gene Land Volume 1: Evolution of Social Behaviour. New York, W.H. Freeman
Hull D. (1981). Units of evolution: a metaphysical essay. In: Jensen U.J. and Harré R. (eds). The Philosophy of Evolution. Brighton, Harvester Press, pp. 23–44
Kerr B. and Godfrey-Smith P. (2002). Individualist and multi-level perspectives on selection in structured populations. Biol. Philos. 17:477–517
Kerr B., Neuhauser C., Bohannan B.J.M. and Dean A.M. (forthcoming). Local Migration Promotes Competitive Restraint in a Host-Pathogen ‘Tragedy of the Commons’
Lack D. (1966). Population Studies of Birds. Oxford, Clarendon Press
Lewontin R.C. (1970). The units of selection. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 1:1–18
Maynard Smith J. (1964). Group selection and kin selection. Nature 201:1145–1147
Maynard Smith J. (1976). Group selection. Q. Rev. Biol. 61:277–283
Maynard Smith J. (1978). The Evolution of Sex. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Maynard Smith J. (1979). Hypercycles and the origin of life. Nature 20:445–446
Maynard Smith J. (1982). Evolution and the Theory of Games. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Maynard Smith J. (1983). Game theory and the evolution of cooperation. In: Bendall D.S. (eds). Evolution from Molecules to Man. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 445–456
Maynard Smith J. (1984). Paleontology at the high table. Nature 309:401–402
Maynard Smith J. (1987). How to model evolution. In: Dupré J. (eds). The Latest on the Best: Essays on Evolution and Optimality. Cambridge MA, MIT Press, pp. 119–131
Maynard Smith J. (1988a). Evolutionary progress and the levels of selection. In: Nitecki M.H. (eds). Evolutionary Progress. Chicago, University of Chicago Press, pp. 219–230
Maynard Smith J. (1988b). Selection for recombination in a polygenic model – the mechanism. Genet. Res. 51:59–63
Maynard Smith J. (1988c). ‘Current Controversies in Evolutionary Biology’, in Did Darwin Get it Right?. New York, Chapman-Hall
Maynard Smith J. (1991). A Darwinian view of symbiosis. In: Margulis L. and Fester R. (eds). Symbiosis as a Source of Evolutionary Innovation. Cambridge MA, MIT Press, pp. 26–39
Maynard Smith J. (1998). The origin of altruism. Nature 393:639–640
Maynard Smith J. (2002). Commentary on Kerr and Godfrey-Smith. Biol. Philos. 17(4):523–527
Maynard Smith J. and Price G.R. (1973). The logic of animal conflict. Nature 246:15–18
Maynard Smith J. and Szathmáry E. (1995). The Major Transitions in Evolution. Oxford, Oxford University Press
Michod R.E. (1999). Darwinian Dynamics: Evolutionary Transitions in Fitness and Individuality. Princeton, Princeton University Press
Nunney L. (1985). Group selection, altruism, and structured-deme models. Am. Nat. 126:212–230
Okasha S. (2001). Why won’t the group selection controversy go away?. Br. J. Philos. Sci. 52(1):25–50
Okasha S. (2004). Multi-level selection and the partitioning of covariance: a comparison of three approaches. Evolution 58(3):486–494
Okasha S. (2006a). Evolution and the Levels of Selection. Oxford, Oxford University Press (in press)
Okasha S. 2006b. Multi-level Selection and the Major Transitions in Evolution, Philosophy of Science (Proceedings of the 2004 PSA) (in press)
Price G.R. (1972). Extension of covariance selection mathematics. Ann. Hum. Genet. 35:485–490
Price G.R. (1995). The nature of selection. J. Theor. Biol. 175:389–396 (written circa 1971)
Queller D.C. (1992). Quantitative genetics, inclusive fitness, and group selection. Am. Nat. 139:540–558
Segersträle U. (2000). Defenders of the Truth: The Battle for Science in the Sociobiology Debate and Beyond. Oxford, Oxford University Press
Sober E. (1984). The Nature of Selection. Chicago, Chicago University Press
Sober E. and Lewontin R. (1982). Artifact, cause and genic selection. Philos. Sci. 49:157–180
Sober E. and Wilson D.S. (1998). Unto Others: the Evolution and Psychology of Unselfish Behavior. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press
Szathmáry E. and Hammerstein P. (2004). John Maynard Smith (1920–2004). Nature 429:258–259
Szathmáry E. and Maynard Smith J. (1997). From replicators to reproducers: the first major transitions leading to life. J. Theor. Biol. 187:555–571
Uyenoyama M. and Feldman M.W. (1980). Theories of Kin and group selection: a population genetics perspective. Theor. Popul. Biol. 17:380–414
Wade M. (1985). Soft selection, hard selection, kin selection, and group selection. Am. Nat. 125:61–73
Williams G.C. (1966). Adaptation and Natural Selection. Princeton, Princeton University Press
Williams G.C. (1992). Natural Selection: Domains, Levels, Challenges. Oxford, Oxford University Press
Wilson D.S. (1975). A theory of group selection. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 7(2):143–146
Wilson D.S. (1980). The Natural Selection of Populations and Communities. Menlo Park CA, Benjamin/Cummings
Wilson D.S. (1987). Altruism in Mendelian populations derived from sibling groups: the haystack model revisited. Evolution 41:1059–1070
Wright S. (1980). Genic and organismic selection. Evolution 34:825–843
Wynne-Edwards V.C. (1962). Animal Dispersion in Relation to Social Behaviour. Edinburgh, Oliver and Boyd
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Okasha, S. Maynard Smith on the levels of selection question. Biol Philos 20, 989–1010 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-9019-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-9019-1